Activity

Filter

Cancel
Date Panel Item Activity
129 actions
Intellectual disability v11.30 CRIPT Ida Ertmanska gene: CRIPT was added
gene: CRIPT was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Q3_26_promote_green tags were added to gene: CRIPT.
Mode of inheritance for gene: CRIPT was set to BIALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal
Publications for gene: CRIPT were set to 24389050; 27250922; 36630262; 37013901
Phenotypes for gene: CRIPT were set to Rothmund-Thomson syndrome, type 3, OMIM:615789; Rothmund-Thomson syndrome type 3, MONDO:0014347
Review for gene: CRIPT was set to GREEN
Added comment: PMID: 37013901 Averdunk et al., 2023
Report of 2 probands diagnosed with Rothmund-Thomson syndrome, harbouring biallelic CRIPT variants.
P1 - 4yo Moroccan female, homozygous for CRIPT: c.132del, p.Ala45Glnfs*86
P2 - 8yo Romanian male homozygous for CRIPT: c.227G>A, p.(Cys76Tyr)
Both patients had facial rash, poikiloderma, sparse hair, short stature, syndactyly of toes, seizures, abnormal teeth, developmental delay, recurrent chest infections; P1 also had cataracts, dystrophic nails, and a proximally placed thumb; only P2 had microcephaly.

Also includes literature review of previously reported patients (PMID: 36630262 Akalın et al., 2023; PMID: 27250922 Leduc et al., 2016; PMID: 24389050 Shaheen et al., 2014) - 4 unrelated probands with unique biallelic CRIPT variants: hmz c.133_134insGG, p.(Ala45Glyfs∗82); hmz c.141del p.(Phe47Leufs∗84); comp het c.8G>A p.(Cys3Tyr) & 1,331 bp del exon 1; hmz c.7_8del; p.(Cys3Argfs∗4).
2 individuals were from Saudi Arabia, one from Turkey, and one African American.
Phenotype: facial rash (3/4), poikiloderma (2/4), short stature (4/4), sparse hair (3/4), Osteopenia/metaphyseal striations (4/4), dystrophic nails (1/4), syndactyly of toes 4&5 (4/4), proportional microcephaly (4/4), dev delay (4/4), recurrent chest infections (4/4), anemia (3/4), variable retinal defects (4/4), abnormal teeth (2/4), scoliosis (4/4), 11 pairs of ribs (2/4).
None of the patients had cataracts.
Microcephaly severity: PMID: 27250922 head circumference was 47 cm (Z=−2.7) at 4 yrs. PMID: 24389050: individuals had head circumference of 45 cm (-2.5SD) and 35 cm (-2.7 SD) respectively at time of report. PMID: 36630262 - proband OFC was 44cm at last evaluation (-4.63 SDS).
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v11.17 LDB1 Achchuthan Shanmugasundram changed review comment from: PMID:42320471 (2026) reported a cohort of 16 individuals with de novo LDB1 variants, of which 14 patients presented with developmental delay, 13 patients with speech delay and 8 patients with motor delay. There were eight other patients reported previously. Developmental delay was present in 9/11 individuals with N-terminal LGD/DD missense variants and 7/7 individuals with C-terminal LID-affecting variants, speech delay present in 10/10 and 5/5, and motor delay present in 5/9 and 5/5 respectively. Unlike the ventriculomegaly phenotype, developmental delay occurs across both N-terminal and C-terminal variant classes, indicating it is a core, mechanism-independent feature of LDB1-related neurodevelopmental disorder.

N-terminal DD missense variants impair LDB1 homodimerization through loss-of-function, while C-terminal LID variants abolish LHX2 binding via a dominant-negative mechanism, both disrupting transcriptional complexes required for neurogenesis. In Drosophila, neuronal knockdown of the LDB1 ortholog chi impaired motor behavior, and both variant types failed to properly rescue this phenotype, confirming LDB1 dysfunction causally contributes to neurological/developmental impairment.

This gene has not yet been associated with relevant phenotypes in OMIM, Gene2Phenotype or ClinGen.; to: PMID:42320471 (2026) reported a cohort of 16 individuals with de novo LDB1 variants, of which 14 patients presented with developmental delay, 13 patients with speech delay and 8 patients with motor delay. There were eight other patients reported previously. Developmental delay was present in 9/11 individuals with N-terminal LGD/DD missense variants and 7/7 individuals with C-terminal LID-affecting variants, speech delay present in 10/10 and 5/5, and motor delay present in 5/9 and 5/5 respectively. Unlike the ventriculomegaly phenotype, developmental delay occurs across both N-terminal and C-terminal variant classes, indicating it is a core, mechanism-independent feature of LDB1-related neurodevelopmental disorder.

N-terminal DD missense variants impair LDB1 homodimerization through loss-of-function, while C-terminal LID variants abolish LHX2 binding via a dominant-negative mechanism, both disrupting transcriptional complexes required for neurogenesis. In Drosophila, neuronal knockdown of the LDB1 ortholog chi impaired motor behavior, and both variant types failed to properly rescue this phenotype, confirming LDB1 dysfunction causally contributes to neurological/developmental impairment.

This gene has not yet been associated with relevant phenotypes in OMIM, Gene2Phenotype or ClinGen (last accessed 16 August 2026).
Intellectual disability v10.63 WAPL Achchuthan Shanmugasundram gene: WAPL was added
gene: WAPL was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Q3_26_promote_green tags were added to gene: WAPL.
Mode of inheritance for gene: WAPL was set to MONOALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal, NOT imprinted
Publications for gene: WAPL were set to 42431198
Phenotypes for gene: WAPL were set to complex neurodevelopmental disorder, MONDO:0100038
Review for gene: WAPL was set to GREEN
Added comment: PMID:42431198 (2026) reported the identification of heterozygous WAPL variants in 27 patients, of which 19 patients had confirmed de novo variants. The WAPL-related disorder was characterised by developmental delay, intellectual disability, and risk of other developmental anomalies. Syndromic intellectual disability was reported in 6 patients and Global developmental delay (GDD) was reported in 10 patients.

Transcriptomics identified significant overlap between WAPL haploinsufficiency and 10q deletion differentially expressed genes. Mice with 50% Wapl expression exhibited mild deficits of growth and learning/memory, whereas those with 25% residual Wapl displayed birth defects and postnatal lethality, revealing a dosage liability threshold below the level of heterozygosity.

This gene has not yet been associated with relevant phenotypes in OMIM, Gene2Phenotype or ClinGen, but associated with green rating on the intellectual disability panel of PanelApp Australia.
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v9.355 BRF2 Ida Ertmanska changed review comment from: PMID: 40229899 Mattioli et al., 2025
Report of six families (3 Icelandic, 1 Iranian, 1 Pakistani, 1 of unknown ancestry) with bi-allelic variants in BRF2 presenting with early mortality, brain, and craniofacial anomalies and/or neurodevelopmental disorders (NDD). Patients had phenotypes ranging from perinatal death to Treacher-Collins and craniosynostosis with radial defects and immunodeficiency or global developmental delay, hearing, and vision impairment.
Families 1-3 = Icelandic families with founder BRF2 variant c.214 + 1G > A, not much detail provided on phenotype beyond "early lethality". Genotyping was not done for the affected fetuses, it was inferred from living family members.

Family 4 - female proband with Treacher-Collins syndrome, presented with hearing impairment, soft cleft palate, microcephaly, and facial dysmorphism. She was homozygous for BRF2 c.481G > T; p.(Gly161*).

Family 5 - 2 sibs compound het for BRF2 c.782C > T ; p.(Pro261Leu) & c.404_409delinsA; p.(Met135Asnfs*15);
Patient II:1 female, presented with coronal synostosis, microcephaly, hypertelorism, a small beaked, nose, retrognathia, shortened right radius, and absent left radius, with radial deviation of the hands and contractures of all fingers. She was found to have anemia, leukocytosis, marked eosinophilia, and thrombocytopenia, and developed a significant rash by 1 month of age; she died at 2 mo from bacterial infection.
Patient II:2, male - presented with frontal bone hypoplasia with bilateral coronal synostosis, micrognathia, small orbits, low-set ears, downward slanting palpebral fissures, and significantly decreased B-cell CD19 subsets. He subsequently developed ichthyosiform erythroderma and eosinophilic myeloid hyperplasia. He had developmental and speech delays.

Family 6 - 4 affected sibs with moderate ID, and delays in motor and speech development; 2 sibs had mild hearing and vision impairment. 2 sibs confirmed homozygous for BRF2 c.31G > A; p.(Gly11Ser).

Zebrafish knocked down for the orthologous brf2 presented with abnormal escape response, reduced swimming velocity and head size, and craniofacial malformations. Phenotype was rescued by human BRF2, but not by isoforms with patients variants.

PMID: 40781771 Yoon et al., 2025
Case report of a girl, presumed Korean born to non-consanguineous parents, with multiple congenital anomalies: polydactyly of the right fifth toe, duplex kidney on the right side, hypodontia, and dysmorphic facial features. She had recurrent infections in the neonatal period, and was diagnosed with primary immunodeficiency at 4 months. Mild ID (IQ=60) was diagnosed at age 16 yrs. She harboured comp het BRF2 variants: c.379C>T, p.Arg127Ter & c.782C>T, p.Pro261Leu. Older sister was similarly affected; she died of infection at 19 months.
Single-cell RNA-seq analysis of the patient sample revealed transcriptional abnormalities in PBMCs from the patient harboring BRF2 mutations. BRF2 mutations disrupt RNA Pol III activity specifically at type III promoters, leading to transcriptional dysregulation of critical noncoding RNAs

BRF2 is not yet associated with a phenotype in OMIM (accessed 27 Mar 2026).
Sources: Literature
Sources: Literature; to: PMID: 40229899 Mattioli et al., 2025
Report of six families (3 Icelandic, 1 Iranian, 1 Pakistani, 1 of unknown ancestry) with bi-allelic variants in BRF2 presenting with early mortality, brain, and craniofacial anomalies and/or neurodevelopmental disorders (NDD). Patients had phenotypes ranging from perinatal death to Treacher-Collins and craniosynostosis with radial defects and immunodeficiency or global developmental delay, hearing, and vision impairment.
Families 1-3 = Icelandic families with founder BRF2 variant c.214 + 1G > A, not much detail provided on phenotype beyond "early lethality". Genotyping was not done for the affected fetuses, it was inferred from living family members.

Family 4 - female proband with Treacher-Collins syndrome, presented with hearing impairment, soft cleft palate, microcephaly, and facial dysmorphism. She was homozygous for BRF2 c.481G > T; p.(Gly161*).

Family 5 - 2 sibs compound het for BRF2 c.782C > T ; p.(Pro261Leu) & c.404_409delinsA; p.(Met135Asnfs*15);
Patient II:1 female, presented with coronal synostosis, microcephaly, hypertelorism, a small beaked, nose, retrognathia, shortened right radius, and absent left radius, with radial deviation of the hands and contractures of all fingers. She was found to have anemia, leukocytosis, marked eosinophilia, and thrombocytopenia, and developed a significant rash by 1 month of age; she died at 2 mo from bacterial infection.
Patient II:2, male - presented with frontal bone hypoplasia with bilateral coronal synostosis, micrognathia, small orbits, low-set ears, downward slanting palpebral fissures, and significantly decreased B-cell CD19 subsets. He subsequently developed ichthyosiform erythroderma and eosinophilic myeloid hyperplasia. He had developmental and speech delays.

Family 6 - 4 affected sibs with moderate ID, and delays in motor and speech development; 2 sibs had mild hearing and vision impairment. 2 sibs confirmed homozygous for BRF2 c.31G > A; p.(Gly11Ser).

Zebrafish knocked down for the orthologous brf2 presented with abnormal escape response, reduced swimming velocity and head size, and craniofacial malformations. Phenotype was rescued by human BRF2, but not by isoforms with patients variants.

PMID: 40781771 Yoon et al., 2025
Case report of a girl, presumed Korean born to non-consanguineous parents, with multiple congenital anomalies: polydactyly of the right fifth toe, duplex kidney on the right side, hypodontia, and dysmorphic facial features. She had recurrent infections in the neonatal period, and was diagnosed with primary immunodeficiency at 4 months. Mild ID (IQ=60) was diagnosed at age 16 yrs. She harboured comp het BRF2 variants: c.379C>T, p.Arg127Ter & c.782C>T, p.Pro261Leu. Older sister was similarly affected; she died of infection at 19 months.
Single-cell RNA-seq analysis of the patient sample revealed transcriptional abnormalities in PBMCs from the patient harboring BRF2 mutations. BRF2 mutations disrupt RNA Pol III activity specifically at type III promoters, leading to transcriptional dysregulation of critical noncoding RNAs

BRF2 is not yet associated with a phenotype in OMIM (accessed 27 Mar 2026).
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v9.354 BRF2 Ida Ertmanska gene: BRF2 was added
gene: BRF2 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Q1_26_promote_green tags were added to gene: BRF2.
Mode of inheritance for gene: BRF2 was set to BIALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal
Publications for gene: BRF2 were set to 40229899; 40781771
Phenotypes for gene: BRF2 were set to multiple congenital anomalies/dysmorphic syndrome, MONDO:0019042; intellectual disability, MONDO:0001071
Review for gene: BRF2 was set to GREEN
Added comment: PMID: 40229899 Mattioli et al., 2025
Report of six families (3 Icelandic, 1 Iranian, 1 Pakistani, 1 of unknown ancestry) with bi-allelic variants in BRF2 presenting with early mortality, brain, and craniofacial anomalies and/or neurodevelopmental disorders (NDD). Patients had phenotypes ranging from perinatal death to Treacher-Collins and craniosynostosis with radial defects and immunodeficiency or global developmental delay, hearing, and vision impairment.
Families 1-3 = Icelandic families with founder BRF2 variant c.214 + 1G > A, not much detail provided on phenotype beyond "early lethality". Genotyping was not done for the affected fetuses, it was inferred from living family members.

Family 4 - female proband with Treacher-Collins syndrome, presented with hearing impairment, soft cleft palate, microcephaly, and facial dysmorphism. She was homozygous for BRF2 c.481G > T; p.(Gly161*).

Family 5 - 2 sibs compound het for BRF2 c.782C > T ; p.(Pro261Leu) & c.404_409delinsA; p.(Met135Asnfs*15);
Patient II:1 female, presented with coronal synostosis, microcephaly, hypertelorism, a small beaked, nose, retrognathia, shortened right radius, and absent left radius, with radial deviation of the hands and contractures of all fingers. She was found to have anemia, leukocytosis, marked eosinophilia, and thrombocytopenia, and developed a significant rash by 1 month of age; she died at 2 mo from bacterial infection.
Patient II:2, male - presented with frontal bone hypoplasia with bilateral coronal synostosis, micrognathia, small orbits, low-set ears, downward slanting palpebral fissures, and significantly decreased B-cell CD19 subsets. He subsequently developed ichthyosiform erythroderma and eosinophilic myeloid hyperplasia. He had developmental and speech delays.

Family 6 - 4 affected sibs with moderate ID, and delays in motor and speech development; 2 sibs had mild hearing and vision impairment. 2 sibs confirmed homozygous for BRF2 c.31G > A; p.(Gly11Ser).

Zebrafish knocked down for the orthologous brf2 presented with abnormal escape response, reduced swimming velocity and head size, and craniofacial malformations. Phenotype was rescued by human BRF2, but not by isoforms with patients variants.

PMID: 40781771 Yoon et al., 2025
Case report of a girl, presumed Korean born to non-consanguineous parents, with multiple congenital anomalies: polydactyly of the right fifth toe, duplex kidney on the right side, hypodontia, and dysmorphic facial features. She had recurrent infections in the neonatal period, and was diagnosed with primary immunodeficiency at 4 months. Mild ID (IQ=60) was diagnosed at age 16 yrs. She harboured comp het BRF2 variants: c.379C>T, p.Arg127Ter & c.782C>T, p.Pro261Leu. Older sister was similarly affected; she died of infection at 19 months.
Single-cell RNA-seq analysis of the patient sample revealed transcriptional abnormalities in PBMCs from the patient harboring BRF2 mutations. BRF2 mutations disrupt RNA Pol III activity specifically at type III promoters, leading to transcriptional dysregulation of critical noncoding RNAs

BRF2 is not yet associated with a phenotype in OMIM (accessed 27 Mar 2026).
Sources: Literature
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v9.227 PRMT9 Achchuthan Shanmugasundram edited their review of gene: PRMT9: Added comment: PMID:41260215 (2025) reported the identification of biallelic loss-of-function variants in PRMT9 gene in 35 individuals from 26 unrelated families primarily presenting with a neurodevelopmental disorder characterised by global developmental delay, learning disabilities, mild to severe intellectual disability, autism spectrum disorder, epilepsy, and hypotonia.

There were 26 different variants identified in total which included frameshifting indels, nonsense variants, missense variants, and two copy-number variants.

Global developmental delay was present un 33 individuals and mild - severe intellectual disability was present in 29 individuals (moderate and above in 11 patients, where ID was mild-moderate or severity not reported in others).

Functional evidence available from skin fibroblasts derived from affected individuals showed reduced expression at the RNA and/or protein level and subsequent aberrant methylation activity. Transcriptomic analysis of fibroblasts from affected individuals indicated differential expression of genes related to intellectual disability, autism, and cilia, suggesting a role of PRMT9 during ciliogenesis. Under ciliogenesis conditions, the skin-derived fibroblasts exhibited anomalies in the length of primary cilia but normal amounts of cilia. In addition, a prmt9 knockout zebrafish model displayed abnormal social preference in adult animals.

This gene has not yet been associated with relevant phenotypes in OMIM (last accessed 09 January 2026), but has been associated with 'Limited' rating on the DD panel in Gene2Phenotype.; Changed publications to: 21937992, 38561334, 41260215
Intellectual disability v9.164 LRRC45 Ida Ertmanska gene: LRRC45 was added
gene: LRRC45 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Other
Mode of inheritance for gene: LRRC45 was set to BIALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal
Publications for gene: LRRC45 were set to 30131441; 34716235; 39638757
Phenotypes for gene: LRRC45 were set to ciliopathy, MONDO:0005308; Abnormal brain morphology, HP:0012443; neurodevelopmental disorder, MONDO:0700092
Review for gene: LRRC45 was set to AMBER
Added comment: PMID: 34716235 Best et al., 2022
2 unrelated individuals with LP biallelic variants in LRRC45.
Proband 1 (CMC Patient 48): Bardet-Biedl syndrome-like multi-systemic ciliopathy - homozygous for NM_144999.4: c.1074_1075insTG, p.(Leu359CysfsTer19), also homozygous for CFAP45 (CCDC19) NM_012337.3: c.433C>T, p.(Arg145Ter).
Sibling with developmental delay and ID was homozygous for the LRRC45 variant, did not harbour the CFAP45 mutation (proposed to account for the ciliopathy phenotype); parents confirmed as het for each.
Proband 2: presented with cone-rod dystrophy (possible ciliopathy basis) - compound het: NM_144999.4: c.1A>T, p.Met1? & NM_144999.4: c.1126–1G>A. Singleton case.

PMID: 39638757 Radhakrishnan et al., 2025
Report of 3 individuals from 2 unrelated families with severe central nervous system anomalies, harbouring biallelic variants in LRRC45: P1: c.1402-2A>G; P2 and P3: c.1262G>C (p.Arg421Thr). Method: Exome seq.
P1 - female, onset at 1yr 8months, Indian origin, presented with febrile seizures and developmental delay, severe brain anomalies. At 3yr 7 mo: titubation, nystagmus, axial and peripheral hypotonia, normal deep tendon reflexes and pes planus.
P2 & 3 - born to Turkish consanguineous parents; P2 - female, presented with severe muscular hypotonia, respiratory insufficiency, and apnea bradycardia syndrome; ophthalmological exam was normal; patient died at 3 months old. P3 - male fetus, pregnancy terminated.
Functional evidence - P1 fibroblasts - variant c.1402-2A>G shown to result in a transcript lacking exon 14 (total 17 exons); LRRC45 mRNA and protein levels significantly reduced; significant reduction of primary cilia frequency and length.
c.1402-2A>G - splice acceptor - MAF 0.0001647 (South Asian population, 14 heterozygotes - gnomAD v4.1).
c.1262G>C (p.Arg421Thr) - MAF 8.475e-7 (1 het in European pop - gnomAD v4.1); Revel score =
Uncertain (0.31).

Functional evidence:
PMID: 30131441 Kurtulmus et al., 2018 - LRRC45 shown to be associated with the basal body of primary and motile cilia in both differentiated and stem cells - broad function in ciliogenesis.

This gene is not yet associated with a disease in OMIM (accessed 11th Nov 2025).
Sources: Other
Intellectual disability v9.94 TSPAN7 Ida Ertmanska changed review comment from: There are at least 7 unrelated families reported with mild to moderate intellectual disability with either LoF variants in TSPAN7, TSPAN7 duplication, or balanced translocations with a breakpoint within the TSPAN7 sequence. However, phenotype in most of the affected individuals does not meet the eligibility criteria of moderate/severe/profound global developmental delay/intellectual disability.

PMID: 10655063 Zemni et al., 2000: Sequencing method: DDGE + sequencing of PCR products (TSPAN7 sequence only).
Female patient with mild MR, mild autistic features, no dysmorphic features; IQ = 64 at 10yo. Heterozygous for a [46,X,t(X;2)(p11.4;p21.3)] balanced translocation affecting within TSPAN7 in a patient with mental retardation. TSPAN7 transcripts were barely detectable by RT-PCR.

Family L28, c.652G>T, p.(Gly218Ter) – IQ 45-60 in affected individuals (no age provided); authors claim variant segregates with disease, but data is not shown; RT-PCR showed normal levels of the transcript in affected patients; variant lies in a region of predicted NMD escape. Not found in gnomAD v4.1.0.

Family T15: 4 males hemizygous for c.515C>A, p.(Pro172His). IQ = 40-45 in 3 affected individuals (age 36-40 at report), individual 16 had IQ = 70 at age 10. In addition, individual 13 had low IQ (64) but did not carry the same mutation.
Conflicting evidence:
p.(Pro172His) variant-disease association disputed in PMID: 12376945 Gomot 2002 – linkage analysis in the same family excluded the TSPAN7 variant, authors suggest it to be a rare polymorphism instead.
Subsequently in PMID: 14735593 (da Costa Maranduba et al,, 2004), authors sequenced TSPAN7 in 105 males with mental retardation and found the same variant, p.Pro172His, in another patient – 21yo at time of report, delayed developmental milestones, severe speech acquisition impairment (started talking at 3.5 years); presented with dysmorphic facial features, abnormally folded ears, hypoplastic nails and alopecia spots.
Variant’s REVEL score = 0.62 (uncertain). Highest frequency in gnomAD v4 = 0.002106 (European population) – includes 2 homozygotes and 613 hemizygotes - unlikely to be causal, frequency too high.

PMID: 12070254 Abidi et al., 2002:
2-bp deletion c.572_573del p.(Val191fs) detected in a family with intellectual disability. Method: Screening exons of TM4SF2 gene only. Variant not in gnomAD v4.1.0. Family 'MRX58': five affected males in two generations with mild to moderate mental retardation (no IQ scores or ages given); affected males live in sheltered homes, are capable of doing simple jobs, and have no dysmorphic features; carrier females in the family have normal intelligence. BsrI restriction enzyme analysis determined that the deletion segregated with the XLMR in MRX58.

PMID: 22511893 Utine et al., 2012
FAMILY 1: moderately retarded 9-year-old patient and his similarly affected 11-year-old brother had infantile hypotonia and delayed motor development; did not acquire language abilities; No dysmorphic characteristics. TSPAN7 gene was duplicated. Unaffected mother had 3 copies of the same region. Copy number variation effect not yet clear as cause of ID.

PMID: 26290131 Moyses-Oliveira et al., 2015
Patient 1 - balanced translocation X;21 disrupting the 3’ UTR of TSPAN7; no TSPAN7 expression in peripheral blood sample. Authors pose that in women with balanced X-autosome translocations, the normal X chromosome is preferentially inactivated, resulting in a lack of expression. Array CGH did not cover the area of the autosomal breakpoint – effect unknown, method limitation. Patient phenotype: ‘borderline’ ID, microsomia, microcephaly.

Other variants reported as pathogenic in databases:
c.271-1G>T, Variation ID: 3767244. Hemizygous in proband with XLID, inherited from unaffected mother. Variant not in gnomAD v4, SpliceIAI = 1 Splice-Altering Strong. ClinVar submission by Kasturba Medical College, Manipal, India.

c.289del (p.Leu97fs), Variation ID: 1164055 – rated Pathogenic in ClinVar for XLID58 by Pediatric Genetics Clinic, Sheba Medical Center. Reported in an individual in clinical testing; Allele origin: inherited; Affected status: yes; Clinical Features: Neurodevelopmental delay, Attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, Abnormal cerebral white matter morphology, Short stature, Microcephaly; Test name: Whole exome sequencing; Zygosity: Hemizygote. Variant not present in gnomAD v4.

c.127dup p.(Thr43AsnfsTer42) – male patient (Patient: 318070) with intellectual disability reported in Decipher https://www.deciphergenomics.org/patient/318070/genotype/192961- variant not in gnomAD v4.

The association between TSPAN7 and non-syndromic X-linked intellectual disability was classified as Moderate by ClinGen (Intellectual Disability and Autism Gene Curation Expert Panel, Dec 2020). TSPAN7 is associated with Intellectual developmental disorder, X-linked 58 in OMIM (OMIM:300210, accessed 22 Sep 2025). Due to conflicting evidence in literature, the gene can only be rated Amber for Intellectual disability.; to: There are at least 7 unrelated families reported with mild to moderate intellectual disability with either LoF variants in TSPAN7, TSPAN7 duplication, or balanced translocations with a breakpoint within the TSPAN7 sequence. However, phenotype in most of the affected individuals does not meet the eligibility criteria of moderate/severe/profound global developmental delay/intellectual disability.

PMID: 10655063 Zemni et al., 2000: Sequencing method: DDGE + sequencing of PCR products (TSPAN7 sequence only).
Female patient with mild MR, mild autistic features, no dysmorphic features; IQ = 64 at 10yo. Heterozygous for a [46,X,t(X;2)(p11.4;p21.3)] balanced translocation affecting within TSPAN7 in a patient with mental retardation. TSPAN7 transcripts were barely detectable by RT-PCR.

Family L28, c.652G>T, p.(Gly218Ter) – IQ 45-60 in affected individuals (no age provided); authors claim variant segregates with disease, but data is not shown; RT-PCR showed normal levels of the transcript in affected patients; variant lies in a region of predicted NMD escape. Not found in gnomAD v4.1.0.

Family T15: 4 males hemizygous for c.515C>A, p.(Pro172His). IQ = 40-45 in 3 affected individuals (age 36-40 at report), individual 16 had IQ = 70 at age 10. In addition, individual 13 had low IQ (64) but did not carry the same mutation.
Conflicting evidence:
p.(Pro172His) variant-disease association disputed in PMID: 12376945 Gomot 2002 – linkage analysis in the same family excluded the TSPAN7 variant, authors suggest it to be a rare polymorphism instead.
Subsequently in PMID: 14735593 (da Costa Maranduba et al,, 2004), authors sequenced TSPAN7 in 105 males with mental retardation and found the same variant, p.Pro172His, in another patient – 21yo at time of report, delayed developmental milestones, severe speech acquisition impairment (started talking at 3.5 years); presented with dysmorphic facial features, abnormally folded ears, hypoplastic nails and alopecia spots.
Variant’s REVEL score = 0.62 (uncertain). Highest frequency in gnomAD v4 = 0.002106 (European population) – includes 2 homozygotes and 613 hemizygotes - unlikely to be causal, frequency too high.

PMID: 12070254 Abidi et al., 2002:
2-bp deletion c.572_573del p.(Val191fs) detected in a family with intellectual disability. Method: Screening exons of TM4SF2 gene only. Variant not in gnomAD v4.1.0. Family 'MRX58': five affected males in two generations with mild to moderate mental retardation (no IQ scores or ages given); affected males live in sheltered homes, are capable of doing simple jobs, and have no dysmorphic features; carrier females in the family have normal intelligence. BsrI restriction enzyme analysis determined that the deletion segregated with the XLMR in MRX58.

PMID: 22511893 Utine et al., 2012
FAMILY 1: moderately retarded 9-year-old patient and his similarly affected 11-year-old brother had infantile hypotonia and delayed motor development; did not acquire language abilities; No dysmorphic characteristics. TSPAN7 gene was duplicated. Unaffected mother had 3 copies of the same region. Copy number variation effect not yet clear as cause of ID.

PMID: 26290131 Moyses-Oliveira et al., 2015
Patient 1 - balanced translocation X;21 disrupting the 3’ UTR of TSPAN7; no TSPAN7 expression in peripheral blood sample. Authors pose that in women with balanced X-autosome translocations, the normal X chromosome is preferentially inactivated, resulting in a lack of expression. Array CGH did not cover the area of the autosomal breakpoint – effect unknown, method limitation. Patient phenotype: ‘borderline’ ID, microsomia, microcephaly.

Supporting evidence - variants in databases:
c.271-1G>T, Variation ID: 3767244. Hemizygous in proband with XLID, inherited from unaffected mother. Variant not in gnomAD v4, SpliceIAI = 1 Splice-Altering Strong. ClinVar submission by Kasturba Medical College, Manipal, India.

c.289del (p.Leu97fs), Variation ID: 1164055 – rated Pathogenic in ClinVar for XLID58 by Pediatric Genetics Clinic, Sheba Medical Center. Reported in an individual in clinical testing; Allele origin: inherited; Affected status: yes; Clinical Features: Neurodevelopmental delay, Attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, Abnormal cerebral white matter morphology, Short stature, Microcephaly; Test name: Whole exome sequencing; Zygosity: Hemizygote. Variant not present in gnomAD v4.

c.127dup p.(Thr43AsnfsTer42) – male patient (Patient: 318070) with intellectual disability reported in Decipher https://www.deciphergenomics.org/patient/318070/genotype/192961- variant not in gnomAD v4.

The association between TSPAN7 and non-syndromic X-linked intellectual disability was classified as Moderate by ClinGen (Intellectual Disability and Autism Gene Curation Expert Panel, Dec 2020). TSPAN7 is associated with Intellectual developmental disorder, X-linked 58 in OMIM (OMIM:300210, accessed 22 Sep 2025). Due to conflicting evidence in literature, the gene can only be rated Amber for Intellectual disability.
Intellectual disability v9.94 TSPAN7 Ida Ertmanska changed review comment from: There are at least 7 unrelated families reported with mild to moderate intellectual disability with either LoF variants in TSPAN7, TSPAN7 duplication, or balanced translocations with a breakpoint within the TSPAN7 sequence. However, phenotype in most of the affected individuals does not meet our criteria for Intellectual Disability testing, i.e. IQ<50, global developmental delay, childhood onset:

PMID: 10655063 Zemni et al., 2000: Sequencing method: DDGE + sequencing of PCR products (TSPAN7 sequence only).
Female patient with mild MR, mild autistic features, no dysmorphic features; IQ = 64 at 10yo. Heterozygous for a [46,X,t(X;2)(p11.4;p21.3)] balanced translocation affecting within TSPAN7 in a patient with mental retardation. TSPAN7 transcripts were barely detectable by RT-PCR.

Family L28, c.652G>T, p.(Gly218Ter) – IQ 45-60 in affected individuals (no age provided); authors claim variant segregates with disease, but data is not shown; RT-PCR showed normal levels of the transcript in affected patients; variant lies in a region of predicted NMD escape. Not found in gnomAD v4.1.0.

Family T15: 4 males hemizygous for c.515C>A, p.(Pro172His). IQ = 40-45 in 3 affected individuals (age 36-40 at report), individual 16 had IQ = 70 at age 10. In addition, individual 13 had low IQ (64) but did not carry the same mutation.
Conflicting evidence:
p.(Pro172His) variant-disease association disputed in PMID: 12376945 Gomot 2002 – linkage analysis in the same family excluded the TSPAN7 variant, authors suggest it to be a rare polymorphism instead.
Subsequently in PMID: 14735593 (da Costa Maranduba et al,, 2004), authors sequenced TSPAN7 in 105 males with mental retardation and found the same variant, p.Pro172His, in another patient – 21yo at time of report, delayed developmental milestones, severe speech acquisition impairment (started talking at 3.5 years); presented with dysmorphic facial features, abnormally folded ears, hypoplastic nails and alopecia spots.
Variant’s REVEL score = 0.62 (uncertain). Highest frequency in gnomAD v4 = 0.002106 (European population) – includes 2 homozygotes and 613 hemizygotes - unlikely to be causal, frequency too high.

PMID: 12070254 Abidi et al., 2002:
2-bp deletion c.572_573del p.(Val191fs) detected in a family with intellectual disability. Method: Screening exons of TM4SF2 gene only. Variant not in gnomAD v4.1.0. Family 'MRX58': five affected males in two generations with mild to moderate mental retardation (no IQ scores or ages given); affected males live in sheltered homes, are capable of doing simple jobs, and have no dysmorphic features; carrier females in the family have normal intelligence. BsrI restriction enzyme analysis determined that the deletion segregated with the XLMR in MRX58.

PMID: 22511893 Utine et al., 2012
FAMILY 1: moderately retarded 9-year-old patient and his similarly affected 11-year-old brother had infantile hypotonia and delayed motor development; did not acquire language abilities; No dysmorphic characteristics. TSPAN7 gene was duplicated. Unaffected mother had 3 copies of the same region. Copy number variation effect not yet clear as cause of ID.

PMID: 26290131 Moyses-Oliveira et al., 2015
Patient 1 - balanced translocation X;21 disrupting the 3’ UTR of TSPAN7; no TSPAN7 expression in peripheral blood sample. Authors pose that in women with balanced X-autosome translocations, the normal X chromosome is preferentially inactivated, resulting in a lack of expression. Array CGH did not cover the area of the autosomal breakpoint – effect unknown, method limitation. Patient phenotype: ‘borderline’ ID, microsomia, microcephaly.

Other variants reported as pathogenic in databases:
c.271-1G>T, Variation ID: 3767244. Hemizygous in proband with XLID, inherited from unaffected mother. Variant not in gnomAD v4, SpliceIAI = 1 Splice-Altering Strong. ClinVar submission by Kasturba Medical College, Manipal, India.

c.289del (p.Leu97fs), Variation ID: 1164055 – rated Pathogenic in ClinVar for XLID58 by Pediatric Genetics Clinic, Sheba Medical Center. Reported in an individual in clinical testing; Allele origin: inherited; Affected status: yes; Clinical Features: Neurodevelopmental delay, Attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, Abnormal cerebral white matter morphology, Short stature, Microcephaly; Test name: Whole exome sequencing; Zygosity: Hemizygote. Variant not present in gnomAD v4.

c.127dup p.(Thr43AsnfsTer42) – male patient (Patient: 318070) with intellectual disability reported in Decipher https://www.deciphergenomics.org/patient/318070/genotype/192961- variant not in gnomAD v4.

The association between TSPAN7 and non-syndromic X-linked intellectual disability was classified as Moderate by ClinGen (Intellectual Disability and Autism Gene Curation Expert Panel, Dec 2020). TSPAN7 is associated with Intellectual developmental disorder, X-linked 58 in OMIM (OMIM:300210, accessed 22 Sep 2025). Due to conflicting evidence in literature, the gene can only be rated Amber for Intellectual disability.; to: There are at least 7 unrelated families reported with mild to moderate intellectual disability with either LoF variants in TSPAN7, TSPAN7 duplication, or balanced translocations with a breakpoint within the TSPAN7 sequence. However, phenotype in most of the affected individuals does not meet the eligibility criteria of moderate/severe/profound global developmental delay/intellectual disability.

PMID: 10655063 Zemni et al., 2000: Sequencing method: DDGE + sequencing of PCR products (TSPAN7 sequence only).
Female patient with mild MR, mild autistic features, no dysmorphic features; IQ = 64 at 10yo. Heterozygous for a [46,X,t(X;2)(p11.4;p21.3)] balanced translocation affecting within TSPAN7 in a patient with mental retardation. TSPAN7 transcripts were barely detectable by RT-PCR.

Family L28, c.652G>T, p.(Gly218Ter) – IQ 45-60 in affected individuals (no age provided); authors claim variant segregates with disease, but data is not shown; RT-PCR showed normal levels of the transcript in affected patients; variant lies in a region of predicted NMD escape. Not found in gnomAD v4.1.0.

Family T15: 4 males hemizygous for c.515C>A, p.(Pro172His). IQ = 40-45 in 3 affected individuals (age 36-40 at report), individual 16 had IQ = 70 at age 10. In addition, individual 13 had low IQ (64) but did not carry the same mutation.
Conflicting evidence:
p.(Pro172His) variant-disease association disputed in PMID: 12376945 Gomot 2002 – linkage analysis in the same family excluded the TSPAN7 variant, authors suggest it to be a rare polymorphism instead.
Subsequently in PMID: 14735593 (da Costa Maranduba et al,, 2004), authors sequenced TSPAN7 in 105 males with mental retardation and found the same variant, p.Pro172His, in another patient – 21yo at time of report, delayed developmental milestones, severe speech acquisition impairment (started talking at 3.5 years); presented with dysmorphic facial features, abnormally folded ears, hypoplastic nails and alopecia spots.
Variant’s REVEL score = 0.62 (uncertain). Highest frequency in gnomAD v4 = 0.002106 (European population) – includes 2 homozygotes and 613 hemizygotes - unlikely to be causal, frequency too high.

PMID: 12070254 Abidi et al., 2002:
2-bp deletion c.572_573del p.(Val191fs) detected in a family with intellectual disability. Method: Screening exons of TM4SF2 gene only. Variant not in gnomAD v4.1.0. Family 'MRX58': five affected males in two generations with mild to moderate mental retardation (no IQ scores or ages given); affected males live in sheltered homes, are capable of doing simple jobs, and have no dysmorphic features; carrier females in the family have normal intelligence. BsrI restriction enzyme analysis determined that the deletion segregated with the XLMR in MRX58.

PMID: 22511893 Utine et al., 2012
FAMILY 1: moderately retarded 9-year-old patient and his similarly affected 11-year-old brother had infantile hypotonia and delayed motor development; did not acquire language abilities; No dysmorphic characteristics. TSPAN7 gene was duplicated. Unaffected mother had 3 copies of the same region. Copy number variation effect not yet clear as cause of ID.

PMID: 26290131 Moyses-Oliveira et al., 2015
Patient 1 - balanced translocation X;21 disrupting the 3’ UTR of TSPAN7; no TSPAN7 expression in peripheral blood sample. Authors pose that in women with balanced X-autosome translocations, the normal X chromosome is preferentially inactivated, resulting in a lack of expression. Array CGH did not cover the area of the autosomal breakpoint – effect unknown, method limitation. Patient phenotype: ‘borderline’ ID, microsomia, microcephaly.

Other variants reported as pathogenic in databases:
c.271-1G>T, Variation ID: 3767244. Hemizygous in proband with XLID, inherited from unaffected mother. Variant not in gnomAD v4, SpliceIAI = 1 Splice-Altering Strong. ClinVar submission by Kasturba Medical College, Manipal, India.

c.289del (p.Leu97fs), Variation ID: 1164055 – rated Pathogenic in ClinVar for XLID58 by Pediatric Genetics Clinic, Sheba Medical Center. Reported in an individual in clinical testing; Allele origin: inherited; Affected status: yes; Clinical Features: Neurodevelopmental delay, Attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, Abnormal cerebral white matter morphology, Short stature, Microcephaly; Test name: Whole exome sequencing; Zygosity: Hemizygote. Variant not present in gnomAD v4.

c.127dup p.(Thr43AsnfsTer42) – male patient (Patient: 318070) with intellectual disability reported in Decipher https://www.deciphergenomics.org/patient/318070/genotype/192961- variant not in gnomAD v4.

The association between TSPAN7 and non-syndromic X-linked intellectual disability was classified as Moderate by ClinGen (Intellectual Disability and Autism Gene Curation Expert Panel, Dec 2020). TSPAN7 is associated with Intellectual developmental disorder, X-linked 58 in OMIM (OMIM:300210, accessed 22 Sep 2025). Due to conflicting evidence in literature, the gene can only be rated Amber for Intellectual disability.
Intellectual disability v9.94 TSPAN7 Ida Ertmanska changed review comment from: There are at least 7 unrelated families reported with mild to moderate intellectual disability with either LoF variants in TSPAN7, TSPAN7 duplication, or balanced translocations with a breakpoint within the TSPAN7 sequence. However, phenotype in most of the affected individuals does not meet our criteria for Intellectual Disability testing, i.e. IQ<50, global developmental delay, childhood onset:

PMID: 10655063 Zemni et al., 2000: Sequencing method: DDGE + sequencing of PCR products (TSPAN7 sequence only).
Female patient with mild MR, mild autistic features, no dysmorphic features; IQ = 64 at 10yo. Heterozygous for a [46,X,t(X;2)(p11.4;p21.3)] balanced translocation affecting within TSPAN7 in a patient with mental retardation. TSPAN7 transcripts were barely detectable by RT-PCR.

Family L28, c.652G>T, p.(Gly218Ter) – IQ 45-60 in affected individuals (no age provided); authors claim variant segregates with disease, but data is not shown; RT-PCR showed normal levels of the transcript in affected patients; variant lies in a region of predicted NMD escape. Not found in gnomAD v4.1.0.

Family T15: 4 males hemizygous for c.515C>A, p.(Pro172His). IQ = 40-45 in 3 affected individuals (age 36-40 at report), individual 16 had IQ = 70 at age 10. In addition, individual 13 had low IQ (64) but did not carry the same mutation.
Conflicting evidence:
p.(Pro172His) variant-disease association disputed in PMID: 12376945 Gomot 2002 – linkage analysis in the same family excluded the TSPAN7 variant, authors suggest it to be a rare polymorphism instead.
Subsequently in PMID: 14735593 (da Costa Maranduba et al,, 2004), authors sequenced TSPAN7 in 105 males with mental retardation and found the same variant, p.Pro172His, in another patient – 21yo at time of report, delayed developmental milestones, severe speech acquisition impairment (started talking at 3.5 years); presented with dysmorphic facial features, abnormally folded ears, hypoplastic nails and alopecia spots.
Variant’s REVEL score = 0.62 (uncertain). Highest frequency in gnomAD v4 = 0.002106 (European population) – includes 2 homozygotes and 613 hemizygotes - unlikely to be causal, frequency too high.

PMID: 12070254 Abidi et al., 2002:
2-bp deletion c.572_573del p.(Val191fs) detected in a family with intellectual disability. Method: Screening exons of TM4SF2 gene only. Variant not in gnomAD v4.1.0. Family 'MRX58': five affected males in two generations with mild to moderate mental retardation (no IQ scores or ages given); affected males live in sheltered homes, are capable of doing simple jobs, and have no dysmorphic features; carrier females in the family have normal intelligence. BsrI restriction enzyme analysis determined that the deletion segregated with the XLMR in MRX58.

PMID: 22511893 Utine et al., 2012
FAMILY 1: moderately retarded 9-year-old patient and his similarly affected 11-year-old brother had infantile hypotonia and delayed motor development; did not acquire language abilities; No dysmorphic characteristics. TSPAN7 gene was duplicated. Unaffected mother had 3 copies of the same region. Copy number variation effect not yet clear as cause of ID.

PMID: 26290131 Moyses-Oliveira et al., 2015
Patient 1 - balanced translocation X;21 disrupting the 3’ UTR of TSPAN7; no TSPAN7 expression in peripheral blood sample. Authors pose that in women with balanced X-autosome translocations, the normal X chromosome is preferentially inactivated, resulting in a lack of expression. Array CGH did not cover the area of the autosomal breakpoint – effect unknown, method limitation. Patient phenotype: ‘borderline’ ID, microsomia, microcephaly.

Other variants reported as pathogenic in databases:
c.271-1G>T, Variation ID: 3767244. Hemizygous in proband with XLID, inherited from unaffected mother. Variant not in gnomAD v4, SpliceIAI = 1 Splice-Altering Strong. ClinVar submission by Kasturba Medical College, Manipal, India.

c.289del (p.Leu97fs), Variation ID: 1164055 – rated Pathogenic in ClinVar for XLID58 by Pediatric Genetics Clinic, Sheba Medical Center. Reported in an individual in clinical testing; Allele origin: inherited; Affected status: yes; Clinical Features: Neurodevelopmental delay, Attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, Abnormal cerebral white matter morphology, Short stature, Microcephaly; Test name: Whole exome sequencing; Zygosity: Hemizygote. Variant not present in gnomAD v4.

c.127dup p.(Thr43AsnfsTer42) – male patient (Patient: 318070) with intellectual disability reported in Decipher https://www.deciphergenomics.org/patient/318070/genotype/192961- variant not in gnomAD v4.

The association between TSPAN7 and non-syndromic X-linked intellectual disability was classified as Moderate by ClinGen (Intellectual Disability and Autism Gene Curation Expert Panel, Dec 2020). TSPAN7 is associated with Intellectual developmental disorder, X-linked 58 in OMIM (OMIM:300210, accessed 22 Sep 2025). Due to conflicting evidence in literature, the gene can only be rated Amber for Intellectual disability.; to: There are at least 7 unrelated families reported with mild to moderate intellectual disability with either LoF variants in TSPAN7, TSPAN7 duplication, or balanced translocations with a breakpoint within the TSPAN7 sequence. However, phenotype in most of the affected individuals does not meet our criteria for Intellectual Disability testing, i.e. IQ<50, global developmental delay, childhood onset:

PMID: 10655063 Zemni et al., 2000: Sequencing method: DDGE + sequencing of PCR products (TSPAN7 sequence only).
Female patient with mild MR, mild autistic features, no dysmorphic features; IQ = 64 at 10yo. Heterozygous for a [46,X,t(X;2)(p11.4;p21.3)] balanced translocation affecting within TSPAN7 in a patient with mental retardation. TSPAN7 transcripts were barely detectable by RT-PCR.

Family L28, c.652G>T, p.(Gly218Ter) – IQ 45-60 in affected individuals (no age provided); authors claim variant segregates with disease, but data is not shown; RT-PCR showed normal levels of the transcript in affected patients; variant lies in a region of predicted NMD escape. Not found in gnomAD v4.1.0.

Family T15: 4 males hemizygous for c.515C>A, p.(Pro172His). IQ = 40-45 in 3 affected individuals (age 36-40 at report), individual 16 had IQ = 70 at age 10. In addition, individual 13 had low IQ (64) but did not carry the same mutation.
Conflicting evidence:
p.(Pro172His) variant-disease association disputed in PMID: 12376945 Gomot 2002 – linkage analysis in the same family excluded the TSPAN7 variant, authors suggest it to be a rare polymorphism instead.
Subsequently in PMID: 14735593 (da Costa Maranduba et al,, 2004), authors sequenced TSPAN7 in 105 males with mental retardation and found the same variant, p.Pro172His, in another patient – 21yo at time of report, delayed developmental milestones, severe speech acquisition impairment (started talking at 3.5 years); presented with dysmorphic facial features, abnormally folded ears, hypoplastic nails and alopecia spots.
Variant’s REVEL score = 0.62 (uncertain). Highest frequency in gnomAD v4 = 0.002106 (European population) – includes 2 homozygotes and 613 hemizygotes - unlikely to be causal, frequency too high.

PMID: 12070254 Abidi et al., 2002:
2-bp deletion c.572_573del p.(Val191fs) detected in a family with intellectual disability. Method: Screening exons of TM4SF2 gene only. Variant not in gnomAD v4.1.0. Family 'MRX58': five affected males in two generations with mild to moderate mental retardation (no IQ scores or ages given); affected males live in sheltered homes, are capable of doing simple jobs, and have no dysmorphic features; carrier females in the family have normal intelligence. BsrI restriction enzyme analysis determined that the deletion segregated with the XLMR in MRX58.

PMID: 22511893 Utine et al., 2012
FAMILY 1: moderately retarded 9-year-old patient and his similarly affected 11-year-old brother had infantile hypotonia and delayed motor development; did not acquire language abilities; No dysmorphic characteristics. TSPAN7 gene was duplicated. Unaffected mother had 3 copies of the same region. Copy number variation effect not yet clear as cause of ID.

PMID: 26290131 Moyses-Oliveira et al., 2015
Patient 1 - balanced translocation X;21 disrupting the 3’ UTR of TSPAN7; no TSPAN7 expression in peripheral blood sample. Authors pose that in women with balanced X-autosome translocations, the normal X chromosome is preferentially inactivated, resulting in a lack of expression. Array CGH did not cover the area of the autosomal breakpoint – effect unknown, method limitation. Patient phenotype: ‘borderline’ ID, microsomia, microcephaly.

Other variants reported as pathogenic in databases:
c.271-1G>T, Variation ID: 3767244. Hemizygous in proband with XLID, inherited from unaffected mother. Variant not in gnomAD v4, SpliceIAI = 1 Splice-Altering Strong. ClinVar submission by Kasturba Medical College, Manipal, India.

c.289del (p.Leu97fs), Variation ID: 1164055 – rated Pathogenic in ClinVar for XLID58 by Pediatric Genetics Clinic, Sheba Medical Center. Reported in an individual in clinical testing; Allele origin: inherited; Affected status: yes; Clinical Features: Neurodevelopmental delay, Attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, Abnormal cerebral white matter morphology, Short stature, Microcephaly; Test name: Whole exome sequencing; Zygosity: Hemizygote. Variant not present in gnomAD v4.

c.127dup p.(Thr43AsnfsTer42) – male patient (Patient: 318070) with intellectual disability reported in Decipher https://www.deciphergenomics.org/patient/318070/genotype/192961- variant not in gnomAD v4.

The association between TSPAN7 and non-syndromic X-linked intellectual disability was classified as Moderate by ClinGen (Intellectual Disability and Autism Gene Curation Expert Panel, Dec 2020). TSPAN7 is associated with Intellectual developmental disorder, X-linked 58 in OMIM (OMIM:300210, accessed 22 Sep 2025). Due to conflicting evidence in literature, the gene can only be rated Amber for Intellectual disability.
Intellectual disability v9.94 TSPAN7 Ida Ertmanska changed review comment from: There are at least 7 unrelated families reported with mild to moderate intellectual disability with either LoF variants in TSPAN7, TSPAN7 duplication, or balanced translocations with a breakpoint within the TSPAN7 sequence. However, phenotype in most of the affected individuals does not meet our criteria for Intellectual Disability testing, i.e. IQ<50, global developmental delay, childhood onset:

PMID: 10655063 Zemni et al., 2000: Sequencing method: DDGE + sequencing of PCR products (TSPAN7 sequence only).
Female patient with mild MR, mild autistic features, no dysmorphic features; IQ = 64 at 10yo. Heterozygous for a [46,X,t(X;2)(p11.4;p21.3)] balanced translocation affecting within TSPAN7 in a patient with mental retardation. TSPAN7 transcripts were barely detectable by RT-PCR.

Family L28, c.652G>T, p.(Gly218Ter) – IQ 45-60 in affected individuals (no age provided); authors claim variant segregates with disease, but data is not shown; RT-PCR showed normal levels of the transcript in affected patients; variant lies in a region of predicted NMD escape. Not found in gnomAD v4.1.0.

Family T15: 4 males hemizygous for c.515C>A, p.(Pro172His). IQ = 40-45 in 3 affected individuals (age 36-40 at report), individual 16 had IQ = 70 at age 10. In addition, individual 13 had low IQ (64) but did not carry the same mutation.
Conflicting evidence:
p.(Pro172His) variant-disease association disputed in PMID: 12376945 Gomot 2002 – linkage analysis in the same family excluded the TSPAN7 variant, authors suggest it to be a rare polymorphism instead.
Subsequently in PMID: 14735593 (da Costa Maranduba et al,, 2004), authors sequenced TSPAN7 in 105 males with mental retardation and found the same variant, p.Pro172His, in another patient – 21yo at time of report, delayed developmental milestones, severe speech acquisition impairment (started talking at 3.5 years); presented with dysmorphic facial features, abnormally folded ears, hypoplastic nails and alopecia spots.
Variant’s REVEL score = 0.62 (uncertain). Highest frequency in gnomAD v4 = 0.002106 (European population) – includes 2 homozygotes and 613 hemizygotes - unlikely to be causal, frequency too high.

PMID: 12070254 Abidi et al., 2002:
2-bp deletion c.572_573del p.(Val191fs) detected in a family with intellectual disability. Method: Screening exons of TM4SF2 gene only. Variant not in gnomAD v4.1.0. Family 'MRX58': five affected males in two generations with mild to moderate mental retardation (no IQ scores or ages given); affected males live in sheltered homes, are capable of doing simple jobs, and have no dysmorphic features; carrier females in the family have normal intelligence. BsrI restriction enzyme analysis determined that the deletion segregated with the XLMR in MRX58.

PMID: 22511893 Utine et al., 2012
FAMILY 1: moderately retarded 9-year-old patient and his similarly affected 11-year-old brother had infantile hypotonia and delayed motor development; did not acquire language abilities; No dysmorphic characteristics. TSPAN7 gene was duplicated. Unaffected mother had 3 copies of the same region. Copy number variation effect not yet clear as cause of ID.

PMID: 26290131 Moyses-Oliveira et al., 2015
Patient 1 - balanced translocation X;21 disrupting the 3’ UTR of TSPAN7; no TSPAN7 expression in peripheral blood sample. Authors pose that in women with balanced X-autosome translocations, the normal X chromosome is preferentially inactivated, resulting in a lack of expression. Array CGH did not cover the area of the autosomal breakpoint – effect unknown, method limitation. Patient phenotype: ‘borderline’ ID, microsomia, microcephaly.

Other variants reported as pathogenic in databases:
c.271-1G>T in intron 2 of TSPAN7 hemizygous in proband with XLID, inherited from unaffected mother. Variant not in gnomAD v4, SpliceIAI = 1 Splice-Altering Strong. ClinVar submission by Kasturba Medical College, Manipal, India.

c.289del (p.Leu97fs) – rated Pathogenic in ClinVar for XLID58 by Pediatric Genetics Clinic, Sheba Medical Center. Collection method: clinical testing; Allele origin: inherited; Affected status: yes; Clinical Features: Neurodevelopmental delay, Attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, Abnormal cerebral white matter morphology, Short stature, Microcephaly; Test name: Whole exome sequencing; Zygosity: Hemizygote. Variant not present in gnomAD v4.

c.127dup p.(Thr43AsnfsTer42) – male patient (Patient: 318070) with intellectual disability reported in Decipher https://www.deciphergenomics.org/patient/318070/genotype/192961/browser - variant not in gnomAD v4.

The association between TSPAN7 and non-syndromic X-linked intellectual disability was classified as Moderate by ClinGen (Intellectual Disability and Autism Gene Curation Expert Panel, Dec 2020). TSPAN7 is associated with Intellectual developmental disorder, X-linked 58 in OMIM (OMIM:300210, accessed 22 Sep 2025). Due to conflicting evidence in literature, the gene can only be rated Amber for Intellectual disability.; to: There are at least 7 unrelated families reported with mild to moderate intellectual disability with either LoF variants in TSPAN7, TSPAN7 duplication, or balanced translocations with a breakpoint within the TSPAN7 sequence. However, phenotype in most of the affected individuals does not meet our criteria for Intellectual Disability testing, i.e. IQ<50, global developmental delay, childhood onset:

PMID: 10655063 Zemni et al., 2000: Sequencing method: DDGE + sequencing of PCR products (TSPAN7 sequence only).
Female patient with mild MR, mild autistic features, no dysmorphic features; IQ = 64 at 10yo. Heterozygous for a [46,X,t(X;2)(p11.4;p21.3)] balanced translocation affecting within TSPAN7 in a patient with mental retardation. TSPAN7 transcripts were barely detectable by RT-PCR.

Family L28, c.652G>T, p.(Gly218Ter) – IQ 45-60 in affected individuals (no age provided); authors claim variant segregates with disease, but data is not shown; RT-PCR showed normal levels of the transcript in affected patients; variant lies in a region of predicted NMD escape. Not found in gnomAD v4.1.0.

Family T15: 4 males hemizygous for c.515C>A, p.(Pro172His). IQ = 40-45 in 3 affected individuals (age 36-40 at report), individual 16 had IQ = 70 at age 10. In addition, individual 13 had low IQ (64) but did not carry the same mutation.
Conflicting evidence:
p.(Pro172His) variant-disease association disputed in PMID: 12376945 Gomot 2002 – linkage analysis in the same family excluded the TSPAN7 variant, authors suggest it to be a rare polymorphism instead.
Subsequently in PMID: 14735593 (da Costa Maranduba et al,, 2004), authors sequenced TSPAN7 in 105 males with mental retardation and found the same variant, p.Pro172His, in another patient – 21yo at time of report, delayed developmental milestones, severe speech acquisition impairment (started talking at 3.5 years); presented with dysmorphic facial features, abnormally folded ears, hypoplastic nails and alopecia spots.
Variant’s REVEL score = 0.62 (uncertain). Highest frequency in gnomAD v4 = 0.002106 (European population) – includes 2 homozygotes and 613 hemizygotes - unlikely to be causal, frequency too high.

PMID: 12070254 Abidi et al., 2002:
2-bp deletion c.572_573del p.(Val191fs) detected in a family with intellectual disability. Method: Screening exons of TM4SF2 gene only. Variant not in gnomAD v4.1.0. Family 'MRX58': five affected males in two generations with mild to moderate mental retardation (no IQ scores or ages given); affected males live in sheltered homes, are capable of doing simple jobs, and have no dysmorphic features; carrier females in the family have normal intelligence. BsrI restriction enzyme analysis determined that the deletion segregated with the XLMR in MRX58.

PMID: 22511893 Utine et al., 2012
FAMILY 1: moderately retarded 9-year-old patient and his similarly affected 11-year-old brother had infantile hypotonia and delayed motor development; did not acquire language abilities; No dysmorphic characteristics. TSPAN7 gene was duplicated. Unaffected mother had 3 copies of the same region. Copy number variation effect not yet clear as cause of ID.

PMID: 26290131 Moyses-Oliveira et al., 2015
Patient 1 - balanced translocation X;21 disrupting the 3’ UTR of TSPAN7; no TSPAN7 expression in peripheral blood sample. Authors pose that in women with balanced X-autosome translocations, the normal X chromosome is preferentially inactivated, resulting in a lack of expression. Array CGH did not cover the area of the autosomal breakpoint – effect unknown, method limitation. Patient phenotype: ‘borderline’ ID, microsomia, microcephaly.

Other variants reported as pathogenic in databases:
c.271-1G>T, Variation ID: 3767244. Hemizygous in proband with XLID, inherited from unaffected mother. Variant not in gnomAD v4, SpliceIAI = 1 Splice-Altering Strong. ClinVar submission by Kasturba Medical College, Manipal, India.

c.289del (p.Leu97fs), Variation ID: 1164055 – rated Pathogenic in ClinVar for XLID58 by Pediatric Genetics Clinic, Sheba Medical Center. Reported in an individual in clinical testing; Allele origin: inherited; Affected status: yes; Clinical Features: Neurodevelopmental delay, Attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, Abnormal cerebral white matter morphology, Short stature, Microcephaly; Test name: Whole exome sequencing; Zygosity: Hemizygote. Variant not present in gnomAD v4.

c.127dup p.(Thr43AsnfsTer42) – male patient (Patient: 318070) with intellectual disability reported in Decipher https://www.deciphergenomics.org/patient/318070/genotype/192961- variant not in gnomAD v4.

The association between TSPAN7 and non-syndromic X-linked intellectual disability was classified as Moderate by ClinGen (Intellectual Disability and Autism Gene Curation Expert Panel, Dec 2020). TSPAN7 is associated with Intellectual developmental disorder, X-linked 58 in OMIM (OMIM:300210, accessed 22 Sep 2025). Due to conflicting evidence in literature, the gene can only be rated Amber for Intellectual disability.
Intellectual disability v9.94 TSPAN7 Ida Ertmanska changed review comment from: There are at least 7 unrelated families reported with mild to moderate intellectual disability with either LoF variants in TSPAN7, TSPAN7 duplication, or balanced translocations with a breakpoint within the TSPAN7 sequence. However, phenotype in most of the affected individuals does not meet our criteria for Intellectual Disability testing, i.e. IQ<50, global developmental delay, childhood onset:

PMID: 10655063 Zemni et al., 2000: Sequencing method: DDGE + sequencing of PCR products (TSPAN7 sequence only).
Female patient with mild MR, mild autistic features, no dysmorphic features; IQ = 64 at 10yo. Heterozygous for a [46,X,t(X;2)(p11.4;p21.3)] balanced translocation affecting within TSPAN7 in a patient with mental retardation. TSPAN7 transcripts were barely detectable by RT-PCR.

Family L28, c.652G>T, p.(Gly218Ter) – IQ 45-60 in affected individuals (no age provided); authors claim variant segregates with disease, but data is not shown; RT-PCR showed normal levels of the transcript in affected patients; variant lies in a region of predicted NMD escape. Not found in gnomAD v4.1.0.

Family T15: 4 males hemizygous for c.515C>A, p.(Pro172His). IQ = 40-45 in 3 affected individuals (age 36-40 at report), individual 16 had IQ = 70 at age 10. In addition, individual 13 had low IQ (64) but did not carry the same mutation.
Conflicting evidence:
p.(Pro172His) variant-disease association disputed in PMID: 12376945 Gomot 2002 – linkage analysis in the same family excluded the TSPAN7 variant, authors suggest it to be a rare polymorphism instead.
Subsequently in PMID: 14735593 (da Costa Maranduba et al,, 2004), authors sequenced TSPAN7 in 105 males with mental retardation and found the same variant, p.Pro172His, in another patient – 21yo at time of report, delayed developmental milestones, severe speech acquisition impairment (started talking at 3.5 years); presented with dysmorphic facial features, abnormally folded ears, hypoplastic nails and alopecia spots.
Variant’s REVEL score = 0.62 (uncertain). Highest frequency in gnomAD v4 = 0.002106 (European population) – includes 2 homozygotes and 613 hemizygotes - unlikely to be causal, frequency too high.

PMID: 12070254 Abidi et al., 2002:
2-bp deletion c.572_573del p.(Val191fs) detected in a family with intellectual disability. Method: Screening exons of TM4SF2 gene only. Variant not in gnomAD v4.1.0. Family 'MRX58': five affected males in two generations with mild to moderate mental retardation (no IQ scores or ages given); affected males live in sheltered homes, are capable of doing simple jobs, and have no dysmorphic features; carrier females in the family have normal intelligence. BsrI restriction enzyme analysis determined that the deletion segregated with the XLMR in MRX58.

PMID: 22511893 Utine et al., 2012
FAMILY 1: moderately retarded 9-year-old patient and his similarly affected 11-year-old brother had infantile hypotonia and delayed motor development; did not acquire language abilities; No dysmorphic characteristics. TSPAN7 gene was duplicated. Unaffected mother had 3 copies of the same region. Copy number variation effect not yet clear as cause of ID.

PMID: 26290131 Moyses-Oliveira et al., 2015
Patient 1 - balanced translocation X;21 disrupting the 3’ UTR of TSPAN7; no TSPAN7 expression in peripheral blood sample. Authors pose that in women with balanced X-autosome translocations, the normal X chromosome is preferentially inactivated, resulting in a lack of expression. Array CGH did not cover the area of the autosomal breakpoint – effect unknown, method limitation. Patient phenotype: ‘borderline’ ID, microsomia, microcephaly.

Other variants reported as pathogenic in databases:
c.271-1G>T in intron 2 of TSPAN7 hemizygous in proband with XLID, inherited from unaffected mother. Variant not in gnomAD v4, SpliceIAI = 1 Splice-Altering Strong. ClinVar submission by Kasturba Medical College, Manipal, India.

c.289del (p.Leu97fs) – rated Pathogenic in ClinVar for XLID58 by Pediatric Genetics Clinic, Sheba Medical Center. Collection method: clinical testing; Allele origin: inherited; Affected status: yes; Clinical Features: Neurodevelopmental delay, Attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, Abnormal cerebral white matter morphology, Short stature, Microcephaly; Test name: Whole exome sequencing; Zygosity: Hemizygote. Variant not present in gnomAD v4.

c.127dup p.(Thr43AsnfsTer42) – male patient (Patient: 318070) with intellectual disability reported in Decipher https://www.deciphergenomics.org/patient/318070/genotype/192961/browser - variant not in gnomAD v4.

The association between TSPAN7 and non-syndromic X-linked intellectual disability was classified as Moderate by ClinGen (Intellectual Disability and Autism Gene Curation Expert Panel, Dec 2020). TSPAN7 is associated with Intellectual developmental disorder, X-linked 58 in OMIM (OMIM:300210, accessed 22 Sep 2025). Due to conflicting evidence in literature, the gene can only be rated Amber for Intellectual disability.; to: There are at least 7 unrelated families reported with mild to moderate intellectual disability with either LoF variants in TSPAN7, TSPAN7 duplication, or balanced translocations with a breakpoint within the TSPAN7 sequence. However, phenotype in most of the affected individuals does not meet our criteria for Intellectual Disability testing, i.e. IQ<50, global developmental delay, childhood onset:

PMID: 10655063 Zemni et al., 2000: Sequencing method: DDGE + sequencing of PCR products (TSPAN7 sequence only).
Female patient with mild MR, mild autistic features, no dysmorphic features; IQ = 64 at 10yo. Heterozygous for a [46,X,t(X;2)(p11.4;p21.3)] balanced translocation affecting within TSPAN7 in a patient with mental retardation. TSPAN7 transcripts were barely detectable by RT-PCR.

Family L28, c.652G>T, p.(Gly218Ter) – IQ 45-60 in affected individuals (no age provided); authors claim variant segregates with disease, but data is not shown; RT-PCR showed normal levels of the transcript in affected patients; variant lies in a region of predicted NMD escape. Not found in gnomAD v4.1.0.

Family T15: 4 males hemizygous for c.515C>A, p.(Pro172His). IQ = 40-45 in 3 affected individuals (age 36-40 at report), individual 16 had IQ = 70 at age 10. In addition, individual 13 had low IQ (64) but did not carry the same mutation.
Conflicting evidence:
p.(Pro172His) variant-disease association disputed in PMID: 12376945 Gomot 2002 – linkage analysis in the same family excluded the TSPAN7 variant, authors suggest it to be a rare polymorphism instead.
Subsequently in PMID: 14735593 (da Costa Maranduba et al,, 2004), authors sequenced TSPAN7 in 105 males with mental retardation and found the same variant, p.Pro172His, in another patient – 21yo at time of report, delayed developmental milestones, severe speech acquisition impairment (started talking at 3.5 years); presented with dysmorphic facial features, abnormally folded ears, hypoplastic nails and alopecia spots.
Variant’s REVEL score = 0.62 (uncertain). Highest frequency in gnomAD v4 = 0.002106 (European population) – includes 2 homozygotes and 613 hemizygotes - unlikely to be causal, frequency too high.

PMID: 12070254 Abidi et al., 2002:
2-bp deletion c.572_573del p.(Val191fs) detected in a family with intellectual disability. Method: Screening exons of TM4SF2 gene only. Variant not in gnomAD v4.1.0. Family 'MRX58': five affected males in two generations with mild to moderate mental retardation (no IQ scores or ages given); affected males live in sheltered homes, are capable of doing simple jobs, and have no dysmorphic features; carrier females in the family have normal intelligence. BsrI restriction enzyme analysis determined that the deletion segregated with the XLMR in MRX58.

PMID: 22511893 Utine et al., 2012
FAMILY 1: moderately retarded 9-year-old patient and his similarly affected 11-year-old brother had infantile hypotonia and delayed motor development; did not acquire language abilities; No dysmorphic characteristics. TSPAN7 gene was duplicated. Unaffected mother had 3 copies of the same region. Copy number variation effect not yet clear as cause of ID.

PMID: 26290131 Moyses-Oliveira et al., 2015
Patient 1 - balanced translocation X;21 disrupting the 3’ UTR of TSPAN7; no TSPAN7 expression in peripheral blood sample. Authors pose that in women with balanced X-autosome translocations, the normal X chromosome is preferentially inactivated, resulting in a lack of expression. Array CGH did not cover the area of the autosomal breakpoint – effect unknown, method limitation. Patient phenotype: ‘borderline’ ID, microsomia, microcephaly.

Other variants reported as pathogenic in databases:
c.271-1G>T in intron 2 of TSPAN7 hemizygous in proband with XLID, inherited from unaffected mother. Variant not in gnomAD v4, SpliceIAI = 1 Splice-Altering Strong. ClinVar submission by Kasturba Medical College, Manipal, India.

c.289del (p.Leu97fs) – rated Pathogenic in ClinVar for XLID58 by Pediatric Genetics Clinic, Sheba Medical Center. Collection method: clinical testing; Allele origin: inherited; Affected status: yes; Clinical Features: Neurodevelopmental delay, Attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, Abnormal cerebral white matter morphology, Short stature, Microcephaly; Test name: Whole exome sequencing; Zygosity: Hemizygote. Variant not present in gnomAD v4.

c.127dup p.(Thr43AsnfsTer42) – male patient (Patient: 318070) with intellectual disability reported in Decipher https://www.deciphergenomics.org/patient/318070/genotype/192961/browser - variant not in gnomAD v4.

The association between TSPAN7 and non-syndromic X-linked intellectual disability was classified as Moderate by ClinGen (Intellectual Disability and Autism Gene Curation Expert Panel, Dec 2020). TSPAN7 is associated with Intellectual developmental disorder, X-linked 58 in OMIM (OMIM:300210, accessed 22 Sep 2025). Due to conflicting evidence in literature, the gene can only be rated Amber for Intellectual disability.
Intellectual disability v9.51 RREB1 Karen Stals gene: RREB1 was added
gene: RREB1 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: RREB1 was set to MONOALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal, NOT imprinted
Publications for gene: RREB1 were set to PMID: 40418122
Phenotypes for gene: RREB1 were set to Rasopathy; Noonan-like; developmental disorder
Penetrance for gene: RREB1 were set to Complete
Review for gene: RREB1 was set to GREEN
Added comment: 6 additional individuals with truncating variants in RREB1 gene and a Rasopathy phenotype, features including congenital heart disease, developmental delay, short stature, and dysmorphic facial features (PMID: 40418122). RREB1 encodes a transcriptional repressor of Ras-MAPK signalling. Supporting functional evidence and animal models.
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v9.31 CRNKL1 Achchuthan Shanmugasundram gene: CRNKL1 was added
gene: CRNKL1 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: CRNKL1 was set to MONOALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal, NOT imprinted
Publications for gene: CRNKL1 were set to https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ajhg.2025.05.013
Phenotypes for gene: CRNKL1 were set to complex neurodevelopmental disorder, MONDO:0100038
Review for gene: CRNKL1 was set to GREEN
Added comment: There are 10 unrelated patents identified with de novo missense variants in the spliceosomal component CRNKL1, where nine of them harboured one of the two missense variants affecting the same amino acid residue, Arg 267 (p.Arg267Cys & p.Arg267His), while the tenth patient harboured a different variant (p.Arg301Gly). All affected individuals share a common and specific phenotype: profound pre- and post-natal microcephaly (8 of 10 patients), with pontocerebellar hypoplasia (9 patients), seizures (8 patients), and severe intellectual disability (8 patients).

Microinjection of mRNA encoding Crnkl1 variant into a zebrafish model caused a severe lack of brain development accompanied by a significant reduction in proliferating cells and widespread cellular stress, as indicated by p53 staining. RNA sequencing analysis of injected zebrafish embryos showed broad transcriptomic changes, with altered expression of neuronal and cell cycle genes.

This gene has not yet been associated with relevant phenotypes in OMIM or in Gene2Phenotype.
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v8.163 DDX39B Mike Spiller gene: DDX39B was added
gene: DDX39B was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: DDX39B was set to MONOALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal, NOT imprinted
Publications for gene: DDX39B were set to PMID: 39918047
Review for gene: DDX39B was set to GREEN
Added comment: PMID: 39918047 - report 4 de novo missense variants in individuals with phenotypes of ID ranging from mild to severe (2 severe, 1 mild, 1 severity not stated but phenotype of GDD).
Hypotonia, short stature and skeletal abnormalities are also observed frequently.
Variants absent from gnomad, affect highly conserved amino acids in constrained regions of DEAD/DEAH box helicase domain.

Splice variant causing inframe deletion also identified in fifth family (proband and mother), but significance of this unclear as neither has ID.

Supported by functional studies:
Transcriptome profiling shows significant increase in abberant splicing events, consistent with DDX39B role as splicing factor.
Drosophila experiments - overexpression of WT human gene is lethal, but flies overexpressing variants were healthy, suggesting these variants cause loss of / reduced protein function.

Overall good evidence for DEAD box helicase missenses causing an autosomal dominant syndromic ID disorder.
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v8.16 LINC01578 Zornitza Stark gene: LINC01578 was added
gene: LINC01578 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: LINC01578 was set to MONOALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal, NOT imprinted
Publications for gene: LINC01578 were set to 39442041
Phenotypes for gene: LINC01578 were set to Neurodevelopmental disorder, MONDO:0700092, CHASERR-related
Review for gene: LINC01578 was set to GREEN
Added comment: CHASERR (aka LINC01578) encodes a human long noncoding RNA (lncRNA) adjacent to CHD2, a coding gene in which de novo loss-of-function variants cause developmental and epileptic encephalopathy. Three unrelated children reported with a syndromic, early-onset neurodevelopmental disorder, each of whom had a de novo deletion in the CHASERR locus. The children had severe encephalopathy, shared facial dysmorphisms, cortical atrophy, and cerebral hypomyelination - a phenotype that is distinct from the phenotypes of patients with CHD2 haploinsufficiency. CHASERR deletion results in increased CHD2 protein abundance in patient-derived cell lines and increased expression of the CHD2 transcript in cis, indicating bidirectional dosage sensitivity in human disease.
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v7.39 LRRC7 Andrew Mumford gene: LRRC7 was added
gene: LRRC7 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Expert Review,Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: LRRC7 was set to MONOALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal, NOT imprinted
Publications for gene: LRRC7 were set to (PMID: 36928819):(PMID: 39256359)
Phenotypes for gene: LRRC7 were set to neurodevelopmental abnormality; intelelctual disability; autism; abnormal earting behaviours
Penetrance for gene: LRRC7 were set to Complete
Review for gene: LRRC7 was set to GREEN
Added comment: The association between monoallelic rare LoF variants in LRRC7 and disease class 'intellectual disability' in 100KGP participants was reported first in in 2023 (PMID 36928819).

Detailed phenotype descriptions of the nine pedigrees in the 100KGP discovery collection plus a further sixteen pedigrees in a multicentre european case collection were subsequently published in 2024 (33 affected cases in total; PMID 39256359). This paper confirms functional impact of observed variants on synaptic targeting of the encoded protein Densin-180 in a manner consistent with human phenotype.
Sources: Expert Review, Literature
Intellectual disability v5.487 ZFX Sarah Leigh changed review comment from: A single ZFX variant has been associated with a neurodevelopmental disorder, that has a Rett syndrome-like phenotype disorder, in a 14 year old male. The ZFX variant was allelic with another X-linked variant in SHROOM4. These variants were inherited from the mother, who had random X inactivation pattern (PMID: 26740508).
PMID: 38325380 reports 11 ZFX variants in 18 subjects from 16 unrelated families (14 males and 4 females) with an X-linked neurodevelopmental disorder with recurrent facial gestalt. Seven variants were truncating and the remaining were missense variants within the Zinc finger array. In the pedigree of family 6 (figure 3, PMID: 38325380), it was apparent that there were female carriers of the ZFX variant (GRCh38 chrX: 24229396A>G, c.2438A>G, p.Tyr774Cys) with hyperparathyroidism and two affected males and one affected female, with the neurodevelopmental disorder. It appeared that skewed X-inactivation in the female carriers was responsible for the different phenotypic features. The association between ZFX variants and a novel neurodevelopmental disorder, was further supported by functional studies showing altered transcriptional activity in missense variants and altered behavior in a zebrafish loss-of-function model.; to: To date, germline variants in ZFX have not been associated with a phenotype in OMIM or Gen2Phen.
A single ZFX variant has been associated with a neurodevelopmental disorder, that has a Rett syndrome-like phenotype disorder, in a 14 year old male. The ZFX variant was allelic with another X-linked variant in SHROOM4. These variants were inherited from the mother, who had random X inactivation pattern (PMID: 26740508).
PMID: 38325380 reports 11 ZFX variants in 18 subjects from 16 unrelated families (14 males and 4 females) with an X-linked neurodevelopmental disorder with recurrent facial gestalt. Seven variants were truncating and the remaining were missense variants within the Zinc finger array. In the pedigree of family 6 (figure 3, PMID: 38325380), it was apparent that there were female carriers of the ZFX variant (GRCh38 chrX: 24229396A>G, c.2438A>G, p.Tyr774Cys) with hyperparathyroidism and two affected males and one affected female, with the neurodevelopmental disorder. It appeared that skewed X-inactivation in the female carriers was responsible for the different phenotypic features. The association between ZFX variants and a novel neurodevelopmental disorder, was further supported by functional studies showing altered transcriptional activity in missense variants and altered behavior in a zebrafish loss-of-function model.
Intellectual disability v5.389 CLDN11 Achchuthan Shanmugasundram gene: CLDN11 was added
gene: CLDN11 was added to Intellectual disability - microarray and sequencing. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: CLDN11 was set to MONOALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal, NOT imprinted
Publications for gene: CLDN11 were set to 33313762
Phenotypes for gene: CLDN11 were set to Leukodystrophy, hypomyelinating, 22, OMIM:619328
Review for gene: CLDN11 was set to GREEN
Added comment: PMID:33313762 reported three unrelated individuals with early-onset spastic movement disorder, expressive speech disorder and eye abnormalities including hypermetropia. These patients exhibit global developmental delay, particularly motor and speech delay. Intellectual disability was maximally mild in two of three individuals and the intelligence is in a low-normal range in third individual, although IQ testing was not performed in them.

Two different heterozygous de novo stop-loss variants were identified in these patients. One of the variants did not lead to a loss of CLDN11 expression on RNA level in fibroblasts indicating this transcript is not subject to nonsense-mediated decay and most likely translated into an extended protein.

This gene has been associated with hypomyelinating leukodystrophy in OMIM, which includes global developmental delay and impaired intellectual development (mild) as clinical presentations. However, this gene has not yet been associated with phenotypes in Gene2Phenotype.
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v5.347 PSMC3 Achchuthan Shanmugasundram changed review comment from: PMID:32500975 - Three individuals from a single extended consanguineous Turkish pedigree was reported with early-onset and rapidly progressive deafness, early-onset cataract, severe developmental delay, severely impaired intellectual development, subcutaneous calcifications and peripheral neuropathy. There were identified with homozygous variant in PSMC3 gene (c.1127 + 337A>G). Functional studies in patient fibroblast cells suggested that the patient PSMC3 variant is responsible for proteasome failure affecting protein homeostasis under stress conditions. This is also supported by evidence from zebrafish models, where PSMC3 knockout has reproduced the human phenotype with inner ear development anomalies as well as cataracts.

PMID:37256937 - 23 individuals with neurodevelopmental disorder were identified with 15 different de novo missense variants. Apart from one child (patient 2), all others had developmental delay characterised by speech delay (19/19) alone or with intellectual disability (16/18) and motor delay (15/19). In addition, structural modeling as well as proteomic and transcriptomic analyses of T cells derived from patients with PSMC3 variants implicated the PSMC3 variants in proteasome dysfunction through disruption of substrate translocation, induction of proteotoxic stress, and alterations in proteins controlling developmental and innate immune program.

The phenotype caused by recessive PSMC3 variants has been reported in OMIM (MIM #619354), but not in Gene2Phenotype. However, the phenotype caused by dominant variants has not yet been reported in either resources.; to: PMID:32500975 - Three individuals from a single extended consanguineous Turkish pedigree was reported with early-onset and rapidly progressive deafness, early-onset cataract, severe developmental delay, severely impaired intellectual development, subcutaneous calcifications and peripheral neuropathy. They were identified with homozygous variant in PSMC3 gene (c.1127 + 337A>G). Functional studies in patient fibroblast cells suggested that the patient PSMC3 variant is responsible for proteasome failure affecting protein homeostasis under stress conditions. This is also supported by evidence from zebrafish models, where PSMC3 knockout has reproduced the human phenotype with inner ear development anomalies as well as cataracts.

PMID:37256937 - 23 individuals with neurodevelopmental disorder were identified with 15 different de novo missense variants. Apart from one child (patient 2), all others had developmental delay characterised by speech delay (19/19) alone or with intellectual disability (16/18) and motor delay (15/19). In addition, structural modeling as well as proteomic and transcriptomic analyses of T cells derived from patients with PSMC3 variants implicated the PSMC3 variants in proteasome dysfunction through disruption of substrate translocation, induction of proteotoxic stress, and alterations in proteins controlling developmental and innate immune program.

The phenotype caused by recessive PSMC3 variants has been reported in OMIM (MIM #619354), but not in Gene2Phenotype. However, the phenotype caused by dominant variants has not yet been reported in either resources.
Intellectual disability v5.347 PSMC3 Achchuthan Shanmugasundram changed review comment from: PMID:32500975 - Three individuals from a single extended consanguineous Turkish pedigree was reported with early-onset and rapidly progressive deafness, early-onset cataract, severe developmental delay, severely impaired intellectual development, subcutaneous calcifications and peripheral neuropathy. There were identified with homozygous variant in PSMC3 gene (c.1127 + 337A>G). Functional studies in patient fibroblast cells suggested that the patient PSMC3 variant is responsible for proteasome failure affecting protein homeostasis under stress conditions. This is also supported by evidence from zebrafish models, where PSMC3 knockout has reproduced the human phenotype with inner ear development anomalies as well as cataracts.

PMID:37256937 - 23 individuals with neurodevelopmental disorder was identified with 15 different de novo missense variants. Apart from one child (patient 2), all others had developmental delay characterised by speech delay (19/19) alone or with intellectual disability (16/18) and motor delay (15/19). In addition, structural modeling as well as proteomic and transcriptomic analyses of T cells derived from patients with PSMC3 variants implicated the PSMC3 variants in proteasome dysfunction through disruption of substrate translocation, induction of proteotoxic stress, and alterations in proteins controlling developmental and innate immune program.

The phenotype caused by recessive PSMC3 variants has been reported in OMIM (MIM #619354), but not in Gene2Phenotype. However, the phenotype caused by dominant variants has not yet been reported in either resources.; to: PMID:32500975 - Three individuals from a single extended consanguineous Turkish pedigree was reported with early-onset and rapidly progressive deafness, early-onset cataract, severe developmental delay, severely impaired intellectual development, subcutaneous calcifications and peripheral neuropathy. There were identified with homozygous variant in PSMC3 gene (c.1127 + 337A>G). Functional studies in patient fibroblast cells suggested that the patient PSMC3 variant is responsible for proteasome failure affecting protein homeostasis under stress conditions. This is also supported by evidence from zebrafish models, where PSMC3 knockout has reproduced the human phenotype with inner ear development anomalies as well as cataracts.

PMID:37256937 - 23 individuals with neurodevelopmental disorder were identified with 15 different de novo missense variants. Apart from one child (patient 2), all others had developmental delay characterised by speech delay (19/19) alone or with intellectual disability (16/18) and motor delay (15/19). In addition, structural modeling as well as proteomic and transcriptomic analyses of T cells derived from patients with PSMC3 variants implicated the PSMC3 variants in proteasome dysfunction through disruption of substrate translocation, induction of proteotoxic stress, and alterations in proteins controlling developmental and innate immune program.

The phenotype caused by recessive PSMC3 variants has been reported in OMIM (MIM #619354), but not in Gene2Phenotype. However, the phenotype caused by dominant variants has not yet been reported in either resources.
Intellectual disability v5.332 AGPAT3 Zornitza Stark gene: AGPAT3 was added
gene: AGPAT3 was added to Intellectual disability - microarray and sequencing. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: AGPAT3 was set to BIALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal
Publications for gene: AGPAT3 were set to 37821758
Phenotypes for gene: AGPAT3 were set to Neurodevelopmental disorder (MONDO#0700092), AGPAT3-related
Review for gene: AGPAT3 was set to AMBER
Added comment: - Single consanguineous family with four individuals with severe intellectual disability and retinitis pigmentosa
- All affected individuals were homozygous for a nonsense variant in AGPAT3, healthy unaffected individuals who were tested were heterozygous for the variant
- Overexpression of mutant transcript revealed absence of AGPAT3 protein compared to WT transcript via Western blot analysis
- KO AGPAT3 mouse demonstrated impaired neuronal migration
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v5.271 ESAM Julia Baptista gene: ESAM was added
gene: ESAM was added to Intellectual disability - microarray and sequencing. Sources: Literature,Expert Review
Mode of inheritance for gene: ESAM was set to BIALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal
Publications for gene: ESAM were set to PMID: 36996813
Phenotypes for gene: ESAM were set to severe ID; seizures, spasticity
Review for gene: ESAM was set to GREEN
Added comment: Lecca et al 2023 reported thirteen patients from eight unrelated families with biallelic loss of function variants (nonsense, frameshift, canonical splice site, all predicted to result in a transcript targeted for nonsense-mediated decay). Protein staining assays in one of the brain fetal samples confirmed loss the loss of protein.
The phenotype reported in this cohort is of a severe neurodevelopmental disorder with brain anomalies (calcifications, hydrocephalus, enlarged ventricles, cerebral atrophy, etc), and dysmorphic features.
Sources: Literature, Expert Review
Intellectual disability v4.92 NUP214 Eleanor Williams changed review comment from: Associated with {Encephalopathy, acute, infection-induced, susceptibility to, 9} 618426 in OMIM and Gene2Phenotype (probable).

PMID: 31178128 - Fichtman et al 2019 - report on two families one of Palestinian decent, the other Northern European (not Finnish descent). Each had two affected siblings in which neurological decline was seen after febrile events. The older son in family A, exhibited minor developmental delay from infancy. A homozygous missense variant was identified in NUP214 (p.Arg38Cys) in family A and segregated with the disease in available family members. In family B affected sisters were compound heterozygous for a frameshift and a missense variant in NUP214 (p.Pro387Ser and p.Pro525Leufs∗6). Functional studies with fibroblasts from one patient in family A showed a decrease in NUP214 and NUP88 levels compared to controls,

PMID: 30758658 - Shamseldin et al 2019 - describe a multiplex consanguineous family in which four affected members presented with severe neonatal hypotonia, profound global developmental delay, progressive microcephaly and early death (<2 year old). Whole exome sequencing revealed the presence of a novel homozygous missense variant in NUP214, p.D154G.

PMID: 29483668 - Egloff et al 2018 - report a 4-year-old girl presenting with developmental delay, growth retardation and facial dysmorphism. She was found to have a 9q deletion inherited from her healthy mother and a hemizygous one-base pair deletion in the NUP214 gene inherited from her father. From patient leukocytes it was found that the expression level of the NUP214 transcript was significantly decreased and close to zero in the patient compared to the controls. ; to: Associated with {Encephalopathy, acute, infection-induced, susceptibility to, 9} 618426 in OMIM and Gene2Phenotype (probable).

PMID: 31178128 - Fichtman et al 2019 - report on two families one of Palestinian decent, the other Northern European (not Finnish descent). Each had two affected family members in which neurological decline was seen after febrile events. The older son in family A, exhibited minor developmental delay from infancy. A homozygous missense variant was identified in NUP214 (p.Arg38Cys) in family A and segregated with the disease in available family members. In family B affected sisters were compound heterozygous for a frameshift and a missense variant in NUP214 (p.Pro387Ser and p.Pro525Leufs∗6). Functional studies with fibroblasts from one patient in family A showed a decrease in NUP214 and NUP88 levels compared to controls,

PMID: 30758658 - Shamseldin et al 2019 - describe a multiplex consanguineous family in which four affected members presented with severe neonatal hypotonia, profound global developmental delay, progressive microcephaly and early death (<2 year old). Whole exome sequencing revealed the presence of a novel homozygous missense variant in NUP214, p.D154G.

PMID: 29483668 - Egloff et al 2018 - report a 4-year-old girl presenting with developmental delay, growth retardation and facial dysmorphism. She was found to have a 9q deletion inherited from her healthy mother and a hemizygous one-base pair deletion in the NUP214 gene inherited from her father. From patient leukocytes it was found that the expression level of the NUP214 transcript was significantly decreased and close to zero in the patient compared to the controls.
Intellectual disability v3.1719 DCHS2 Sarah Leigh Added comment: Comment on phenotypes: This Mondo term is a general description and not specific to a conidition associated with DCHS2 variants.
Intellectual disability v3.1714 ANK3 Sarah Leigh edited their review of gene: ANK3: Added comment: Associated with Intellectual developmental disorder, autosomal recessive 37 (OMIM:615493) in OMIM, but not associated with a phenotype in Gen2Phen. At least six ANK3 variants have now been associated with an autosomal dominant neurodevelopmental condition (PMIDs: 23390136; 28687526; 34218362). These terminating variants affect the transcripts for all of the ANK3 isoforms and are de novo (where trio evidence is available).; Changed rating: GREEN; Changed mode of inheritance: BOTH monoallelic and biallelic, autosomal or pseudoautosomal
Intellectual disability v3.1677 ZMYND8 Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: ZMYND8 was added
gene: ZMYND8 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: ZMYND8 was set to MONOALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal, imprinted status unknown
Publications for gene: ZMYND8 were set to 35916866; 32530565
Phenotypes for gene: ZMYND8 were set to Delayed speech and language development; Motor delay; Intellectual disability; Abnormality of cardiovascular system morphology; Hearing abnormality; Abnormality of vision; Abnormality of the face; Seizures
Penetrance for gene: ZMYND8 were set to unknown
Review for gene: ZMYND8 was set to GREEN
Added comment: Dias et al (2022 - PMID: 35916866) describe the phenotype of 11 unrelated individuals with monoallelic de novo (or suspected de novo) missense (N=9) or truncating (N=2) ZMYND8 variants. One of these subjects was previously reported by Suzuki et al (2020 - PMID: 32530565).

Features included speech delay/language difficulties (9/11), motor delay (9/11), ID (in 10/11 - profound in 1, moderate in 2), CHD (7/11 - PDA, VSD, ASD, pulmonary stenosis, etc), hearing or vision impairment (7/11). Seizures were reported in few (in text 5/11, table 2/11). Variable non-familial facial features were present in (9/11).

As the authors discuss, ZMYND8 encodes a multidomain protein playing a role in transcription regulation, chromatin remodeling, regulation of super enhancers, DNA damage response/tumor suppression.

The protein is broadly expressed in brain and shows highest expression in early development.

Molecular modeling and/or a yeast two-hybrid system were suggestive of disrupted interaction of ZMYND8 with Drebrin (missense variants in PWWP domain) or GATAD2A (variants in MYND domain).

Neuronal Zmynd8 knockdown in Drosophila resulted in deficits in habituation learning.
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v3.1677 ZMYND15 Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: ZMYND15 was added
gene: ZMYND15 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: ZMYND15 was set to MONOALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal, imprinted status unknown
Publications for gene: ZMYND15 were set to 35916866; 32530565
Phenotypes for gene: ZMYND15 were set to Delayed speech and language development; Motor delay; Intellectual disability; Abnormality of cardiovascular system morphology; Hearing abnormality; Abnormality of vision; Abnormality of the face; Seizures
Penetrance for gene: ZMYND15 were set to unknown
Review for gene: ZMYND15 was set to GREEN
Added comment: Dias et al (2022 - PMID: 35916866) describe the phenotype of 11 unrelated individuals with monoallelic de novo (or suspected de novo) missense (N=9) or truncating (N=2) ZMYND8 variants. One of these subjects was previously reported by Suzuki et al (2020 - PMID: 32530565).

Features included speech delay/language difficulties (9/11), motor delay (9/11), ID (in 10/11 - profound in 1, moderate in 2), CHD (7/11 - PDA, VSD, ASD, pulmonary stenosis, etc), hearing or vision impairment (7/11). Seizures were reported in few (in text 5/11, table 2/11). Variable non-familial facial features were present in (9/11).

As the authors discuss, ZMYND8 encodes a multidomain protein playing a role in transcription regulation, chromatin remodeling, regulation of super enhancers, DNA damage response/tumor suppression.

The protein is broadly expressed in brain and shows highest expression in early development.

Molecular modeling and/or a yeast two-hybrid system were suggestive of disrupted interaction of ZMYND8 with Drebrin (missense variants in PWWP domain) or GATAD2A (variants in MYND domain).

Neuronal Zmynd8 knockdown in Drosophila resulted in deficits in habituation learning.
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v3.1628 PPFIBP1 Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: PPFIBP1 was added
gene: PPFIBP1 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: PPFIBP1 was set to BIALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal
Publications for gene: PPFIBP1 were set to 35830857; 30214071
Phenotypes for gene: PPFIBP1 were set to Global developmental delay; Intellectual disability; Microcephaly; Seizures; Abnormality of brain morphology; Abnormality of the cerebral white matter; Cerebral calcification; Abnormal cortical gyration; Hypertonia; Spastic tetraplegia; Generalized hypotonia; Small for gestational age; Growth delay; Failure to thrive; Feeding difficulties; abnormal heart morphology; Hearing abnormality; Cryptorchidism; Abnormality of vision
Penetrance for gene: PPFIBP1 were set to Complete
Review for gene: PPFIBP1 was set to GREEN
Added comment: Consider inclusion with green rating in the ID, epilepsy as well as other likely relevant gene panels (microcephaly, white matter disorders, corpus callosum abnormalities, intracerebral calficication disorders, malformations of cortical development, hereditary spastic paraplegia, growth failure in early childhood, etc) based on the summary below.

----

Rosenhahn et al (2022 - PMID: 35830857) describe the phenotype of 16 individuals - belonging to 12 unrelated families - with biallelic PPFIBP1 pathogenic variants. Most (14/16) were born to consanguineous parents. One of these families was previously reported by Shaheen et al (2019 - PMID: 30214071) who first identified PPFIBP1 as a candidate gene for congenital microcephaly. In the current study, Rosenhahn also identified a fetus homozygous for a missense variant and similar features.

All individuals presented global DD/ID (16/16 - in 15 cases profound/severe) and epilepsy (16/16 - onset 1d-4y / median 2m - focal seizures in 11/16, epileptic spams in 7/16, generalized onset in 7/16, myoclonic in 6/16 - drug-resistant : 13/16). Almost all (15/16) had microcephaly, commonly congenital (9/16) and progressive (11/16). Other neurological findings included hypertonia (10/16), spastic tetraplegia (6/16), hypotonia (5/16), dystonic movements (3/16) or nystagmus (4/16). Brain abnormalities were identified in all investigated with MRI and included leukoencephalopathy (11/14) mostly periventricular, abnormal cortex morphology (7/14 - polymicrogyria 1, increased cortical thickness 4, pachygyria 3), cortical atrophy, corpus callosum hypoplasia (7/14). Intracranial calcifications were identified in all (9/9) investigated with CT scan. Abnormal growth was reported for several (SGA in 9/16, FTT 8/16, short stature 7/16) often associated with feeding difficulties (7/16). Other features incl. abnormal hearing (4/16), congenital heart defects (7/16), ophthalmologic findings (8/16), undescended testes (3/10). There were no overlapping facial features.

The fetus displayed similar features incl. SGA, microcephaly, intracranial calcifications.

Investigations incl. exome/genome sequencing (singleton or trio) with Sanger for confirmation/segregation of variants where necessary. Variable previous investigations incl. metabolic screening, TORCH screening, chromosomal studies (CMA) are mentioned in the supplement and were non-diagnostic. Additional candidate variants were identified in few cases although cases with plausible dual diagnoses (e.g. ind14) were not included in the overall phenotypic description.

9 pLoF variants (nonsense, frameshift, 1 splicing) predicted to lead to NMD were identified. There were no functional studies performed.
The missense variant c.2177G>T / p.Gly726Val (NM_003622.4) was predicted deleterious by in silico tools while the AA change causing severe steric problems upon modelling.

PPFIBP1 encodes PPFIA-binding protein 1 also known as liprin-β1. As the authors discuss: The liprin family of proteins comprises liprins α1 to 4 and liprin β1 and β2 in mammals. Liprin β1 is known to homodimerize and heterodimerize with α-liprins. In fibroblast cultures liprins β1 and α1 colocalize to cell membrane and periphery of focal adhesions. Members of the liprin-α fam. are scaffold proteins playing a role in synapse formation/signaling and axonal transport.

A ko model of the PPFIBP1 ortholog in C.elegans displayed abnormal locomotion behavior. In Drosophila, null-allele mutants resulted in altered axon outgrowth and synapse formation of R7 photoreceptors and reduced neuromuscular junction size (Refs provided in article).

Using a PPFIBP1/hlb-1 ko C.elegans model the authors demonstrated defects in spontaneous and light-induced behavior. Sensitivity of the worms to an acetylcholinesterase inhibitor (aldicarb) was suggestive of a presynaptic defect.

----

There is currently no PPFIBP1 - associated phenotype in OMIM / G2P.
SysNDD lists PPFIBP1 among the ID genes (limited evidence based on the 3 sibs reported by Shaheen et al, 2019 - PMID: 30214071).
In PanelApp Australia the gene is listed with green rating for ID, epilepsy, microcephaly based on the medRxiv pre-print.
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v3.1593 ALKBH8 Konstantinos Varvagiannis edited their review of gene: ALKBH8: Added comment: Please consider upgrade to green rating.

2 additional relevant families reported in literature, as summarized below. While affected individuals from 3 (of the 4 total) families with the disorder were homozygous for truncating variants in the last exon (potentially corresponding to hypomorphic / incomplete LoF rather than null alleles), a more recent publication describes 2 sibs homozygous for a missense SNV with demonstrated loss-of-function in the context of normal protein levels.

-----

Saad et al (2020 - PMID: 33544954) report 2 sibs, born to consanguineous parents from Egypt homozygous for an ALKBH8 frameshift variant. Both exhibited global DD and ID (proband IQ of 51 / Stanford Binet test, sib: 42 using Weschler scale). There was no history of seizures. Family based exome sequencing of both sibs and parents revealed homozygosity for NM_001301010.1:c.1684delC [p.(Arg562Alafs*56))] within a region of AOH. As the authors note this variant also occurred in the last exon of the gene, likely escaping NMD and based on previous evidence from Monnies et al, hypothesize that truncating variants in the last exon represent hypomorphic alleles encoding for a partially functional protein, while protein truncating variants in earlier exons may be null alleles.

Maddirevula et al (2021 - PMID: 34757492) describe the phenotype of 2 sibs, homozygous for a missense variant. Features included severe DD and ID, microcephaly, facial dysmorphism and epilepsy (the latter limited to the elder one). Exome with autozygome analysis identified homozygosity for a missense variant (NM_138775.2:c.1874G>A / p.Arg625His) with Sanger for confirmation / segregation studies.LC-MS/MS using tRNA isolated from LCLs from the affected individual, a carrier parent and controls revealed complete loss of ALKBH8-dependent tRNA posttranscriptional modifications, the results being suggestive of abrogation of the catalytic activities of both MT and Ox domains. The protein was detected at low levels in LCLs from control and patient samples, a finding that was also supported by immunoblot analysis suggesting that the observed loss-of-function is not mediated by loss of the protein.; Changed rating: GREEN; Changed publications to: 33544954, 34757492
Intellectual disability v3.1562 PABPC1 Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: PABPC1 was added
gene: PABPC1 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: PABPC1 was set to MONOALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal, imprinted status unknown
Publications for gene: PABPC1 were set to 35511136
Phenotypes for gene: PABPC1 were set to Global developmental delay; Expressive language delay; Intellectual disability; Behavioral abnormality; Seizures
Penetrance for gene: PABPC1 were set to unknown
Review for gene: PABPC1 was set to AMBER
Added comment: Wegler et al (2022 - PMID: 35511136) describe the phenotype of 4 individuals with de novo variants in the PABP domain of PABPC1.

Overlapping features included DD (4/4) with weak expressive language (4/4), learning disability/borderline intellectual functioning (in 2) to more severe ID (in 2 others), treatable/self-limiting seizures (in 3 for whom this information was available) as well as variable behavioral issues (impaired social skills, concentration/sleeping problems, ADHD, anxiety or autism). Other features involved feeding difficulties (3/4), hearing impairment (in 2/3) or variable other phenotypes. Contribution of de novo variants found in other genes was thought possible.

All 4 were investigated by trio exome sequencing following negative previous routine diagnostic work-up. WES revealed heterozygous de novo PABPC1 variants, 3 of which were missense SNVs (c.1687G>A/p.Gly563Ser, c.1691A>C/p.Glu564Gly, c.1709T>C/p.Ile570Thr using NM_002568.3) and a fourth an in-frame deletion (c.1664_1666del/p.Pro555del).

Additional de novo variants were reported in 3 cases (IGF2R missense SNV, htz KDM5B stopgain, RBBP4 - the latter not associated with any phenotype to date).

PABPC1 encodes Polyadenylate-binding protein, cytoplasmic, 1 which as the authors summarize has an important role overall in regulation of gene expression (poly(A) tail length, mRNA formation, export of processed mRNAs to cytoplasm, translation initiation promotion and termination, mRNA stability, NMD). Translation is regulated by Polyadenylate-binding protein–interacting proteins (PAIPs) which control PABP activity. PAIP2 in particular, which is highly expressed in CNS, is known to inhibit translation via binding to the PABP domain of PABPC1 and is thought to play an important role through transcriptional regulation for synaptic plasticity and memory.

To evaluate plausibility as a DD gene the authors performed analyses using publicly available data, with PABPC1 ranking high in terms of protein-protein interaction (PPI) and co-expression with known DD genes.

Variants were absent from gnomAD with in silico predictions in favour of a deleterious effect.

While PABPC1 is intolerant to both missense and LoF variants (z-score 4.49, pLI of 1), occurrence of these 4 dn variants and their clustering in the PABP domain appeared to be of statistical significance (p=0.002 and p=2.8x10-8) rather than being explained by random occurrence.

Structural modeling of variants suggested that all were in close spatial vicinity within the PABP domain, likely influencing PAIP2 binding.

In HeLa cells the variants were shown not to affect subcellular localization (to the cytoplasm) compared to wt. In addition, there were no significant differences upon stress conditions under which the protein localizes to stress granules.

In HeLa cells, co-immunoprecipitation assays using C-terminal HA tagged PABPC1, revealed that 3 variants (Gly563Ser, Glu564Gly, Ile570Thr) significantly reduced physical PABPC1-PAIP2 interaction compared with wt, which was also observed though to a not significant extent for Pro555del. (Other variants from literature also studied as discussed below).

Pabpc1 is highly expressed in all regions of the developing mouse brain with remarkable decrease after birth, suggesting a critical role in prenatal brain development. Through electroporation with Pabpc1-directed shRNA the authors provided evidence that Pabpc1 LoF results in abnormal neural progenitor cell proliferation with rescue experiments using human WT or missense variants (Gly563Ser, Glu564Gly, Ile570Thr) showing that only the WT could rescue the proliferation phenotype.

Overall a model whereby weakened PABPC1-PAIP2 interaction, leading to dysregulation to gene expression homeostasis and interference with proliferation of neural progenitors and the later to the NDD phenotype is proposed.

Given previous reports in the literature for de novo PABPC1 variants, namely Lys138Glu, Asp204Val, Arg481His, Pro456Leu the authors noted that the phenotypes reported in the respective individuals were rather explained by other variants (16p11.2 dup, ARID1A dn, TBL1XR1 dn variants). These PABPC1 variants do not lie in the PABP domain, have lower in silico pathogenicity scores (MPC/CADD), with structural modelling suggestive of no significant effect. Importantly, upon co-immunoprecipitation studies with PAIP2 which were here performed, these variants had no effect. Pathogenicity of these variants - not located within the PABP domain - through another mechanism cannot be however ruled out. (PMIDs cited, though not reviewed based on this discussion: De Rubeis et al, 2014 - PMID: 25363760, Guo et al, 2019 - PMID: 30504930, Kaplanis et al, 2020 - PMID: 33057194).

Currently there is no PABPC1-related phenotype in other databases (incl. OMIM, G2P, SysID, PanelApp Australia).

Consider inclusion in the gene panels for ID and epilepsy with amber / green rating (DD with or without ID in >= 3 individuals/families/variants – also the case for seizures, role of the gene, statistical evidence for the gene/occurrence and clustering of variants, functional studies with strong evidence for at least 3 variants || learning difficulties/borderline intellectual functioning in 2 affected individuals, phenotype in few might be "blended" due to additional de novo variants).
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v3.1562 CTR9 Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: CTR9 was added
gene: CTR9 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: CTR9 was set to BIALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal
Publications for gene: CTR9 were set to 35499524; 2815719; 25363760; 27479843; 25099282; 29292210
Phenotypes for gene: CTR9 were set to Delayed speech and language development; Motor delay; Intellectual disability; Behavioral abnormality; Autistic behavior; Failure to thrive; Feeding difficulties; Abnormality of the cardiovascular system
Penetrance for gene: CTR9 were set to unknown
Mode of pathogenicity for gene: CTR9 was set to Loss-of-function variants (as defined in pop up message) DO NOT cause this phenotype - please provide details in the comments
Review for gene: CTR9 was set to AMBER
Added comment: Meuwissen, Verstraeten, Ranza et al (2022 - PMID: 35499524) describe the phenotype of 13 unrelated individuals harboring heterozygous - predominantly de novo - CTR9 missense variants.

Overlapping features included delayed speech and/or motor development (each in 9 cases) with the latter complicated by hypotonia or hyperlaxity in some cases. Balance or coordination problems were also reported in some. Variable degrees of ID ranging from mild to severe were observed in all individuals of relevant age except for 3 who however experienced impairment in other domains and/or learning difficulties (8/11 - 2 individuals were too young for evaluation). Few had evidence of regression. Other features included behavioral abnormalities (incl. ASD in 4), FTT/feeding problems (in 5), cardiovascular findings (in 4 - incl. infantile thoracic aortic aneurysm, VSD, pulm. valve stenosis, SVAS). The authors reported variable/nonspecific dysmorphic features.

WES revealed heterozygous CTR9 missense variants in all cases (NM_014633.5 as RefSeq). The variants occurred de novo in most (11/13) individuals with a one proband having inherited the variant from his affected parent. For one case, a single parental sample was available. Most SNVs were absent from gnomAD with the exception of c.1364A>G/p.Asn455Ser and c.2633G>A/p.Arg878Gln present once in the database (Z-score for CTR9: 4.3 / pLI : 1). The variants affected highly conserved residues with in silico predictions mostly in favor of a deleterious effect.

CTR9 encodes a subunit of the PAF1 complex (PAF1C) with the other subunits encoded by PAF1, LEO1, CDC73, RTF1 and WDR61/SKI8. The complex acts as a transcriptional regulator with CTR9 binding RNA polymerase II. The complex influences gene expression by promoting H2BK123 ubiquitylation, H3K4 and H3K36 methylation. In yeast, Paf1 and Ctr9 appear to mediate involvement of Paf1C in induction of mitophagy (several Refs provided).

In silico modeling: a group of N-terminal variants likely destabilize structure, another group possibly perturbs CTR9-PAF1 interactions and a 3rd class influences interactions with other subunits. p.Glu15Lys did not appear to influence protein stability.

Functional studies: H3K4/H3K36 methylation analysis, mitochondrial quality assessment and RNA-seq studies in fibroblasts did not provide conclusive evidence for downstream consequences of the variants (albeit a brain-specific effect - as demonstrated for other disorders – cannot be excluded).

Animal models: In zebrafish, the Paf1C complex has been shown to play a role in cardiac specification and heart morphogenesis with ctr9 mutants showing severe defects in morphogenesis of primitive heart tube (cited PMID: 21338598). This supports a role of the CTR9 variants in the cardiac abnormalities observed in 4 individuals. Although Paf1C zebrafish homologues are required for Notch-regulated transcription (cited PMID: 17721442), there was no supporting evidence from RNA-seq analyses performed by the authors. In Drosophila, Ctr9 has a key role at multiple stages of nervous system development in Drosophila (cited PMID: 27520958). In rat, Ctr9 is expressed in dopaminergic neurons, with its expression not restricted to the nucleus, regulating dopamine transporter activity (cited PMID: 26048990).

As commented, de novo CTR9 variants have been identified in indivdiduals with developmental disorders in larger cohorts, though without phenotypic details (DDD study - PMID:2815719, De Rubeis et al, 2014 - PMID: 25363760, Lelieveld et al PMID: 27479843) [ https://denovo-db.gs.washington.edu/denovo-db/QueryVariantServlet?searchBy=Gene&target=CTR9 ]

Two previous studies (Hanks et al, 2014 - PMID: 25099282, Martins et al 2018, PMID: 29292210) have identified individuals with pLoF variants [in almost all cases leading to skipping of ex9 e.g. NM_014633.4:c.958-9A>G or (RefSeq not provided) c.1194+2T>C, c.1194+3A>C, the single exception being c.106C>T/p.Q36*] in individuals and families with Wilms tumor after exclusion of other genetic causes. Analyses of tumor samples revealed in several of these cases either LOH (most commonly) or truncating variants as second hits. These individuals did not display neurodevelopmental phenotypes (despite detailed clinical information provided in the 2 studies). CTR9 is included in the gene panels for WT and Tumor predisposition - childhood onset with green rating. [In addition few individuals with hyperparathyroidism jaw tumor syndrome due to heterozygous variants in CDC73 - another subunit of the PAF1 complex - have been reported with WT].

Given these reports, commenting on the embryonic lethality of Ctr9 homozygous ko mice (MGI) and the observation of only missense variants in their cohort Meuwissen, Verstraeten, Ranza et al presume that a dominant-negative effect may apply for the variants they report.

Consider inclusion in the current panel with amber (variant effect/underlying mechanism unknown) or green rating (>3 individuals/families/variants, multiple reports, some supporting evidence from animal models).
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v3.1561 CDK9 Konstantinos Varvagiannis changed review comment from: There are 4 studies reporting on the phenotype associated with biallelic CDK9 pathogenic variants. DD and ID are part of the phenotype which appears to be relatively consistent.

CDK9 encodes Cyclin-dependent kinase 9. There are 4 missense variants reported to date - one of which recurrent (NM_001261.3:c.673C>T / p.Arg225Cys) - with studies for 3 variants suggesting a LoF effect (loss of kinase activity) [Ref4].

Animal models also provide some supporting evidence [discussed Ref4].

Consider inclusion in the current panel (probably with green rating) as well as other possibly relevant ones. Details provided below.

[1]-----
Shaheen et al (2016 - PMID: 26633546) studied patients with apparently novel phenotypes with positive family history consistent with AR inheritance mode due to consanguinity.

After autozygome analysis the authors determined the shared autozygome (ROH >1 Mb / Axiom SNP Chip) in families with multiple affected individuals. This analysis was followed by whole exome/genome sequencing.

Using this approach, they managed to map the phenotype of interest to a single novel locus in some families, which was also the case in a large consanguineous family with 2 similarly affected cousins (11DG0424, 11DG1630).

Within a 20 Mb region of homozygosity, followed by WES in a single affected individual and Sanger confirmation with compatible segregation studies in parents and 10 unaffected sibs, the authors identified a homozygous CDK9 missense SNV (NM_001261.3:c.673C>T / p.Arg225Cys) responsible for this phenotype. In silico predictions were concordant in favor of a deleterious effect.

Features (detailed in the suppl.) included global DD (2/2), severe ID (1/1), cerebral and (mild) cerebellar atrophy (2/2), microcephaly (2/2), ocular anomalies (2/2, coloboma in 2/2, congenital cataract 2/2, etc), heart defects (2/2, PDA in both, ASD), variable genitourinary anomalies (2/2 incl. hydronephrosis, VUR reflux/recurrent UTIs, kidney atrophy, abn. genitalia in 1), abnormalities of the limbs (2/2, bilateral talipes equinovarus : 2/2) or the skeleton (1/2 - butterfly vertebrae). One was reported to have some degree of growth delay (<10th centile for length, <5th for weight and OFC). There was no hearing defect reported (large ears in 1/2). Overall, the authors used the term CHARGE-like phenotype.

[2]-----
Maddirevula et al (2019 - PMID: 30237576) performed autozygome and exome analysis of individuals with suspected Mendelian disorders. They reported 3 individuals (18DG0161, 18DG0162, 18DG0165) born to 3 different consanguineous families (information in fig2) from Qatar, homozygous for CDK9 p.Arg225Cys.

All presented a CHARGE-like phenotype with features ophtalmologic findings (3/3 - abnormal ERG in one, congenital cataracts the other, visual impairment in the 3rd, though NO evidence of coloboma in at least two), heart defect (2/3 had VSD), choanal atresia (3/3), retarded growth/FTT (1/3) or global DD (3/3 - in suppl. table 1), (genito)urinary anomalies (1/3 - dysplastic atrophic kidney) or ear anomalies (3/3 - preauricular tags 2/3, bilateral deafness 1/3, bilat.ossicular anomalies 1/3). Other features incl. epilepsy (2/3), brain MRI abnormalities (2/3), facial asymmetry in one, vertebral segmentation defect in 1/3.

[3]-----
Hu et al (2019 - PMID: 29302074) performed WES/WGS in 404 consanguineous families from Iran, having 2 or more offspring with ID.

In this context they reported 2 females and a male (III:1,4,3 belonging to fam. M9100018 - details in suppl. text) born to first cousin parents from Iran. Features included DD (3/3 - walking at 3y, words at 4y), moderate ID (3/3 - WAIS-IV IQ of 40-43), short stature (3/3 below 3rd %le). Vision and hearing were normal.

All three were homozygous for a missense SNV (NM_001261:c.280C>T, p.Arg94Cys) which was ultrarare in ExAC, with severa in silico tools in favor of a deleterious effect.

The authors commented that CDK9 is the catalytic core of transcription elongation factor p-TEFb essential for transcription elongation of numerous genes, Cdk9/Cyclin T1 complex may participate in neuronal differentiation, CDK9-cyclinK in maintenance of genomic integrity, with the protein encoded also interacted with AF4/FMR2.

In addition the gene was commented to have ubiquitous expression with high protein expression in glial and neuronal cells of the cortex (based on Uniprot and Human Protein Atlas).

[4]-----
Nishina et al (2021 - PMID: 33640901) described an 8 y.o. male with facial asymmetry, ear/hearing anomalies (microtia, preauricular tags, bilateral hearing loss), ocular/vision anomalies (blepharophimosis, lacrimal obstruction, eyelid dermoids, duane-like anomaly, congenital cataracts, retinal dystrophy), cleft lip and palate, abnormalities of the limbs (finger contractures with associated absence of creases, cutaneous syndactyly, etc). Other features included cardiac dysrhythmia and undescended testes. Development was delayed with associated ID (walking 3y, words 7y, at 10y: could count to 20, 4 word sentences). There was no evidence of coloboma or choanal atresia.

Trio exome sequencing revealed that the child was compound htz for 2 missense SNVs (NM_001261.3:c.862G>A / p.Ala288Thr and c.907C>T /p.Arg303Cys) with Sanger confirmation. These were ultrarare/not present in gnomAD. Both lied in the protein kinase catalytic domain of CDK9, with high conservation across different species and in silico predictions in favor of deleterious effect.

In vitro studies in HEK293 cells demonstrated that the kinase activity for both variants was significantly reduced compared to wt. Kinase activity was also reduced for the Arg225Cys variant (reported in Refs 1 & 2).

The authors briefly discuss evidence from zebrafish (regulates larval morphogenesis incl. brain, heart, eye, blood vessels) and mouse models. In the latter complete LoF is lethal while heterozygous LoF is associated with abnormal morphology of heart, skin and epididymis (PMIDs cited by the authors : 27715402, 30100824).
Sources: Literature; to: There are 4 studies reporting on the phenotype associated with biallelic CDK9 pathogenic variants. DD and ID are part of the phenotype which appears to be relatively consistent.

CDK9 encodes Cyclin-dependent kinase 9. There are 4 missense variants reported to date - one of which recurrent (NM_001261.3:c.673C>T / p.Arg225Cys) - with studies for 3 variants suggesting a LoF effect (loss of kinase activity) [Ref4].

Animal models also provide some supporting evidence [discussed Ref4].

Consider inclusion in the current panel (probably with green rating) as well as other possibly relevant ones. Details provided below.

[1]-----
Shaheen et al (2016 - PMID: 26633546) studied patients with apparently novel phenotypes with positive family history consistent with AR inheritance due to consanguinity.

Using autozygome analysis the authors determined the shared autozygome (ROH >1 Mb / Axiom SNP Chip) in families with multiple affected individuals. This analysis was followed by whole exome/genome sequencing.

Using this approach, they managed to map the phenotype of interest to a single novel locus in some families, which was also the case in a large consanguineous family with 2 similarly affected cousins (11DG0424, 11DG1630).

Within a 20 Mb region of homozygosity, followed by WES in a single affected individual and Sanger confirmation with compatible segregation studies in parents and 10 unaffected sibs, the authors identified a homozygous CDK9 missense SNV (NM_001261.3:c.673C>T / p.Arg225Cys) responsible for this phenotype. In silico predictions were concordant in favor of a deleterious effect.

Features (detailed in the suppl.) included global DD (2/2), severe ID (1/1), cerebral and (mild) cerebellar atrophy (2/2), microcephaly (2/2), ocular anomalies (2/2, coloboma in 2/2, congenital cataract 2/2, etc), heart defects (2/2, PDA in both, ASD), variable genitourinary anomalies (2/2 incl. hydronephrosis, VUR/recurrent UTIs, kidney atrophy, abn. genitalia in 1), abnormalities of the limbs (2/2, bilateral talipes equinovarus : 2/2) or the skeleton (1/2 - butterfly vertebrae). One was reported to have some degree of growth delay (<10th centile for length, <5th for weight and OFC). There was no hearing defect reported (large ears in one case). Overall, the authors used the term CHARGE-like for this phenotype.

[2]-----
Maddirevula et al (2019 - PMID: 30237576) performed autozygome and exome analysis of individuals with suspected Mendelian disorders. They reported 3 individuals (18DG0161, 18DG0162, 18DG0165) born to 3 different consanguineous families (information in fig2) from Qatar, homozygous for CDK9 p.Arg225Cys.

All presented a CHARGE-like phenotype with ophthalmologic findings (3/3 - abnormal ERG in one, congenital cataracts the other, visual impairment in the 3rd, though NO evidence of coloboma in at least two of them), heart defect (2/3 with VSD), choanal atresia (3/3), retarded growth/FTT (1/3) or global DD (3/3 - in suppl. table 1), (genito)urinary anomalies (1/3 - dysplastic atrophic kidney) or ear anomalies (3/3 - preauricular tags in 2/3, bilateral deafness 1/3, bilateral ossicular anomalies 1/3). Other features incl. epilepsy (2/3), brain MRI abnormalities (2/3), facial asymmetry in one, vertebral segmentation defect in 1/3.

[3]-----
Hu et al (2019 - PMID: 29302074) performed WES/WGS in 404 consanguineous families from Iran, having 2 or more offspring with ID.

In this context they reported 2 females and a male (III:1,4,3 belonging to fam. M9100018 | suppl. text) born to first cousin parents from Iran. Features included DD (3/3 - walking at 3y, words at 4y), moderate ID (3/3 - WAIS-IV IQ of 40-43), short stature (3/3 below 3rd %le). Vision and hearing were normal.

All three were homozygous for a missense SNV (NM_001261:c.280C>T, p.Arg94Cys) which was ultrarare in ExAC, with several in silico tools in favor of a deleterious effect.

The authors commented that CDK9 is the catalytic core of transcription elongation factor p-TEFb essential for transcription elongation of numerous genes, Cdk9/Cyclin T1 complex may participate in neuronal differentiation, CDK9-cyclinK in maintenance of genomic integrity, with the protein encoded also interacting with AF4/FMR2.

In addition the gene was commented to have ubiquitous expression with high protein expression in glial and neuronal cells of the cortex (based on Uniprot and Human Protein Atlas).

[4]-----
Nishina et al (2021 - PMID: 33640901) described an 8 y.o. male with facial asymmetry, ear/hearing anomalies (microtia, preauricular tags, bilateral hearing loss), ocular/vision anomalies (blepharophimosis, lacrimal obstruction, eyelid dermoids, duane-like anomaly, congenital cataracts, retinal dystrophy), cleft lip and palate, abnormalities of the limbs (finger contractures with associated absence of creases, cutaneous syndactyly, etc). Other features included cardiac dysrhythmia and undescended testes. Development was delayed with ID (walking 3y, words 7y, at 10y: could count to 20, 4 word sentences). There was no evidence of coloboma or choanal atresia.

Trio exome revealed that the child was compound htz for 2 missense SNVs (NM_001261.3:c.862G>A / p.Ala288Thr and c.907C>T /p.Arg303Cys) with Sanger confirmation. These were ultrarare/not present in gnomAD. Both lied in the protein kinase catalytic domain of CDK9, with high conservation across different species and in silico predictions in favor of deleterious effect.

In vitro studies in HEK293 cells demonstrated that the kinase activity for both variants was significantly reduced compared to wt. Kinase activity was also reduced for the Arg225Cys variant (reported in Refs 1 & 2).

The authors briefly discuss evidence from zebrafish (regulates larval morphogenesis incl. brain, heart, eye, blood vessels) and mouse models. In the latter complete LoF is lethal while heterozygous LoF is associated with abnormal morphology of heart, skin and epididymis (PMIDs cited : 27715402, 30100824).
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v3.1561 CDK9 Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: CDK9 was added
gene: CDK9 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: CDK9 was set to BIALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal
Publications for gene: CDK9 were set to 26633546; 30237576; 29302074; 33640901
Phenotypes for gene: CDK9 were set to Global developmental delay; Intellectual disability; Abnormality of vision; Congenital cataract; Iris coloboma; Abnormal heart morphology; Choanal atresia; Abnormality of the ear; Preauricular skin tag; Hearing impairment; Abnormality of the genitourinary system; Abnormality of limbs; Abnormality of the vertebrae; Abnormality of nervous system morphology; Seizures
Penetrance for gene: CDK9 were set to Complete
Review for gene: CDK9 was set to GREEN
Added comment: There are 4 studies reporting on the phenotype associated with biallelic CDK9 pathogenic variants. DD and ID are part of the phenotype which appears to be relatively consistent.

CDK9 encodes Cyclin-dependent kinase 9. There are 4 missense variants reported to date - one of which recurrent (NM_001261.3:c.673C>T / p.Arg225Cys) - with studies for 3 variants suggesting a LoF effect (loss of kinase activity) [Ref4].

Animal models also provide some supporting evidence [discussed Ref4].

Consider inclusion in the current panel (probably with green rating) as well as other possibly relevant ones. Details provided below.

[1]-----
Shaheen et al (2016 - PMID: 26633546) studied patients with apparently novel phenotypes with positive family history consistent with AR inheritance mode due to consanguinity.

After autozygome analysis the authors determined the shared autozygome (ROH >1 Mb / Axiom SNP Chip) in families with multiple affected individuals. This analysis was followed by whole exome/genome sequencing.

Using this approach, they managed to map the phenotype of interest to a single novel locus in some families, which was also the case in a large consanguineous family with 2 similarly affected cousins (11DG0424, 11DG1630).

Within a 20 Mb region of homozygosity, followed by WES in a single affected individual and Sanger confirmation with compatible segregation studies in parents and 10 unaffected sibs, the authors identified a homozygous CDK9 missense SNV (NM_001261.3:c.673C>T / p.Arg225Cys) responsible for this phenotype. In silico predictions were concordant in favor of a deleterious effect.

Features (detailed in the suppl.) included global DD (2/2), severe ID (1/1), cerebral and (mild) cerebellar atrophy (2/2), microcephaly (2/2), ocular anomalies (2/2, coloboma in 2/2, congenital cataract 2/2, etc), heart defects (2/2, PDA in both, ASD), variable genitourinary anomalies (2/2 incl. hydronephrosis, VUR reflux/recurrent UTIs, kidney atrophy, abn. genitalia in 1), abnormalities of the limbs (2/2, bilateral talipes equinovarus : 2/2) or the skeleton (1/2 - butterfly vertebrae). One was reported to have some degree of growth delay (<10th centile for length, <5th for weight and OFC). There was no hearing defect reported (large ears in 1/2). Overall, the authors used the term CHARGE-like phenotype.

[2]-----
Maddirevula et al (2019 - PMID: 30237576) performed autozygome and exome analysis of individuals with suspected Mendelian disorders. They reported 3 individuals (18DG0161, 18DG0162, 18DG0165) born to 3 different consanguineous families (information in fig2) from Qatar, homozygous for CDK9 p.Arg225Cys.

All presented a CHARGE-like phenotype with features ophtalmologic findings (3/3 - abnormal ERG in one, congenital cataracts the other, visual impairment in the 3rd, though NO evidence of coloboma in at least two), heart defect (2/3 had VSD), choanal atresia (3/3), retarded growth/FTT (1/3) or global DD (3/3 - in suppl. table 1), (genito)urinary anomalies (1/3 - dysplastic atrophic kidney) or ear anomalies (3/3 - preauricular tags 2/3, bilateral deafness 1/3, bilat.ossicular anomalies 1/3). Other features incl. epilepsy (2/3), brain MRI abnormalities (2/3), facial asymmetry in one, vertebral segmentation defect in 1/3.

[3]-----
Hu et al (2019 - PMID: 29302074) performed WES/WGS in 404 consanguineous families from Iran, having 2 or more offspring with ID.

In this context they reported 2 females and a male (III:1,4,3 belonging to fam. M9100018 - details in suppl. text) born to first cousin parents from Iran. Features included DD (3/3 - walking at 3y, words at 4y), moderate ID (3/3 - WAIS-IV IQ of 40-43), short stature (3/3 below 3rd %le). Vision and hearing were normal.

All three were homozygous for a missense SNV (NM_001261:c.280C>T, p.Arg94Cys) which was ultrarare in ExAC, with severa in silico tools in favor of a deleterious effect.

The authors commented that CDK9 is the catalytic core of transcription elongation factor p-TEFb essential for transcription elongation of numerous genes, Cdk9/Cyclin T1 complex may participate in neuronal differentiation, CDK9-cyclinK in maintenance of genomic integrity, with the protein encoded also interacted with AF4/FMR2.

In addition the gene was commented to have ubiquitous expression with high protein expression in glial and neuronal cells of the cortex (based on Uniprot and Human Protein Atlas).

[4]-----
Nishina et al (2021 - PMID: 33640901) described an 8 y.o. male with facial asymmetry, ear/hearing anomalies (microtia, preauricular tags, bilateral hearing loss), ocular/vision anomalies (blepharophimosis, lacrimal obstruction, eyelid dermoids, duane-like anomaly, congenital cataracts, retinal dystrophy), cleft lip and palate, abnormalities of the limbs (finger contractures with associated absence of creases, cutaneous syndactyly, etc). Other features included cardiac dysrhythmia and undescended testes. Development was delayed with associated ID (walking 3y, words 7y, at 10y: could count to 20, 4 word sentences). There was no evidence of coloboma or choanal atresia.

Trio exome sequencing revealed that the child was compound htz for 2 missense SNVs (NM_001261.3:c.862G>A / p.Ala288Thr and c.907C>T /p.Arg303Cys) with Sanger confirmation. These were ultrarare/not present in gnomAD. Both lied in the protein kinase catalytic domain of CDK9, with high conservation across different species and in silico predictions in favor of deleterious effect.

In vitro studies in HEK293 cells demonstrated that the kinase activity for both variants was significantly reduced compared to wt. Kinase activity was also reduced for the Arg225Cys variant (reported in Refs 1 & 2).

The authors briefly discuss evidence from zebrafish (regulates larval morphogenesis incl. brain, heart, eye, blood vessels) and mouse models. In the latter complete LoF is lethal while heterozygous LoF is associated with abnormal morphology of heart, skin and epididymis (PMIDs cited by the authors : 27715402, 30100824).
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v3.1556 FBXW7 Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: FBXW7 was added
gene: FBXW7 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: FBXW7 was set to MONOALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal, imprinted status unknown
Publications for gene: FBXW7 were set to 33057194; 35395208; 30885698; 26482194; 19963109; 20332316
Phenotypes for gene: FBXW7 were set to Neurodevelopmental abnormality; Global developmental delay; Intellectual disability; Macrocephaly; Microcephaly; Abnormality of brain morphology; Abnormality of the corpus callosum; Abnormality of the cerebellum; Abnormality of the cardiovascular system; Seizures; Strabismus; Abnormality of the palate
Penetrance for gene: FBXW7 were set to unknown
Review for gene: FBXW7 was set to AMBER
Added comment: While Kaplanis et al (2020 - Ref1), identified FBXW7 among 285 genes significantly associated with developmental disorders, a recent study by Stephenson et al (2022 - Ref2) describes the neurodevelopmental phenotype of 35 individuals making this gene relevant to the current panel. There are previous reports of dn/inh germline variants in individuals (likely 7) with tumor predisposition although a neurodevelopmental phenotype was not reported in most cases.

There is currently no FBXW7-related phenotype in OMIM.

The gene is included in the DD panel of G2P [associated with: FBXW7-related developmental disorder (monoallelic), confidence: definitive, citing the study by Kaplanis et al]. SysID lists FBXW7 among the candidate ID genes (same Ref.). The gene has a green rating for ID in PanelApp Australia (VCGS participating in the recent publication).

Consider inclusion with amber/green rating. Also consider inclusion in other panels that may be relevant(macro/microcephaly, seizures, CHD, corpus callosum / cerebellar abnormalities, cleft palate, WT, etc).

[1]------------
Kaplanis et al (2020 - PMID: 33057194), by combining exome data from 31,058 parent offspring trios from the DDD study, Radboudumc and GeneDx, identified 285 genes significantly associated with developmental disorders, 28 of which (incl. FBXW7) not previously robustly associated with these disorders.

[2]------------
Stephenson et al (2022 - PMID: 35395208) provide clinical information on 35 individuals harboring germline monoallelic FBXW7 variants or chromosomal deletions spanning this gene.

The phenotype corresponded to a phenotypically variable NDD characterized by hypotonia (in about 2/3), neurodevelopmental abnormality (34/35 - as discussed later), seizures (8/35), abnormal brain morphology (13/17 - in 7/17 abnormal CC, in 5/17 abn. cerebellum, etc), head circumference (macrocephaly in 10/35, microcephaly in 2/35). Additional features included abnormal palate or uvula morphology (10/35 - cleft palate in 3 from 2 families while 1 individual from a 3rd family had bifid uvula) or abnormal heart morphology (11/35), ophthalmologic features (e.g. strabismus in 5/35) or hearing impairment (2/35). There was no recognizable gestalt (deeply set eyes with upper eyelid fullness in 9/35).

As for the DD/ID this ranged from borderline to severe, characterized as mild-moderate in 27/35, severe in 3/35. One individual did not present neurodevelopmental abnormality 1/35.

FBXW7 encodes F-box and WD40 domain protein 7 which is part of the SCF E3 ligase complex (SKP1/CUL1/F-box protein) exerting a role of recognition and binding of target proteins for degradation by the ubiquitin proteasome system. In this way FBWX7 participates in regulating a network of proteins involved in cell division, growth, differentiation (as summarized by Roversi et al - Ref2).

Most individuals were investigated by trio-WES/WGS (few with singleton WES or CMA only). 28 germline FBXW7 variants were identified incl. missense (N=21), pLoF (predicted or not to undergo NMD) and 2 deletions encompassing but not limited to FBXW7.

Additional SNVs/CNVs (e.g. an inh intragenic DPP6 dup in one individual (#9) with deletion, other de novo 4q CNVs (#10), an inh 22q spanning partially an ISCA TS region, a CACNA1A and KMT2D SNV, etc) were reported in few individuals.

Most variants arose dn (N=30) with two individuals displaying mosaicism (2/30) and three individuals having inherited the variant from their affected parent. CNVs had occurred dn.

3 missense SNVs were recurrent in unrelated individuals.

All variants identified affected all FBXW7 isoforms.

As the authors comment missense variants clustered at the C-terminal half of the protein with most (16/21) occurring within the WD40 domain. [The N-terminal part commented in the literature to affect localization].

The crystal structure of FBXW7 and SKP1 complex has been determined with CYCLIN E1/DISC1 as substrates, and in silico modeling revealed that all missense variants aligned with residues required for this interaction, or adjacent ones.

All were absent from gnomAD, while missense variants from gnomAD (N=78) were not predicted have significant effect on the binding affinity.

Variant studies revealed that most missense variants (6/7 tested - Arg689Gln being the exception) are unlikely to cause protein instability or degradation in vivo.

Co-expression of these missense variants with CYCLIN E1 / E2, known FBXW7 substrates revealed that variants were less efficient at degrading the substrate with variants in the WD40 domain having greater impact (in some cases E1 / E2 - specific).

Elav-Gal4 mediated neuronal knockdown of the Drosophila ortholog archipelago (ago) using 2 RNAi-s with different efficiency was shown to affect learning or compromise neuronal function (also related to the level of knockdown).

The authors summarize results from animal models for the role of this gene in development and the nervous system.

KO mice die in utero at E10.5 manifesting abn. of hematopoietic or vascular development and heart-chamber maturation(*). Some htz knock-in for human cancer variants, display perinatal lethality, abn lung, cleft palate (30%)(*),etc. Conditional gut specific deletion results in impaired differentiation of intestinal goblet cells (*)(constipation in 16/35 in cohort). KO limited to CNS and PNS results in defective sucking and morphological brain abnormalities. Haploinsufficiency in the nervous system was associated with impaired differentiation of neural stem cells (possibly through a Notch-mediated mechanism). KO in Schwann cells of the peripheral nervous system resulted in enhanced myelination.

Excessive oligodendrocyte cells and hypermyelination (as a result of elevated Notch & mTOR signaling) are observed in homozygous mutant zebrafish or after morpholino-mediated fbxw7 knockdown.

Overall, the authors propose haploinsufficiency or loss-of-function as the underlying mechanism.

Finally, as the authors comment, FBXW7 is a tumor suppressor among the most commonly mutated genes in human cancer (3.5%). Germline variants have been previously reported in individuals with cancer (Wilms tumor, rhabdoid, etc - most summarized below). However, none of the 35 individuals in this cohort (oldest 44 y.o.) had any history of cancer.

Reports of individuals with germline variants causing (monoallelic) disruption of FBXW7 - cases without DD/ID:

[3]------------
Mahamdallie et al (2019 - PMID: 30885698) investigated with WES a cohort of 890 individuals with Wilms tumor (799 non-familial disease, 91 from WT pedigrees). In this context they identified 4 individuals having developed WT (ages: 28-76m) with FBXW7 dn or inherited LoF variants (710G>A / p.Trp237* dn - 1972C>T / p.Arg658* - inh:NA, 1017_1021del5, 670C>T - paternal / p.Arg224* inh:NA - RefSeq not provided). One additional individual with a missense variant (1753A>T / p.Ser585Cys - dn) had developed rhabdoid tumor. While the authors mentioned additional features for other subjects in their cohort, among the 5 individuals with FBXW7 variants, only one had hypotonia (ID_0592) and another (ID_7520) had two febrile convulsions.

[4]------------
Roversi et al (2015 - PMID: 26482194) described the phenotype of a 34 y.o. female with syndromic presentation (macrocephaly, nephrotic syndrome due to FSGS, Hodgkin's lymphoma, Wilms tumor, ovarian cystadenoma, breast carcinoma) harboring a 157 kb deletion of 4q31.3.

Eventual DD/ID was not reported despite detailed clinical description.

The deletion spanned almost the entire FBXW7 gene and a pseudogene (hg19 - chr4:153205202-153362047). The authors provided evidence that the del affected the maternal allele as dn event (maternal mosaicism excluded). Expression of FBXW7 in patient-derived EBV lymphoblastoid cell line revealed decreased levels of expression compared to controls. At somatic level, the authors looked for eventual 2nd hit in tumor tissue (which was not the case) while they demonstrated decreased FBXW7 expression in a WT sample compared to normal renal tissue. Previously, variants in other genes candidate for the phenotype were ruled out (Sanger & MLPA for TP53, BRCA1/2, PALB2, WT1, 11p15 MS-MLPA, std karyotype).

[5]------------
Kuiper et al (2015 - PMID: 19963109), in a 58 y.o. patient with recurrence of RCC, identified a constitutional translocation [t(3;4)(q21;q31)]. Using long-range PCR they defined the breakpoints at 3q21.3 (128379059 - hg18) between the PLXNA1 and C3orf56 genes while the chr4 breakpoint was located within the second intron of FBXW7 (pos. 153500813 - hg18). There were no additional phenotypes reported.

[6]------------
Williams et al (2010 - PMID: 20332316) reported a patient with WT harboring germline variants in WT1 and FBXW7. While the phenotype was sufficiently explained by a germline stopgain WT1 variant with a frameshift WT1 variant (as 2nd hit) confined to the tumor, the authors identified a germline in-frame FBXW7 insertion in the same individual (c.45_46insCCT / p.Thr15_Gly16insPro - RefS : NA) [if correct corresponding to: https://gnomad.broadinstitute.org/variant/4-153332910-C-CAGG - 345/281696 alleles in gnomAD].
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v3.1534 ZBTB7A Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: ZBTB7A was added
gene: ZBTB7A was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature,Other
Mode of inheritance for gene: ZBTB7A was set to MONOALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal, imprinted status unknown
Publications for gene: ZBTB7A were set to 31645653; 34515416
Phenotypes for gene: ZBTB7A were set to Global developmental delay; Intellectual disability; Macrocephaly; Abnormality of the lymphatic system; Sleep apnea; Increased body weight; Autism; Persistence of hemoglobin F; Abnormal leukocyte count; Recurrent infections; Umbilical hernia
Penetrance for gene: ZBTB7A were set to unknown
Review for gene: ZBTB7A was set to AMBER
Added comment: Monoallelic pathogenic ZBTB7A variants cause Macrocephaly, neurodevelopmental delay, lymphoid hyperplasia, and persistent fetal hemoglobin (#619769).
----
Ohishi et al (2020 - PMID: 31645653) described the phenotype of a 6y5m-old male harboring a heterozygous, de novo ZBTB7A missense variant. Features included macrocephaly, mild intellectual disability (tIQ 65) and sleep apnea. Available hemoglobin levels (in the 1st month) supported high Hb and HbF levels. Other features included PDA and an umbilical hernia.

Initial investigations incl. karyotype and CMA were normal.

The ZBTB7A variant (NM_015898.3:c.1152C>G / p.Cys384Tyr) was identified following trio WES with a list of additional findings (in suppl.) not explaining the phenotype. This SNV, confirmed by Sanger sequencing, was absent from public db with several in silico predictions in favor of a deleterious effect.

ZBTB7A on 19p encodes zinc finger- and BTB domain-containing protein 7 (or Pokemon).

The authors performed a review of 19p13.3 microdeletion cases supporting a minimum region of overlap spanning PIAS4, ZBTB7A and MAP2K2 and common features of DD and ID, macrocephaly with prominent forehead, sleep apnea. The authors argue that loss of ZBTB7A explains part of - but probably not all - features of 19p13.3 microdeletions.

ZBTB7A is known to repress expression of HBG1 and HBG2 (γ-globin), with the few available HbF patient measurements in line with this role.

Based on the structure of the protein, Cys384 (along with 3 other residues) forms a coordinate bond with the Zn+2 ion, this bond predicted to be disrupted by Tyr. Further they favor a dominant negative effect given that ZBTB7A protein is known to form dimer via interaction at the BTB domain [hetero (variant+wt) and homodimers (variant+variant) having compromised function]. To support this notion, 3 previously reported somatic variants within the zinc-finger domain have been shown to exert a dominant-negative effect (PMID cited: 26455326).
----
In a collaborative study, von der Lippe et al (2022 - PMID: 34515416) identified 12 additional individuals (from 10 families) harboring monoallelic ZBTB7A missense/pLoF variants most commonly as de novo events.

The authors describe a consistent phenotype with motor (9/11) and speech delay (9/12), cognitive impairment/ID (12/12 - commonly mild, ranged from specific learning difficulties to severe ID), macrocephaly (>90%le in 11/12, >97% in 7/12), lymphoid hypertrophy of pharyngeal tissue/adenoid overgrowth (12/12), sleep apnea (9/12). Autistic features were observed in 7/12. Other phenotypes included frequent upper airway infections (10/11), weight above 97th percentile (7/11). HbF levels were elevated in 4/5 individuals with available measurements (range: 2.2% to 11.2% - ref. for subjects above 6m of age : <2% ). Other hematological issues were observed in few individuals (abn. monocyte/neutrophil counts in 3-4). Cardiovascular issues were reported in 4 (2 fam). 3 subjects had umbilical hernia. There was no common dysmorphic feature.

Various initial investigations were normal or did not appear to explain the NDD phenotype and incl. standard karyotype, CMA, targeted testing for genes/disorders previously considered (PTEN, FMR1, NSD1, BWS and PWS methylation studies, CFTR, etc). One male had a maternally inherited chrX dup not thought to explain his complex phenotype, while another had a concurrent diagnosis of thalassemia.

Individuals were investigated with singleton (or trio) WES. Of note some individuals were DDD study participants.

8 had de novo ZBTB7A variants, incl. one who harbored 2 de novo missense SNVs several residues apart. 2 sibs had inherited a fs variant from their affected parent. For the latter as well as for another subject parental samples were unavailable.

There were no other variants of interest upon exome analysis.

5 different missense, 2 nonsense and 3 fs variants were identified with pLoF all predicted to lead to NMD.

All variants were absent from gnomAD (pLI of 0.96, LOEUF 0.33 and missense Z-score of 4.04) which lists one individual with htz LoF, likely not an artifact.

Given this individual (and the familial case) the authors discuss on the mild phenotype and/or eventual reduced penetrance or underdiagnosis of the disorder.

There was no difference in severity between those with missense/truncating variants.

ZBTB7A transcription factor (or pokemon or lymphoma/leukemia-related factor) is widely expressed. It is involved in several activities being among others required to block Notch signaling which in turn drives T-cell at the expense of B-cell development. Notch pathway activation has been demonstrated in Zbtba7 ko mouse models. Finally, the authors discuss the role of notch signaling in thymus and the nervous system, as well as that ZBTB7A up/down-regulation known to repress/increase respectively HbF expression (several refs in text).
----
MGI (1335091) for Zbtb7a : "Mice homozygous for a knock-out allele die around E16.5 due to anemia and exhibit a cell autonomous defect in early B cell development". (Phenotypes from nervous system not commented on).
----
Apart from OMIM (#619769), ZBTB7A is included in the DD panel of G2P (ZBTB7A-associated developmental disorder / monoallelic_autosomal / absent gene product / confidence limited) as well as among the primary ID genes in SysID. In PanelApp Australia the gene is incl. with green rating in the ID and Macrocephaly gene panels.
----
Consider inclusion with amber or green rating (several individuals/families/variants, highly consistent phenotype, overlap with 19p microdeletions || variant effect not studied, animal models supporting contribution of the gene to the phenotype though no data on associated NDD ones).

Please also consider inclusion in other relevant panels (macrocephaly, lymphatic disorders, ASD, etc).
Sources: Literature, Other
Intellectual disability v3.1520 PAN2 Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: PAN2 was added
gene: PAN2 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: PAN2 was set to BIALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal
Publications for gene: PAN2 were set to 29620724; https://doi.org/10.1038/s41431-022-01077-y
Phenotypes for gene: PAN2 were set to Global developmental delay; Intellectual disability; Sensorineural hearing impairment; Abnormality of the genitourinary system; Abnormality of the cardiovascular system; Abnormality of blood and blood-forming tissues; EEG abnormality; Seizures; Anorectal anomaly; Abnormality of the skeletal system; Abnormality of the eye; Abnormality of head or neck
Penetrance for gene: PAN2 were set to Complete
Review for gene: PAN2 was set to AMBER
Added comment: 1.
Maddirevula et al (2018 - PMID: 29620724) first reported on the phenotype associated with biallelic pathogenic variants in PAN2.

This concerned a male (15DG2222) born to consanguineous parents and exhibiting MCA, dysmorphic features and global DD (age of 34 m). Features incl. imperforate anus, metopic craniosynostosis, scoliosis, CHD (PFO, PDA, VSD), renal anomalies (duplicated collecting system) and abnormalities of the eye (posterior embryotoxon, maculopathy).

As the other 411 individuals from the cohort, the child had 1st-tier testing genetic testing using a dysmorphology/skeletal dysplasia panel of 296 genes.

Subsequent autozygome analysis (Axiom genotyping platform) was used to identify ROH (authors state "segregating within the family", in pedigree the proband was the single affected person and single child).

WES revealed a PAN2 indel. [NM_001166279.1:c.3162delC / p.(Ser1055Profs*4)].

There were no additional studies.

Role of PAN2 and animal models discussed as below.
---
2.
Reuter et al. (2022 - https://doi.org/10.1038/s41431-022-01077-y) describe the phenotype of 5 additional individuals - from 3 unrelated families (2 consanguineous) - harboring biallelic PAN2 variants. The authors review the phenotype of the previously described case.

Features included DD (6/6), ID (4/5 with relevant age in the mild-moderate range, 1/5 had borderline IF), sensorineural hearing loss (5/6) and incompletely penetrant congenital anomalies of the heart (4/6 - TOF, septal defects, Ao root dilat), urinary malformations (4/6 - hypoplasia/agenesis, anovesical fistula), ophthalmological anomalies (2/6 - Rieger, posterior embryotoxon, etc). EEG anomalies or seizures were noted in 4/6. Craniofacial feat. in >=2/6 included cleft palate/bifid uvula, ptosis, hypertelorism, abn. of the nose, low-set ears, short neck. There was no comprehensive evaluation for skeletal dysplasia despite short stature/skeletal anomalies in multiple individuals. Hematological anomalies were reported in 2, possibly explained by another concurrent diagnosis (of GSD) in one individual.

WGS was performed for 1 individual, and WES for 4 members of the 2nd family and the proband in the 3rd. ROH identified in all 3 families (1 non-consanguineous but from the same region of Italy) are mentioned in the suppl. Sanger sequencing for parents and affected/unaffected sibs was mentioned for the 2 families with solo WGS/WES. One individual had a dual - previously established - diagnosis (of SLC37A4-related GSD) not related to his NDD. There were no other candidate variants except for VUS or variants in 'genes of uncertain significance'.

The majority of mammalian mature mRNAs have polyA tails, added during RNA processing. PAN2 encodes a subunit of the Pan2-Pan3 deadenylation complex which shortens mRNA 3' polyA tails, regulating mRNA stability/translation efficiency.

Specifically Pan2 is the catalytic subunit, while the interaction with Pan3 mediates efficient mRNA binding. Deadenylation in cytoplasm is mostly carried out by the Pan2-Pan3 or Ccr4-Not compexes. While perturbations of mRNA metabolism/decay are established causes of NDD and ID. In particular, monoallelic variants in genes of Ccr4-Not complex (inc. CNOT1/2/3) already causative of NDDs.

All affected individuals were homozygous for pLoF PAN2 variants, namely (NM_001166279.2): c.2335G>T / p.(Glu779*) [Fam1], c.3408dupT / p.(Glu1137*) [Fam2], c.574-2A>G / p.? [Fam3].

Variants were absent from gnomAD (where PAN2 has a pLI:0.94, o/e:0.19).

There were no variant studies performed. The splicing variant is predicted in silico to abolish the splice-acceptor site, with in-frame skippling of ex5 which codes a repeat within the WD40 domain. Previous studies in yeast have shown that this domain is important for sensing the length of the polyA tail, with absence of this domain resulting in impaired deadenylation of 90A tails (similarly to complete Pan2 del) [cited PMID: 31104843].

Overall PAN2 loss-of-function is thought to be the underlying disease mechanism.

Partial functional redundancy of Pan2/Pan3 (initiation of deadenylation) and Ccr4-Not complexes (further shortening of polyA) is speculated to mitigate consequences of PAN2 LoF in humans.

In yeast Pan2Δ, Ccr4Δ and Pan2Δ/Ccr4Δ have been studied with more severe phenotypes in double mutants where ability to shorten mRNA polyA tails was abolished [cited PMID:11239395]. In yeast extracts lacking Pan2p and Pan3p, transcripts were polyadenylated to >90-200 adenosines [cited PMID: 9774670]

Mouse mutants (MGI:1918984) had increased heart weight, increased eosinophil cell number while homozygosity for a stopgain allele (by ENU mutagenesis) was shown to result in embyonic lethality.

Finally, given the presence of thrombocytopenia and anemia in 3 individuals (2 families) as well as the link between mRNA deadenylation and telomere disease, telomere length analyses from WGS data were performed (TelSeq/Expansion Hunter dn), but there was no evidence for telomeric shortening.
---
Currently, there is no PAN2-related phenotype in OMIM/G2P/SysID/PanelApp Australia.
---
Consider inclusion in the ID panel with amber rating [>3 individuals/families/variants, though variant studies not performed (NMD/splicing) and authors of 2nd study recognize possibility of additional/concurrent diagnoses in individuals from consanguineous families, possibility of missed dn variants due to singleton WGS/WES in 2 fam. Also the presumed deadenylation defect not studied to date].

Please consider adding this gene to other panels - eg. for sens. hearing loss (5/6 - 3 fam), urinary tract anomalies (4/6 - 4 fam), congenital (4/6 - 3fam), anorectal malformations (2/6 - 2 families, incl. fistula or imperforate anus), clefting (2/6 - 1 fam), hematological disorders, etc.

For the time being, not added in epilepsy panel as some individuals had only EEG anomalies, few had also clinical seizures not necessarily requiring treatment.
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v3.1520 HIST1H4D Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: HIST1H4D was added
gene: HIST1H4D was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: HIST1H4D was set to MONOALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal, imprinted status unknown
Publications for gene: HIST1H4D were set to 35202563
Phenotypes for gene: HIST1H4D were set to Global developmental delay; Intellectual disability; Microcephaly; Growth abnormality; Abnormality of the face
Penetrance for gene: HIST1H4D were set to Complete
Mode of pathogenicity for gene: HIST1H4D was set to Loss-of-function variants (as defined in pop up message) DO NOT cause this phenotype - please provide details in the comments
Review for gene: HIST1H4D was set to AMBER
Added comment: Histone H4 is a core component of the nucleosome, the basic repeating unit of eukaryotic chromatin. Each nucleosome consists of ~150 bp of DNA wrapped around a histone octamer. Each histone octamer is composed of 2 copies of each of the histones H2A, H2B, H3, H4. This organization is important for DNA replication, transcription and repair.

There are 14 canonical histone H4 genes in the human genome, which despite being different at the nucleotide level encode an identical protein. These cluster in 3 genomic loci. Their transcription is independently regulated with differing expression during brain development and in human tissues.

Histone H4 forms a dimer with H3 (which however has variant isoforms linked to specific cellular processes).

Pathogenic variants in genes encoding H4 have been reported in several individuals. Irrrespective of the gene for H4 involved, all patients presented with highly overlapping features, DD and ID being universal. Available reports to date concern :
- H4C3/HIST1H4C (9 subjects - PMID: 28920961, 35202563),
- H4C11/HIST1H4J (1 subject - PMID: 31804630, 35202563),
- H4C4/HIST1H4D (1 subject - PMID:35202563),
- H4C5/HIST1H4E (17 subjects - PMID: 35202563),
- H4C6/HIST1H4F (1 subject - PMID: 35202563),
- H4C9/HIST1H4I (3 subjects - PMID: 35202563).

Variants in all cases were missense SNVs, occurring (in almost all cases) as dn variants and affecting the same residue in the same and/or different H4 genes (details for clusters below). Eg. Arg45Cys was a recurrent variant for H4C5 (>=7 subjects), while variants affecting Arg40 have been reported in H4C4, H4C5, H4C9, H4C11 (7 subjects overall).

Zebrafish studies for all genes reported have included most - if not all - patient variants and recapitulate features observed in affected individuals (head size/structure and growth).

Additional studies specificaly for H4C3/HIST1H4C have been performed in patient fibroblasts (demonstrating among others transcriptional dysregulation) and zebrafish (accumulation of DSBs, increased apoptosis in head/tail, abn. cell cycle progression).

Note that the nomenclature for variants - at the protein level - used in literature commonly takes into consideration cleavage of Met1, thus the numbering may not correspond to the HGVS one.

Relevant entries exist in OMIM, G2P and SysID only for H4C3/HIST1H4C (Tessadori-van Haaften neurodevelopmental syndrome 1, #619758) and H4C11/HIST1H4J (?Tessadori-van Haaften neurodevelopmental syndrome 2, #619759) but not for other genes.

Rating in PanelApp Australia - ID Panel : HIST1H4C Green, H4J Amber, H4D Amber, H4E Green, H4F Amber, H4I Green.

Please consider inclusion in other possibly relevant panels (microcephaly, short stature/FTT, etc).

------
Initial work from Tessadori et al (incl. DDD study, 2017 - PMID:28920961) identified monoallelic missense SNVs affecting the same residue of H4C3 (HIST1H4C), in 3 individuals from 2 families. [c.274A>C/ HGVS p.(Lys92Gln) dn in 1 subject and c.275A>C/ HGVS p.(Lys92Arg) inherited from unaffected mosaic parent].

Individuals from both families having relevant age had intellectual disability (2/2 - 2 families). Other features incl. growth delay (3/3) and microcephaly (3/3).

Expression of the variants in zebrafish severely affected structural development recapitulating the patient phenotypes (microcephaly and short stature).

RNA sequencing in fibroblasts from 2 unrelated patients and a control, revealed that expression of H4C3 variants was similar to wt. The authors estimated that ~8% of H4 cDNA molecules contained the variant. LC-MS/MS analysis suggested that the mutant protein was present in nucleosomes at a level of 1-2% while RNA-seq identified 115 differential expressed genes, with enrichment for relevant procedures (chr. organization, histone binding, DNA packaging, nucleosomal organization, cell cycle).

Post-translational modifications of Lys92 (H4K91) are highly conserved and have been previously associated with processes from chromatin assembly , DNA damage sensitivity, etc. Post-translational marks on Lys92 (K91) were absent in patient derived cells as a result of each variant.

Zebrafish models for both variants were suggestive for accumulation of double strand breaks (DSBs) more visible in heads and tails of larvae. Embryos expressing mutants displayed increased apoptosis in head and tail. Additional studies in larvae were suggestive of abnormal cell cycle progression (rel. increase in cellls in S/G2/M phase, increased occurrence of activated CHK2 with p53 stabilization) applying to both variants studied.

------
In a subsequent publication, Tessadori et al. (2020 - PMID: 31804630) described the phenotype of a 14 y.o. boy harboring a dn heterozygous missense H4C11 (HIST1H4J) variant following trio-ES [c.274A>G / HGVS p.(Lys92Glu)]. Features incl. profound ID, microcephaly, short stature with some dysmorphic features (uplsanting p-f, hypertelorism, etc). Previous work-up was normal/non-diagnostic and incl. FMR1, MECP2 and a CMA showing an inherited 207 kb CNV involving KCNV1. Upon mRNA microinjection in zebrafish embryos - either for wt or for Lys92Glu HIST1H4J - effect for wt was very mild. Lys92Glu expression led to defective development of head structures (brain, eyes), faulty body axis growth and dysmorphic tail reproducing the microcephaly and short stature phenotype. This was similar to previous zebrafish studies for HIS1H4C variants (above).

------
Tessadori et al. (2022 - PMID: 35202563) describe 29 *additional individuals with de novo missense variants in genes encoding H4, namely:
- H4C3 (HIST1H4C/N=6 subjects),
- H4C11 (HIST1H4J/N=1),
- H4C4 (HIST1H4D/N=1),
- H4C5 (HIST1H4E/N=17),
- H4C6 (HIST1H4F/N=1),
- H4C9 (HIST1H4I/N=3).

All individuals, exhibited DD and ID (29/29). Other features incl. hypotonia (10/29), seizures (5/29), autism (5/29), ataxia (4/29). Abnormal growth incl. progressive microcephaly (2/19 prenatal, 20/29 postnatal onset), short stature/FTT (each 11/29). Few had skeletal features (craniosynostosis 2/29, abn. digits 4/29, vertebral 4/29). Some had visual (17/28) or hearing impairment (7/29). Facial features incl. hypertelorism (5/29), upslanting p-f (3/29), broad nasal tip (11/29), thin upper lip (4/29) and teeth anomalies (6/29 - notably gap between central incisors).

The authors state that the cohort was collected with trio WES but also after data sharing via Genematcher / DECIPHER.

Identified variants were in all cases missense and de novo, the latter either by trio WES or Sanger sequencing of parents.

Previous work-up or presence of additional variants are not discussed.

At the protein level 10 aa were affected, 6 of which recurrently within the same gene (Arg45, His75, Lys91, Tyr98) as well among several genes for H4 (Pro32, Arg40). Variants lied within two clusters, one corresponding to the α-helix of H4 (reported variants affected Lys31 - Arg45) important for DNA contacts, interactions with H3 and histone chaperones. The other within the core of nucleosome (reported patient variants : His75-Tyr98) with important strucural contact between H3-H4 dimer and histone chaperones.

There were no detectable genotype-phenotype patterns separating individual H4 genes or protein regions. Of note, variability was observed even among 7 individuals with the same dn H4C5 variant (Arg45Cys).

All variants were absent from control databases incl. gnomAD and affected residues conserved through to S. cerevisiae. Substitutions affecting Arg45 and Gly94 and His75 have been studied previously with effect in growth/fitness/chromatin remodeling/DNA damage repair depending on variant (5 studies cited).

Zebrafish embryos at the 1 cell stage were injected with mRNA encoding either wt or identified variants, the latter inducing significant developmental defects with the exception of Pro32Ala (H4C3) and Arg40Cys (H4C5, H4C11).

For Pro32Ala and Arg40Cys however, the strong recurrence in this cohort supports pathogenicity. A dosage dependent effect was observed for 2 variants.

H4 genes appear to be tolerant to both missense and loss-of-function variation (the latter even in homozygous form) suggesting a dominant effect of the variants.

------
[RefSeqs : H4C3/HIST1H4C - NM_0035242.4 | H4C4/HIST1H4D - NM_003539.4 | H4C5/HIST1H4E - NM_003545.3 | H4C6/HIST1H4F - NM_003540.4 | H4C9/HIST1H4I - NM_003495.2 | H4C11/HIST1H4J - NM_021968.4 // Variants at the protein level above are according to the HGVS nomenclature. However as the N-terminal methionine is cleaved, numbering relative to the mature peptide has also been used in publications eg. p.Pro33Ala HGVS corresponding to Pro32Ala]
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v3.1520 HIST1H4E Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: HIST1H4E was added
gene: HIST1H4E was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: HIST1H4E was set to MONOALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal, imprinted status unknown
Publications for gene: HIST1H4E were set to 35202563
Phenotypes for gene: HIST1H4E were set to Global developmental delay; Intellectual disability; Microcephaly; Growth abnormality; Abnormality of the face
Penetrance for gene: HIST1H4E were set to unknown
Mode of pathogenicity for gene: HIST1H4E was set to Loss-of-function variants (as defined in pop up message) DO NOT cause this phenotype - please provide details in the comments
Review for gene: HIST1H4E was set to GREEN
Added comment: Histone H4 is a core component of the nucleosome, the basic repeating unit of eukaryotic chromatin. Each nucleosome consists of ~150 bp of DNA wrapped around a histone octamer. Each histone octamer is composed of 2 copies of each of the histones H2A, H2B, H3, H4. This organization is important for DNA replication, transcription and repair.

There are 14 canonical histone H4 genes in the human genome, which despite being different at the nucleotide level encode an identical protein. These cluster in 3 genomic loci. Their transcription is independently regulated with differing expression during brain development and in human tissues.

Histone H4 forms a dimer with H3 (which however has variant isoforms linked to specific cellular processes).

Pathogenic variants in genes encoding H4 have been reported in several individuals. Irrrespective of the gene for H4 involved, all patients presented with highly overlapping features, DD and ID being universal. Available reports to date concern :
- H4C3/HIST1H4C (9 subjects - PMID: 28920961, 35202563),
- H4C11/HIST1H4J (1 subject - PMID: 31804630, 35202563),
- H4C4/HIST1H4D (1 subject - PMID:35202563),
- H4C5/HIST1H4E (17 subjects - PMID: 35202563),
- H4C6/HIST1H4F (1 subject - PMID: 35202563),
- H4C9/HIST1H4I (3 subjects - PMID: 35202563).

Variants in all cases were missense SNVs, occurring (in almost all cases) as dn variants and affecting the same residue in the same and/or different H4 genes (details for clusters below). Eg. Arg45Cys was a recurrent variant for H4C5 (>=7 subjects), while variants affecting Arg40 have been reported in H4C4, H4C5, H4C9, H4C11 (7 subjects overall).

Zebrafish studies for all genes reported have included most - if not all - patient variants and recapitulate features observed in affected individuals (head size/structure and growth).

Additional studies specificaly for H4C3/HIST1H4C have been performed in patient fibroblasts (demonstrating among others transcriptional dysregulation) and zebrafish (accumulation of DSBs, increased apoptosis in head/tail, abn. cell cycle progression).

Note that the nomenclature for variants - at the protein level - used in literature commonly takes into consideration cleavage of Met1, thus the numbering may not correspond to the HGVS one.

Relevant entries exist in OMIM, G2P and SysID only for H4C3/HIST1H4C (Tessadori-van Haaften neurodevelopmental syndrome 1, #619758) and H4C11/HIST1H4J (?Tessadori-van Haaften neurodevelopmental syndrome 2, #619759) but not for other genes.

Rating in PanelApp Australia - ID Panel : HIST1H4C Green, H4J Amber, H4D Amber, H4E Green, H4F Amber, H4I Green.

Please consider inclusion in other possibly relevant panels (microcephaly, short stature/FTT, etc).

------
Initial work from Tessadori et al (incl. DDD study, 2017 - PMID:28920961) identified monoallelic missense SNVs affecting the same residue of H4C3 (HIST1H4C), in 3 individuals from 2 families. [c.274A>C/ HGVS p.(Lys92Gln) dn in 1 subject and c.275A>C/ HGVS p.(Lys92Arg) inherited from unaffected mosaic parent].

Individuals from both families having relevant age had intellectual disability (2/2 - 2 families). Other features incl. growth delay (3/3) and microcephaly (3/3).

Expression of the variants in zebrafish severely affected structural development recapitulating the patient phenotypes (microcephaly and short stature).

RNA sequencing in fibroblasts from 2 unrelated patients and a control, revealed that expression of H4C3 variants was similar to wt. The authors estimated that ~8% of H4 cDNA molecules contained the variant. LC-MS/MS analysis suggested that the mutant protein was present in nucleosomes at a level of 1-2% while RNA-seq identified 115 differential expressed genes, with enrichment for relevant procedures (chr. organization, histone binding, DNA packaging, nucleosomal organization, cell cycle).

Post-translational modifications of Lys92 (H4K91) are highly conserved and have been previously associated with processes from chromatin assembly , DNA damage sensitivity, etc. Post-translational marks on Lys92 (K91) were absent in patient derived cells as a result of each variant.

Zebrafish models for both variants were suggestive for accumulation of double strand breaks (DSBs) more visible in heads and tails of larvae. Embryos expressing mutants displayed increased apoptosis in head and tail. Additional studies in larvae were suggestive of abnormal cell cycle progression (rel. increase in cellls in S/G2/M phase, increased occurrence of activated CHK2 with p53 stabilization) applying to both variants studied.

------
In a subsequent publication, Tessadori et al. (2020 - PMID: 31804630) described the phenotype of a 14 y.o. boy harboring a dn heterozygous missense H4C11 (HIST1H4J) variant following trio-ES [c.274A>G / HGVS p.(Lys92Glu)]. Features incl. profound ID, microcephaly, short stature with some dysmorphic features (uplsanting p-f, hypertelorism, etc). Previous work-up was normal/non-diagnostic and incl. FMR1, MECP2 and a CMA showing an inherited 207 kb CNV involving KCNV1. Upon mRNA microinjection in zebrafish embryos - either for wt or for Lys92Glu HIST1H4J - effect for wt was very mild. Lys92Glu expression led to defective development of head structures (brain, eyes), faulty body axis growth and dysmorphic tail reproducing the microcephaly and short stature phenotype. This was similar to previous zebrafish studies for HIS1H4C variants (above).

------
Tessadori et al. (2022 - PMID: 35202563) describe 29 *additional individuals with de novo missense variants in genes encoding H4, namely:
- H4C3 (HIST1H4C/N=6 subjects),
- H4C11 (HIST1H4J/N=1),
- H4C4 (HIST1H4D/N=1),
- H4C5 (HIST1H4E/N=17),
- H4C6 (HIST1H4F/N=1),
- H4C9 (HIST1H4I/N=3).

All individuals, exhibited DD and ID (29/29). Other features incl. hypotonia (10/29), seizures (5/29), autism (5/29), ataxia (4/29). Abnormal growth incl. progressive microcephaly (2/19 prenatal, 20/29 postnatal onset), short stature/FTT (each 11/29). Few had skeletal features (craniosynostosis 2/29, abn. digits 4/29, vertebral 4/29). Some had visual (17/28) or hearing impairment (7/29). Facial features incl. hypertelorism (5/29), upslanting p-f (3/29), broad nasal tip (11/29), thin upper lip (4/29) and teeth anomalies (6/29 - notably gap between central incisors).

The authors state that the cohort was collected with trio WES but also after data sharing via Genematcher / DECIPHER.

Identified variants were in all cases missense and de novo, the latter either by trio WES or Sanger sequencing of parents.

Previous work-up or presence of additional variants are not discussed.

At the protein level 10 aa were affected, 6 of which recurrently within the same gene (Arg45, His75, Lys91, Tyr98) as well among several genes for H4 (Pro32, Arg40). Variants lied within two clusters, one corresponding to the α-helix of H4 (reported variants affected Lys31 - Arg45) important for DNA contacts, interactions with H3 and histone chaperones. The other within the core of nucleosome (reported patient variants : His75-Tyr98) with important strucural contact between H3-H4 dimer and histone chaperones.

There were no detectable genotype-phenotype patterns separating individual H4 genes or protein regions. Of note, variability was observed even among 7 individuals with the same dn H4C5 variant (Arg45Cys).

All variants were absent from control databases incl. gnomAD and affected residues conserved through to S. cerevisiae. Substitutions affecting Arg45 and Gly94 and His75 have been studied previously with effect in growth/fitness/chromatin remodeling/DNA damage repair depending on variant (5 studies cited).

Zebrafish embryos at the 1 cell stage were injected with mRNA encoding either wt or identified variants, the latter inducing significant developmental defects with the exception of Pro32Ala (H4C3) and Arg40Cys (H4C5, H4C11).

For Pro32Ala and Arg40Cys however, the strong recurrence in this cohort supports pathogenicity. A dosage dependent effect was observed for 2 variants.

H4 genes appear to be tolerant to both missense and loss-of-function variation (the latter even in homozygous form) suggesting a dominant effect of the variants.

------
[RefSeqs : H4C3/HIST1H4C - NM_0035242.4 | H4C4/HIST1H4D - NM_003539.4 | H4C5/HIST1H4E - NM_003545.3 | H4C6/HIST1H4F - NM_003540.4 | H4C9/HIST1H4I - NM_003495.2 | H4C11/HIST1H4J - NM_021968.4 // Variants at the protein level above are according to the HGVS nomenclature. However as the N-terminal methionine is cleaved, numbering relative to the mature peptide has also been used in publications eg. p.Pro33Ala HGVS corresponding to Pro32Ala]
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v3.1520 HIST1H4F Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: HIST1H4F was added
gene: HIST1H4F was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: HIST1H4F was set to MONOALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal, imprinted status unknown
Publications for gene: HIST1H4F were set to 35202563
Phenotypes for gene: HIST1H4F were set to Global developmental delay; Intellectual disability; Microcephaly; Growth abnormality; Abnormality of the face
Penetrance for gene: HIST1H4F were set to unknown
Mode of pathogenicity for gene: HIST1H4F was set to Loss-of-function variants (as defined in pop up message) DO NOT cause this phenotype - please provide details in the comments
Review for gene: HIST1H4F was set to AMBER
Added comment: Histone H4 is a core component of the nucleosome, the basic repeating unit of eukaryotic chromatin. Each nucleosome consists of ~150 bp of DNA wrapped around a histone octamer. Each histone octamer is composed of 2 copies of each of the histones H2A, H2B, H3, H4. This organization is important for DNA replication, transcription and repair.

There are 14 canonical histone H4 genes in the human genome, which despite being different at the nucleotide level encode an identical protein. These cluster in 3 genomic loci. Their transcription is independently regulated with differing expression during brain development and in human tissues.

Histone H4 forms a dimer with H3 (which however has variant isoforms linked to specific cellular processes).

Pathogenic variants in genes encoding H4 have been reported in several individuals. Irrrespective of the gene for H4 involved, all patients presented with highly overlapping features, DD and ID being universal. Available reports to date concern :
- H4C3/HIST1H4C (9 subjects - PMID: 28920961, 35202563),
- H4C11/HIST1H4J (1 subject - PMID: 31804630, 35202563),
- H4C4/HIST1H4D (1 subject - PMID:35202563),
- H4C5/HIST1H4E (17 subjects - PMID: 35202563),
- H4C6/HIST1H4F (1 subject - PMID: 35202563),
- H4C9/HIST1H4I (3 subjects - PMID: 35202563).

Variants in all cases were missense SNVs, occurring (in almost all cases) as dn variants and affecting the same residue in the same and/or different H4 genes (details for clusters below). Eg. Arg45Cys was a recurrent variant for H4C5 (>=7 subjects), while variants affecting Arg40 have been reported in H4C4, H4C5, H4C9, H4C11 (7 subjects overall).

Zebrafish studies for all genes reported have included most - if not all - patient variants and recapitulate features observed in affected individuals (head size/structure and growth).

Additional studies specificaly for H4C3/HIST1H4C have been performed in patient fibroblasts (demonstrating among others transcriptional dysregulation) and zebrafish (accumulation of DSBs, increased apoptosis in head/tail, abn. cell cycle progression).

Note that the nomenclature for variants - at the protein level - used in literature commonly takes into consideration cleavage of Met1, thus the numbering may not correspond to the HGVS one.

Relevant entries exist in OMIM, G2P and SysID only for H4C3/HIST1H4C (Tessadori-van Haaften neurodevelopmental syndrome 1, #619758) and H4C11/HIST1H4J (?Tessadori-van Haaften neurodevelopmental syndrome 2, #619759) but not for other genes.

Rating in PanelApp Australia - ID Panel : HIST1H4C Green, H4J Amber, H4D Amber, H4E Green, H4F Amber, H4I Green.

Please consider inclusion in other possibly relevant panels (microcephaly, short stature/FTT, etc).

------
Initial work from Tessadori et al (incl. DDD study, 2017 - PMID:28920961) identified monoallelic missense SNVs affecting the same residue of H4C3 (HIST1H4C), in 3 individuals from 2 families. [c.274A>C/ HGVS p.(Lys92Gln) dn in 1 subject and c.275A>C/ HGVS p.(Lys92Arg) inherited from unaffected mosaic parent].

Individuals from both families having relevant age had intellectual disability (2/2 - 2 families). Other features incl. growth delay (3/3) and microcephaly (3/3).

Expression of the variants in zebrafish severely affected structural development recapitulating the patient phenotypes (microcephaly and short stature).

RNA sequencing in fibroblasts from 2 unrelated patients and a control, revealed that expression of H4C3 variants was similar to wt. The authors estimated that ~8% of H4 cDNA molecules contained the variant. LC-MS/MS analysis suggested that the mutant protein was present in nucleosomes at a level of 1-2% while RNA-seq identified 115 differential expressed genes, with enrichment for relevant procedures (chr. organization, histone binding, DNA packaging, nucleosomal organization, cell cycle).

Post-translational modifications of Lys92 (H4K91) are highly conserved and have been previously associated with processes from chromatin assembly , DNA damage sensitivity, etc. Post-translational marks on Lys92 (K91) were absent in patient derived cells as a result of each variant.

Zebrafish models for both variants were suggestive for accumulation of double strand breaks (DSBs) more visible in heads and tails of larvae. Embryos expressing mutants displayed increased apoptosis in head and tail. Additional studies in larvae were suggestive of abnormal cell cycle progression (rel. increase in cellls in S/G2/M phase, increased occurrence of activated CHK2 with p53 stabilization) applying to both variants studied.

------
In a subsequent publication, Tessadori et al. (2020 - PMID: 31804630) described the phenotype of a 14 y.o. boy harboring a dn heterozygous missense H4C11 (HIST1H4J) variant following trio-ES [c.274A>G / HGVS p.(Lys92Glu)]. Features incl. profound ID, microcephaly, short stature with some dysmorphic features (uplsanting p-f, hypertelorism, etc). Previous work-up was normal/non-diagnostic and incl. FMR1, MECP2 and a CMA showing an inherited 207 kb CNV involving KCNV1. Upon mRNA microinjection in zebrafish embryos - either for wt or for Lys92Glu HIST1H4J - effect for wt was very mild. Lys92Glu expression led to defective development of head structures (brain, eyes), faulty body axis growth and dysmorphic tail reproducing the microcephaly and short stature phenotype. This was similar to previous zebrafish studies for HIS1H4C variants (above).

------
Tessadori et al. (2022 - PMID: 35202563) describe 29 *additional individuals with de novo missense variants in genes encoding H4, namely:
- H4C3 (HIST1H4C/N=6 subjects),
- H4C11 (HIST1H4J/N=1),
- H4C4 (HIST1H4D/N=1),
- H4C5 (HIST1H4E/N=17),
- H4C6 (HIST1H4F/N=1),
- H4C9 (HIST1H4I/N=3).

All individuals, exhibited DD and ID (29/29). Other features incl. hypotonia (10/29), seizures (5/29), autism (5/29), ataxia (4/29). Abnormal growth incl. progressive microcephaly (2/19 prenatal, 20/29 postnatal onset), short stature/FTT (each 11/29). Few had skeletal features (craniosynostosis 2/29, abn. digits 4/29, vertebral 4/29). Some had visual (17/28) or hearing impairment (7/29). Facial features incl. hypertelorism (5/29), upslanting p-f (3/29), broad nasal tip (11/29), thin upper lip (4/29) and teeth anomalies (6/29 - notably gap between central incisors).

The authors state that the cohort was collected with trio WES but also after data sharing via Genematcher / DECIPHER.

Identified variants were in all cases missense and de novo, the latter either by trio WES or Sanger sequencing of parents.

Previous work-up or presence of additional variants are not discussed.

At the protein level 10 aa were affected, 6 of which recurrently within the same gene (Arg45, His75, Lys91, Tyr98) as well among several genes for H4 (Pro32, Arg40). Variants lied within two clusters, one corresponding to the α-helix of H4 (reported variants affected Lys31 - Arg45) important for DNA contacts, interactions with H3 and histone chaperones. The other within the core of nucleosome (reported patient variants : His75-Tyr98) with important strucural contact between H3-H4 dimer and histone chaperones.

There were no detectable genotype-phenotype patterns separating individual H4 genes or protein regions. Of note, variability was observed even among 7 individuals with the same dn H4C5 variant (Arg45Cys).

All variants were absent from control databases incl. gnomAD and affected residues conserved through to S. cerevisiae. Substitutions affecting Arg45 and Gly94 and His75 have been studied previously with effect in growth/fitness/chromatin remodeling/DNA damage repair depending on variant (5 studies cited).

Zebrafish embryos at the 1 cell stage were injected with mRNA encoding either wt or identified variants, the latter inducing significant developmental defects with the exception of Pro32Ala (H4C3) and Arg40Cys (H4C5, H4C11).

For Pro32Ala and Arg40Cys however, the strong recurrence in this cohort supports pathogenicity. A dosage dependent effect was observed for 2 variants.

H4 genes appear to be tolerant to both missense and loss-of-function variation (the latter even in homozygous form) suggesting a dominant effect of the variants.

------
[RefSeqs : H4C3/HIST1H4C - NM_0035242.4 | H4C4/HIST1H4D - NM_003539.4 | H4C5/HIST1H4E - NM_003545.3 | H4C6/HIST1H4F - NM_003540.4 | H4C9/HIST1H4I - NM_003495.2 | H4C11/HIST1H4J - NM_021968.4 // Variants at the protein level above are according to the HGVS nomenclature. However as the N-terminal methionine is cleaved, numbering relative to the mature peptide has also been used in publications eg. p.Pro33Ala HGVS corresponding to Pro32Ala]
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v3.1520 HIST1H4I Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: HIST1H4I was added
gene: HIST1H4I was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: HIST1H4I was set to MONOALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal, imprinted status unknown
Publications for gene: HIST1H4I were set to 35202563
Phenotypes for gene: HIST1H4I were set to Global developmental delay; Intellectual disability; Microcephaly; Growth abnormality; Abnormality of the face
Penetrance for gene: HIST1H4I were set to unknown
Mode of pathogenicity for gene: HIST1H4I was set to Loss-of-function variants (as defined in pop up message) DO NOT cause this phenotype - please provide details in the comments
Review for gene: HIST1H4I was set to GREEN
Added comment: Histone H4 is a core component of the nucleosome, the basic repeating unit of eukaryotic chromatin. Each nucleosome consists of ~150 bp of DNA wrapped around a histone octamer. Each histone octamer is composed of 2 copies of each of the histones H2A, H2B, H3, H4. This organization is important for DNA replication, transcription and repair.

There are 14 canonical histone H4 genes in the human genome, which despite being different at the nucleotide level encode an identical protein. These cluster in 3 genomic loci. Their transcription is independently regulated with differing expression during brain development and in human tissues.

Histone H4 forms a dimer with H3 (which however has variant isoforms linked to specific cellular processes).

Pathogenic variants in genes encoding H4 have been reported in several individuals. Irrrespective of the gene for H4 involved, all patients presented with highly overlapping features, DD and ID being universal. Available reports to date concern :
- H4C3/HIST1H4C (9 subjects - PMID: 28920961, 35202563),
- H4C11/HIST1H4J (1 subject - PMID: 31804630, 35202563),
- H4C4/HIST1H4D (1 subject - PMID:35202563),
- H4C5/HIST1H4E (17 subjects - PMID: 35202563),
- H4C6/HIST1H4F (1 subject - PMID: 35202563),
- H4C9/HIST1H4I (3 subjects - PMID: 35202563).

Variants in all cases were missense SNVs, occurring (in almost all cases) as dn variants and affecting the same residue in the same and/or different H4 genes (details for clusters below). Eg. Arg45Cys was a recurrent variant for H4C5 (>=7 subjects), while variants affecting Arg40 have been reported in H4C4, H4C5, H4C9, H4C11 (7 subjects overall).

Zebrafish studies for all genes reported have included most - if not all - patient variants and recapitulate features observed in affected individuals (head size/structure and growth).

Additional studies specificaly for H4C3/HIST1H4C have been performed in patient fibroblasts (demonstrating among others transcriptional dysregulation) and zebrafish (accumulation of DSBs, increased apoptosis in head/tail, abn. cell cycle progression).

Note that the nomenclature for variants - at the protein level - used in literature commonly takes into consideration cleavage of Met1, thus the numbering may not correspond to the HGVS one.

Relevant entries exist in OMIM, G2P and SysID only for H4C3/HIST1H4C (Tessadori-van Haaften neurodevelopmental syndrome 1, #619758) and H4C11/HIST1H4J (?Tessadori-van Haaften neurodevelopmental syndrome 2, #619759) but not for other genes.

Rating in PanelApp Australia - ID Panel : HIST1H4C Green, H4J Amber, H4D Amber, H4E Green, H4F Amber, H4I Green.

Please consider inclusion in other possibly relevant panels (microcephaly, short stature/FTT, etc).

------
Initial work from Tessadori et al (incl. DDD study, 2017 - PMID:28920961) identified monoallelic missense SNVs affecting the same residue of H4C3 (HIST1H4C), in 3 individuals from 2 families. [c.274A>C/ HGVS p.(Lys92Gln) dn in 1 subject and c.275A>C/ HGVS p.(Lys92Arg) inherited from unaffected mosaic parent].

Individuals from both families having relevant age had intellectual disability (2/2 - 2 families). Other features incl. growth delay (3/3) and microcephaly (3/3).

Expression of the variants in zebrafish severely affected structural development recapitulating the patient phenotypes (microcephaly and short stature).

RNA sequencing in fibroblasts from 2 unrelated patients and a control, revealed that expression of H4C3 variants was similar to wt. The authors estimated that ~8% of H4 cDNA molecules contained the variant. LC-MS/MS analysis suggested that the mutant protein was present in nucleosomes at a level of 1-2% while RNA-seq identified 115 differential expressed genes, with enrichment for relevant procedures (chr. organization, histone binding, DNA packaging, nucleosomal organization, cell cycle).

Post-translational modifications of Lys92 (H4K91) are highly conserved and have been previously associated with processes from chromatin assembly , DNA damage sensitivity, etc. Post-translational marks on Lys92 (K91) were absent in patient derived cells as a result of each variant.

Zebrafish models for both variants were suggestive for accumulation of double strand breaks (DSBs) more visible in heads and tails of larvae. Embryos expressing mutants displayed increased apoptosis in head and tail. Additional studies in larvae were suggestive of abnormal cell cycle progression (rel. increase in cellls in S/G2/M phase, increased occurrence of activated CHK2 with p53 stabilization) applying to both variants studied.

------
In a subsequent publication, Tessadori et al. (2020 - PMID: 31804630) described the phenotype of a 14 y.o. boy harboring a dn heterozygous missense H4C11 (HIST1H4J) variant following trio-ES [c.274A>G / HGVS p.(Lys92Glu)]. Features incl. profound ID, microcephaly, short stature with some dysmorphic features (uplsanting p-f, hypertelorism, etc). Previous work-up was normal/non-diagnostic and incl. FMR1, MECP2 and a CMA showing an inherited 207 kb CNV involving KCNV1. Upon mRNA microinjection in zebrafish embryos - either for wt or for Lys92Glu HIST1H4J - effect for wt was very mild. Lys92Glu expression led to defective development of head structures (brain, eyes), faulty body axis growth and dysmorphic tail reproducing the microcephaly and short stature phenotype. This was similar to previous zebrafish studies for HIS1H4C variants (above).

------
Tessadori et al. (2022 - PMID: 35202563) describe 29 *additional individuals with de novo missense variants in genes encoding H4, namely:
- H4C3 (HIST1H4C/N=6 subjects),
- H4C11 (HIST1H4J/N=1),
- H4C4 (HIST1H4D/N=1),
- H4C5 (HIST1H4E/N=17),
- H4C6 (HIST1H4F/N=1),
- H4C9 (HIST1H4I/N=3).

All individuals, exhibited DD and ID (29/29). Other features incl. hypotonia (10/29), seizures (5/29), autism (5/29), ataxia (4/29). Abnormal growth incl. progressive microcephaly (2/19 prenatal, 20/29 postnatal onset), short stature/FTT (each 11/29). Few had skeletal features (craniosynostosis 2/29, abn. digits 4/29, vertebral 4/29). Some had visual (17/28) or hearing impairment (7/29). Facial features incl. hypertelorism (5/29), upslanting p-f (3/29), broad nasal tip (11/29), thin upper lip (4/29) and teeth anomalies (6/29 - notably gap between central incisors).

The authors state that the cohort was collected with trio WES but also after data sharing via Genematcher / DECIPHER.

Identified variants were in all cases missense and de novo, the latter either by trio WES or Sanger sequencing of parents.

Previous work-up or presence of additional variants are not discussed.

At the protein level 10 aa were affected, 6 of which recurrently within the same gene (Arg45, His75, Lys91, Tyr98) as well among several genes for H4 (Pro32, Arg40). Variants lied within two clusters, one corresponding to the α-helix of H4 (reported variants affected Lys31 - Arg45) important for DNA contacts, interactions with H3 and histone chaperones. The other within the core of nucleosome (reported patient variants : His75-Tyr98) with important strucural contact between H3-H4 dimer and histone chaperones.

There were no detectable genotype-phenotype patterns separating individual H4 genes or protein regions. Of note, variability was observed even among 7 individuals with the same dn H4C5 variant (Arg45Cys).

All variants were absent from control databases incl. gnomAD and affected residues conserved through to S. cerevisiae. Substitutions affecting Arg45 and Gly94 and His75 have been studied previously with effect in growth/fitness/chromatin remodeling/DNA damage repair depending on variant (5 studies cited).

Zebrafish embryos at the 1 cell stage were injected with mRNA encoding either wt or identified variants, the latter inducing significant developmental defects with the exception of Pro32Ala (H4C3) and Arg40Cys (H4C5, H4C11).

For Pro32Ala and Arg40Cys however, the strong recurrence in this cohort supports pathogenicity. A dosage dependent effect was observed for 2 variants.

H4 genes appear to be tolerant to both missense and loss-of-function variation (the latter even in homozygous form) suggesting a dominant effect of the variants.

------
[RefSeqs : H4C3/HIST1H4C - NM_0035242.4 | H4C4/HIST1H4D - NM_003539.4 | H4C5/HIST1H4E - NM_003545.3 | H4C6/HIST1H4F - NM_003540.4 | H4C9/HIST1H4I - NM_003495.2 | H4C11/HIST1H4J - NM_021968.4 // Variants at the protein level above are according to the HGVS nomenclature. However as the N-terminal methionine is cleaved, numbering relative to the mature peptide has also been used in publications eg. p.Pro33Ala HGVS corresponding to Pro32Ala]
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v3.1518 HEATR3 Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: HEATR3 was added
gene: HEATR3 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: HEATR3 was set to BIALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal
Publications for gene: HEATR3 were set to 35213692
Phenotypes for gene: HEATR3 were set to Anemia; Thrombocytopenia; Growth delay; Short stature; Abnormality of the skeletal system; Abnormality of finger; Abnormality of the thumb; Intellectual disability; Obesity; Abnormality of the face
Penetrance for gene: HEATR3 were set to Complete
Review for gene: HEATR3 was set to AMBER
Added comment: O'Donohue et al (2022 - PMID: 35213692) describe the clinical features of 6 individuals (from 4 unrelated families) with biallelic pathogenic HEATR3 variants.

These included bone marrow failure (anemia/anemia and thrombocytopenia at presentation), short stature/growth retardation (4/6), facial features (5/6 - in some: straight eyebrows, d-s palpebral fissures, synophrys) and skeletal findings incl. disproportionately short fingers/thumb anomaly. ID was reported in 4/6 individuals from 3 families (all: mild ID | 2/6 without ID). The phenotype corresponded overall to a variant form Diamond-Blackfan anemia (DBA, disorder caused by variants in genes encoding for ribosomal proteins) with additional features.

The 1st family (2 affected sibs and parents) underwent WES, not diagnostic for DBA. Analysis suggested variants in HEATR3 (prioritized due to its potential role in ribosome biogenesis) and 4 additional genes as candidates. Collaboration in the European DBA consortium and national DBA consortia led to identification of additional families.

HEATR3 encodes Heat-repeat-containing protein 3 or symportin, a protein that co-imports uL5 (encoded by RPL11) and uL18 (RPL5) in the nucleus where they assemble with 5S rRNA to form 5S RNP. The 5S RNP complex incorporates with maturing large ribosomal subunits to form the central protuberance. When 5S RNP is not incorporated, it accumulates and associates with Hdm2 ubiquitin ligase, the later normally targeting p53 proteasomal degradation.

The following missense and splice variants were identified (NM_182922):
- c.1751G>Α/p.(Gly584Glu) hmz
- c.1337G>A/p.(Cys446Tyr) hmz
- c.399+1G>T in trans with c.719C>T/p.(Pro240Leu)
- c.400T>C/p.(Cys134Arg) hmz

Variants were confirmed with Sanger sequencing. They were dispersed across HEATR3 without clustering although they affect residues either in the ARM (38-320) or HEAT (415-675) repeat domains, at positions evolutionary conserved, with in silico predictions in favor of a deleterious effect. With the exception of Cys134Arg (AF:4.11x10-6/no hmz), all were absent from gnomAD.

Studies in yeast suggested that deletions in symportin gene (syo1) lead to a mild growth defect and accumulation of 40S subunits. Similarly, two yeast strains engineered to test for the effect of the p.Gly584Glu (yeast p.Gly522Glu/Ala) exhibited growth defect and ribosomal subunit imbalance, both restored by wt Syo1.

HA-tagged HEATR3 in HeLa cells suggested that the co-translational capture mechanism to chaperone uL18 (RPL5) is conserved in human cells but was not observed upon expression of the p.Cys446Tyr variant.

While HEATR3 transcription was not affected in LCLs from individuals hmz for Gly584Glu or Cys446Tyr, protein levels were barely detectable, suggesting destabilization of the protein.

While uL18 accumulates in cytoplasm and nucleus with expected enrichment in nucleolus, upon siRNA knockdown of HEATR3 in HeLa cells this enrichment was lost. Studies in fibroblasts (Gly584Glu) demonstrated reduced uL18 nuclear staining. Overall, HEATR3 was suggested to be important for nuclear import of uL18 (though not for uL5).

LCL studies demonstrated pre-rRNA processing defects in patient cells with accumulation of 32S and 12S pre-rRNAs, the former being reminiscent of accumulations observed in individuals with RPL5- and RPL11-related DBA. Expression of wt HEATR3 restored processing defects.

LCLs from affected individuals revealed loss of free 60S subunits (as in yeast) with expression of wt cDNA restoring Nl levels.

Western blots of LCLs demonstrated that the levels of uL5, uL18 and p53 were not affected (the latter also observed in RPL5-related DBA)

Studies of bone marrow smears from 2 affected individuals allowed to conclude in a strong defect in erythroid cell proliferation.

Currently, there is no HEATR3-associated phenotype in OMIM, PanelApp Australia, G2P or the SysID database.

Consider inclusion in the ID panel with amber (mild ID in >3 individuals/families/variants although not universal feature) or green rating. Also consider inclusion in other possibly relevant panels eg. for cytopenias/congenital anemias, short stature, etc.
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v3.1352 SNIP1 Sarah Leigh Added comment: Comment on list classification: Associated with relevant phenotype in OMIM and as possible Gen2Phen gene. A single (founder) variant NM_024700.4:c.1097A>G, p.(Glu366Gly) has been reported in over 30 cases of Psychomotor retardation, epilepsy, and craniofacial dysmorphism OMIM:614501 in the Amish community (PMIDs: 22279524; 34570759). Cases are homozygous for this variant and unaffected members of the families are heterozygous or wt. Overexpression of the equivalent mouse variant in mouse inner medullary collecting duct cells, resulted in a more aggregated appearance in the nucleus compared to wildtype. The variant protein maybe unstable as Western blots showed reduced levels of the variant protein (PMID: 22279524). Whole transcriptomic analysis of patient blood was performed in PMID: 34570759. This revealed 11 upregulated and 32 downregulated genes, of which 24 had previously been associated with neurological disease.
Intellectual disability v3.1220 VPS50 Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: VPS50 was added
gene: VPS50 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: VPS50 was set to BIALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal
Publications for gene: VPS50 were set to 34037727
Phenotypes for gene: VPS50 were set to Neonatal cholestatic liver disease; Failure to thrive; Profound global developmental delay; Postnatal microcephaly; Seizures; Abnormality of the corpus callosum
Penetrance for gene: VPS50 were set to Complete
Review for gene: VPS50 was set to AMBER
Added comment: Schneeberger et al (2021 - PMID: 34037727) describe the phenotype of 2 unrelated individuals with biallelic VPS50 variants.

Common features included transient neonatal cholestasis, failure to thrive, severe DD with failure to achieve milestones (last examination at 2y and 2y2m respectively), postnatal microcephaly, seizures (onset at 6m and 25m) and irritability. There was corpus callosum hypoplasia on brain imaging.

Both individuals were homozygous for variants private to each family (no/not known consanguinity applying to each case). The first individual was homozygous for a splicing variant (NM_017667.4:c.1978-1G>T) and had a similarly unaffected sister deceased with no available DNA for testing. The other individual was homozygous for an in-frame deletion (c.1823_1825delCAA / p.(Thr608del)).

VPS50 encodes a critical component of the endosome-associated recycling protein (EARP) complex, which functions in recycling endocytic vesicles back to the plasma membrane [OMIM based on Schindler et al]. The complex contains VPS50, VPS51, VPS52, VPS53, the three latter also being components of GARP (Golgi-associated-retrograde protein) complex. GARP contains VPS54 instead of VPS50 and is required for trafficking of proteins to the trans-golgi network. Thus VPS50 (also named syndetin) and VPS54 function in the EARP and GARP complexes, to define directional movement of their endocytic vesicles [OMIM based on Schindler et al]. The VPS50 subunit is required for recycling of the transferrin receptor.

As discussed by Schneeberger et al (refs provided in text):
- VPS50 has a high expression in mouse and human brain as well as throughout mouse brain development.
- Mice deficient for Vps50 have not been reported. vps50 knockdown in zebrafish results in severe developmental defects of the body axis. Knockout mice for other proteins of the EARP/GARP complex (e.g. Vps52, 53 and 54) display embryonic lethality.

Studies performed by Schneeberger et al included:
- Transcript analysis for the 1st variant demonstrated skipping of ex21 (in patient derived fabriblasts) leading to an in frame deletion of 81 bp (r.1978_2058del) with predicted loss of 27 residues (p.Leu660_Leu686del).
- Similar VPS50 mRNA levels but significant reduction of protein levels (~5% and ~8% of controls) were observed in fibroblasts from patients 1 and 2. Additionally, significant reductions in the amounts of VPS52 and VPS53 protein levels were observed despite mRNA levels similar to controls. Overall, this suggested drastic reduction of functional EARP complex levels.
- Lysosomes appeared to have similar morphology, cellular distribution and likely unaffected function in patient fibroblasts.
- Transferrin receptor recycling was shown to be delayed in patient fibroblasts suggestive of compromise of endocytic-recycling function.

As the authors comment, the phenotype of both individuals with biallelic VPS50 variants overlaps with the corresponding phenotype reported in 15 subjects with biallelic VPS53 or VPS51 mutations notably, severe DD/ID, microcephaly and early onset epilepsy, CC anomalies. Overall, for this group, they propose the term "GARP and/or EARP deficiency disorders".

There is no VPS50-associated phenotype in OMIM or G2P. SysID includes VPS50 among the ID candidate genes.

Consider inclusion in other relevant gene panels (e.g. for neonatal cholestasis, epilepsy, microcephaly, growth failure in early infancy, corpus callosum anomalies, etc) with amber rating pending further reports.
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v3.1217 PIDD1 Konstantinos Varvagiannis changed review comment from: There is enough evidence to include this gene in the current panel with green rating.

Biallelic PIDD1 pathogenic variants have been reported in 26 individuals (11 families) with DD (all), variable degrees of ID (mild to severe), behavioral (eg. aggression/self-mutilation in several, ADHD) and/or psychiatric abnormalities (ASD, psychosis in 5 belonging to 3 families), well-controlled epilepsy is some (9 subjects from 6 families) and MRI abnormalities notably abnormal gyration pattern (pachygyria with predominant anterior gradient) as well as corpus callosum anomalies (commonly thinning) in several. Dysmorphic features have been reported in almost all, although there has been no specific feature suggested.

The first reports on the phenotype associated with biallelic PIDD1 mutations were made by Harripaul et al (2018 - PMID: 28397838) and Hu et al (2019 - PMID: 29302074) [both studies investigating large cohorts of individuals with ID from consanguineous families].

Sheikh et al (2021 - PMID: 33414379) provided details on the phenotype of 15 individuals from 5 families including those from the previous 2 reports and studied provided evidence on the role of PIDD1 and the effect of variants.

Zaki et al (2021 - PMID: 34163010) reported 11 additional individuals from 6 consanguineous families, summarize the features of all subjects published in the literature and review the neuroradiological features of the disorder.

PIDD1 encodes p53-induced death domain protein 1. The protein is part of the PIDDosome, a multiprotein complex also composed of the bipartite linker protein CRADD (also known as RAIDD) and the proform of caspase-2 and induces apoptosis in response to DNA damage.

There are 5 potential PIDD1 mRNA transcript variants with NM_145886.4 corresponding to the longest. Similar to the protein encoded by CRADD, PIDD1 contains a death domain (DD - aa 774-893). Constitutive post-translational processing gives PIDD1-N, PIDD1-C the latter further processed into PIDD1-CC (by auto-cleavage). Serine residues at pos. 446 and 588 are involved in this autoprocessing generating PIDD1-C (aa 446-910) and PIDD1-CC (aa 774-893). The latter is needed for caspase-2 activation.

Most (if not all) individuals belonged to consanguineous families of different origins and harbored pLoF or missense variants.

Variants reported so far include : c.2587C>T; p.Gln863* / c.1909C>T ; p.Arg637* / c.2443C>T / p.Arg815Trp / c.2275-1G>A which upon trap assay was shown to lead to skipping of ex15 with direct splicing form exon14 to the terminal exon 16 (resulting to p.Arg759Glyfs*1 with exlcusion of the entire DD) / c.2584C>T; p.Arg862Trp / c.1340G>A; p.Trp447* / c.2116_2120del; p.Val706His*, c.1564_1565del; p.Gly602fs*26

Evidence so far provided includes:
- Biallelic CRADD variants cause a NDD disorder and a highly similar gyration pattern.
- Confirmation of splicing effect (eg. for c.2275-1G>A premature stop in position 760) or poor expression (NM_145886.3:c.2587C>T; p.Gln863*). Arg815Trp did not affect autoprocessing or protein stability.
- Abnormal localization pattern, loss of interaction with CRADD and failure to activate caspase-2 (MDM2 cleavage assay) [p.Gln863* and Arg815Trp]
- Available expression data from GTEx (PIDD1 having broad expression in multiple tissues, but higher in brain cerebellum) as well as BrainSpan and PsychEncode studies suggesting high coexpression of PIDD1, CRADD and CASP2 in many regions in the developing human brain.
- Variants in other genes encoding proteins interacting with PIDD1 (MADD, FADD, DNAJ, etc) are associated with NDD.

Pidd-1 ko mice (ex3-15 removal) lack however CNS-related phenotypes. These show decreased anxiety but no motor anomalies. This has also been the case with Cradd-/- mice displaying no significant CNS phenotypes without lamination defects.

There is currently no associated phenotype in OMIM, PanelApp Australia. PIDD1 is listed in the DD panel of G2P (PIDD1-relared NDD / biallelic / loss of function / probable) . SysID includes PIDD1 among the current primary ID genes.

Overall the gene appears to be relevant for the epilepsy panel, panels for gyration and/or corpus callosum anomalies etc.
Sources: Literature, Other; to: There is enough evidence to include this gene in the current panel with green rating.

Biallelic PIDD1 pathogenic variants have been reported in 26 individuals (11 families) with DD (all), variable degrees of ID (mild to severe), behavioral (eg. aggression/self-mutilation in several, ADHD) and/or psychiatric abnormalities (ASD, psychosis in 5 belonging to 3 families), well-controlled epilepsy is some (9 subjects from 6 families) and MRI abnormalities notably abnormal gyration pattern (pachygyria with predominant anterior gradient) as well as corpus callosum anomalies (commonly thinning) in several. Dysmorphic features have been reported in almost all, although there has been no specific feature suggested.

The first reports on the phenotype associated with biallelic PIDD1 mutations were made by Harripaul et al (2018 - PMID: 28397838) and Hu et al (2019 - PMID: 29302074) [both studies investigating large cohorts of individuals with ID from consanguineous families].

Sheikh et al (2021 - PMID: 33414379) provided details on the phenotype of 15 individuals from 5 families including those from the previous 2 reports and studied provided evidence on the role of PIDD1 and the effect of variants.

Zaki et al (2021 - PMID: 34163010) reported 11 additional individuals from 6 consanguineous families, summarize the features of all subjects published in the literature and review the neuroradiological features of the disorder.

PIDD1 encodes p53-induced death domain protein 1. The protein is part of the PIDDosome, a multiprotein complex also composed of the bipartite linker protein CRADD (also known as RAIDD) and the proform of caspase-2 and induces apoptosis in response to DNA damage.

There are 5 potential PIDD1 mRNA transcript variants with NM_145886.4 corresponding to the longest. Similar to the protein encoded by CRADD, PIDD1 contains a death domain (DD - aa 774-893). Constitutive post-translational processing gives PIDD1-N, PIDD1-C the latter further processed into PIDD1-CC (by auto-cleavage). Serine residues at pos. 446 and 588 are involved in this autoprocessing generating PIDD1-C (aa 446-910) and PIDD1-CC (aa 774-893). The latter is needed for caspase-2 activation.

Most (if not all) individuals belonged to consanguineous families of different origins and harbored pLoF or missense variants.

Variants reported so far include : c.2587C>T; p.Gln863* / c.1909C>T ; p.Arg637* / c.2443C>T / p.Arg815Trp / c.2275-1G>A which upon trap assay was shown to lead to skipping of ex15 with direct splicing form exon14 to the terminal exon 16 (resulting to p.Arg759Glyfs*1 with exlcusion of the entire DD) / c.2584C>T; p.Arg862Trp / c.1340G>A; p.Trp447* / c.2116_2120del; p.Val706His*, c.1564_1565del; p.Gly602fs*26

Evidence so far provided includes:
- Biallelic CRADD variants cause a NDD disorder and a highly similar gyration pattern.
- Confirmation of splicing effect (eg. for c.2275-1G>A premature stop in position 760) or poor expression (NM_145886.3:c.2587C>T; p.Gln863*). Arg815Trp did not affect autoprocessing or protein stability.
- Abnormal localization pattern, loss of interaction with CRADD and failure to activate caspase-2 (MDM2 cleavage assay) [p.Gln863* and Arg815Trp]
- Available expression data from GTEx (PIDD1 having broad expression in multiple tissues, but higher in brain cerebellum) as well as BrainSpan and PsychEncode studies suggesting high coexpression of PIDD1, CRADD and CASP2 in many regions in the developing human brain.
- Variants in other genes encoding proteins interacting with PIDD1 (MADD, FADD, DNAJ, etc) are associated with NDD.

Pidd-1 ko mice (ex3-15 removal) lack however CNS-related phenotypes. These show decreased anxiety but no motor anomalies. This has also been the case with Cradd-/- mice displaying no significant CNS phenotypes without lamination defects.

There is currently no associated phenotype in OMIM, PanelApp Australia. PIDD1 is listed in the DD panel of G2P (PIDD1-related NDD / biallelic / loss of function / probable) . SysID includes PIDD1 among the current primary ID genes.

Overall the gene appears to be relevant for the epilepsy panel, panels for gyration and/or corpus callosum anomalies etc.
Sources: Literature, Other
Intellectual disability v3.1217 PIDD1 Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: PIDD1 was added
gene: PIDD1 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature,Other
Mode of inheritance for gene: PIDD1 was set to BIALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal
Publications for gene: PIDD1 were set to 28397838; 29302074; 33414379; 34163010
Phenotypes for gene: PIDD1 were set to Global developmental delay; Intellectual disability; Seizures; Autism; Behavioral abnormality; Psychosis; Pachygyria; Lissencephaly; Abnormality of the corpus callosum
Penetrance for gene: PIDD1 were set to Complete
Review for gene: PIDD1 was set to GREEN
Added comment: There is enough evidence to include this gene in the current panel with green rating.

Biallelic PIDD1 pathogenic variants have been reported in 26 individuals (11 families) with DD (all), variable degrees of ID (mild to severe), behavioral (eg. aggression/self-mutilation in several, ADHD) and/or psychiatric abnormalities (ASD, psychosis in 5 belonging to 3 families), well-controlled epilepsy is some (9 subjects from 6 families) and MRI abnormalities notably abnormal gyration pattern (pachygyria with predominant anterior gradient) as well as corpus callosum anomalies (commonly thinning) in several. Dysmorphic features have been reported in almost all, although there has been no specific feature suggested.

The first reports on the phenotype associated with biallelic PIDD1 mutations were made by Harripaul et al (2018 - PMID: 28397838) and Hu et al (2019 - PMID: 29302074) [both studies investigating large cohorts of individuals with ID from consanguineous families].

Sheikh et al (2021 - PMID: 33414379) provided details on the phenotype of 15 individuals from 5 families including those from the previous 2 reports and studied provided evidence on the role of PIDD1 and the effect of variants.

Zaki et al (2021 - PMID: 34163010) reported 11 additional individuals from 6 consanguineous families, summarize the features of all subjects published in the literature and review the neuroradiological features of the disorder.

PIDD1 encodes p53-induced death domain protein 1. The protein is part of the PIDDosome, a multiprotein complex also composed of the bipartite linker protein CRADD (also known as RAIDD) and the proform of caspase-2 and induces apoptosis in response to DNA damage.

There are 5 potential PIDD1 mRNA transcript variants with NM_145886.4 corresponding to the longest. Similar to the protein encoded by CRADD, PIDD1 contains a death domain (DD - aa 774-893). Constitutive post-translational processing gives PIDD1-N, PIDD1-C the latter further processed into PIDD1-CC (by auto-cleavage). Serine residues at pos. 446 and 588 are involved in this autoprocessing generating PIDD1-C (aa 446-910) and PIDD1-CC (aa 774-893). The latter is needed for caspase-2 activation.

Most (if not all) individuals belonged to consanguineous families of different origins and harbored pLoF or missense variants.

Variants reported so far include : c.2587C>T; p.Gln863* / c.1909C>T ; p.Arg637* / c.2443C>T / p.Arg815Trp / c.2275-1G>A which upon trap assay was shown to lead to skipping of ex15 with direct splicing form exon14 to the terminal exon 16 (resulting to p.Arg759Glyfs*1 with exlcusion of the entire DD) / c.2584C>T; p.Arg862Trp / c.1340G>A; p.Trp447* / c.2116_2120del; p.Val706His*, c.1564_1565del; p.Gly602fs*26

Evidence so far provided includes:
- Biallelic CRADD variants cause a NDD disorder and a highly similar gyration pattern.
- Confirmation of splicing effect (eg. for c.2275-1G>A premature stop in position 760) or poor expression (NM_145886.3:c.2587C>T; p.Gln863*). Arg815Trp did not affect autoprocessing or protein stability.
- Abnormal localization pattern, loss of interaction with CRADD and failure to activate caspase-2 (MDM2 cleavage assay) [p.Gln863* and Arg815Trp]
- Available expression data from GTEx (PIDD1 having broad expression in multiple tissues, but higher in brain cerebellum) as well as BrainSpan and PsychEncode studies suggesting high coexpression of PIDD1, CRADD and CASP2 in many regions in the developing human brain.
- Variants in other genes encoding proteins interacting with PIDD1 (MADD, FADD, DNAJ, etc) are associated with NDD.

Pidd-1 ko mice (ex3-15 removal) lack however CNS-related phenotypes. These show decreased anxiety but no motor anomalies. This has also been the case with Cradd-/- mice displaying no significant CNS phenotypes without lamination defects.

There is currently no associated phenotype in OMIM, PanelApp Australia. PIDD1 is listed in the DD panel of G2P (PIDD1-relared NDD / biallelic / loss of function / probable) . SysID includes PIDD1 among the current primary ID genes.

Overall the gene appears to be relevant for the epilepsy panel, panels for gyration and/or corpus callosum anomalies etc.
Sources: Literature, Other
Intellectual disability v3.1163 RFX4 Zornitza Stark gene: RFX4 was added
gene: RFX4 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: RFX4 was set to MONOALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal, NOT imprinted
Publications for gene: RFX4 were set to 33658631
Phenotypes for gene: RFX4 were set to ID, ASD, ADHD
Review for gene: RFX4 was set to GREEN
Added comment: Report of 38 individuals (from 33 unrelated families) with de novo or inherited loss of function variants in RFX3 (15 families), RFX4 (4 families), and RFX7 (14 families), identified through WES. Individuals share neurobehavioural features including ASD, intellectual disability, and/or ADHD; other frequent features include hypersensitivity to sensory stimuli and sleep problems. RFX3, RFX4, and RFX7 are strongly expressed in developing and adult human brain, and X-box binding motifs as well as RFX ChIP-seq peaks are enriched in the cis-regulatory regions of known ASD risk genes. These genes are potentially critical transcriptional regulators of neurobiological pathways associated with neurodevelopmental disease pathogenesis.
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v3.1163 RFX3 Zornitza Stark gene: RFX3 was added
gene: RFX3 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: RFX3 was set to MONOALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal, NOT imprinted
Publications for gene: RFX3 were set to 33658631
Phenotypes for gene: RFX3 were set to ID, ASD, ADHD
Review for gene: RFX3 was set to GREEN
Added comment: Report of 38 individuals (from 33 unrelated families) with de novo or inherited loss of function variants in RFX3 (15 families), RFX4 (4 families), and RFX7 (14 families), identified through WES. Individuals share neurobehavioural features including ASD, intellectual disability, and/or ADHD; other frequent features include hypersensitivity to sensory stimuli and sleep problems. RFX3, RFX4, and RFX7 are strongly expressed in developing and adult human brain, and X-box binding motifs as well as RFX ChIP-seq peaks are enriched in the cis-regulatory regions of known ASD risk genes. These genes are potentially critical transcriptional regulators of neurobiological pathways associated with neurodevelopmental disease pathogenesis.
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v3.1163 RFX7 Zornitza Stark gene: RFX7 was added
gene: RFX7 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: RFX7 was set to MONOALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal, NOT imprinted
Publications for gene: RFX7 were set to 33658631
Phenotypes for gene: RFX7 were set to ID, ASD, ADHD
Review for gene: RFX7 was set to GREEN
Added comment: Report of 38 individuals (from 33 unrelated families) with de novo or inherited loss of function variants in RFX3 (15 families), RFX4 (4 families), and RFX7 (14 families), identified through WES. Individuals share neurobehavioural features including ASD, intellectual disability, and/or ADHD; other frequent features include hypersensitivity to sensory stimuli and sleep problems. RFX3, RFX4, and RFX7 are strongly expressed in developing and adult human brain, and X-box binding motifs as well as RFX ChIP-seq peaks are enriched in the cis-regulatory regions of known ASD risk genes. These genes are potentially critical transcriptional regulators of neurobiological pathways associated with neurodevelopmental disease pathogenesis.
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v3.500 PRKAR1B Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: PRKAR1B was added
gene: PRKAR1B was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: PRKAR1B was set to MONOALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal, imprinted status unknown
Publications for gene: PRKAR1B were set to https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.09.10.20190314; 25414040
Phenotypes for gene: PRKAR1B were set to Global developmental delay; Intellectual disability; Autism; Attention deficit hyperactivity disorder; Aggressive behavior; Abnormality of movement; Upslanted palpebral fissure
Penetrance for gene: PRKAR1B were set to unknown
Review for gene: PRKAR1B was set to AMBER
Added comment: Please consider inclusion of this gene with amber rating pending publication of the preprint and/or additional evidence.

Marbach et al. (2020 - medRxiv : https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.09.10.20190314 - last author : C. Schaaf) report 6 unrelated individuals with heterozygous missense PRKAR1B variants.

All presented formal ASD diagnosis (6/6), global developmental delay (6/6) and intellectual disability (all - formal evaluations were lacking though). Additional features included neurologic anomalies (movement disorders : dyspraxia, apraxia, clumsiness in all, with tremor/dystonia or involuntary movements as single occurrences). Three displayed high pain tolerance. Regression in speech was a feature in two. Additional behavior anomalies included ADHD (4-5/6) or aggression (3/6). There was no consistent pattern of malformations, physical anomalies or facial features (with the exception of uplsanted palpebral fissures reported in 4).

3 different missense variants were identified (NM_00116470:c.1003C>T - p.Arg335Trp, c.586G>A - p.Glu196Lys, c.500_501delAAinsTT - p.Gln167Leu) with Arg355Trp being a recurrent one within this cohort (4/6 subjects). A possible splicing effect may apply for the MNV. All variants are absent from gnomAD and the SNVs had CADD scores > 24.

In all cases were parental samples were available (5/6), the variant had occurred as a de novo event.

Protein kinase A (PKA) is a tetrameric holoenzyme formed by the association of 2 catalytic (C) subunits with a regulatory (R) subunit dimer. Activation of PKA is achieved through binding of 2 cAMP molecules to each R-subunit, and unleashing(/dissociation) of C-subunits to engage substrates. PRKACA/B genes encode the Cα- and Cβ-subunits while the 4 functionally non-redundant regulatory subunits are encoded by PRKAR1A/1B/2A/2B genes. As the authors comment, the RIβ subunit is primarily expressed in brain with higher expression in cortex and hypothalamus.

The functional consequences of the variants at cellular level were not studied.

Previous studies have demonstrated that downregulation of RIβ in murine hippocampal cultures, reduced phosphorylation of CREB, a transcription factor involved in long-term memory formation. The authors speculate that a similar effect on cAMP/PKA/CREB cascade may mediate the cognitive effects in humans. RIβ deficient mice also display diminished nociceptive pain, similar to the human phenotype. [Several refs provided].

The authors cite the study by Kaplanis et al (2020 - PMID: 33057194), where in a large sample of 31,058 trio exomes of children with developmental disorders, PRKAR1B was among the genes with significant enrichment for de novo missense variants. [The gene has a pLI score of 0.18 in gnomAD / o/e = 0.26 - so pLoF variants may not be deleterious].

Please note that a specific PRKAR1B variant (NM_002735.2:c.149T>G - p.Leu50Arg) has been previous reported to segregate with a late-onset neurodegenerative disorder characterized by dementia and/or parkinsonism within a large pedigree with 12 affected individuals [Wong et al 2014 - PMID: 25414040].
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v3.405 NUP214 Eleanor Williams changed review comment from: Associated with {Encephalopathy, acute, infection-induced, susceptibility to, 9} 618426 in OMIM and Gene2Phenotype (probable).

PMID: 31178128 - Fichtman et al 2019 - report on two families one of Palestinian decent, the other Northern European (not Finnish descent). Each had two affected siblings in which neurological decline was seen after febrile events. The older son in family A, exhibited minor developmental delay from infancy. A homozygous missense variant was identified in NUP214 (p.Arg38Cys) in family A and segregated with the disease in available family members. In family B affected sisters were compound heterozygous for a frameshift and a missense variant in NUP214 (p.Pro387Ser and p.Pro525Leufs∗6). Functional studies with fibroblasts from one patient in family A showed a decrease in NUP214 and NUP88 levels compared to controls,

PMID: 30758658 - Shamseldin et al 2019 - describe a multiplex consanguineous family in which four affected members presented with severe neonatal hypotonia, profound global developmental delay, progressive microcephaly and early death. Whole exome sequencing revealed the presence of a novel homozygous missense variant in NUP214, p.D154G.

PMID: 29483668 - Egloff et al 2018 - report a 4-year-old girl presenting with developmental delay, growth retardation and facial dysmorphism. She was found to have a 9q deletion inherited from her healthy mother and a a hemizygous one-base pair deletion in the NUP214 gene inherited from her father. From patient leukocytes it was found that the expression level of the NUP214 transcript was significantly decreased and close to zero in the patient compared to the controls. ; to: Associated with {Encephalopathy, acute, infection-induced, susceptibility to, 9} 618426 in OMIM and Gene2Phenotype (probable).

PMID: 31178128 - Fichtman et al 2019 - report on two families one of Palestinian decent, the other Northern European (not Finnish descent). Each had two affected siblings in which neurological decline was seen after febrile events. The older son in family A, exhibited minor developmental delay from infancy. A homozygous missense variant was identified in NUP214 (p.Arg38Cys) in family A and segregated with the disease in available family members. In family B affected sisters were compound heterozygous for a frameshift and a missense variant in NUP214 (p.Pro387Ser and p.Pro525Leufs∗6). Functional studies with fibroblasts from one patient in family A showed a decrease in NUP214 and NUP88 levels compared to controls,

PMID: 30758658 - Shamseldin et al 2019 - describe a multiplex consanguineous family in which four affected members presented with severe neonatal hypotonia, profound global developmental delay, progressive microcephaly and early death (<2 year old). Whole exome sequencing revealed the presence of a novel homozygous missense variant in NUP214, p.D154G.

PMID: 29483668 - Egloff et al 2018 - report a 4-year-old girl presenting with developmental delay, growth retardation and facial dysmorphism. She was found to have a 9q deletion inherited from her healthy mother and a hemizygous one-base pair deletion in the NUP214 gene inherited from her father. From patient leukocytes it was found that the expression level of the NUP214 transcript was significantly decreased and close to zero in the patient compared to the controls.
Intellectual disability v3.405 NUP214 Eleanor Williams changed review comment from: Associated with {Encephalopathy, acute, infection-induced, susceptibility to, 9} 618426 in OMIM and Gene2Phenotype (probable).

PMID: 31178128 - Fichtman et al 2019 - report on two families. Family A have first-cousin parents of Palestinian descent. The proband exhibited minor developmental delay from infancy, presented with ataxia, mental retardation, and intractable epilepsy and died at 11 years. He suffered deterioration in association with febrile illnesses. His cousin presented at 5.5 months with partially reversible encephalopathy and developmental regression after a febrile illness. Family B were sisters born to non-consanguineous parents of Northern European (non-Finnish) descent. The older sister had nystagmus at 2 months and mild hypotonia, but she was otherwise meeting milestones appropriately . At 15 months of age, she developed a fever that led to a rapid neurological decline, seizures, and abnormal movements. The younger sister presented at 7 months with failure to thrive and hyponatremia but was meeting developmental milestones appropriately. By 24 months of age, she had motor and speech delay, ataxic gait, and occasional very mild head bobbing. In family A a homozygous NUP214 p.Arg38Cys variant segregated with the disease in available family members. In family B the sisters were found to be compound heterozygous for a frameshift and a missense variant in NUP214 (p.Pro387Ser and p.Pro525Leufs∗6).; to: Associated with {Encephalopathy, acute, infection-induced, susceptibility to, 9} 618426 in OMIM and Gene2Phenotype (probable).

PMID: 31178128 - Fichtman et al 2019 - report on two families one of Palestinian decent, the other Northern European (not Finnish descent). Each had two affected siblings in which neurological decline was seen after febrile events. The older son in family A, exhibited minor developmental delay from infancy. A homozygous missense variant was identified in NUP214 (p.Arg38Cys) in family A and segregated with the disease in available family members. In family B affected sisters were compound heterozygous for a frameshift and a missense variant in NUP214 (p.Pro387Ser and p.Pro525Leufs∗6). Functional studies with fibroblasts from one patient in family A showed a decrease in NUP214 and NUP88 levels compared to controls,

PMID: 30758658 - Shamseldin et al 2019 - describe a multiplex consanguineous family in which four affected members presented with severe neonatal hypotonia, profound global developmental delay, progressive microcephaly and early death. Whole exome sequencing revealed the presence of a novel homozygous missense variant in NUP214, p.D154G.

PMID: 29483668 - Egloff et al 2018 - report a 4-year-old girl presenting with developmental delay, growth retardation and facial dysmorphism. She was found to have a 9q deletion inherited from her healthy mother and a a hemizygous one-base pair deletion in the NUP214 gene inherited from her father. From patient leukocytes it was found that the expression level of the NUP214 transcript was significantly decreased and close to zero in the patient compared to the controls.
Intellectual disability v3.315 ZMYM2 Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: ZMYM2 was added
gene: ZMYM2 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: ZMYM2 was set to MONOALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal, imprinted status unknown
Publications for gene: ZMYM2 were set to 32891193
Phenotypes for gene: ZMYM2 were set to Abnormality of the urinary system; Global developmental delay; Intellectual disability; Microcephaly; Abnormality of the cardiovascular system; Autism; Seizures; Abnormality of the head or neck; Abnormality of the nail; Small hand; Short foot; Clinodactyly
Penetrance for gene: ZMYM2 were set to unknown
Review for gene: ZMYM2 was set to AMBER
Added comment: Heterozygous pathogenic (pLoF) ZMYM2 variants have been reported in individuals with syndromic presentation including CAKUT (in several cases) and variable neurological manifestations among extra-renal features. DD and ID were reported in some of the families described to date as summarized below. You might consider inclusion with green/amber rating in the ID panel and green in the panel for CAKUT.

--

Connaughton et al (2020 - PMID: 32891193) report on 19 individuals (from 15 unrelated families) with heterozygous pathogenic ZMYM2 variants. [Article not reviewed in detail].

Affected individuals from 7 families presented with CAKUT while all of them displayed extra-renal features. Neurological manifestations were reported in 16 individuals from 14 families (data not available for 1 fam), among others hypotonia (3/14 fam), speech delay (4/14 fam), global DD (9/14 fam), ID (4/14 fam), microcephaly (4/14 fam). ASD was reported in 4 fam (4 indiv). Seizures were reported in 2 fam (2 indiv). Variable other features included cardiac defects, facial dysmorphisms, small hands and feet with dys-/hypo-plastic nails and clinodactyly.

14 pLoF variants were identified, in most cases as de novo events (8 fam). In 2 families the variant was inherited from an affected parent. Germline mosaicism occurred in 1 family.

The human disease features were recapitulated in a X. tropicalis morpholino knockdown, with expression of truncating variants failing to rescue renal and craniofacial defects. Heterozygous Zmym2-deficient mice also recapitulated the features of CAKUT.

ZMYM2 (previously ZNF198) encodes a nuclear zinc finger protein localizing to the nucleus (and PML nuclear body).

It has previously been identified as transcriptional corepressor interacting with nuclear receptors and the LSD1-CoREST-HDAC1 complex. It has also been shown to interact with FOXP transcription factors.

The authors provide evidence for loss of interaction of the truncated ZMYM2 with FOXP1 (mutations in the latter having recently been reported in syndromic CAKUT).
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v3.289 SLC12A2 Arina Puzriakova changed review comment from: - PMID: 28940097 (2017) - SLC12A2 first identified as a novel candidate gene in a 3.3-year-old male with GDD, failure to thrive, hypotonia, microcephaly, neonatal respiratory distress, recurrent aspiration pneumonia, and osteopenia. Sequencing revealed a homozygous variant (c.2617-2A>G) that segregated within the family.

- PMID: 30740830 (2019) - Homozygous 22kb deletion identified in a 5-year-old male with GDD, sensorineural hearing loss, gastrointestinal abnormalities, early postnatal respiratory distress, generalised hypotonia, and absent salivation. Neuropsychological testing demonstrated profound delays in all developmental areas, with skills ranging from 1 to 6 months. The deletion was the result of uniparental paternal isodisomy.

Functional studies using patient-derived fibroblasts showed truncated SLC12A2 transcripts and markedly reduced protein levels compared to control. Knockout mouse model recapitulated phenotypic features such as deafness, abnormal neuronal growth and migration, gastrointestinal abnormalities, and absent salivation.

- PMID: 32754646 (2020) - Compound heterozygous variants (c.1431delT and c.2006-1G>A) were identified in two sibs. The proband, an 8-year-old girl, presented a severe neurodevelopmental disorder (including severe ID), hearing impairment, gastrointestinal problems, hypotonia, and absent tear fluid, saliva, and sweat. Phenotypic overlap was noted in an affected older sister, who died at 22 days of age.; to: - PMID: 28940097 (2017) - SLC12A2 first identified as a novel candidate gene in a 3.3-year-old male with GDD, failure to thrive, hypotonia, microcephaly, neonatal respiratory distress, recurrent aspiration pneumonia, and osteopenia. Sequencing revealed a homozygous variant (c.2617-2A>G) that segregated within the family.

- PMID: 30740830 (2019) - Homozygous 22kb deletion identified in a 5-year-old male with GDD, sensorineural hearing loss, gastrointestinal abnormalities, early postnatal respiratory distress, generalised hypotonia, and absent salivation. Neuropsychological testing demonstrated profound delays in all developmental areas, with skills ranging from 1 to 6 months. The deletion was the result of uniparental paternal isodisomy.

Functional studies using patient-derived fibroblasts showed truncated SLC12A2 transcripts and markedly reduced protein levels compared to control. Knockout mouse model recapitulated phenotypic features such as deafness, abnormal neuronal growth and migration, gastrointestinal abnormalities, and absent salivation.

- PMID: 32754646 (2020) - Compound heterozygous variants (c.1431delT and c.2006-1G>A) were identified in two sibs. The proband, an 8-year-old girl, presented a severe neurodevelopmental disorder (including severe ID), hearing impairment, gastrointestinal problems, hypotonia, and absent tear fluid, saliva, and sweat. Phenotypic overlap was noted in an affected older sister, who died at 22 days of age.

- PMID: 32658972 (2020) - Six unrelated children, all with mild-severe ID/DD, associated with de novo variants in SLC12A2. Additional clinical features included bilateral sensorineural hearing loss (2/6), abnormalities on brain MRI (2/4), and cerebral palsy (2/6). Some functional data in Xenopus laevis oocytes, indicating a role of SLC12A2 in neurogenesis.
Intellectual disability v3.255 TAF1C Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: TAF1C was added
gene: TAF1C was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: TAF1C was set to BIALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal
Publications for gene: TAF1C were set to 32779182
Phenotypes for gene: TAF1C were set to Global developmental delay; Intellectual disability; Spasticity; Strabismus; Seizures; Abnormality of nervous system morphology
Penetrance for gene: TAF1C were set to Complete
Review for gene: TAF1C was set to AMBER
Added comment: Knuutinen et al (2020 - PMID: 32779182) report on 2 individuals from 2 consanguineous families, homozygous for TAF1C missense variants.

Both presented with an early onset neurological phenotype with severe global DD, ID (2/2 - moderate and profound), spasticity (2/2), ophthalmic findings (strabismus 2/2, nystagmus 1/2). Epilepsy, abnormal brain MRI (cerebral and cerebellar atrophy and white matter hyperintensities) as well and additional findings were reported in one (always the same individual).

Following a normal CMA, exome in the first case revealed a homozygous missense SNV (NM_005679.3:c.1165C>T / p.Arg389Cys) supported by in silico predictions. mRNA and protein levels were substantially reduced in fibroblasts from this subject. Only the patient and parents were tested for the variant but not 3 unaffected sibs (fig1).

The second individual was homozygous for another missense variant (p.Arg405Cys) also supported by in silico predictions. The girl was the single affected person within the family with an unaffected sib and parents heterozygous for the variant. Several other unaffected relatives in the extended pedigree were either carriers for this variant or homozygous for the wt allele.

TAF1C encodes the TATA-box binding protein associated factor (TAF) RNA polymerase I subunit.

RNA polymerase I (Pol I) transcribes genes to produce rRNA. For Pol I to initiate transcription, two transcription factors are required : UBF (upstream binding factor encoded by UBTF) and SL1 (selectivity factor 1). The latter is formed by TBP (TATA-binding protein) and 3 Pol I-specific TBP-associated factors (TAFs).

A recurrent de novo missense variant in UBTF (encoding the other Pol I transcription factor) causes a disorder with highly similar features. The specific variant acts through a gain-of-function mechanism (and not by LoF which appears to apply for TAF1C based on expression data).

The authors hypothesize that altered Pol I activity and resulting ribosomal stress could cause the microcephaly and leukodystrophy (both reported in 1 - the same - individual).

As a result, TAF1C may be considered for inclusion in the ID panel with amber rating pending further evidence.
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v3.239 FAM50A Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: FAM50A was added
gene: FAM50A was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: FAM50A was set to X-LINKED: hemizygous mutation in males, monoallelic mutations in females may cause disease (may be less severe, later onset than males)
Publications for gene: FAM50A were set to 32703943
Phenotypes for gene: FAM50A were set to Mental retardation syndrome, X-linked, Armfield type (MIM #300261)
Penetrance for gene: FAM50A were set to unknown
Review for gene: FAM50A was set to GREEN
Added comment: Lee et al (2020 - PMID: 32703943) provide evidence that Armfield X-Linked intellectual disability syndrome is caused by monoallelic FAM50A pathogenic variants. The current review is based only on this reference.

The authors provide clinical details on 6 affected individuals from 5 families.

Features included postnatal growth delay, DD and ID (6/6 - also evident for those without formal IQ assesment), seizures (3/6 from 2 families), prominent forehead with presence of other facial features and variable head circumference (5th to >97th %le), ocular anomalies (5/6 - strabismus/nystagmus/Axenfeld-Rieger), cardiac (3/6 - ASD/Fallot) and genitourinary anomalies (3/6).

In the first of these families (Armfield et al 1999 - PMID: 10398235), linkage analysis followed by additional studies (Sanger, NGS of 718 genes on chrX, X-exome NGS - several refs provided) allowed the identification of a FAM50A variant. Variants in other families were identified by singleton (1 fam) or trio-ES (3 fam).

In affected individuals from 3 families, the variant had occurred de novo. Carrier females in the other families were unaffected (based on pedigrees and/or the original publication). XCI was rather biased in most obligate carrier females from the 1st family (although this ranged from 95:5 to 60:40).

Missense variants were reported in all affected subjects incl. Trp206Gly, Asp255Gly, Asp255Asn (dn), Glu254Gly (dn), Arg273Trp (dn) (NM_004699.3).

Previous studies have demonstrated that FAM50A has ubiquitous expression in human fetal and adult tissues (incl. brain in fetal ones).

Immunostaining suggests a nuclear localization for the protein (NIH/3T3 cells). Comparison of protein levels in LCLs from affected males and controls did not demonstrate significant differences. Protein localization for 3 variants (transfection of COS-7 cells) was shown to be similar to wt.

Complementation studies in zebrafish provided evidence that the identified variants confer partial loss of function (rescue of the morpholino phenotype with co-injection of wt but not mt mRNA). The zebrafish ko model seemed to recapitulate the abnormal development of cephalic structures and was indicative of diminished/defective neurogenesis. Transcriptional dysregulation was demonstrated in zebrafish (altered levels and mis-splicing). Upregulation of spliceosome effectors was demonstrated in ko zebrafish.

Similarly, mRNA expression and splicing defects were demonstrated in LCLs from affected individuals. FAM50A pulldown followed by mass spectrometry in transfected HEK293T cells demonstrated enrichment of binding proteins involved in RNA processing and co-immunoprecipitation assays (transfected U-87 cells) suggested that FAM50A interacts with spliceosome U5 and C-complex proteins.

Overall aberrant spliceosome C-complex function is suggested as the underlying pathogenetic mechanism.

Several other neurodevelopmental syndromes are caused by variants in genes encoding C-complex affiliated proteins (incl. EFTUD2, EIF4A3, THOC2, etc.).

Please consider inclusion in the ID panel with green rating and epilepsy panel with amber (seizures in individuals from 2 families).
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v3.219 ZNF407 Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: ZNF407 was added
gene: ZNF407 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: ZNF407 was set to BOTH monoallelic and biallelic, autosomal or pseudoautosomal
Publications for gene: ZNF407 were set to 24907849; 32737394; 23195952
Phenotypes for gene: ZNF407 were set to Global developmental delay; Intellectual disability
Penetrance for gene: ZNF407 were set to unknown
Review for gene: ZNF407 was set to AMBER
Added comment: You may consider inclusion of this gene probably with amber rating (or green if the evidence for biallelic variants is considered sufficient).

Biallelic variants:

- Kambouris et al. (2014 - PMID: 24907849) described 2 brothers with severe DD and ID, born to first cousin parents. Homozygosity mapping, following other non-diagnostic investigations (incl. aCGH), revealed 4 major homozygosity intervals. Exome sequencing in one identified 5 variants within these intervals, ZNF407 (c.5054C>G, p.Ser1685Trp) being the best candidate, supported also by segregation studies. The authors commented that zinc finger proteins act as transcriptional regulators, with mutations in genes encoding for other zinc finger proteins interfering with normal brain development.

- Zahra et al. (2020 - PMID: 32737394) report on 7 affected individuals (from 3 families) homozygous or compound heterozygous for ZNF407 variants. Features included hypotonia, DD and ID (in all) and variable occurrence of short stature (6/6), microcephaly (in at least 5), behavioural, visual problems and deafness. Linkage analysis in the first family revealed a 4.4 Mb shared homozygosity region and exome (30x) revealed a 3-bp duplication, confirmed by Sanger sequencing and segregating with the disease (NM_001146189:c.2814_2816dup, p.Val939dup). Affected subjects from the 2 other families were each found to be homozygous (c.2405G>T) or compound heterozygous (c.2884C>G, c.3642G>C) for other variants. Segregation was compatible in all families. Other studies were not performed. The authors comment than only the 3-bp duplication fulfilled ACMG criteria for classification as LP, the other variants being all formally classified as VUS (also due to in silico predictions predicting a LB effect). In addition, while several features such as DD/ID and short stature appeared to be frequent among all patients reported, Zahra et all comment that there was partial clinical overlap with the sibs described by Kambouris et al (additional variants?).


Monoallelic disruption of ZNF407:

- Ren et al (2013 - PMID: 23195952) described an 8 y.o. boy with ID and ASD. The boy was found to harbor a de novo translocation between chromosomes 3 and 18 [46,XY,t(3;18)(p13;q22.3)]. Array CGH did not reveal any P/LP CNV. Delineation of the breakpoints (FISH, long-range PCR) revealed that the chr18 breakpoint disrupted intron 3 of ZNF407 (isoform 1) with the other breakpoint within a gene-free region of exon 3. There was a loss of 4-8 nt in chr18 and 2-6 in chr3. Sequencing of ZNF407 did not reveal additional variants. RNA isolation in blood followed by RT-PCR studied expression of all 3 ZNF407 isoforms (the intronic region being shared by isoforms 1 and 2). Expression of isoform 1 was shown to be significantly reduced compared to controls. Isoform 2 was undetectable (in blood) while isoform 3 expression was similar to controls. Sequencing of 105 additional patients with similar clinical presentation (ID & ASD) revealed 2 further individuals with de novo missense variants.

- Based on the discussion by Kambouris et al (PMID: 24907849 - cited literature not here reviewed) ZNF407 may be deleted in patients with congenital aural atresia due to deletion of a critical region of 18q22.3 (though TSHZ1 is responsible for this phenotype) or 18q- although such deletions span several other genes (cited PMID: 16639285). In one case the breakpoint was shown to be disrupting ZNF407 (cited PMID: 24092497).

- The denovo db and Decipher (research variant tab) list few individuals with de novo ZNF407 SNVs although these do not seem to allow conclusions.

https://denovo-db.gs.washington.edu/denovo-db/QueryVariantServlet?searchBy=Gene&target=ZNF407
https://decipher.sanger.ac.uk/search/ddd-research-variants/results?q=znf407
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v3.201 MORC2 Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: MORC2 was added
gene: MORC2 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: MORC2 was set to MONOALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal, imprinted status unknown
Publications for gene: MORC2 were set to https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ajhg.2020.06.013
Phenotypes for gene: MORC2 were set to Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease, axonal, type 2Z, MIM #616688
Penetrance for gene: MORC2 were set to unknown
Mode of pathogenicity for gene: MORC2 was set to Loss-of-function variants (as defined in pop up message) DO NOT cause this phenotype - please provide details in the comments
Review for gene: MORC2 was set to GREEN
Added comment: The current review is based on a recent report by Sacoto et al (2020 - https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ajhg.2020.06.013).

While several previous studies focused on the phenotype of axonal motor and senory neuropathy in individuals with heterozygous MORC2 pathogenic variants (Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease, axonal, type 2Z, MIM #616688) some of them presented among others with hypotonia, muscle weakness, intellectual disability, microcephaly or hearing loss [refs provided by Sacoto et al - learning disabilities (in some patients) also listed in OMIM's clinical synopsis].

Sacoto et al present a cohort of 20 individuals having genetic testing for developmental delay or growth failure (with a single one for a diagnosis of sensorimotor neuropathy).

Overlapping features included DD, ID (18/20 - mild to severe), short stature (18/20), microcephaly (15/20) and variable craniofacial dysmorphisms. The authors comment that features suggestive of neuropathy (weakness, hyporeflexia, abnormal EMG/NCS) were frequent but not the predominant complaint. EMG/NCS abnormalities were abnormal in 6 out of 10 subjects investigated in this cohort. Other findings included brain MRI abnormalities (12/18 - in 5/18 Leigh-like lesions), hearing loss (11/19) and pigmentary retinopathy in few (5).

Affected subjects were found to harbor in all cases missense variants in the ATPase module of MORC2 [residues 1 to 494 - NM_001303256.1 - the module consists of an ATPase domain (aa 1-265), a transducer S5-like domain (266-494) and a coiled-coiled domain (CC1 - aa 282-361)].

Variants had occured mostly as de novo events although inheritance from a similarly affected parent was also reported.

Some of them were recurring within this cohort and/or the literature eg. c.79G>A/p.Glu27Lys (x5), c.260C>T/p.Ser87Leu (x2), c.394C>T/p.Arg132Cys (4x), c.1164C>G/p.Ser388Arg (x2), c.1181A>G/p.Tyr394Cys (x3).

MORC2 encodes an ATPase involved in chromatin remodeling, DNA repair and transcriptional regulation. Chromatin remodeling and epigenetic silencing by MORC2 is mediated by the HUSH (Human Silencing Hub) complex. Functional studies (MORC2-knockout HeLa cells harboring a HUSH-sensitive GFP reporter were transduced with wt or mt MORC2 followed by measurement of reporter repression) supported the deleterious effect of most variants known at the time (hyperactivation of HUSH-mediating silencing, in line with previous observations).

Overall this gene can be considered for inclusion in the ID panel with green rating. Also other gene panels (e.g. for short stature, microcephaly, hearing loss, pigmentary retinopathy, etc) if it meets the respective criteria for inclusion.
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v3.170 PAX1 Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: PAX1 was added
gene: PAX1 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature,Radboud University Medical Center, Nijmegen
Mode of inheritance for gene: PAX1 was set to BIALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal
Publications for gene: PAX1 were set to 29681087; 23851939; 28657137
Phenotypes for gene: PAX1 were set to Otofaciocervical syndrome 2, 615560
Penetrance for gene: PAX1 were set to Complete
Review for gene: PAX1 was set to AMBER
Added comment: Biallelic PAX1 pathogenic variants cause Otofaciocervical syndrome 2 (OMIM 615560).

Brief review of the literature suggests 3 relevant publications to date (04-07-2020).

2 individuals with DD and ID have been reported (Patil et al, 2018 - PMID: 29681087 and Pohl et al, 2013 - PMID: 23851939). Other subjects reported were only evaluated as newborns(mostly)/infants [Paganini et al, 2017 - PMID: 28657137, Patil et al, 2018 - PMID: 29681087].

While the first report by Pohl et al identified a homozygous missense variant supported by functional studies [NM_006192.5:c.497G>T - p.(Gly166Val)] subsequent ones identified homozygosity for pLoF mutations [Patil et al: NM_006192.4:c.1173_1174insGCCCG / Paganini et al: NM_006192:c.1104C>A - p.(Cys368*)].

As discussed by Pohl et al:

PAX1 encodes a transcription factor with critical role in pattern formation during embryogenesis. Study of the mouse Gly157Val (equivalent to human Gly166Val) Pax1 variant suggested reduced binding affinity (reduced transactivation of a regulatory sequence of the Nkx3-2 promoter) and hypofunctional nature of this variant.

Mouse models seem to recapitulate features of the disorder (skeletal, immunodeficiency) while the role of Pax1 in hearing process was thought to be supported by early expression (P6) in mouse cochlea.

Overall this gene can be considered for inclusion in the ID panel with amber/green rating.
Sources: Literature, Radboud University Medical Center, Nijmegen
Intellectual disability v3.170 HERC2 Konstantinos Varvagiannis edited their review of gene: HERC2: Added comment: Please consider upgrading this gene to green in the current panel based on the following updated review (13-07-2020):

Biallelic pathogenic HERC2 variants cause Mental retardation, autosomal recessive 38 (MIM 615516).

The current review is based mostly on the information provided by Elpidorou et al (2020 - PMID: 32571899) summarizing the findings in several affected individuals as published in the literature. ID was a universal feature among them (27/27) and seizures were reported in some (9/27):
- 22 subjects from Amish/Mennonite families were homozygous for p.Pro594Leu [NM_004667.5(HERC2):c.1781C>T] (Puffenberger et al 2012 - PMID: 23065719, Harlalka et al 2013 - PMID: 23243086, Abraham et al - PMID: 30902390)
- 2 additional patients were homozygous for another missense SNV [NM_004667.5(HERC2):c.4625G>A - p.Arg1542His] (Abraham et al 2019 - PMID: 30902390)
- 3 sibs born to consanguineous parents, homozygous for NM_004667.5:c.13767_13770delTGAA - p.(Asn4589LysTer4598)] as described by Elpidorou et al.
- 1 male homozygous 286 kb deletion spanning several 5' exons of HERC2 as well as the first exons of OCA2 was described by Morice-Picard et al (2016 - PMID: 27759030). Despite a neurological presentation (axial hypotonia, peripheral hypertonia, extrapyramidal symptoms and uncoordinated movements) further information was not available.

Apart from the cases summarized by Elpidorou et al, there have been few additional ones e.g. :
- Trujillano et al (2017 - PMID: 27848944) reported briefly on a patient, homozygous for NM_004667.5:c.4676-1G>A displaying seizures, hypotonia, global DD, "Encephalopathy" and abnormality of the liver.
- Yavarna et al (2015 - PMID: 26077850) provided few details with on an individual with primarily 'neurocognitive' phenotype but rather atypical presentation (MRI abnormalities, TGA, VSD, renal anomaly, growth retardation, hearing loss) due to p.Q3164X variant (recessive inheritance was specified).

Several lines of evidence support an important role for the protein encoded (an E3 ubiquitin protein ligase, interacting also with UBE3A, involved in several cellular processes incl. cell cycle regulation, spindle formation during mitosis, mitochondrial functions, DNA damage responses by targeting proteins such as XPA) as well as the effect of the reported variants (mRNA studies, Western blot, detection of a fusion transcript in the case of the deletion, etc).

Individuals from the Amish families displayed Angelman-like features (in line with HERC2-UBE3A interaction) with - among others - gait instability. Mouse models recapitulate some of these features (e.g. the movement disorder) as extensively discussed by Abraham et al.

Overall this gene can be included in the ID and epilepsy panels with green rating.

-----; Changed rating: GREEN; Changed publications: 23065719, 23243086, 30902390, 32571899, 27848944, 26077850, 27759030
Intellectual disability v3.90 SCAF4 Eleanor Williams changed review comment from: ESHG2020 - C02.1 - SCAF4 loss of function in humans and Drosophila implicates mRNA transcriptional termination in neurodevelopmental disorders - Fliedner et al - report 9 unrelated patients with likely pathogenic variants in SCAF4 and mild developmental delay and intellectual disability. 8 de novo. 1 inherited. Seizures, skeletal, renal and cardiac anomalies were also seen.
Sources: Literature; to: Conference talk/abstract from ESHG2020 - C02.1 - SCAF4 loss of function in humans and Drosophila implicates mRNA transcriptional termination in neurodevelopmental disorders - Fliedner et al - report 9 unrelated patients with likely pathogenic variants in SCAF4 and mild developmental delay and intellectual disability. 8 de novo. 1 inherited. Seizures, skeletal, renal and cardiac anomalies were also seen.
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v3.90 SCAF4 Eleanor Williams gene: SCAF4 was added
gene: SCAF4 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: SCAF4 was set to MONOALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal, imprinted status unknown
Added comment: ESHG2020 - C02.1 - SCAF4 loss of function in humans and Drosophila implicates mRNA transcriptional termination in neurodevelopmental disorders - Fliedner et al - report 9 unrelated patients with likely pathogenic variants in SCAF4 and mild developmental delay and intellectual disability. 8 de novo. 1 inherited. Seizures, skeletal, renal and cardiac anomalies were also seen.
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v3.87 DSCR3 Zornitza Stark gene: DSCR3 was added
gene: DSCR3 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: DSCR3 was set to BIALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal
Publications for gene: DSCR3 were set to 31845315
Phenotypes for gene: DSCR3 were set to Intellectual disability, no OMIM # yet
Review for gene: DSCR3 was set to RED
Added comment: 1 family/2 cousins with cognitive impairment, growth failure, skeletal abnormalities, and distinctive facial features. Both shared the homozygous nonsense variant c.178G>T (p.Glu60*) in the VPS26C gene. This gene encodes VPS26C, a member of the retriever integral membrane protein recycling pathway. The nature of the variant which is predicted to result in loss‐of‐function, expression studies revealing significant reduction in the mutant transcript, and the co‐segregation of the homozygous variant with the phenotype in two affected individuals.
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v3.39 NR4A2 Konstantinos Varvagiannis edited their review of gene: NR4A2: Added comment: Singh et al (2020 - https://doi.org/10.1038/s41436-020-0815-4) provide details on the phenotype of 9 unrelated individuals with NR4A2 pathogenic variants (in almost all cases de novo).

Features included hypotonia (in 6/9), DD (9/9), varying levels of ID (mild to severe in 8/8 for whom this information was available), seizures (6/9 - variable epilepsy phenotypes), behavioral problems (5/9 - with autism reported for one). Less frequent features incl. hypermobility (in 3), ataxia/movement disorder (in 3).

8 total pLoF and missense variants were identified as de novo events following trio exome sequencing with Sanger validation (7/8 variants). For 1(/8) individual with a stopgain variant, a single parental sample was available. A 9th individual was found to harbor a ~3.7 Mb 2q deletion spanning also other genes (which might also contribute to his phenotype of epilepsy).

Only the effect of a variant affecting the splice-acceptor site was studied (c.865-1_865delGCinsAAAAAGGAGT - NM_006186.3) with RT-PCR demonstrating an out-of-frame skipping of exon 4. Another variant (NM_006186.3:c.325dup) found in a subject with DD, ID and epilepsy had also previously been reported in another individual with similar phenotype of epilepsy and ID (Ramos et al - PMID: 31428396 - the variant was de novo with other causes for his phenotype excluded).

As discussed by Singh et al, NR4A2 encodes a steroid-thyroid-retinoid receptor which acts as a nuclear receptor transcription factor. The authors summarize previous reports on NR4A2 haploinsufficiency (NR4A2 has a pLI of 1 and HI score of 1.28% - Z-score is 2.24).

The authors comment on mouse models suggesting a role of NR4A2 for dopaminergic neurons, and provide plausible explanations for the phenotype of ID/seizures.; Changed publications: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41436-020-0815-4, 31428396, 29770430, 30504930, 28544326, 27569545, 23554088, 28135719, 27479843, 25363768; Changed phenotypes: Generalized hypotonia, Global developmental delay, Intellectual disability, Seizures, Behavioral abnormality, Abnormality of movement, Joint hypermobility
Intellectual disability v3.0 SUPT16H Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: SUPT16H was added
gene: SUPT16H was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: SUPT16H was set to MONOALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal, imprinted status unknown
Publications for gene: SUPT16H were set to http://dx.doi.org/10.1136/jmedgenet-2019-106193
Phenotypes for gene: SUPT16H were set to Global developmental delay; Intellectual disability; Abnormality of the corpus callosum
Penetrance for gene: SUPT16H were set to Complete
Review for gene: SUPT16H was set to AMBER
Added comment: Bina et al (2020 - http://dx.doi.org/10.1136/jmedgenet-2019-106193) report on 4 unrelated individuals with heterozygous SNVs affecting SUPT16H as well as 1 further with microdeletion spanning this gene.

The phenotype consisted of DD with subsequent ID in a subset of them (ages of the cohort: 2y-14y), autistic features in few, abnormalities of the corpus callosum (for 3 with available MRI images), variable gastrointestinal problems in some, and possibly minor dysmorphic features.

SUPT16H encodes a subunit of the FACT (facilitates chromatin transcription) complex, a chromatin-specific factor required for transcription elongation as well as for DNA replication and repair (OMIM citing Belotserkovskaya et al. 2003 - PMID: 12934006). The 2 subunits of the complex [Spt16 (encoded by SUPT16H) and SSRP1] are essential for histone regulation. As the authors note, Spt16 interacts with the histone dimer H2A-H2B during transcription to allow RNA polymerase access to previously coiled DNA [cited PMIDs : 9489704, 10421373 / A recent study by Liu et al 2019 (PMID: 31775157) appears highly relevant].

SUPT16H has a Z-score of 5.1 in gnomAD and a pLI of 1 (%HI of 22.56 in Decipher).

SNVs :
4 de novo missense SNVs were identified following exome sequencing (NM_007192.3:c.484A>G or I162V / L432P / N571S / R734W), all absent from gnomAD and mostly predicted to be deleterious (I162V predicted benign, tolerated, disease-causing by PolyPhen2, SIFT, MutationTaster respectively and had a CADD score of 13.61). Prior work-up for these individuals (incl. CMA in some / MS-MLPA for Angelman s. in 1 / metabolic investigations) had (probably) not revealed an apparent cause, with small CNVs inherited from healthy parents (a 4q13.3 dup / 20q13.2 del - coordinates not provided).

There were no studies performed for the identified variants.

CNVs :
A 5th individual reported by Bina et al was found to harbor a 2.05 Mb 14q11.2 deletion spanning SUPT16H. The specific deletion also spanned CHD8 while the same individual harbored also a 30.17 Mb duplication of 18p11.32q12.1.

CNVs spanning SUPT16H reported to date, also span the (very) proximal CHD8. [Genomic coordinates (GRCh38) for SUPT16H and CHD8 as provided by OMIM : 14:21,351,471-21,384,018 / 14:21,385,198-21,456,122]. Haploinsufficiency of CHD8 is associated with a distinctive syndrome with overgrowth and ID (Douzgou et al 2019 - PMID: 31001818). The phenotype of SUPT16H-CHD8 duplications is discussed in other studies/reviews. [Smol et al 2020 - PMID: 31823155 / Smyk et al 2016 - PMID: 26834018].

Animal models were not commented on by Bina et al (possibly not available for mouse : http://www.informatics.jax.org/marker/MGI:1890948 / https://www.mousephenotype.org/data/genes/MGI:1890948 ).
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v3.0 MN1 Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: MN1 was added
gene: MN1 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: MN1 was set to MONOALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal, imprinted status unknown
Publications for gene: MN1 were set to 31834374; 31839203; 15870292
Phenotypes for gene: MN1 were set to Central hypotonia; Feeding difficulties; Global developmental delay; Intellectual disability; Hearing impairment; Abnormality of facial skeleton; Craniosynostosis; Abnormality of the face; Abnormality of the cerebellum; Abnormality of the corpus callosum; Polymicrogyria
Penetrance for gene: MN1 were set to Complete
Review for gene: MN1 was set to GREEN
Added comment: Two studies by Mak et al (2019 - PMID: 31834374 / Ref1) and Miyake et al (2019 - PMID: 31839203 / Ref2) provide sufficient evidence for heterozygous MN1 C-terminal truncating variants (predicted to escape NMD - localizing within the last nucleotides of exon 1 or in exon 2) being associated with a distinctive phenotype and DD and ID among the features.

Mak et al also discuss on the phenotype of individuals with variants causing N-terminal truncation or with MN1 deletions (discussed at the end of this review).

Overlapping features for C-terminal truncating variants included hypotonia, feeding difficulties, global DD and ID, hearing loss, cranial shape defects (/craniosynostosis in few), highly suggestive/distinctive facial features (eg. frontal bossing, hypertelorism, downslanting palpebral-fissures, shallow orbits, short upturned nose, low-set/posteriorly rotated/dysplastic ears, etc) and brain MRI abnormalities (eg. rhomboencephalosynapsis or cerebellar dysplasia, polymicrogyria, dysplastic CC).

The majority of the affected individuals were investigated by WES/WGS with a single one tested by targeted MN1 Sanger sequencing due to highly suggestive features. Variable previous investigations incl. CMA in several, gene panel testing (Rasopathies, hearing loss, craniofacial panels, FMR1, etc) and metabolic work were normal in most. In a single case a likely pathogenic ACSL4 also explained part of the phenotype (Ref2). In the majority of these individuals, the variant had occured as a de novo event. Two sibs had inherited the truncating variant from a milder affected mosaic parent. A parental sample was not available for an additional individual.

p.(Arg1295*) or NM_002430.2:c.3883C>T was a recurrent variant, seen in several individuals and in both studies.

Several lines of evidence are provided for the MN1 variants and the role of the gene including:
- For few individuals for whom cell lines were available, variants were shown to escape NMD by cDNA/RT-PCR/RNA-seq [Ref1 & 2].
- The gene has a high expression in fetal brain [Ref2 / fig S2]
- MN1 (* 156100 - MN1 protooncogene, transcriptional regulator) has been proposed to play a role in cell proliferation and shown to act as transcription cofactor (increasing its transactivation capacity in synergy with coactivators EP300 and RAC3) [Discussion and Refs provided in Ref2].
- In vitro studies suggested increased protein stability (upon transfection of wt/mut constructs in HEK293T cells), enhanced MN1 aggregation in nuclei (when wt/mut GFP-tagged MN1 was expressed in HeLa cells), increased inhibitory effect on cell growth (MG63 cells - role of MN1 in cell proliferation discussed above) and retained transactivation activity (upon transient MN1 overexpression of wt/mt MN1 in HEK293T cells) for the variants. These seem to support a gain-of-function effect for the C-terminal truncating variants [Ref2].
- The truncating variants are proposed to raise the fraction of Intrinsically disordered regions (IDRs = regions without fixed tertiary structure) probably contributing to the above effects [Ref2].
- Expression of FLAG-tagged MN1 wt/mut MN1 followed by immunoprecipitation and mass spectrometry analysis (mCAT-Hela cells), provided evidence that MN1 is involved in transcriptional regulation: a. through binding ZBTB24 and RING1 E3 ubiquitin ligase (with mutant MN1 displaying impaired interaction with ZBTB24 and no binding to RING1) and/or b. through interaction with DNA-binding transcription factors PBX1 and PKNOX1. Proper MN1 degradation is proposed to mediate precise transcriptional regulation. [Ref2]
- Transcriptome analysis in LCLs from an affected individual suggested dysregulation of genes relevant to neuronal development (eg. LAMP, ITGA, etc) and GO analysis suggested enrichment for pathways possibly linked to the observed phenotypes [Ref2].
- Discussed in both Refs1/2, homozygous Mn1-ko mice display abnormal skull bone development and die at/shortly after birth as a result of cleft palate. Heterozygous Mn1-ko mice display hypoplastic membranous bones of the cranial skeleton and cleft palate (CP), the latter with incomplete penetrance [Meester-Smoor et al 2005 - PMID: 15870292]. This is thus compatible with the cranial shape defects observed in C-terminal truncations (while CP has been reported in gene deletions, bifid uvula was reported once in C-terminal and N-terminal truncating variants, in the latter case with submucous CP).
-----
The phenotype of other MN1 variants is discussed by Mak et al (Ref1) :
- 3 individuals with MN1 N-terminal truncating variants (eg. Ser179*, Pro365Thrfs*120, Ser472*) presented speech delay, mild conductive hearing loss and facial features different from C-terminal truncations. None of these individuals had significant ID.
- Microdeletions: One individual (#27) with 130 kb deletion harboring only MN1, presented microcephaly, DD and ID and mildly dysmorphic facial features. Deletions spanning MN1 and other genes (eg a 1.17 Mb deletion in ind. #28) and relevant cases from the literature reviewed, with mild DD/ID, variable palatal defects and/or facial dysmorphisms (distinct from the C-terminal truncating variants) among the frequent findings.

[Please consider inclusion in other possibly relevant gene panels eg. for hearing loss (conductive/sensorineural in 16/20 reported by Mak et al) or craniosynostosis, etc].
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v3.0 UGP2 Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: UGP2 was added
gene: UGP2 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: UGP2 was set to BIALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal
Publications for gene: UGP2 were set to 31820119
Phenotypes for gene: UGP2 were set to Seizures; Global developmental delay; Intellectual disability; Feeding difficulties; Abnormality of vision; Abnormality of the face
Penetrance for gene: UGP2 were set to Complete
Review for gene: UGP2 was set to GREEN
Added comment: Perenthaler et al. (2019 - PMID: 31820119) provide evidence that homozygosity for a variant abolishing the start codon of the UGP2 transcript (NM_001001521.1) encoding the predominant (short) protein isoform in brain, leads to a severe epileptic encephalopathy.

This variant (chr2:64083454A>G / NM_001001521.1:c.1A>G - p.?) is also predicted to result in a substitution of a methionine at position 12 by a valine of the longer UGP2 transcript (NM_006759.3:c.34A>G - p.Met12Val).

The 2 isoforms differ only by 11 amino acids at the N-terminal and are otherwise expected to be functionally equivalent.

The authors provide details on 22 individuals from 15 families (some of which consanguineous).

Features included intractable seizures (in all), absence of developmental milestones (in all), progressive microcephaly, visual impairment. The authors reported also presence of somewhat similar facial features. Some of these individuals passed away early.

Previous work-up in several of them (incl. SNP-array, gene panel testing and metabolic investigations) had not revealed any abnormality, apart from ROH in some individuals. In all cases, the homozygous UGP2 SNV was the only P/LP variant for the neurodevelopmental phenotype following exome/genome sequencing. Segregation studies in affected/unaffected family members were compatible.

Families came from the Netherlands (but mostly from) India, Pakistan and Iran. Presence of a region of homozygosity shared between individuals from different families suggested that the variant might represent a mutation that originated several generations ago (in the area of Balochistan). The variant is present 15x in gnomAD, only in heterozygous state (in Asian mostly, reported once in Ashkenazi Jewish or Europeans) [ https://gnomad.broadinstitute.org/variant/2-64083454-A-G ].

UGP2 encodes UDP-glucose pyrophosphorylase which is an essential enzyme in sugar metabolism, catalyzing conversion of glucose-1-phosphate to UDP-glucose. UDP-glucose, in turn, serves as precursor for production of glycogen by glycogen synthase.

The authors provide several lines of evidence for a the role of the gene in the CNS as well as for the deleterious effect of the specific variant :
- In patient fibroblasts total UGP2 levels were not signifficantly different compared to parent / control fibroblasts, the longer isoform being upregulated (and stable) when the shorter is missing. Immunocytochemistry demonstrated similar localization of UGP2 in the case of mutant or wt cells. Enzymatic activity (/capacity to produce UDP-glucose) was similar between homozygous mut, heterozygous and wt fibroblasts.
- In H9-derived neural stem cells, Western Blot, RT-PCR and qRT-PCR suggested that the short isoform is the predominant one. (In embryonic stem cells, or fibroblasts the ratio between short and long isoform was lower).
- Analysis of RNA-seq data from human fetal tissues suggested that the short isoform is the predominant in brain.
- UGP2 was detected upon immunohistochemistry in fetal brain tissues from first to third trimester of pregnancy while Western Blot confirmed preferential expression of the shorter isoform.
- Homozygous embryonic (ESC) or neural stem cells (NSC) for the variant (knock-in/KI) or for a frameshift variant (knock-out/KO) were generated. Study of NSCs demonstrated reduced total UGP2 protein expression upon Western Blot in the case of KI cells and depleted in KO ones. Transcriptome analysis did not show major transcriptome alterations in KI/KO ESCs compared to wt. In NSC KI/KO cells transcriptome alterations were observed compared to wt with upregulation among others of genes for synaptic processes and genes implicated in epilepsy.
- The absence of UGP2 was shown to result in reduced ability of KO/KI NSCs to produce UDP-glucose, reduced capacity to synthesize glycogen under hypoxia (rescued in the case of KO cells by overexpression of wt or long isoform), defects of protein glycosylation as well as in increased unfolded protein response (/susceptibility to ER stress). These alterations are commented to be possibly implicated in pathogenesis of epilepsy, progressive microcephaly, etc.
- A CRISPR-Cas9 zebrafish model leading with loss of ugp2a and hypomorphic ugp2b (the zebrafish homologs of UGP2) demonstrated abnormal behavior, reduced eye movements and increased frequency/duration of movements upon stimulation with a potent convulsant (suggestive of increased seizure susceptibility).
- UGP knockout in drosophila is lethal while flies compound heterozygous for hypomorphic alleles are viable but show a movement defects due to altered synaptogenesis secondary to glycosylation defects (cited PMID: 27466186).
- The authors make speculations as for the occurrence of a single variant (and not others) eg. absence of UGP2 (in the case of LoF variants affecting both isoforms) would possibly be incompatible with life, Met12Val being tolerable for the long transcript not affecting stability/enzymatic activity (which may not be the case for other substitutions affecting Met12), etc.
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v3.0 RARS Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: RARS was added
gene: RARS was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: RARS was set to BIALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal
Publications for gene: RARS were set to 31814314; 28905880; 24777941
Phenotypes for gene: RARS were set to Cerebral hypomyelination; Global developmental delay; Intellectual disability; Seizures; Cerebral atrophy; Nystagmus; Ataxia; Feeding difficulties
Penetrance for gene: RARS were set to Complete
Review for gene: RARS was set to GREEN
Added comment: Biallelic pathogenic RARS1 variants cause Leukodystrophy, hypomyelinating, 9 (# 616140).

The current review was based primarily on PMID: 31814314 (Mendes et al, 2019) providing details on 20 affected individuals from 15 families. 5 of these patients were included in a previous publication (Wolf et al, 2014 - PMID: 24777941) sharing authors with this study.

Clinical presentation and severity can be highly variable. However, among the 15 patients of relevant age (5/20 deceased at an early age), ID was observed in 13 (in 6/13 mild-moderate, in 7/13 severe/profound). Epilepsy was reported in half (10/20) with seizures being refractory to treatment in most and the phenotype corresponding to an infantile epileptic encephalopathy. DD and seizures were the presenting feature in 7 and 5 patients respectively, while in other cases presenting features were less specific (eg. failure to thrive in 1/20, irritabilty in 2/20). As a result the gene appears to be relevant to both DD/ID and epilepsy panels.

RARS1 encodes the cytoplasmic arginyl-tRNA synthetase 1, which is a component of the aminoacyl-tRNA synthetase complex (OMIM and Wolf et al, 2014 - PMID: 24777941). Aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases catalyze the aminoacylation ('charging') of tRNA by (with) their cognate amino acid.

Utilisation of alternative initiation codons, from a single mRNA transcript, results in translation of a long and a short protein isoform (Zheng et al 2006 - PMID: 16430231). The long isoform is needed for the formation of the multi-synthetase complex (MSC), while the short is free in the cytoplasm and does not have any interaction with the MSC. The long isoform appears to be essential for protein synthesis (discussed with several refs provided in PMID: 28905880 - Nafisinia et al, 2017).

The role of variants has been supported in several patients by additional studies - among others :
[PMID 31814314] Impaired Arginyl-tRNA synthetase activity was demonstrated in fibroblasts from 3 patients. Activity was normal in one additional individual compound heterozygous for a variant affecting initiation codon and a missense one. Western blot however demonstrated presence mainly of the short protein isoform. The authors suggest that this isoform possibly contributed to enzymatic activity. The long isoform which is needed for the MSC complex was only represented by a faint band in the Western Blot of the same individual.
[PMID: 28905880] Using fibroblasts from an affected subject homozygous for a missense variant (NM_002887.3:c.5A>G / p.Asp2Gly) and controls, a 75% reduction of the long isoform was shown upon WB. The short isoform was present at similar levels. As the N-terminus (of the long isoform) mediates interaction with the MSC (and AIMP1), assembly of the latter was 99% reduced in patient fibroblasts. Proliferation of patient fibroblasts was significantly reduced when cultured in a medium with limited arginine, a finding which was thought to reflect inefficient protein synthesis.

Mutations in other genes encoding for aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases (eg. AARS1, VARS1) or scaffolding proteins of the multisynthetase complex (eg. AIMP1 and AIMP2) lead to neurodevelopmental disorders with overlapping phenotype [most genes rated green in both the ID and epilepsy panel].
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v2.1143 AFF3 Konstantinos Varvagiannis changed review comment from: Voisin et al. (2019 - https://doi.org/10.1101/693937) report on 10 individuals with de novo missense AFF3 variants affecting a 9-amino-acid sequence (degron) important for the protein's degradation and summarize the phenotype of an additional individual previously described by Steichen-Gersdorf et al. (2008 - PMID: 18616733) with a 500 kb affecting only AFF3 (LAF4) and removing also this sequence.

The phenotype of missense variants consisted of kidney anomalies, mesomelic dysplasia, seizures, hypertrichosis, intellectual disability and pulmonary problems and was overlapping with that of the deletion. [10 of 11 subjects exhibited severe developmental epileptic encephalopathy].

9 probands harbored missense variants affecting the codon 258 while one individual had a variant affecting codon 260 [c.772G>T or p.Ala258Ser (x2), c.772G>A or p.Ala258Thr (x6), c.773C>T or p.Ala258Val (x1) and c.779T>G or p.(Val260Gly) (x1) - NM_001025108.1 / NP_001020279.1]. The deletion removed exons 4-13.

AFF1-4 are ALF transcription factor paralogs, components of the transcriptional super elongation complex regulating expression of genes involved in neurogenesis and development.

Using HEK293T cells expressing FLAG-tagged AFF3 (and AFF4) wt or mutants, accumulation of mutated forms was shown upon immunoblot.

Aff3+/- and/or -/- mice exhibit skeletal defects. These were more pronounced in homozygous mice which demonstrated also some elements in favor of kidney dysfunction and/or metabolic deregulation and possible neurological dysfunction (signs of impaired hearing and diminished grip strength). Homozygous mice had CNS anomalies (enlarged lateral ventricles and decreased corpus callosum size) similar to some affected individuals, although these were not observed in another Aff3-/- model. Knock-in mice modeling the microdeletion and the Ala258Thr variant displayed lower mesomelic limb deformities and early lethality respectively [cited PMIDs : 21677750, 25660031, knock-in model was part of the present study].

Accumulation of the protein in zebrafish (by overexpression of the human wt AFF3 mRNA), led to morphological defects.

Reanalysis of transcriptome data from previously generated HEK293T cell lines knocked down for AFF2, AFF3 and AFF4 by shRNAs (study) suggested that these transcription factors are not redundant.

Finally, CHOPS syndrome (#616368) due to mutations of AFF4 also leading to increased protein stability presents a partially overlapping phenotype (incl. cognitive impairment) to that of AFF3.
----
Shimizu et al. (8/2019 - PMID: 31388108) describe an additional individual with de novo AFF3 missense variant. The phenotype overlaps with that summarized by Voisin et al. incl. mesomelic dysplasia with additional skeletal anomalies, bilateral kidney hypoplasia and severe DD at the age of 2.5 years. Seizures and pulmonary problems were not observed. Although a different RefSeq is used the variant is among those also reported by Voisin et al. [NM_002285.2:c.697G>A (p.Ala233Thr) corresponding to NM_001025108.1:c.772G>A (p.Ala258Thr)].
----
In G2P, AFF3 is associated with Skeletal dysplasia with severe neurological disease (disease confidence : probable / ID and seizures among the assigned phenotypes). There is no associated phenotype in OMIM.
Some diagnostic laboratories include AFF3 in their ID panel (eg. among the many co-authors' affiliations GeneDx and Victorian Clinical Genetics - which was already listed as source for AFF3 in the current panel).
----
As a result this gene can be considered for upgrade to green (relevant phenotype and severity, sufficient cases, evidence for accumulation similar to AFF4, animal models, etc) or amber (pending publication of the article).

[Review modified to add additional reference/case report]; to: Voisin et al. (2019 - https://doi.org/10.1101/693937) report on 10 individuals with de novo missense AFF3 variants affecting a 9-amino-acid sequence (degron) important for the protein's degradation and summarize the phenotype of an additional individual previously described by Steichen-Gersdorf et al. (2008 - PMID: 18616733) with a 500 kb deletion affecting only AFF3 (LAF4) and removing also this sequence.

The phenotype of missense variants consisted of kidney anomalies, mesomelic dysplasia, seizures, hypertrichosis, intellectual disability and pulmonary problems and was overlapping with that of the deletion. [10 of 11 subjects exhibited severe developmental epileptic encephalopathy].

9 probands harbored missense variants affecting the codon 258 while one individual had a variant affecting codon 260 [c.772G>T or p.Ala258Ser (x2), c.772G>A or p.Ala258Thr (x6), c.773C>T or p.Ala258Val (x1) and c.779T>G or p.(Val260Gly) (x1) - NM_001025108.1 / NP_001020279.1]. The deletion removed exons 4-13.

AFF1-4 are ALF transcription factor paralogs, components of the transcriptional super elongation complex regulating expression of genes involved in neurogenesis and development.

Using HEK293T cells expressing FLAG-tagged AFF3 (and AFF4) wt or mutants, accumulation of mutated forms was shown upon immunoblot.

Aff3+/- and/or -/- mice exhibit skeletal defects. These were more pronounced in homozygous mice which demonstrated also some elements in favor of kidney dysfunction and/or metabolic deregulation and possible neurological dysfunction (signs of impaired hearing and diminished grip strength). Homozygous mice had CNS anomalies (enlarged lateral ventricles and decreased corpus callosum size) similar to some affected individuals, although these were not observed in another Aff3-/- model. Knock-in mice modeling the microdeletion and the Ala258Thr variant displayed lower mesomelic limb deformities and early lethality respectively [cited PMIDs : 21677750, 25660031, knock-in model was part of the present study].

Accumulation of the protein in zebrafish (by overexpression of the human wt AFF3 mRNA), led to morphological defects.

Reanalysis of transcriptome data from previously generated HEK293T cell lines knocked down for AFF2, AFF3 and AFF4 by shRNAs (study) suggested that these transcription factors are not redundant.

Finally, CHOPS syndrome (#616368) due to mutations of AFF4 also leading to increased protein stability presents a partially overlapping phenotype (incl. cognitive impairment) to that of AFF3.
----
Shimizu et al. (8/2019 - PMID: 31388108) describe an additional individual with de novo AFF3 missense variant. The phenotype overlaps with that summarized by Voisin et al. incl. mesomelic dysplasia with additional skeletal anomalies, bilateral kidney hypoplasia and severe DD at the age of 2.5 years. Seizures and pulmonary problems were not observed. Although a different RefSeq is used the variant is among those also reported by Voisin et al. [NM_002285.2:c.697G>A (p.Ala233Thr) corresponding to NM_001025108.1:c.772G>A (p.Ala258Thr)].
----
In G2P, AFF3 is associated with Skeletal dysplasia with severe neurological disease (disease confidence : probable / ID and seizures among the assigned phenotypes). There is no associated phenotype in OMIM.
Some diagnostic laboratories include AFF3 in their ID panel (eg. among the many co-authors' affiliations GeneDx and Victorian Clinical Genetics - which was already listed as source for AFF3 in the current panel).
----
As a result this gene can be considered for upgrade to green (relevant phenotype and severity, sufficient cases, evidence for accumulation similar to AFF4, animal models, etc) or amber (pending publication of the article).

[Review modified to add additional reference/case report]
Intellectual disability v2.1135 TRAPPC4 Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: TRAPPC4 was added
gene: TRAPPC4 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: TRAPPC4 was set to BIALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal
Publications for gene: TRAPPC4 were set to 31794024
Phenotypes for gene: TRAPPC4 were set to Feeding difficulties; Progressive microcephaly; Intellectual disability; Seizures; Spastic tetraparesis; Abnormality of the face; Scoliosis; Cortical visual impairment; Hearing impairment
Penetrance for gene: TRAPPC4 were set to Complete
Review for gene: TRAPPC4 was set to GREEN
Added comment: Van Bergen et al. (2019 - PMID: 31794024) report on 7 affected individuals from 3 famillies (only 1 of which consanguineous), all homozygous for a TRAPPC4 splicing variant.

Overlapping features included feeding difficulties, progressive microcephaly, severe to profound developmental disability (7/7 - DD also prior to the onset of seizures / regression also reported in 3), epilepsy (7/7 - onset in the first year), spastic quadriparesis. Other findings in some/few incl. scoliosis, cortical visual and hearing impairment. Some facial features were shared (eg. bitemporal narrowing, long philtrum, open mouth with thin tented upper lip, pointed chin, etc). Brain imaging demonstrated abnormalities in those performed (among others cerebral with/without cerebellar atrophy).

Work-up prior to exome sequencing was normal (highly variable incl. metabolic testing, CMA, MECP2, CDKL5, mitochondrial depletion studies, etc).

Exome of affected individuals (and parents +/- affected sibs in some families) revealed a homozygous TRAPPC4 splicing variant [NM_016146.5:c.454+3A>G / chr11:g.118890966A>G (hg19)]. Sanger sequencing confirmed variant in affecteds, heterozygosity in parents and compatible genotypes with disease status in sibs/other members.

Families were of Caucasian/Turkish and French-Canadian ethnicities. SNP array to compare haplotypes between affecteds in 2 families did not reveal a shared haplotype (/founder effect) and the variant is present in gnomAD (68/281054 - no hmz) in many populations (European/Asian/African/Latino) [https://gnomad.broadinstitute.org/variant/11-118890966-A-G].

mRNA studies in fibroblasts from an affected individual confirmed the splicing defect (2 RT-PCR products corresponding to wt and a shorter due to skipping of exon 3, the latter further confirmed by Sanger sequencing. The shorter transcript is not present in controls). qPCR revealed that the normal transript in patient fibroblasts was present at 6% of the level observed in control fibroblasts (or 54% in the case of a heterozygote parent compared to controls).

Western blot in patient fibroblasts, revealed presence of full-length protein in significantly reduced levels compared to fibroblasts from carrier parents or controls. There was no band using an antibody targeting the N-terminal region of the protein prior to exon 3, suggesting that NMD applies (skipping of ex3 is also predicted to lead to frameshift).

TRAPPC4 encodes one of the core proteins of the TRAPP complex. Use of different accessory proteins leads to formation of 2 distinct complexes (TRAPPII / III). The complex has an important role in intracellular trafficking. Both TRAPPII & TRAPPIII have a function in the secretory pathway, while complex III has a role also in autophagy. Core proteins are important for the complex stability. The TRAPP complex serves as a GEF for Ypt/Rab GTPases [several refs in article].

Mutations in genes for other proteins of the complex lead to neurodevelopmental disorders with associated ID ('TRAPPopathies' used by the authors / TRAPPC12, C6B, C9 green in the current panel).

Western blot suggested that levels of other TRAPP subunits (TRAPPC2 or C12) under denaturing conditions, although PAGE/size exclusion chromatography suggested that the levels of fully-assembled TRAPP complexes were lower in affected individuals.

Studies in patient fibroblasts showed a secretory defect (between ER, Golgi and the plasma membrane) which was restored upon lentiviral transduction with wt TRAPPC4 construct. Basal and starvation-induced autophagy were also impaired in patient fibroblasts (increased LC3 marker and LC3-positive structures / impaired co-localization with lysosomes) partly due to defective autophagosome formation (/sealing).

TRAPPC4 is the human orthologue of the yeast Trs23. In a yeast model of reduced Trs23 (due to temperature instability) the authors demonstrated impaired assembly of the TRAPP core. The yeast model recapitulated the autophagy as well as well as the secretory defect observed in patient fibroblasts.
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v2.1134 OXR1 Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: OXR1 was added
gene: OXR1 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: OXR1 was set to BIALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal
Publications for gene: OXR1 were set to https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ajhg.2019.11.002
Phenotypes for gene: OXR1 were set to Central hypotonia; Global developmental delay; Delayed speech and language development; Intellectual disability; Seizures; Abnormality of the cerebellum
Penetrance for gene: OXR1 were set to Complete
Review for gene: OXR1 was set to GREEN
Added comment: Wang et al (2019 - https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ajhg.2019.11.002 ) report on 5 individuals (from 3 families) with biallelic OXR1 LoF variants.

Common features included hypotonia (4/5), severe global DD (5/5) and speech delay (5/5), ID (5/5), epilepsy (5/5) with cerebellar dysplasia/atrophy (5/5) and in some scoliosis.

All were investigated by exome sequencing and were found to harbor biallelic loss-of-function variants (2 splice-site, a stopgain and a frameshift one) either in homozygosity (2 consanguineous families) or in compound heterozygosity. In all cases parental segregation studies were compatible and in one family, an unaffected sib shown to be carrier.

Althouhgh OXR1 has been shown to affect several processes (among others DNA lesions induced by oxidative stress in E.coli, neuronal maintenance, mitochondrial morphology and DNA maintenance, etc), its mechanism of action is still not well defined. There are 6 RefSeq transcripts, the longest (NM_018002.3) encoding 3 protein domains (LysM, GRAM, TLDc). The TLDc domain is encoded by all transcripts.

Identified variants affected (probably all - fig1D) transcripts expressed in the CNS, namely NM_018002.3, NM_001198532.1, NM_181354.4. The 3 transcripts not expressed in the CNS are NM_001198533.1, NM_001198534.1 and NM_001198535.1.

Western blot with 2 different antibodies which would bind upstream of the truncation site failed to detect presence of truncated proteins in 2 affected individuals from 2 families.

The Drosophila homolog of OXR is mustard (mtd). The authors provide evidence that loss of mtd is lethal. This was however rescued by expression of an 80kb fly BAC clone covering mtd, or the fly mtd-RH isoform cDNA, or a short human OXR1 cDNA containing only the TLDc domain or a human NCOA7 cDNA. The latter is another human mtd homolog which also contains the TLDc domain. As a result the TLDc domain compensated sufficiently for loss of mtd.

Flies that survived displayed bang sensitivity and climbing defects the former assay being suggestive of susceptibility to seizures and the latter of impaired neurological/muscular function.

The authors provided evidence that mtd is broadly expressed in the fly CNS. RNAi mediated mtd knockdown specific to neurons (elav/nSyb-GAL4 expression of mtd RNAi) led to lethal eclosion defects for RNAis targeting most (18)/all(23) mtd isoforms. Lifespan was increased upon expression of human OXR1 cDNA. Neuronal loss and vacuolization was demonstrated and additional experiments in R7 photoreceptors showed presence of aberrant lysosomal structures (autolysosomes, autophagosomes and/or endolysosomes).

Aberrant lysosomal structures were also observed in fibroblasts from affected individuals (accumulation of lysosomes and/or presence of highly aberrant compartments with content typical of lysosomal dysfunction).

Overall the data presented suggest a critical role for OXR1 in lysosomal biology.

Although previous reports suggested that OXR1 is involved in oxidative stress resistance, studies performed by the authors suggested that oxidative stress is probably not the driver of the mutant fly defects.
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v2.1122 TMX2 Konstantinos Varvagiannis edited their review of gene: TMX2: Added comment: A recent report by Vandervore, Schot et al. following the previous review (Am J Hum Genet. 2019 Nov 12 - PMID: 31735293), provides further evidence that biallelic TMX2 mutations cause malformations of cortical development, microcephaly, DD and ID and epilepsy.

As a result this gene should probably be considered for inclusion in the ID/epilepsy panels with green rating.

Overall, 14 affected subjects from 10 unrelated families are reported in the aforementioned study. The majority had severe DD/ID (failure to achieve milestones, absent speech/ambulation and signs of cerebral palsy) with few having a somewhat milder impairment. 12 (of the 14) presented with epilepsy (spasms, myoclonic seizures, focal seizures with/without generalization or generalized tonic-clonic seizures) with onset most often in early infancy. Upon brain MRI (in 12 individuals), 5 presented polymicrogyria, 2 others pachygyria, 4 with brain atrophy, etc.

All individuals were found to harbor biallelic TMX2 mutations by exome sequencing while previous investigations in several had ruled out alternative causes (infections, metabolic or chromosomal anomalies). Missense variants, an in-frame deletion as well as pLoF (stopgain/frameshift) variants were reported. [NM_015959.3 used as ref below].

The effect of variants was supported by mRNA studies, eg. RT-qPCR/allele specific RT-qPCR. The latter proved reduced expression for a frameshift variant (c.391dup / p.Leu131Profs*6) most likely due to NMD. Total mRNA levels were also 23% lower in an individual compound htz for a missense variant and a stopgain one localized in the last exon (c.757C>T / p.Arg253*). As for the previously reported c.614G>A (p.Arg205Gln), affecting the last nucleotide of exon 6, total mRNA in skin fibroblasts from a homozygous individual was not significantly decreased. RNA-Seq however demonstrated the presence of 4 different transcripts (roughly 25% each), one representing the regular mRNA, one with intron 6 retention (also present at low levels in healthy individuals), one with loss of 11 nucleotides within exon 6 and a fourth one due to in-frame skipping of exon 6.

*To the best of my understanding :

Thioredoxin (TRX)-related transmembrane proteins (TMX) belong to the broader family of oxidoreductases of protein disulfide isomerase (PDI) having an important role in protein folding.

Study of the data from the Allen Human Brain Atlas suggest relevant fetal expression also increasing during postnatal life.

As RNA-seq was carried out for 2 individuals, GO analysis suggested that the most deregulated clusters of genes are implicated in post-translational protein modifications (as would be expected for PDIs), membranes and synapse while pathway analysis suggested that relevant categories were inhibited eg. nervous system development/function and cell growth/proliferation/survival.

Upon transfection of HEK293T cells, exogenous TMX2 was shown to co-localize with calnexin (CNX) to the (ER) mitochondria-associated-membrane. Mass-spectrometry based analysis of co-immunoprecipitated proteins confirmed interaction with CNX but also other regulators of calcium homeostasis, mitochondrial membrane components and respiratory chain NADH dehydrogenase.

Study of the mitochondrial activity of TMX2-deficient fibroblasts suggested reduced respiratory reserve capacity, compensated by increased glycolytic activity.

TMX2 occurs in both reduced and oxidized monomeric form. It also forms (homo)dimers with the ratio of dimers/monomers increasing under conditions of oxidative stress. Variant TMX2 increased propensity to form dimers, thus mimicking increased oxidative state. This was observed under stress but also under native conditions.

---------; Changed rating: GREEN
Intellectual disability v2.1098 ZNF292 Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: ZNF292 was added
gene: ZNF292 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Radboud University Medical Center, Nijmegen,Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: ZNF292 was set to MONOALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal, imprinted status unknown
Publications for gene: ZNF292 were set to 31723249; 29904178
Phenotypes for gene: ZNF292 were set to Intellectual disability; Autism; Attention deficit hyperactivity disorder; Abnormality of the face; Abnormal muscle tone; Abnormality of nervous system morphology; Growth abnormality; Feeding difficulties; Abnormality of the skeletal system; Abnormality of the cardiovascular system; Microcephaly; Seizures
Penetrance for gene: ZNF292 were set to Incomplete
Review for gene: ZNF292 was set to GREEN
gene: ZNF292 was marked as current diagnostic
Added comment: Mirzaa et al. (2019 - PMID: 31723249) report on 28 individuals (from 27 families) with putatively pathogenic ZNF292 variants.

Main features consisted of DD and ID (27/28 - mild in 40%, moderate in 22%, severe in 11%) with or without ASD and ADHD. A single individual had no evidence of ID but had speech delay and ASD at the age of 6. Additional features (by diminishing order of frequency) included presence of non-specific dysmorphic features (~45%), abnormal tone, brain MRI abnormalities, growth failure, feeding difficulties, skeletal and cardiac anomalies, microcephaly and epilepsy (~11%).

As the authors comment, ZNF292 encodes a zinc finger protein, acting as a transcription factor.

Evidence is provided that gene has high expression in the developing human brain, with its expression being higher in prenatal development and diminishing postnatally. Znf292 is also expressed in adult mouse brain (highest in hippocampus/Purkinje cells).

Variants were identified by exome or targeted panel sequencing (targeted capture/molecular inversion probes). Previous investigations (eg. aCGH, analysis of relevant genes) had probably ruled out alternative causes in most with few having VUS or possibly relevant additional variants (eg. a KDM5C stopgain variant in a male).

24 putatively pathogenic variants were observed in this cohort, all predicting LoF (stopgain, frameshift or splice variants). All were de novo with the exception of one family where the variant was inherited from an affected parent. Almost all were absent from gnomAD and had CADD scores > 35.

Most variants lied within the last and largest exon that encodes a DNA binding domain. RT-PCR on RNA from 2 individuals harboring such variants confirmed that NMD does not apply. This exon however represents ~88% of the total coding length so the distribution of variants in this (NMD escaping) region was consistent with what would also be expected by chance.

ZNF292 has a pLI of 1 in gnomAD. Manual review of some relevant LoF variants in gnomAD suggested that they represent false positive calls.

As a result, the effect of variants is not clear although haploinsufficiency is still possible based also on phenotype of (larger) deletions spanning this gene (cited: Engwerda et al - PMID: 29904178 / The study focuses on deletions of the broader 6q. A possible role of ZNF292 is discussed as autism was present in 4/10 individuals with deletions encompassing this gene).

Based on the aforementioned cohort with one individual being diagnosed with mild ID only as an adult and/or presence of 5 pLoF variants in gnomAD the authors propose that some variants may be incompletely penetrant or associated with only mild features.

Finally, 15 additional individuals (belonging to 12 families) harbored variants for which pathogenicity was suspected (but could not be concluded) due to insufficient phenotypic information, lack of sufficient parental studies or missense variants. In this cohort variants were mostly pLoF, while 3 individuals (incl. 2 sibs) had a de novo missense SNV.
------
Other studies were not here reviewed as some of the individuals reported were published previously in larger cohorts.
------
There is no associated phenotype in OMIM / G2P. SysID includes this gene among the candidate ID ones.
ZNF292 is included in gene panels for ID offered by some diagnostic laboratories (incl. Radboudumc and GeneDx).
------
Overall ZNF292 could be added to the ID panel probably with green (or amber) rating.

[Please consider inclusion in other possibly relevant panels eg. autism, epilepsy]
Sources: Radboud University Medical Center, Nijmegen, Literature
Intellectual disability v2.1098 CNOT2 Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: CNOT2 was added
gene: CNOT2 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature,Radboud University Medical Center, Nijmegen
Mode of inheritance for gene: CNOT2 was set to MONOALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal, imprinted status unknown
Publications for gene: CNOT2 were set to 31512373; 31145527; 28135719; 28159701; 30768759; 21505450; 18076123; 22247066
Phenotypes for gene: CNOT2 were set to Intellectual developmental disorder with nasal speech, dysmorphic facies, and variable skeletal anomalies, MIM 618608
Penetrance for gene: CNOT2 were set to unknown
Review for gene: CNOT2 was set to GREEN
gene: CNOT2 was marked as current diagnostic
Added comment: Heterozygous pathogenic CNOT2 variants cause Intellectual developmental disorder with nasal speech, dysmorphic facies, and variable skeletal anomalies (MIM 618608 - recently added disorder in OMIM). Larger 12q15 deletions, spanning CNOT2 have been reported in patients with similar phenotype.

Relevant individuals - most discussed below - include 2 patients with truncating de novo mutation, 1 with de novo intragenic deletion, few with small deletions spanning also 2-3 additional proximal genes and others with larger 12q15 deletions encompassing CNOT2 and several other genes.

Overall the phenotype - summarized by Uehara et al. (Ref1 - below) - seems to consist of language delay, mild motor delay (in most), some suggestive facial features (upslanted palpebral fissures, anteverted nares, thin upper lip and micrognathia). Nasal speech has also been reported in some individuals.

As commented by Uehara et al. (Ref1), CNOT2 (CCR4-NOT transcription complex subunit 2) is a member of the carbon catabolite repressor 4 complex (CCR4-NOT), the latter having an important role in deadenylation of mRNA and global mRNA expression. Disruption of the complex - which can be caused by loss of one of its components - results in various human disorders incl. neural diseases. siRNA CNOT2 depletion has been shown to induce CCR4-NOT disruption (cited PMIDs: 16284618, 29438013, 31006510, 21299754).

The type of variants (truncating, intragenic deletion, larger deletions) and the highly overlapping phenotypes in the respective patients suggest happloinsufficiency as the underlying mechanism. CNOT2 has also a pLI of 1 in gnomAD (o/e =0.06) and a %HI in Decipher of 4.39.

The gene appears to have relevant expression (https://www.proteinatlas.org/ENSG00000111596-CNOT2/tissue).
Animal models have not been discussed (or phenotypes possibly not sufficiently studied - MGI for Cnot2 : http://www.informatics.jax.org/marker/MGI:1919318).

CNOT2 is not associated with any phenotype in G2P. It is listed among the ID candidate genes in SysID.
This gene is included in gene panels for ID offered by some diagnostic laboratories (incl. Radboudumc).

Overall CNOT2 could be considered for inclusion in the ID panel with amber (DD although outcome is not known, presumed dysfunction of the CCR4-NOT complex, variant studies or animal models not available) or green rating (sufficient cases and variants, consistent phenotype).
-----
Individuals with CNOT2-only disruption:
[1] PMID: 31512373 (Uehara et al., 2019) - A 6 y.o. male investigated for hypotonia, feeding problems, DD (speech and motor), macrocephaly (+3 SD) and some possibly suggestive facial/other features was found to harbor a de novo stopgain variant (NM_001199302.1: c.946A>T, p.Lys316Ter) after trio exome sequencing. The variant and its de novo occurrence were confirmed by Sanger sequencing. NMD was the predicted effect (variant in ex11 of 21 / effect not further studied). Previous metabolic work-up and chromosomal testing had not revealed an alternative diagnosis.
[2] PMID: 31145527 (Alesi et al. 2019) - A 13 y.o. boy with hypotonia, failure to thrive, DD and following a specific schooling program for children with learning difficulties is reported. The authors comment on the facial phenotype (incl. upslanted p-f, anteverted nares, etc). Other features included valvular/supravalvular pulm. stenosis, mid aortic insufficiency, renal anomalies/failure, skeletal anomalies. Speech was nasal. CMA revealed an 85-kb 12q15 deletion spanning only CNOT2 (exons 3-15). Real-time PCR in proband and parents confirmed the variant and its de novo occurrence.
[3] PMID: 28135719 (DDD study, 2017) - An individual with developmental disorder and a de novo (validated) frameshift variant was identified [DDD4K.00807 - NM_014515.5:c.1158del / p.(L387Sfs*3)]. Phenotype in Decipher incl. abnormality of head/neck, nervous, skeletal system and growth. [https://decipher.sanger.ac.uk/ddd/research-variant/16b4f7866652f08e25a194f65535b4c5#overview].

Individuals with disruption of additional proximal genes due to CNVs:
[4] PMID: 28159701 (Alesi et al. 2017) - The authors report on a 29 y.o. individual with history of DD, learning difficulties, ID (WAIS-R IQ of 48 at the age of 17 y), some dysmorphic facial features. Additional features incl. recurrent infections, nasal voice as well as skeletal anomalies. CMA revealed a 742 kb microdeletion spanning CNOT2, KCNMB4 and PTPRB. Real-time PCR confirmed deletion and it's de novo occurrence in the proband.
[5] PMID: 30768759 (Uehara et al. 2019) - A female investigated among others for global DD (walking/1st words at 24m), mild ID, submucosal cleft palate with some distinctive facial features (upslanted p-f, micrognathia, etc) was found to harbor a 1.32-Mb deletion of 12q15 encompassing CNOT2 and 14 other genes. Given the phenotypic resemblance to patients with 12q15 deletions, the previously defined smallest region of overlap (ref 4,6), the LoF SNV in Decipher the authors suggested that CNOT2 is the critical gene for the phenotype of 12q15 deletion syndrome.

Larger deletions defining the smallest region of overlap
[6] PMID: 21505450 (Vergult et al. 2011) - 3 patients with de novo microdeletions of ~ 2.5 Mb in size with a 1.34 MB common region of overlap are reported. Learning diability, DD, nasal speech and hypothyroidism were among the common features.
[7] PMID: 18076123 (Schluth et al. 2008) - A girl with large (~10 Mb) de novo deletion of 12q15 - q21.2 identified by BAC array was described. The phenotype consisted of hypotonia, DD, moderate ID, growth delay and facial dysmorphic features.
[8] PMID: 22247066 (Lopez et al. 2012) - A patient with ID and features of Floating-Harbor syndrome was found to harbor a 4.7 Mb de novo 12q15-q21.1 deletion spanning CNOT2 and 18 additional genes.
[..]
Sources: Literature, Radboud University Medical Center, Nijmegen
Intellectual disability v2.1098 TMX2 Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: TMX2 was added
gene: TMX2 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: TMX2 was set to BIALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal
Publications for gene: TMX2 were set to 31586943; 31270415
Phenotypes for gene: TMX2 were set to Global developmental delay; Intellectual disability; Seizures; Microcephaly; Abnormal cortical gyration
Penetrance for gene: TMX2 were set to Complete
Review for gene: TMX2 was set to AMBER
Added comment: PMID: 31586943 - Ghosh et al. 2019 - reported on 8 individuals from 4 consanguineous families from the Middle East and Central Asia, all with a phenotype of DD/ID, seizures and microcephaly with lissencephaly (microlissencephaly is the term applying to the combination of two) upon brain MRI.

All patients were investigated by exome sequencing and the variant localized within a region of ROH which was common to all 4 families. All were homozygous for a TMX2 missense variant (NM_001144012.2:c.500G>A or p.Arg167Gln / NM_015959.4:c.614G>A p.Arg205Gln or hg38 - Chr11:g.57739039G>A). The variant was considered to be the best candidate, upon review of all other homozygous ones.

Sanger sequencing confirmed homozygosity for the variant in affected subjects, with additional compatible segregation studies including parents in all families as well as unaffected sibs (in two families).

Despite presence of the same mutation in all, several proximal to this variant SNPs did not appear to be shared among the families studied, thus suggesting that the variant had arisen within different haplotype blocks.

The authors comment that the variant was not previously identified in public databases. (The variant seems to correspond to rs370455806, present in 10 htz individuals in gnomAD, as well as in the GME database [GME Genotype Count 992:0:1 (hmz?) | Allele Count: 2,1984] . GME includes primarily - although not necessarily - healthy individuals).

This SNV affecting the last nucleotide of an exon of several transcripts (correct ref. is NM_001144012.2 as appears in the supplement / using NM_001347898.1 as in the fig./text the variant would lie within an intron), an eventual splicing effect was studied. mRNA transcript levels were assessed following RT-PCR using different sets of primers. There was no evidence of novel splice isoforms but mRNA levels were reduced compared to controls (15-50% in affected individuals, to a lesser level in carriers). This led to the hypothesis that NMD of an aberrantly spliced mRNA might apply, although this was not proven.

TMX2 encodes a protein disulfide isomerase (PDI). PDIs are transmembrane ER proteins which have a critical role in protein folding (PMID cited: 12670024). There were no relevant studies carried out in the article.

As for animal models, the authors comment that mice homozygous for null mutations display preweaning lethality with complete penetrance.(http://www.informatics.jax.org/diseasePortal/popup?isPhenotype=true&markerID=MGI:1914208&header=mortality/aging).
-------
Previously, Schot el al. (ESHG Conference 2018 Oral Presentation - Mutations in the thioredoxin related gene TMX2 cause primary microcephaly, polymicrogyria and severe neurodegeneration with impaired mitochondrial energy metabolism - available in PMID: 31270415 / https://www.nature.com/articles/s41431-019-0407-4 ) reported on 7 individuals from 5 unrelated families with biallelic TMX2 mutations. A newborn with microcephaly, polymicrogyria who died of refractory epilepsy, was compound heterozygous for 2 TMX2 variants. 6 additional individuals (from 4 unrelated families) with similar phenotype were found to harbor biallelic TMX2 mutations. It was commented that TMX2 is enriched in mitochondria-associated membrane of the ER with a role in ER stress protection and regulation of neuronal apoptosis. In line with this, fibroblasts from 2 unrelated patients showed secondary OXPHOS deficiency and increased glycolytic activity (the latter possibly as a compensatory mechanism).
-------
There is no associated phenotype in OMIM/G2P/SysID.
-------
Overall this gene could be considered for inclusion in the ID/epilepsy panel probably with amber (/red) rating pending further evidence.
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v2.1098 PCYT2 Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: PCYT2 was added
gene: PCYT2 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: PCYT2 was set to BIALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal
Publications for gene: PCYT2 were set to 31637422
Phenotypes for gene: PCYT2 were set to Global developmental delay; Developmental regression; Intellectual disability; Spastic paraparesis; Seizures; Spastic tetraparesis; Cerebral atrophy; Cerebellar atrophy
Penetrance for gene: PCYT2 were set to Complete
Review for gene: PCYT2 was set to GREEN
Added comment: Vaz et al. (2019 - PMID: 31637422 - DDD study among the co-authors) report on 5 individuals - from 4 families - with biallelic PCYT2 mutations.

The phenotype corresponded to a complex hererditary paraplegia with global DD, regression (4/5), ID (mild in 3/5, severe in 2/5), spastic para-/tetraparesis, epilepsy (5/5 - variable onset 2-16 yrs - focal or tonic-clonic seizures) and progressive cerebral and cerebellar atrophy.

Exome sequencing in all revealed biallelic PCYT2 variants, confirmed with Sanger s. in probands and their parents (NM_001184917.2 - corresponding to the canonical transcript used as Ref below):
- P1 (Fam1) : 2 missense SNVs in trans configuration, c.730C>T or p.His244Tyr and c.920C>T or p.Pro307Leu
- P2 (Fam2 - consanguineous of White British origin), P3 (Fam3 - Consanguineous of Turkish origin), P4,5 (Fam4 - consanguineous, unspecified origin) : homozygosity for c.1129C>T or p.Arg377Ter) affecting the last exon of 8/12 transcripts, including the canonical one.

Individuals with the same genotype displayed variable degrees of ID (eg P3 - severe / P2, P4,5 - mild ID).

For sibs in Fam4, homozygosity for a missense SACS variant led to consideration of the respective disorder (AR spastic ataxia of Charlevoix-Saguenay) though the variant was predicted to be tolerated in silico and notably the MRI images not suggestive.

All variants were absent from / had extremely low AF in public databases, with no homozygotes.

Posphatidylethanolamine (PE) is a membrane lipid, particularly enriched in human brain (45% of phospholypid fraction). PE is synthesized either via the CDP-ethanolamine pathway or by decarboxylation of phosphatidylserine in mitochondria. PCYT2 encodes CTP:phosophoethanolamine cytidyltransferase (ET) which is an ubiquitously expressed rate-limiting enzyme for PE biosynthesis in the former pathway.

In silico, the 2 missense variants - localizing in the CTP catalytic domain 2 - were predicted to be damaging, as well as to affect protein stability.

Fibroblasts of 3 patients (P1, P2, P3) representing all variants were studied:
- Enzymatic activity was shown to be significantly reduced (though not absent) compared to controls. Abnormalities were noted upon Western Blot incl. absence in all 3 patients studied of one of the 2 bands normally found in controls (probably representing the longer isoform), reduced intensity in all 3 of another band probably corresponding to a shorter isoform, and presence of an additional band of intermediate molec. mass in patients with the truncating variant.
- RT-PCR on mRNA from patient fibroblasts did not reveal (significant) reduction compared to controls.
- Lipidomic profile of patient fibroblasts was compatible with the location of the block in the phospholipid biosynthesis pathway and different from controls.

The lipidomic profile had similarities with what has been reported for EPT1 deficiency, the enzyme directly downstream of ET. The SELENO1-related phenotype (/EPT1 deficiency) is also highly overlapping.

CRISPR-Cas9 was used to generate pcyt2 partial or complete knockout (ko) zebrafish, targeting either the final (ex13) or another exon (ex3) respectively. mRNA expression was shown to be moderately reduced in the first case and severely reduced/absent in the second, compared to wt. Similarly, complete-ko (ex3) led to significantly lower survival, with impaired though somewhat better survival of partial-ko (ex13) zebrafish.

Complete knockout of Pcyt2 in mice is embryonically lethal (PMID cited: 17325045) while heterozygous mice develop features of metabolic syndrome (PMID cited: 22764088).

Given lethality in knockout zebrafish / mice and the residual activity (15-20%) in patient fibroblasts, the variants reported were thought to be hypomorphic and complete loss of function possibly incompatible with life.

PCYT2 is not associated with any phenotype in OMIM/G2P/SysID and not commonly included in gene panels for ID.

As a result this gene could included in the ID / epilepsy panels with green (~/>3 indiv/fam/variants with the nonsense found in different populations, consistent phenotype, lipidomics, in silico/in vitro/in vivo evidence) or amber rating.

[Please consider inclusion in other possibly relevant panels eg. for metabolic disorders, etc].
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v2.1098 PDE6D Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: PDE6D was added
gene: PDE6D was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: PDE6D was set to BIALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal
Publications for gene: PDE6D were set to 24166846; 30423442
Phenotypes for gene: PDE6D were set to ?Joubert syndrome 22 - MIM 615665
Penetrance for gene: PDE6D were set to Complete
Review for gene: PDE6D was set to AMBER
gene: PDE6D was marked as current diagnostic
Added comment: Thomas et al. (2014 - PMID: 24166846) reported on a consanguineous Pakistani family with 3 members presenting variable polydactyly, brain anomalies (incl. molar tooth sign), microphthalmia/coloboma with retinal disease, renal hypoplasia suggestive of Joubert syndrome.

Genotyping with a SNP array identified a unique 17-Mb region of homozygosity on chr2 with LOD score of 2.6. The region contained 208 genes, of which 15 present in ciliary gene databases. A homozygous splicing variant appeared to be the only relevant, PDE6D being a ciliary gene within this region [NM_002601.4:c.140-1G>A]. Status of all affected members, parents and 2 unaffected sibs was verified with Sanger sequencing.

PDE6D encodes a phosphodiesterase that binds to prenyl groups and has a critical role in ciliogenesis (Humbert et al. - PMID: 23150559 and OMIM).
Several lines of evidence provided support a role for PDE6D and the reported variants :
- Study of PDE6D expression during human embryogenesis suggests ubiquitous localization and highest levels in organs affected in ciliopathies (CNS, kidney tubules, respiratory tract epitherlial cells).
- RT-PCR of mRNA from control/patient fibroblasts and sequencing confirmed the splicing defect leading to an in-frame deletion of exon 3.
- Wt and mutant protein both localized in the basal body of primary cilia (patient/control fibroblasts). Cilia in both cases had normal morphology.
- Experiments in RPE cells confirmed that INPP5E (involved in Joubert/MORM syndrome) interacts (/is probably a cargo of) PDE6D, a process dependent on prenylation.
- Exon 3 deletion was confirmed to disrupt PDE6D binding to INPP5E.
- Analysis by immunofluoresence of INPP5E localization using control/patient fibroblasts and renal tissue showed absence of INPP5E from primary cilia in the case of patient cells (but not controls) suggesting that PDE6D is important for trafficking INPP5E to the cilium.
- Previous study in mice suggested altered photoreceptor physiology in Pde6d (-/-) animals, resulting in a slowly progressing rod/cone dystrophy. The effect was however limited to the eye. (PMID cited : 17496142 - Zhang et al., 2007).
- Morpholino knockdown of pde6d resulted in pericardial edema, eye abnormalities (microphthalmia and disorganized retinal cell layers) and kidney morphogenesis defects (distended, blocked pronephric openings and proximal tubule cysts). Edema was rescued upon coinjection of morpholino with wt (but not mutant) mRNA. Similarly coinjection led to complete or partial rescue of eye development in the case of wt and mutant mRNA respectively supporting pathogenicity and (partial) loss-of-function effect for the variant.
---------
Mégarbané et al. (2019 - PMID: 30423442) reported on an affected 6 month-old boy born to Lebanese first-cousin parents. Features included hypotonia, developmental delay, microcephaly, oculomotor apraxia, postaxial polydactyly of hands and feet and presence of a molar tooth sign upon brain MRI. Renal and retinal anomalies were absent (also given his age). Exome sequencing revealed homozygosity for a frameshift PDE6D variant [NM_002601.3:c.367_368insG or p.(Leu123Cysfs*13)]. Sanger sequencing confirmed presence of the variant in the proband and carrier status of the parents. The variant affected the penultimate exon (note : present in only this longest transcript) and was not predicted to trigger NMD but rather lead to elimination of a highly conserved PDZ-interaction domain.
---------
The phenotype associated with biallelic PDE6D variants in OMIM is ?Joubert syndrome 22 - MIM 615665 based only on the 1st report ('delayed psychomotor development' among the features). There is no relevant entry in G2P. PDE6D is listed as a Current primary (/confirmed) ID gene in SysID (the aforementioned PMIDs cited).

This gene is included in gene panels for ID offered by some diagnostic laboratories (eg. GeneDx).
---------
Overall PDE6D could be considered for inclusion in the ID panel probably with amber rating (2 families/variants, DD but outcome otherwise unknown - evidence for the the gene causing JS seems however sufficient).
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v2.1098 AP1B1 Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: AP1B1 was added
gene: AP1B1 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: AP1B1 was set to BIALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal
Publications for gene: AP1B1 were set to 31630788; 31630791
Phenotypes for gene: AP1B1 were set to Failure to thrive; Abnormality of the skin; Hearing abnormality; Abnormality of copper homeostasis; Global developmental delay; Intellectual disability
Penetrance for gene: AP1B1 were set to Complete
Review for gene: AP1B1 was set to AMBER
Added comment: Boyden et al. (2019 - PMID: 31630788) and Alsaif et al (2019 - PMID: 31630791) report on the phenotype related to biallelic AP1B1 mutations.

Common features included failure to thrive, ichthyosis (with variable palmoplantar keratoderma/erythroderma/abnormal hair) and hearing loss. Each study focused on different additional features eg. thrombocytopenia or photophobia in all individuals reported by Boyden et al, while Alsaif et al. focused on abnormal copper metabolism (low plasma copper and ceruloplasmin) observed in all 3 affected individuals and enteropathy/hepatopathy observed in 2 sibs.

DD was observed in all 3 individuals (2 families) reported by Alsaif et al. and patient 424 reported by Boyden et al. ID was noted in all individuals of relevant age (2 from 2 families) in the study by Alsaif. Boyden commented that ID is not part of the phenotype. The adult (424) - despite his early DD - was noted to have normal intellect and had graduated college. The other patient (1325) was last followed up at 11 months (still DD was not reported).

AP1B1 encodes one of the large subunits (β1) of the adaptor protein complex 1. Each of the AP complexes is a heterotetramer composed of two large (one of γ, α, δ, ε and β1-β4 for AP-1 to AP-4 respectively), one medium (μ1-μ4) and one small (σ1-σ4) adaptin subunit. The complex is involved in vesicle-mediated transport.

Variants were confirmed in probands and carrier parents (NM_001127.3):
Boyden Pat424 (33y) : c.430T>C (p.Cys144Arg) in trans with c.2335delC (p.Leu779Serfs*26)
Boyden Pat1325 (11m) [consanguineous Ashkenazi Jewish family] : homozygosity for c.2374G>T (p.Glu792*)
Alsaif sibs P1,P2 (4y4m, 1y5m) [consanguineous - Pakistani origin] : homozygous for a chr22 75 kb deletion spanning only the promoter and ex1-2 of AP1B1
Alsaif P3 (4y6m) [consanguineous - Saudi origin] : homozygous for a c.38-1G>A

Variant / additional studies :
22q 75-kb deletion: PCR deletion mapping and Sanger delineated the breakpoints of the 22q12.2 del to chr22:29758984-29815476 (hg?). Complete absence of transcript upon RT-PCR (mRNA from fibrolasts).
Splicing variant (c.38-1G>A): RT-PCR confirmed replacement of the normal transcript by an aberrant harboring a 1 bp deletion (r.40del).
Stopgain variant (c.2374G>T): Western blot demonstrated loss of AP1B1 (and marked reduction also for AP1G1) in cultured keratinocytes of the homozygous patient.

Loss-of-function is the effect predicted by variants. Vesicular defects were observed in keratinocytes of an affected individual (homozygous for the nonsense variant). Rescue of these vesicular defects upon transduction with wt AP1B1 lentiviral construct confirmed the LoF effect. [Boyden et al.]

ATP7A and ATP7B, two copper transporters, have been shown to depend on AP-1 for their trafficking. Similar to MEDNIK syndrome, caused by mutations in AP1S1 and having an overlapping phenotype with AP1B1 (also including hypocupremia and hypoceruloplasminemia), fibroblasts from 2 affected individuals (from different families) demonstrated abnormal ATP7A trafficking. [Alsaif et al.]

Proteomic analysis of clathrin coated vesicles (2 ind from 2 fam) demonstrated that AP1B1 was the only AP1/AP2 CCV component consistently reduced in 2 individuals (from 2 families). [Alsaif et al.]

Boyden et al. provided evidence for abnormal differentiation and proliferation in skin from an affected individual. In addition E-cadherin and β-catenin were shown to be mislocalized in keratinocytes from this affected individual.

Loss of ap1b1 in zebrafish is not lethal but lead to auditory defects (/vestibular deficits). The inner ears appear to develop normally, although there is progressive degeneration of ear epithelia. There are no behavioral/neurological phenotypes listed for mouse models. [ http://www.informatics.jax.org/marker/MGI:1096368 ].

AP1B1 is not associated with any phenotype in OMIM/G2P/SysID.

Overall this gene could be considered for inclusion in the ID panel probably with amber rating.
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v2.1098 FDFT1 Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: FDFT1 was added
gene: FDFT1 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: FDFT1 was set to BIALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal
Publications for gene: FDFT1 were set to 29909962
Phenotypes for gene: FDFT1 were set to Profound global developmental delay; Intellectual disability; Seizures; Abnormality of nervous system morphology; Cortical visual impairment; Abnormality of the skin; Abnormality of the face
Penetrance for gene: FDFT1 were set to Complete
Review for gene: FDFT1 was set to AMBER
Added comment: Biallelic pathogenic FDFT1 variants cause Squalene synthase deficiency (MIM 618156). 3 individuals from 2 families (and 3 variants) have been reported. DD, ID and seizures are part of the phenotype (3/3). The metabolic profile observed is specific and highly suggestive of disruption of the cholesterol biosynthesis pathway (at the specific level) while the clinical presentation is similar to other disorders of the pathway (SLO). The effect of 2 variants has been studied in detail (in one case mis-splicing demonstrated and in the other regulatory effect). Overall, this gene could be considered for inclusion in the ID/epilepsy panel with amber rating. As the gene is currently present only in the DDG2P panel, please consider adding it to relevant ones (eg. IEMs, undiagnosed metabolic disorders, etc). [Details provided below].
----
Coman et al. (2018 - PMID: 29909962) reported on 3 relevant individuals from 2 unrelated families.

The phenotype consisted of seizures (3/3 - neonatal onset - generalized), profound DD (ID can be inferred from the description in the supplement), variable brain MRI abnormalities (white matter loss, hypoplastic CC), cortical visual impairment, dry skin with photosensitivity as well facial dysmorphic features. Male subjects presented genital anomalies (cryptorchidism/hypospadias).

FDFT1 encodes squalene synthase, the enzyme which catalyzes conversion of farnesyl-pyrophosphate to squalene - the first specific step in cholesterol biosynthesis.

A specific pattern of metabolites was observed in all, similar to a pattern previously observed in animal models/humans treated with squalene synthase inhibitor or upon loading with farnesol (in animals). Overall the pattern was suggestive of a cholesterol biosynthesis defect at the level of squalene synthase as suggested by increased total farnesol levels (farnesyl-pyrophosphate + free farnesol), reduced/normal squalene, low plasma cholesterol as well as other metabolites.

Clinical features also resembled those observed in Smith-Lemli-Opitz syndrome (another disorder of cholesterol biosynthesis).

WES was carried out in affected individuals and their parents and revealed for sibs of the first family, compound heterozygosity for a maternally inherited 120-kb deletion spanning exons 6-10 of FDFT1 and CTSB and a paternally inherited FDFT1 variant in intron 8 (TC deletion/AG insertion). Variant studies for the latter included:
- Minigene splice assay demonstrating retention of 22 bp in intron 8.
- Partial splicing defect with both nl and mis-spliced cDNA (patient fibroblasts)
- Reduced protein levels in lymphoblasts/fibroblasts from both sibs upon Western blot.
Contribution of the CTSB deletion was considered unlikely (carrier mother was unaffected).

As for the 2nd family, WES data allowed identification of a homozygous deep-intronic (although this is transcript-specific) 16-bp deletion in the proband. Parents were carriers. For the specific variant :
- cDNA studies failed to detect 3 (of 10) isoforms which are normally present in control fibroblasts. Eventual NMD (which would be predicted if the deletion resulted in splicing defect) was eliminated given the absent effect of cyclohexamide addition, thus suggesting a regulatory effect.
- Given a predicted promoter/enhancer effect of the deleted region, a luciferase assay performed, suggested that the sequence had promoter capacity, with the construct containing the 16-bp deletion showing reduced promoter activity.

Fdft1 knockout mice demonstrate embryonic lethality around mid-gestation while they exhibit severe growth retardation and defective neural tube closure.

In G2P FDFT1 is associated with 'Defect in Cholesterol Biosynthesis' (confidence:possible/biallelic/LoF). The gene belongs to the Current primary ID gene group of SysID. It is not commonly included in gene panels for ID offered by diagnostic laboratories.
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v2.1062 TDP2 Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: TDP2 was added
gene: TDP2 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature,Radboud University Medical Center, Nijmegen
Mode of inheritance for gene: TDP2 was set to MONOALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal, NOT imprinted
Publications for gene: TDP2 were set to 24658003; 30109272; 31410782
Phenotypes for gene: TDP2 were set to Spinocerebellar ataxia, autosomal recessive 23, 616949)
Penetrance for gene: TDP2 were set to unknown
Review for gene: TDP2 was set to GREEN
gene: TDP2 was marked as current diagnostic
Added comment: Biallelic pathogenic TGP2 variants cause Spinocerebellar ataxia, autosomal recessive 23 (MIM 616949). At least 6 affected individuals from 4 families have been reported, in all cases homozygous for LoF variants (3 different). ID, epilepsy and ataxia are consistent features of the disorder.

TDP2 encodes a phosphodiesterase that is required for efficient repair of double strand breaks (DSBs) produced by abortive topoisomerase II (TOP2) activity.

The gene is expressed in fetal and adult human brain.

Evidence at the variant level (mRNA, protein levels) and additional studies for impairment of TOP2-induced DSB repair support a role.

Animal models (primarily mice) reproduce the DSB repair defect, provide some histopathological evidence, show transcriptional dysregulation of genes (in line with the role of TOP2 in transcription). They have however failed to reproduce relevant neurological phenotypes.

Published studies are summarized below.

TDP2 is included in gene panels for ID offered by some diagnostic laboratories (incl. Radboudumc and GeneDx). There is no associated phenotype in G2P. TDP2 is listed among the current primary ID genes in SysID.

Overall, this gene could be considered for inclusion in the ID and epilepsy panels probably as green (>=3 patients/families/variants, relevant ID and seizures in all, expression in brain, mRNA/protein levels tested, impaired activity) or amber (absence of neurological phenotypes in mouse model).
------------

[1] - PMID: 24658003 (Gómez-Herreros et al. 2014):
Reports 3 individuals from a consanguineous Irish family. Features included seizures (onset by 2m, 6m and 12y), ID (3/3) and ataxia (3/3).

A splicing variant (NM_016614.3:c.425+1G>A) was found in a 9.08-Mb region of homozygosity shared by all. A further ZNF193 missense variant localizing in the same region was thought unlikely to contribute to the phenotype (evidence also provided in subsequent study).

The effect of the specific variant was proven by abnormal mRNA size, lower mRNA levels due to NMD (corrected upon cyclohexamide treatment), loss of TDP2 protein upon WB, loss of protein activity in lymphoblastoid cells from affected individuals, decreased repair of DSBs and increased cell death upon addition of etoposide (which promotes TOP2 abortive activity).

The authors report very briefly on a further patient (from Egypt), with ID, 'reports of fits' and ataxia. This individual, with also affected sibs, was homozygous LoF (c.413_414delinsAA / p.Ser138*). Again, the authors were not able to detect TDP2 activity in blood from this subject.

As also commented:
- TDP2 has relevant expression in human (particularly adult) brain.
- Mouse model : Tdp2 is expressed in relevant tissues, absence of Tdp2 activity was observed in neural tissue of mice homoyzgous for an ex1-3 del, with impairment of DSB repair. The authors were unable to detect a neurological phenotype with behavioral analyses, preliminary assesment of seizure propensity. Mice did not show developmental defects. Histopathology however, revealed ~25% reduction in the density of interneurons in cerebellum (a 'hallmark of DSB repair' and associated with seizures and ataxia). Transcription of several genes was shown to be disregulated.
- Knockdown in zebrafish appears to affect left-right axis detremination (cited PMID: 18039968).

[2] - PMID: 30109272 (Zagnoli-Vieira et al. 2018):
A 6 y.o. male with seizures (onset by 5m), hypotonia, DD and ID, microcephaly and some additional clinical features and testing (ETC studies on muscle biopsy, +lactate, +(lactate/pyruvate) ratio) which could be suggestive of mitochondrial disorder. This individual from the US was homozygous for the c.425+1G>A variant but lacked the ZNF193 one (despite a shared haplotype with the Irish patients). Again absence of the protein was shown upon WB in patient fibroblasts, also supported by its activity. Complementation studies restored the DSB repair defect. The defect was specific to TOP2-induced DSBs as suggested by hypersensitivity to etoposide but not to ionizing radiation. CRISPR/Cas9 generated mutant human A549 cells demonstrated abnormal DSB repair. Fibroblasts / edited A549 cells failed to show mitochondrial defects (which were noted in muscle).

[3] - PMID: 31410782 (Ciaccio et al. 2019):
A girl born to consanguineous Italian parents, presented with moderate/severe ID, seizures (onset at 12y) and - among others - gait ataxia, tremor and dysmetria. MRI at the age of 12, demonstrated cerebellar atrophy (although previous exams were N). WES revealed a homozygous nonsense variant (c.400C>T / p.Arg134Ter) for which each parent was found to be carrier. Previous investigations included aCGH, NGS testing for epilepsy and metabolic testing.
Sources: Literature, Radboud University Medical Center, Nijmegen
Intellectual disability v2.1046 PMPCA Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: PMPCA was added
gene: PMPCA was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature,Radboud University Medical Center, Nijmegen
Mode of inheritance for gene: PMPCA was set to BIALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal
Publications for gene: PMPCA were set to 25808372; 26657514; 27148589; 30617178
Phenotypes for gene: PMPCA were set to Spinocerebellar ataxia, autosomal recessive 2 (MIM 213200)
Penetrance for gene: PMPCA were set to Complete
Review for gene: PMPCA was set to GREEN
gene: PMPCA was marked as current diagnostic
Added comment: Biallelic pathogenic PMPCA variants cause Spinocerebellar ataxia, autosomal recessive 2 (SCAR2 - MIM 213200). More than 20 individuals from several unrelated families have been reported. At least 6 different pathogenic variants have been identified. Loss of PMPCA function is the suggested mechanism. ID is a feature of the disorder.

PMPCA encodes the α-subunit of mitochondrial processing peptidase (αMPP), a heterodimeric enzyme responsible for the cleavage of nuclear-encoded mitochondrial precursor proteins after import in the mitochondria (summary by Jobling et al and OMIM).

Arguments for involvement of the gene include the highly similar phenotype, segregation studies, expression of the gene in fetal and relevant adult tissues (in brain/cerebellum/cerebellar vermis), lower protein levels demonstrated for some variants, abnormal processing of frataxin (in line with the role of αMPP) demonstrated in most cases, rescue of the maturation defect upon transduction of wt PMPCA cDNA, disruption of REDOX balance in patient cells, etc.

Relevant studies are summarized below.

PMPCA is included in gene panels for ID offered by several diagnostic laboratories (incl. Radboud UMC, GeneDx, etc) and listed as a confirmed ID gene in SysID. It is not associated with any phenotype in G2P.

As a result, this gene can be considered for inclusion in the current panel probably as green (or amber).

----

[1] - Jobling et al. (2015 - PMID: 25808372) described the phenotype of 17 individuals from 4 families, all presenting with non-progressive cerebellar ataxia and the majority with ID of variable severity (15/17 - relevant to the current panel). Individuals from 3 of the families - all of Lebanese origin - were homozygous for NM_015160.3:c.1129G>A (p.Ala377Thr). A further similarly affected subject was compound heterozygous for c.287C>T (p.Ser96Leu) and c.1543G>A (p.Gly515Arg).

The homozygous variant in the first family was found within a 2.85 Mb linkage region on chr 9q34. An additional variant within this region (in CAMSAP1) was discarded following results in other families of the same origin.

Semi-quantitative RT-PCR demonstrated fetal expression of the PMPCA as well as relatively higher expression in adult brain, cerebellum and cerebellar vermis.

As for Ala377Thr, protein levels were shown to be lowest in affected individuals (LCLs, fibroblasts) and low - though somewhat higher - in carrier parents (LCL) compared to controls. RT-PCR on total RNA from LCLs did not show evidence of abnormal transcripts/additional splicing defect. Localization of mutant protein and morphology of mitochondrial reticulum was similar to controls. Maturation of frataxin - the protein depleted in Friedreich ataxia - was shown to be abnormal in patient lymphoblasts, compatible with the role of αMPP. In line with abnormal mitochondrial function, REDOX balance was increased in patient cells.

[2] - Choquet et al. (2016 - PMID: 26657514) reported on 2 sibs - born to distantly related parents. The authors noted a phenotype corresponding to SCAR2 although the presentation was somewhat milder, intellectual disability was not a feature (despite some learning difficulties in one) and ataxia was progressive. WES demonstrated homozygosity for NM_015160:c.766G>A (p.Val256Met). Western blot in patient lymphoblasts showed αMPP levels similar to carriers and controls. Abnormal maturation (accumulation of specific isoforms) was shown for frataxin.

[3] - Joshi et al. (2016 - PMID: 27148589) described the phenotype of 2 cousins belonging to a large Lebanese pedigree. Presentation in both was compatible with multisystem involvement incl. profound global DD, severe hypotonia, weakness, respiratory insufficiency, blindness suggestive of mitochondrial disorder. mtDNA, analyses of mitochondrial focused nuclear gene panel and aCGH were non-diagnostic. Both subjects were compound heterozygous for NM_015160.3:c.1066G>A (p.Gly356Ser) and c.1129G>A (p.Ala377Thr) following WES, with compatible segregation studies within the family. Western blot revealed PMPCA levels similar to control. Reduction of PMPCA staining and abnormally enlarged mitochondria were observed upon immunofluorescence in patient fibroblasts. Frataxin processing was abnormal. Lentiviral transduction of patient fibroblasts with wt PMPCA cDNA, led to increased PMPCA levels and correction of frataxin processing.

[4] - Rubegni et al. (2019 - PMID: 30617178) report on a 7-y.o. boy with global DD, spastic-ataxic gait and 'low IQ'. MRI images were suggestive of cerebellar atrophy with hyperintensity in the striatum. The child was homozygous for c.553C>T / p.Arg185Trp (reference not specified, although the variant would be compatible with NM_015160.3).
Sources: Literature, Radboud University Medical Center, Nijmegen
Intellectual disability v2.1022 CACNA2D2 Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: CACNA2D2 was added
gene: CACNA2D2 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: CACNA2D2 was set to BIALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal
Publications for gene: CACNA2D2 were set to 23339110; 24358150; 30410802; 29997391; 31402629; 11487633; 11756448; 4177347; 14660671; 15331424
Phenotypes for gene: CACNA2D2 were set to Cerebellar atrophy with seizures and variable developmental delay (MIM 618501)
Penetrance for gene: CACNA2D2 were set to Complete
Review for gene: CACNA2D2 was set to AMBER
gene: CACNA2D2 was marked as current diagnostic
Added comment: Gene reviewed for the epilepsy panel. Due to the phenotype of EE, with variable GDD (severe in many cases) and/or ID (either specifically commented on or inferred in some cases, although not universal) this gene might also be relevant for the current panel. CACNA2D2 is also included in gene panels for ID offered by some diagnostic laboratories (eg. GeneDx) as well as the SysID database. There is no associated phenotype in G2P.

Copied from the epilepsy panel:

Biallelic pathogenic CACNA2D2 variants cause Cerebellar atrophy with seizures and variable developmental delay (MIM 618501).

A recent OMIM update, a subsequent relevant publication by Punatha et al. as well as several additional LP/P variants in ClinVar for the phenotype of epileptic encephalopathy, support possible upgrade to green.

The following affected individuals appear to be relevant [NM_006030.3 used as RefSeq unless otherwise specified]:

[1] Edvardson et al. (PMID: 23339110) - 3 sibs born to consanguineous parents with EIEE, severe GDD / ID (inferred from the descritpion, at least for the oldest one), cerebellar atrophy and movement abnormalities. A CACNA2D2 variant (c.3137T>C / p.Leu1046Pro) was found in affected individuals by SNP-arrays and WES in one of them. Functional studies (reduction in current density of calcium channels in Xenopus laevis oocytes) supported the deleterious effect of the variant. A role of a rare hmz CESLR3 variant could not be ruled out.

[2] Pippucci et al. (PMID: 24358150) - 1 individual born to consanguineous parents, presenting with EE (onset at 1-2 m), severe GDD, cerebellar atrophy and choreiform movements. Homozygosity for a LoF variant (c.1294delA - p.Asn432fs) was found by WES. The role of the variant was further supported by expression studies (80% reduced mRNA levels, protein levels estimated at 3% of control / milder effect in htz parents). The proband was also hmz for a CESLR3 variant. Previous studies incl. 'high-resolution karyotype' and metabolic investigations.

[3] Butler et al. (PMID: 30410802) - A 5 y.o. male, with EE (seizure onset at 7m / GDD) and cerebellar atrophy. Compound heterozygosity for c.782C>T (p.Pro261Leu) and c.3137T>C (p.Leu1046Pro) was demonstrated by WES and supported by segregation studies.

[4] Valence et al. (PMID: 29997391) - Reported on a 20 y.o. male belonging to a cohort of 20 individuals with congenital ataxia, all from consaguineous families. This individual, who had cerebellar atrophy, ataxia, a single episode of febrile seizures and normal cognitive impairment was homozygosity for c.2971G>A (p.Asp991Asn). RT-PCR revealed presence of a normal length transcript as well as an additional, longer one, due to a concurrent splicing effect (activation of a cryptic donor splice site and retention of 4 bases of intronic sequence). Presence of both nl/abn length transcripts was presumed to explain the mild phenotype (variability also commented in OMIM).

[5] Punatha et al. (PMID: 31402629) - 3 affected individuals from 2 consanguineous families presenting with early onset EE (onset 1-7m), GDD/ID, cerebelar atrophy and ataxia. Sibs from the first family were homozygous for c.1778G>C (p.Arg593Pro). An affected 5 y.o. child from the 2nd family was homozygous for c.485_486delAT (p.Tyr162Ter). Mutations were found by WES in regions of AOH.

The following variants - not reported in the literature - have been submitted in ClinVar as LP / P for EE:
[VCV000645106.1] NM_006030.4:c.1389+2T>C - EIEE with suppression bursts - Likely Pathogenic (Invitae)
[VCV000570589.1] NM_006030.4:c.1956_1960del (p.Asn652fs) - EIEE - Pathogenic (Invitae)
[VCV000578284.1] NM_006030.4:c.1555C>T (p.Gln519Ter) - EIEE - Pathogenic (Invitae)
[VCV000653393.1] NM_006030.4:c.851dup (p.Ala286fs) - EIEE with suppression bursts - Pathogenic (Invitae)
[VCV000411003.1] NM_006030.4:c.485_486del (p.Tyr161_Tyr162insTer) - EIEE - Pathogenic (Invitae)

Additional ones have been reported as LP / P although the condition is not specified.
[VCV000620551.1] NM_006030.4:c.1023C>A (p.Cys341Ter) - Likely pathogenic (GeneDx)
[VCV000373439.2] NM_006030.4:c.1846-1G>A - Likely pathogenic (GeneDx)
[VCV000423330.2] NM_006030.4:c.200dup (p.His68fs) - Pathogenic (GeneDx).

The aforementioned laboratories include CACNA2D2 in gene panels for epilepsy (Invitae) and/or ID (GeneDx).

A role for the CACNA2D2 is supported by :
- The highly overlapping features (with the exception of the milder phenotype reported by Valence et al.) incl. early onset of seizures, GDD, cerebellar atrophy in all (9/9 incl. the individual reported by Valence, as evaluated Punatha et al). Ataxia was a feature in many (with movement abnormalities also in the remaining ones).
- The role of the gene encoding the alpha-2-delta-2 auxiliary subunit of high voltage-gated calcium channels. Auxiliary subunits modulate calcium current and channel activation and inactivation kinetics, and may be involved in proper assembly and membrane localization of the channels (summary by Edvardson and OMIM).
- Functional / expression studies for some of the variants (as in Refs 1,2,4).
- Relevant expression patterns (notably in cerebellum) [GTEx project]
- Mouse models recapitulating the human phenotypes (summarized by Edvardson et al) : The 'ducky' mouse model (due to biallelic Cacna2d2 mutations) presenting absence epilepsy, spike-wave seizures and ataxia. Dysgenesis of the cerebellum is among the neuropathological findings (PMIDs cited : 11487633, 11756448, 4177347). The 'entla' mouse model (also AR due to an in-frame duplication) presents also epilepsy and ataxia (PMID : 14660671). Targeted knockout in another mouse model resulted also in ataxic gait, seizure susceptibility and cerebellar anomalies/degeneration (PMID: 15331424).

[Please consider inclusion in other relevant panels eg. for cerebellar anomalies / ataxia].
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v2.1022 GABRA2 Konstantinos Varvagiannis changed review comment from: Heterozygous pathogenic GABRA2 variants cause Epileptic encephalopathy, early infantile, 78 (MIM 618557) [new OMIM entry].

At least 8 relevant individuals have been reported to date in the following studies:
- Orenstein et al. (2018 - PMID: 29422393) - 1 individual
- Butler et al. (2018 - PMID: 29961870) - 1 subject
- Maljevic et al. (2019 - PMID: 31032849 - 3 unrelated children as well as 2 affected sibs
- Sanchis-Juan et al. (2019 - bioRxiv / https://doi.org/10.1101/678219) - 1 further patient

In all affected individuals the variants were missense and - in almost all cases - had occurred as de novo events. The 2 sibs reported by Maljevic however, had inherited a missense variant from their unaffected mosaic parent.

Clinical descriptions for individuals from the 3 studies are provided in OMIM and also summarized in the suppl. table 1 by Sanchis-Juan et al. (https://www.biorxiv.org/content/biorxiv/early/2019/06/21/678219/DC2/embed/media-2.xlsx). Seizures, DD and ID (relevant to the current panel) are among the reported features. Functional studies have been performed for most of the variants and are summarized for each one in the OMIM entry for GABRG2 and the aforementioned table as well.

The following variants have been reported (NM_000807.2): c.1003A>C - p.Asn335His (dn) / c.875C>A - Thr292Lys (dn) / c.871C>G - p.Leu291Val (dn) / c.788T>C - p.Met263Thr (dn) / c.851T>C - p.Val284Ala (dn) / c.975C>A - p.Phe325Leu (inherited from mosaic parent) / c.839C>T - p.Pro280Leu (dn - Sanchis-Juan et al).

As commented by Jenkins and Escayg (2019 - PMID: 31032848 / both among the authors of the 1st report) as well as by Sanchis-Juan et al., both loss- and gain- of function effects explain the pathogenicity of the various mutations reported to date. [In gnomAD GABRA2 has a Z-score for missense variants of 3.13 as well as a pLI of 1].
------
GABRA2 is not associated with any phenotype in G2P.
This gene is not commonly included in gene panels for ID offered by diagnostic laboratories.
------
As a result, GABRA2 can be considered for inclusion in the epilepsy and ID panels probably as green (several relevant individuals, several reported variants with supporting functional studies for most, etc.).

[Consider inclusion in other possibly relevant gene panels eg. for ASD which was feature in some patients at relevant age and/or among those evaluated].; to: Heterozygous pathogenic GABRA2 variants cause Epileptic encephalopathy, early infantile, 78 (MIM 618557) [new OMIM entry].

At least 8 relevant individuals have been reported to date in the following studies:
- Orenstein et al. (2018 - PMID: 29422393) - 1 individual
- Butler et al. (2018 - PMID: 29961870) - 1 subject
- Maljevic et al. (2019 - PMID: 31032849 - 3 unrelated children as well as 2 affected sibs
- Sanchis-Juan et al. (2019 - bioRxiv / https://doi.org/10.1101/678219) - 1 further patient

In all affected individuals the variants were missense and - in almost all cases - had occurred as de novo events. The 2 sibs reported by Maljevic however, had inherited a missense variant from their unaffected mosaic parent.

Clinical descriptions for individuals from the 3 studies are provided in OMIM and also summarized, Maljevic - Table 1 (7 patients) and/or in the suppl. table 1 by Sanchis-Juan et al. (8 patients) (https://www.biorxiv.org/content/biorxiv/early/2019/06/21/678219/DC2/embed/media-2.xlsx). Seizures, DD and ID (relevant to the current panel) are among the reported features. Functional studies have been performed for most of the variants and are summarized for each one in the OMIM entry for GABRG2 and the aforementioned table as well.

The following variants have been reported (NM_000807.2): c.1003A>C - p.Asn335His (dn) / c.875C>A - Thr292Lys (dn) / c.871C>G - p.Leu291Val (dn) / c.788T>C - p.Met263Thr (dn) / c.851T>C - p.Val284Ala (dn) / c.975C>A - p.Phe325Leu (inherited from mosaic parent) / c.839C>T - p.Pro280Leu (dn - Sanchis-Juan et al).

As commented by Jenkins and Escayg (2019 - PMID: 31032848 / both among the authors of the 1st report) as well as by Sanchis-Juan et al., both loss- and gain- of function effects explain the pathogenicity of the various mutations reported to date. [In gnomAD GABRA2 has a Z-score for missense variants of 3.13 as well as a pLI of 1].
------
GABRA2 is not associated with any phenotype in G2P.
This gene is not commonly included in gene panels for ID offered by diagnostic laboratories.
------
As a result, GABRA2 can be considered for inclusion in the epilepsy and ID panels probably as green (several relevant individuals, several reported variants with supporting functional studies for most, etc.).

[Consider inclusion in other possibly relevant gene panels eg. for ASD which was feature in some patients at relevant age and/or among those evaluated].
Intellectual disability v2.1022 GABRA2 Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: GABRA2 was added
gene: GABRA2 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: GABRA2 was set to MONOALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal, imprinted status unknown
Publications for gene: GABRA2 were set to 29422393; 29961870; 31032849; 31032848; doi.org/10.1101/678219
Phenotypes for gene: GABRA2 were set to Epileptic encephalopathy, early infantile, 78 (MIM 618557)
Penetrance for gene: GABRA2 were set to unknown
Review for gene: GABRA2 was set to GREEN
Added comment: Heterozygous pathogenic GABRA2 variants cause Epileptic encephalopathy, early infantile, 78 (MIM 618557) [new OMIM entry].

At least 8 relevant individuals have been reported to date in the following studies:
- Orenstein et al. (2018 - PMID: 29422393) - 1 individual
- Butler et al. (2018 - PMID: 29961870) - 1 subject
- Maljevic et al. (2019 - PMID: 31032849 - 3 unrelated children as well as 2 affected sibs
- Sanchis-Juan et al. (2019 - bioRxiv / https://doi.org/10.1101/678219) - 1 further patient

In almost all affected individuals, the variants were missense and had occurred as de novo events. The 2 sibs reported by Maljevic however, had inherited a missense variant from their unaffected mosaic parent.

Clinical descriptions for individuals from the 3 studies are provided in OMIM and also summarized in the suppl. table 1 by Sanchis-Juan et al. (https://www.biorxiv.org/content/biorxiv/early/2019/06/21/678219/DC2/embed/media-2.xlsx?download=true). Seizures, DD and ID (relevant to the current panel) are among the reported features. Functional studies have been performed for most of the variants and are summarized for each one in the OMIM entry for GABRG2 and the aforementionned table as well.

The following variants have been reported (NM_000807.2): c.1003A>C - p.Asn335His (dn) / c.875C>A - Thr292Lys (dn) / c.871C>G - p.Leu291Val (dn) / c.788T>C - p.Met263Thr (dn) / c.851T>C - p.Val284Ala (dn) / c.975C>A - p.Phe325Leu (inherited from mosaic parent) / c.839C>T - p.Pro280Leu (dn - Sanchis-Juan et al).

As commented by Jenkins and Escayg (2019 - PMID: 31032848 / both among the authors of the 1st report) as well as by Sanchis-Juan et al., both loss- and gain- of function effects explain the pathogenicity of the various reported (all) missense mutations. [In gnomAD GABRA2 has a Z-score for missense variants of 3.13 as well as a pLI of 1].
------
GABRA2 is not associated with any phenotype in G2P.
This gene is not commonly included in gene panels for ID offered by diagnostic laboratories.
------
As a result, GABRA2 can be considered for inclusion in the epilepsy and ID panels probably as green (several relevant individuals, several reported variants with supporting functional studies for most, etc.).

[Consider inclusion in other possibly relevant gene panels eg. for ASD which was feature in some patients at relevant age and/or among those evaluated].
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v2.1022 PIGP Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: PIGP was added
gene: PIGP was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: PIGP was set to BIALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal
Publications for gene: PIGP were set to 28334793; 31139695
Phenotypes for gene: PIGP were set to Generalized hypotonia; Global developmental delay; Seizures; Intellectual disability; Feeding difficulties; Cortical visual impairment
Penetrance for gene: PIGP were set to Complete
Review for gene: PIGP was set to GREEN
gene: PIGP was marked as current diagnostic
Added comment: Johnstone et al. (2017 - PMID: 28334793) report on 2 sibs born to non-consanguineous parents of French-Irish ancestry. Both presented with seizures (onset at the age of 2 and 7 weeks respectively), hypotonia and profound DD. Other features included CVI and feeding difficulties. Extensive metabolic testing as well as prior genetic testing (ARX, STXBP1, MECP2, aCGH) in the family were non-diagnostic. WES suggested the presence of 2 PIGP variants with Sanger sequencing used for confirmation and segregation studies.

PIGP encodes a subunit of the enzyme that catalyzes the first step of glycophosphatidylinositol (GPI) anchor biosynthesis. Mutations in other genes whose proteins are in complex with PIGP (PIGA, PIGC, PIGQ, PIGY, DPM2) lead to similar phenotypes. The phenotype overall was also overlapping with the inherited GPI deficiencies (belonging to the broader group of CDGs).

PIGP has 2 isoforms, which differ by 24 amino acids due to utilization of alternative start codons [corresponding to NM_153681.2 (158 aa) and NM_153682.2 (134 aa)].

The variants identified affected both transcripts with the first SNV leading either to loss of the start codon (NM_153682.2:c.2T>C - p.Met1Thr) or to substitution of a methionine at position 25(NM_153681.2:c.74T>C;p.Met25Thr). The second variant led to frameshift in the last exon of both transcripts predicting a longer protein product (NM_153681.2:c.456delA / p.Glu153AsnfsTer34 or NM_153682.2:c.384delA / p.Glu129AsnfsTer34).

Overall extensive studies demonstrated decreased levels of PIGP mRNA in patient fibroblast, decreased amounts of mutant protein in transfected HEK293 cells. The decreased levels of GPI-APs further supported the effect of variants :

- mRNA levels in patient fibroblasts were reduced compared to controls. Conclusions could not be drawn from Western blot, since no antibodies could specifically detect PIGP. HEK293 cells transfected of mt or wt HA-tagged PIGP cDNA led to undetectable amounts for the first variant (both M1T/M25T) and a protein product of increased molecular weight for the frameshift one.
- Flow cytometry of patient granulocytes indicated reduced signal of CD16 (a GPI-anchored protein) and FLAER (binding directly to the GPI anchor).
- Reduced levels of GPI-APs were also observed in PIGP deficient HAP1 cells transfected with either wt, or mutant PIGP cDNA (of both isoforms for the M1T/M25T or isoform 2 for the frameshift mutation).

--------

Krenn et al. (2019 - PMID: 31139695) described a patient born to non-consanguineous Polish parents. Features were highly similar to those reported by Johnstone et al. and incl. intractable infantile seizures (onset at 7m), hypotonia, severe DD and feeding difficulties. Metabolic work-up failed to identify an alternative diagnosis. WES revealed homozygosity for the frameshift variant reported by Johnstone et al. Sanger sequencing confirmed the variant and carrier state in both parents. Identified ROH of less than 7 Mb in the WES data, suggested a founder mutation rather than unreported consanguinity. The variant is present 9 times in gnomAD (AF of 3.2e-5 / no homozygotes). Flow cytometry of patient granulocytes, revealed markedly reduced expression of GPI-APs (CD157, CD59, FLAER) compared to parents/controls.

ALP was normal in all aforementioned individuals (probably in line with PIGP being involved in the 1st step of the GPI anchor biosynthesis).

--------

A further individual with phenotype of EIEE-55;GPIBD-14 is reported in LOVD [Individual #00246132]. This individual, born to consanguineous parents, was tested by WES and found to be homozygous for a frameshift variant, also affecting the last exon in both transcripts (NM_153681.2:c.384delA (p.Glu129ArgfsTer7) / NM_153682.2:c.312delA (p.Glu105ArgfsTer7). This was probably in agreement with segregation studies according to the respective entry. The specific variant is reported as pathogenic [variant ID #0000500090].

--------

?Epileptic encephalopathy, early infantile, 55 (MIM 617599) is the corresponding phenotype in OMIM. There is no relevant G2P entry.
PIGP is included in gene panels for ID offered by some diagnostic laboratories (eg. GeneDx).

--------

As a result, PIGP can be considered for inclusion in the ID/epilepsy panels probably as green (3 individuals, role of the gene and similarity to other inherited GPI deficiencies, extensive supporting studies) or amber.

(Please consider inclusion in other possibly relevant panels eg. CDGs, etc).
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v2.1021 MED13 Konstantinos Varvagiannis changed review comment from: Snijders Blok et al. (2018 - PMID: 29740699) report on 13 individuals with MED13 mutations.

Features included DD with speech difficulties (both universal) and motor delay in some. ID was observed in at least 9/13 and in most cases was in the borderline/mild range (moderate ID reported for 1 individual). Other features were ASD (5/13), ADHD, eye/vision abnormalities and in few individuals obstipation or congenital heart anomalies. Some possibly overlapping facial characteristics were also noted.

MED13 and MED13L are mutually exclusive components of the CDK8 kinase module that regulates the activity of the Mediator complex. The Mediator transmits signals from various transcription factors to RNA polymerase II (Pol II). Reversible binding of the CDK8 kinase controls Mediator - Pol II interaction (prevents Pol II recruitment) and thus acts as a molecular switch in Pol II - mediated transcription. DD and ID are features of the MED13L- and CDK8- related disorders.

3 stopgain, 2 frameshift, 6 missense variants and 1 in-frame deletion were reported. In 11 cases, the variants had occurred as de novo events, while 1 individual had inherited a nonsense variant from a similarly affected mother (unknown inheritance in her case).

Effect of a stopgain variant was studied with similar (total) transcript levels between the affected patient and his parents/controls upon qPCR. Sanger sequencing of cDNA amplicons was suggestive of the presence of an aberrant transcript at ~70% levels relative to the normal transcript. Truncated protein was undetectable by Western Blot in mononuclear blood cells from affected subjects. Total MED13 protein levels were not clearly different when comparing an affected individual with his unaffected parent (?).

Missense variants and the inframe deletion clustered either in the N- or the C-terminal domain, with the N-terminal ones all (T326I, T326del, P327S, P327Q / NM_005121.2 - NP_005112.2) affecting positions of a known phosphodegron sequence, important for the protein's ubiquitination and degradation. Another previously studied variant (T326A) had been shown to prevent degradation. As a result, the variants affecting aa 326-327 might lead to altered (increased) levels of MED13.

The remaining missense variants affected the C-terminal portion (Q2060L, A2064V).

As a result the impact of the different subcategories of variants remains unclear/inconclusive.

MED13 is not associated with any phenotype in OMIM. This gene is part of the DD panel of G2P, associated with "MED13 - Neurodevelopment disorder" (dis. confidence : probable / mutation consequence : LoF / GDD, speech/language delay, ID, autistic behavior among the assigned phenotypes).

MED13 is included in gene panels for ID offered by some diagnostic laboratories (incl. Radboudumc).

ID is part of the phenotype of MED13-related disorder, however as the severity in most individuals - when present - was in the borderline/mild range (not relevant for the present panel) and/or the underlying effect of mutations remains unclear, amber rating can probably be considered for this gene.
Sources: Radboud University Medical Center, Nijmegen, Literature; to: Snijders Blok et al. (2018 - PMID: 29740699) report on 13 individuals with MED13 mutations.

Features included DD with speech difficulties (both universal) and motor delay in some. ID was observed in at least 9/13 and in most cases was in the borderline/mild range (moderate ID reported for 1 individual). Other features were ASD (5/13), ADHD, eye/vision abnormalities and in few individuals obstipation or congenital heart anomalies. Some possibly overlapping facial characteristics were also noted.

MED13 and MED13L are mutually exclusive components of the CDK8 kinase module that regulates the activity of the Mediator complex. The Mediator transmits signals from various transcription factors to RNA polymerase II (Pol II). Reversible binding of the CDK8 kinase controls Mediator - Pol II interaction (prevents Pol II recruitment) and thus acts as a molecular switch in Pol II - mediated transcription. DD and ID are features of the MED13L- and CDK8- related disorders.

3 stopgain, 2 frameshift, 6 missense variants and 1 in-frame deletion were reported. In 11 cases, the variants had occurred as de novo events, while 1 individual had inherited a nonsense variant from a similarly affected mother (unknown inheritance in her case).

Effect of a stopgain variant was studied with similar (total) transcript levels between the affected patient and his parents/controls upon qPCR. Sanger sequencing of cDNA amplicons was suggestive of the presence of an aberrant transcript at ~70% levels relative to the normal transcript. Truncated protein was undetectable by Western Blot in mononuclear blood cells from affected subjects. Total MED13 protein levels were not clearly different when comparing an affected individual with his unaffected parent (?).

Missense variants and the inframe deletion clustered either in the N- or the C-terminal domain, with the N-terminal ones all (T326I, T326del, P327S, P327Q / NM_005121.2 - NP_005112.2) affecting positions of a known phosphodegron sequence, important for the protein's ubiquitination and degradation. Another previously studied variant (T326A) had been shown to prevent degradation. As a result, the variants affecting aa 326-327 might lead to altered (increased) levels of MED13.

The remaining missense variants affected the C-terminal portion (Q2060L, A2064V).

As a result the impact of the different subcategories of variants remains unclear/inconclusive.

MED13 is not associated with any phenotype in OMIM. This gene is part of the DD panel of G2P, associated with "MED13 - Neurodevelopment disorder" (dis. confidence : probable / mutation consequence : LoF / GDD, speech/language delay, ID, autistic behavior among the assigned phenotypes).

MED13 is included in gene panels for ID offered by some diagnostic laboratories (incl. Radboudumc).

ID is part of the phenotype of MED13-related disorder. However as the severity in most individuals - when present - was in the borderline/mild range (not relevant for the present panel) and/or the underlying effect of mutations remains unclear, amber rating seems more appropriate.
Sources: Radboud University Medical Center, Nijmegen, Literature
Intellectual disability v2.1021 MED13 Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: MED13 was added
gene: MED13 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Radboud University Medical Center, Nijmegen,Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: MED13 was set to MONOALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal, imprinted status unknown
Publications for gene: MED13 were set to 29740699
Phenotypes for gene: MED13 were set to Delayed speech and language development; Motor delay; Intellectual disability; Autistic behavior; Attention deficit hyperactivity disorder; Abnormality of the eye; Constipation
Penetrance for gene: MED13 were set to unknown
Review for gene: MED13 was set to AMBER
gene: MED13 was marked as current diagnostic
Added comment: Snijders Blok et al. (2018 - PMID: 29740699) report on 13 individuals with MED13 mutations.

Features included DD with speech difficulties (both universal) and motor delay in some. ID was observed in at least 9/13 and in most cases was in the borderline/mild range (moderate ID reported for 1 individual). Other features were ASD (5/13), ADHD, eye/vision abnormalities and in few individuals obstipation or congenital heart anomalies. Some possibly overlapping facial characteristics were also noted.

MED13 and MED13L are mutually exclusive components of the CDK8 kinase module that regulates the activity of the Mediator complex. The Mediator transmits signals from various transcription factors to RNA polymerase II (Pol II). Reversible binding of the CDK8 kinase controls Mediator - Pol II interaction (prevents Pol II recruitment) and thus acts as a molecular switch in Pol II - mediated transcription. DD and ID are features of the MED13L- and CDK8- related disorders.

3 stopgain, 2 frameshift, 6 missense variants and 1 in-frame deletion were reported. In 11 cases, the variants had occurred as de novo events, while 1 individual had inherited a nonsense variant from a similarly affected mother (unknown inheritance in her case).

Effect of a stopgain variant was studied with similar (total) transcript levels between the affected patient and his parents/controls upon qPCR. Sanger sequencing of cDNA amplicons was suggestive of the presence of an aberrant transcript at ~70% levels relative to the normal transcript. Truncated protein was undetectable by Western Blot in mononuclear blood cells from affected subjects. Total MED13 protein levels were not clearly different when comparing an affected individual with his unaffected parent (?).

Missense variants and the inframe deletion clustered either in the N- or the C-terminal domain, with the N-terminal ones all (T326I, T326del, P327S, P327Q / NM_005121.2 - NP_005112.2) affecting positions of a known phosphodegron sequence, important for the protein's ubiquitination and degradation. Another previously studied variant (T326A) had been shown to prevent degradation. As a result, the variants affecting aa 326-327 might lead to altered (increased) levels of MED13.

The remaining missense variants affected the C-terminal portion (Q2060L, A2064V).

As a result the impact of the different subcategories of variants remains unclear/inconclusive.

MED13 is not associated with any phenotype in OMIM. This gene is part of the DD panel of G2P, associated with "MED13 - Neurodevelopment disorder" (dis. confidence : probable / mutation consequence : LoF / GDD, speech/language delay, ID, autistic behavior among the assigned phenotypes).

MED13 is included in gene panels for ID offered by some diagnostic laboratories (incl. Radboudumc).

ID is part of the phenotype of MED13-related disorder, however as the severity in most individuals - when present - was in the borderline/mild range (not relevant for the present panel) and/or the underlying effect of mutations remains unclear, amber rating can probably be considered for this gene.
Sources: Radboud University Medical Center, Nijmegen, Literature
Intellectual disability v2.1015 HNRNPR Konstantinos Varvagiannis changed review comment from: Duijkers et al. (2019 - PMID: 31079900) report on the phenotype of 4 individuals with de novo HNRNPR variants and provide additional information on a previously published case (Helbig et al, 2016 - PMID: 26795593). All 5 were unrelated.

The phenotype consisted of DD (5/5 - moderate to severe in 4 for which this has been commented on), postnatal microcephaly, seizures, brachydactyly, with additional (cardiac, urogenital, etc) anomalies observed in few. Some partially overlapping facial features were also noted.

3 truncating variants as well as a missense one, all localizing within the last exon of the gene (NM_001102398.2 used as ref. although this exon is shared by all transcripts).

HNRNPR encodes heterogeneous nuclear ribonucleoprotein R, which is part of the spliceosome C. The latter functions in the nucleus to process and transport mRNA. Apart from splicing hnRNPs are also involved in other levels of gene regulation (PMID: 27215579). Some hnRNPs have been found in the cytoplasm in stress granules, aggregations of protein, RNAs and stalled initiation complexes that are formed as stress response upon oxidative insult and dissipate upon cessation of this insult.

Western blot in LCLs from affected individuals demonstrated the presence of the truncated protein as well as the full-length and short isoform (as expected by the variant localization).
As the C-terminal part has features of a "prion-like domain" (PrLD), critical for the formation of stress granules in the case of hnRNP-related disorders, comparison of fibroblasts from affected and healthy individuals revealed abnormal persistence of these granules in affected individuals following a recovery period, despite similar formation either at basal levels or under conditions of stress.

In line with a role of hnRNPs in splicing and gene regulation, RNA-Sequencing in fibroblasts from 2 affected individuals revealed abnormal splicing of some genes (eg. HOXA5, HOXB3, LHX9) and significant dysregulation of genes important for the development (upregulation of FOXG1, TBX1, several members of the HOX family and downregulation of LHX9, IRX3, etc) possibly contributing to the patient features.

Helbig et al. provide details on animal studies incl.expression in neural tissues (cerebrum and cerebellum), higher levels of expression early in the development (of both R1/R2 isoforms), etc (extensive discussion in the supplement with several articles cited).

HNRNPR is not associated with any phenotype in OMIM/G2P.

As a result this gene can be considered for inclusion as amber (developmental outcome not commented on sufficiently despite moderate/severe DD in most).
Sources: Literature; to: Duijkers et al. (2019 - PMID: 31079900) report on the phenotype of 4 individuals with de novo HNRNPR variants and provide additional information on a previously published case (Helbig et al, 2016 - PMID: 26795593). All 5 were unrelated.

The phenotype consisted of DD (5/5 - moderate to severe in 4 for which this has been commented on), postnatal microcephaly, seizures, brachydactyly, with additional (cardiac, urogenital, etc) anomalies observed in few. Some partially overlapping facial features were also noted.

3 truncating variants as well as a missense one, all localizing within the last exon of the gene (NM_001102398.2 used as ref. although this exon is shared by all transcripts).

HNRNPR encodes heterogeneous nuclear ribonucleoprotein R, which is part of the spliceosome C. The latter functions in the nucleus to process and transport mRNA. Apart from splicing hnRNPs are also involved in other levels of gene regulation (PMID: 27215579). Some hnRNPs have been found in the cytoplasm in stress granules, aggregations of protein, RNAs and stalled initiation complexes that are formed as stress response upon oxidative insult and dissipate upon cessation of this insult.

Western blot in LCLs from affected individuals demonstrated the presence of the truncated protein as well as the full-length and short isoform (as expected by the variant localization).
As the C-terminal part has features of a "prion-like domain" (PrLD), critical for the formation of stress granules in the case of hnRNP-related disorders, comparison of fibroblasts from affected and healthy individuals revealed abnormal persistence of these granules in affected individuals following a recovery period, despite similar formation either at basal levels or under conditions of stress.

In line with a role of hnRNPs in splicing and gene regulation, RNA-Sequencing in fibroblasts from 2 affected individuals revealed abnormal splicing of some genes (eg. HOXA5, HOXB3, LHX9) and significant dysregulation of genes important for the development (upregulation of FOXG1, TBX1, several members of the HOX family and downregulation of LHX9, IRX3, etc) possibly contributing to the patient features.

Helbig et al. provide details on animal studies incl.expression in neural tissues (cerebrum and cerebellum), higher levels of expression early in the development (of both R1/R2 isoforms), etc (extensive discussion in the supplement with several articles cited).

HNRNPR is not associated with any phenotype in OMIM/G2P.

As a result this gene can be considered for inclusion as amber (developmental outcome not commented on sufficiently despite moderate/severe DD in most) or green.
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v2.1015 HNRNPR Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: HNRNPR was added
gene: HNRNPR was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: HNRNPR was set to MONOALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal, imprinted status unknown
Publications for gene: HNRNPR were set to 31079900; 26795593
Phenotypes for gene: HNRNPR were set to Global developmental delay; Intellectual disability; Seizures; Postnatal microcephaly; Short digit
Penetrance for gene: HNRNPR were set to unknown
Review for gene: HNRNPR was set to GREEN
Added comment: Duijkers et al. (2019 - PMID: 31079900) report on the phenotype of 4 individuals with de novo HNRNPR variants and provide additional information on a previously published case (Helbig et al, 2016 - PMID: 26795593). All 5 were unrelated.

The phenotype consisted of DD (5/5 - moderate to severe in 4 for which this has been commented on), postnatal microcephaly, seizures, brachydactyly, with additional (cardiac, urogenital, etc) anomalies observed in few. Some partially overlapping facial features were also noted.

3 truncating variants as well as a missense one, all localizing within the last exon of the gene (NM_001102398.2 used as ref. although this exon is shared by all transcripts).

HNRNPR encodes heterogeneous nuclear ribonucleoprotein R, which is part of the spliceosome C. The latter functions in the nucleus to process and transport mRNA. Apart from splicing hnRNPs are also involved in other levels of gene regulation (PMID: 27215579). Some hnRNPs have been found in the cytoplasm in stress granules, aggregations of protein, RNAs and stalled initiation complexes that are formed as stress response upon oxidative insult and dissipate upon cessation of this insult.

Western blot in LCLs from affected individuals demonstrated the presence of the truncated protein as well as the full-length and short isoform (as expected by the variant localization).
As the C-terminal part has features of a "prion-like domain" (PrLD), critical for the formation of stress granules in the case of hnRNP-related disorders, comparison of fibroblasts from affected and healthy individuals revealed abnormal persistence of these granules in affected individuals following a recovery period, despite similar formation either at basal levels or under conditions of stress.

In line with a role of hnRNPs in splicing and gene regulation, RNA-Sequencing in fibroblasts from 2 affected individuals revealed abnormal splicing of some genes (eg. HOXA5, HOXB3, LHX9) and significant dysregulation of genes important for the development (upregulation of FOXG1, TBX1, several members of the HOX family and downregulation of LHX9, IRX3, etc) possibly contributing to the patient features.

Helbig et al. provide details on animal studies incl.expression in neural tissues (cerebrum and cerebellum), higher levels of expression early in the development (of both R1/R2 isoforms), etc (extensive discussion in the supplement with several articles cited).

HNRNPR is not associated with any phenotype in OMIM/G2P.

As a result this gene can be considered for inclusion as amber (developmental outcome not commented on sufficiently despite moderate/severe DD in most).
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v2.1015 DDX6 Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: DDX6 was added
gene: DDX6 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: DDX6 was set to MONOALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal, imprinted status unknown
Publications for gene: DDX6 were set to 31422817
Phenotypes for gene: DDX6 were set to Generalized hypotonia; Global developmental delay; Intellectual disability; Unsteady gait; Abnormality of the cardiovascular system; Abnormality of the genitourinary system; Abnormality of limbs
Penetrance for gene: DDX6 were set to unknown
Review for gene: DDX6 was set to GREEN
Added comment: Balak et al. (2019 - PMID: 31422817) report on 5 individuals with de novo likely pathogenic DDX6 variants.

Clinical details are provided for 4. Frequent features included hypotonia, DD, ID (4/4), gait instability, cardiac, genitourinary as well anomalies of the extremities.

DDX6 belongs to the DEAD box family of RNA helicases. This helicase is an essential component of processing bodies (P-bodies / PBs), which are mebrane-less organelles involved in storage of mRNAs and proteins related to mRNA decay thus playing an important role in translational repression/post-transcriptional regulation (PMID: 29381060).

All 5 variants had occurred as de novo events, clustered in exon 11 (NM_004397.5) and affected residues 372-373 of the QxxR motif (c.1115A>G or p.His372Arg / c.1118G>A or p.Arg373Gln) or 390-391 of the V motif (c.1168T>C or p.Cys390Arg / c.1171A>C or p.Thr391Pro / c.1172C>T or p.Thr391Ile). The specific motifs (and RecA-2 domain) are involved in RNA binding, helicase activity and protein-partner binding.

Fibroblasts from 2 individuals were studied. Patient cells contained fewer PBs compared to cells from relatives/control-subjects, despite similar amounts of DDX6 protein upon immunobloting. Additional studies suggested that DDX6 variants caused impaired binding of other DDX6 protein partners involved in PB formation / translation repression (eg. LSM14A, 4E-T, etc) thus resulting in defective PB assembly.

Transcriptome analysis in fibroblasts from one affected individual revealed (significant) differential expression of >1000 genes, enriched for genes related to protein translation, ribosome and RNA processing.

As the authors discuss, given the residual PB assembly, haploinsufficiency is favored over a dominant-negative effect which would result in complete suppression of PBs (as sugested by a previous study of a dominant-negative DDX6 variant - PMID cited: 19297524). [In gnomAD, DDX6 has a Z-score for missense variants of 3.78 and a pLI of 1].

DDX6 is not associated with any phenotype in OMIM.
In G2P it is associated with ID (disease confidence : probable / mutations : all missense/in frame).

As a result, this gene can be considered for inclusion in the ID panel as green (sufficient cases, relevant phenotype, functional studies) or amber.
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v2.996 POLR2A Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: POLR2A was added
gene: POLR2A was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: POLR2A was set to MONOALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal, imprinted status unknown
Publications for gene: POLR2A were set to 31353023
Phenotypes for gene: POLR2A were set to Generalized hypotonia; Global developmental delay; Feeding difficulties
Penetrance for gene: POLR2A were set to unknown
Review for gene: POLR2A was set to GREEN
gene: POLR2A was marked as current diagnostic
Added comment: Haijes et al. (2019 - PMID: 31353023) report on 16 individuals with heterozygous de novo POLR2A variants.

DD in all domains was observed in all individuals, ranging from mild to severe (in 8/16 moderate or more severe). The developmental scores were stable over time (as for eventual catch-up/decline) supporting relevance to the current panel.

POLR2A encodes RPB1, the largest subunit of RNA polymerase II (pol II). Pol II is responsible for the transcription of all protein coding genes as well as several long/short non-coding RNA genes.

Missense, in-frame deletions as well as truncating mutations were observed. POLR2A has a pLI of 1 and a Z-score for missense variants of 7.13 (one of the highest ones). The reported variants did not cluster in specific domains of the protein although many were in regions relatively depleted in benign variants in gnomAD (stretches of desert Z-scores). Measures such as the CADD scores did not discriminate between deleterious ones and those in gnomAD.

Different layers of structural analyses, functional analyses (impaired growth in S. cerevisiae in genetic background lacking transcr. factors Dst1 / Sub1 - suggesting reduced transcriptional fidelity / reduced HeLa cell viability) or phenotypic overlap were used to classify variants in probably disease causing (11), possibly disease causing (4 - only based on phenotypic overlap) or of unknown effect (1 variant - due to unavailable/incomplete phenotype).

Some variants were predicted to act by haploinsufficiency while others (missense ones) by a dominant-negative mechanism, the latter being more likely to result in severe phenotypes.

Mutations in genes encoding subunits of pol III (responsible for tRNA synthesis) are associated with leukodystrophy phenotypes with some limited overlap with POLR2A (delayed myelination/white-matter loss/tooth misalignment). Mutations in genes encoding other subunits of pol II (other than RPB1 encoded by POLR2A) have not been implicated in disease though.

POLR2A is not associated with any phenotype in OMIM/G2P. This gene is included in panels for ID offered by some diagnostic laboratories [eg. Utrecht UMC - affiliation of many co-authors of this study or GeneDx].

As a result, this gene can be considered for inclusion in the ID panel probably as green, or amber.
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v2.996 AFF3 Konstantinos Varvagiannis changed review comment from: Voisin et al. (2019 - https://doi.org/10.1101/693937) report on 10 individuals with de novo missense AFF3 variants affecting a 9-amino-acid sequence (degron) important for the protein's degradation and summarize the phenotype of an additional individual previously described by Steichen-Gersdorf et al. (2008 - PMID: 18616733) with a 500 kb affecting only AFF3 (LAF4) and removing also this sequence.

The phenotype of missense variants consisted of kidney anomalies, mesomelic dysplasia, seizures, hypertrichosis, intellectual disability and pulmonary problems and was overlapping with that of the deletion. [10 of 11 subjects exhibited severe developmental epileptic encephalopathy].

9 probands harbored missense variants affecting the codon 258 while one individual had a variant affecting codon 260 [c.772G>T or p.Ala258Ser (x2), c.772G>A or p.Ala258Thr (x6), c.773C>T or p.Ala258Val (x1) and c.779T>G or p.(Val260Gly) (x1) - NM_001025108.1 / NP_001020279.1]. The deletion removed exons 4-13.

AFF1-4 are ALF transcription factor paralogs, components of the transcriptional super elongation complex regulating expression of genes involved in neurogenesis and development.

Using HEK293T cells expressing FLAG-tagged AFF3 (and AFF4) wt or mutants, accumulation of mutated forms was shown upon immunoblot.

Aff3+/- and/or -/- mice exhibit skeletal defects. These were more pronounced in homozygous mice which demonstrated also some elements in favor of kidney dysfunction and/or metabolic deregulation and possible neurological dysfunction (signs of impaired hearing and diminished grip strength). Homozygous mice had CNS anomalies (enlarged lateral ventricles and decreased corpus callosum size) similar to some affected individuals, although these were not observed in another Aff3-/- model. Knock-in mice modeling the microdeletion and the Ala258Thr variant displayed lower mesomelic limb deformities and early lethality respectively [cited PMIDs : 21677750, 25660031, knock-in model was part of the present study].

Accumulation of the protein in zebrafish (by overexpression of the human wt AFF3 mRNA), led to morphological defects.

Reanalysis of transcriptome data from previously generated HEK293T cell lines knocked down for AFF2, AFF3 and AFF4 by shRNAs (study) suggested that these transcription factors are not redundant.

Finally, CHOPS syndrome (#616368) due to mutations of AFF4 also leading to increased protein stability presents a partially overlapping phenotype (incl. cognitive impairment) to that of AFF3.
----
In G2P, AFF3 is associated with Skeletal dysplasia with severe neurological disease (disease confidence : probable / ID and seizures among the assigned phenotypes). There is no associated phenotype in OMIM.
Some diagnostic laboratories include AFF3 in their ID panel (eg. among the many co-authors' affiliations GeneDx and Victorian Clinical Genetics - which was already listed as source for AFF3 in the current panel).
----
As a result this gene can be considered for upgrade to green (relevant phenotype and severity, sufficient cases, evidence for accumulation similar to AFF4, animal models, etc) or amber (pending publication of the article).; to: Voisin et al. (2019 - https://doi.org/10.1101/693937) report on 10 individuals with de novo missense AFF3 variants affecting a 9-amino-acid sequence (degron) important for the protein's degradation and summarize the phenotype of an additional individual previously described by Steichen-Gersdorf et al. (2008 - PMID: 18616733) with a 500 kb affecting only AFF3 (LAF4) and removing also this sequence.

The phenotype of missense variants consisted of kidney anomalies, mesomelic dysplasia, seizures, hypertrichosis, intellectual disability and pulmonary problems and was overlapping with that of the deletion. [10 of 11 subjects exhibited severe developmental epileptic encephalopathy].

9 probands harbored missense variants affecting the codon 258 while one individual had a variant affecting codon 260 [c.772G>T or p.Ala258Ser (x2), c.772G>A or p.Ala258Thr (x6), c.773C>T or p.Ala258Val (x1) and c.779T>G or p.(Val260Gly) (x1) - NM_001025108.1 / NP_001020279.1]. The deletion removed exons 4-13.

AFF1-4 are ALF transcription factor paralogs, components of the transcriptional super elongation complex regulating expression of genes involved in neurogenesis and development.

Using HEK293T cells expressing FLAG-tagged AFF3 (and AFF4) wt or mutants, accumulation of mutated forms was shown upon immunoblot.

Aff3+/- and/or -/- mice exhibit skeletal defects. These were more pronounced in homozygous mice which demonstrated also some elements in favor of kidney dysfunction and/or metabolic deregulation and possible neurological dysfunction (signs of impaired hearing and diminished grip strength). Homozygous mice had CNS anomalies (enlarged lateral ventricles and decreased corpus callosum size) similar to some affected individuals, although these were not observed in another Aff3-/- model. Knock-in mice modeling the microdeletion and the Ala258Thr variant displayed lower mesomelic limb deformities and early lethality respectively [cited PMIDs : 21677750, 25660031, knock-in model was part of the present study].

Accumulation of the protein in zebrafish (by overexpression of the human wt AFF3 mRNA), led to morphological defects.

Reanalysis of transcriptome data from previously generated HEK293T cell lines knocked down for AFF2, AFF3 and AFF4 by shRNAs (study) suggested that these transcription factors are not redundant.

Finally, CHOPS syndrome (#616368) due to mutations of AFF4 also leading to increased protein stability presents a partially overlapping phenotype (incl. cognitive impairment) to that of AFF3.
----
Shimizu et al. (8/2019 - PMID: 31388108) describe an additional individual with de novo AFF3 missense variant. The phenotype overlaps with that summarized by Voisin et al. incl. mesomelic dysplasia with additional skeletal anomalies, bilateral kidney hypoplasia and severe DD at the age of 2.5 years. Seizures and pulmonary problems were not observed. Although a different RefSeq is used the variant is among those also reported by Voisin et al. [NM_002285.2:c.697G>A (p.Ala233Thr) corresponding to NM_001025108.1:c.772G>A (p.Ala258Thr)].
----
In G2P, AFF3 is associated with Skeletal dysplasia with severe neurological disease (disease confidence : probable / ID and seizures among the assigned phenotypes). There is no associated phenotype in OMIM.
Some diagnostic laboratories include AFF3 in their ID panel (eg. among the many co-authors' affiliations GeneDx and Victorian Clinical Genetics - which was already listed as source for AFF3 in the current panel).
----
As a result this gene can be considered for upgrade to green (relevant phenotype and severity, sufficient cases, evidence for accumulation similar to AFF4, animal models, etc) or amber (pending publication of the article).

[Review modified to add additional reference/case report]
Intellectual disability v2.951 POU3F3 Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: POU3F3 was added
gene: POU3F3 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature,Radboud University Medical Center, Nijmegen
Mode of inheritance for gene: POU3F3 was set to MONOALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal, imprinted status unknown
Publications for gene: POU3F3 were set to https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ajhg.2019.06.007; 24550763
Phenotypes for gene: POU3F3 were set to Generalized hypotonia; Delayed speech and language development; Global developmental delay; Intellectual disability; Autistic behavior
Penetrance for gene: POU3F3 were set to unknown
Review for gene: POU3F3 was set to GREEN
gene: POU3F3 was marked as current diagnostic
Added comment: Snijders Blok et al. (2019, DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ajhg.2019.06.007) report on 19 individuals with heterozygous POU3F3 variants.

Features included hypotonia in some, DD/ID (19/19) with impairment in speech and language skills, and autism-like symptoms with formal ASD diagnosis in 7(/19). Epilepsy was reported for 2 individuals. Overlapping facial features were noted among these individuals.

POU3F3 encodes a member of the class III POU family of transcription factors expressed in the central nervous system (Sumiyama et al. 1996, PMID: 8703082 cited in OMIM) and as the authors comment holds a role in regulation of key processes, eg. cortical neuronal migration, upper-layer specification and production and neurogenesis (PMIDs cited: 11859196, 12130536, 22892427, 17141158).

In almost all subjects (17/19) the variant had occurred as a de novo event, while one individual had inherited the variant from a similarly affected parent.

In total 12 nonsense/frameshift variants, 5 missense ones as well as 1 in-frame deletion were identified following (mostly) trio exome sequencing. All variants were absent from gnomAD, with in silico predictions in favour of pathogenicity.

The few missense variants and the in-frame deletion were found either in the POU-specific (NM_006236.2:c.1085G>T / p.Arg362Leu found in 2 subjects) or the POU-homeobox domain (where 2 variants affected the same residue, namely p.Arg407Gly/Leu, the other variant was p.Asn456Ser).

POU3F3 is an intronless gene and as a result truncating variants are not subject to NMD. The gene appears to be intolerant to LoF variants (pLI of 0.89 in gnomAD).

Western blot analysis of YFP-tagged POU3F3 variants (in HEK293 cell lysates) showed that the YFP-fusion proteins were expressed and had the expected molecular weights.

For several truncating variants tested as well as the in-frame deletion, aberrant subcellular localization pattern was demonstrated although this was not the case for 4 missense variants.

In vitro studies were carried out and suggested that POU3F3, as is known to be the case for POU3F2, is able to activate an intronic binding site in FOXP2. Using a luciferase assay, transcriptional activation was severely impaired for truncating variants tested, significantly lower for many missense ones with the exception of those affecting Arg407 in which case luciferase expression was either similar to wt (for Arg407Gly) or even increased in the case of Arg407Leu.

As the authors comment, both loss- and gain- of function mechanisms may underly pathogenicity of variants.

The ability of mutant proteins to form dimers either with wt or themselves was tested. Dimerization capacity was intact for most missense variants but was lost/decreased for truncating variants. The in-frame deletion resulted in impaired dimerization with wt, although homo-dimerization was found to be normal.
---
Dheedene et al. (2014 - PMID: 24550763) had previously reported on a boy with ID. aCGH had demonstrated a de novo 360-kb deletion of 2q12.1 spanning only POU3F3 and MRPS9 the latter encoding a mitochondrial ribosomal protein (which would be most compatible with a - yet undescribed - recessive inheritance pattern / disorder).
---
POU3F3 is not associated with any phenotype in OMIM/G2P.
The gene is included in gene panels for ID offered by some diagnostic laboratories (incl. Radboudumc, among the principal authors of the study).
---
As a result POU3F3 seems to fulfill criteria for inclusion in the current panel probably as green [DD/ID was a universal feature - severity of ID was relevant in 5/10 individuals for whom details were available, functional evidence provided] or amber.
Sources: Literature, Radboud University Medical Center, Nijmegen
Intellectual disability v2.938 CTBP1 Konstantinos Varvagiannis changed review comment from: 12 individuals with a recurrent missense variant in CTBP1 have been reported, all summarized in the last article:
- Beck et al. 2016 (PMID: 27094857) : 4 individuals
- Sommerville et al. 2017 (PMID: 28955726) : 1 subject
- Beck et al. 2019 (PMID: 31041561) : 7 further individuals

Features included hypotonia, DD/ID, ataxia and tooth enamel defects. The degree of ID - when present - appeared to be highly variable based at least on the first two reports (3 individuals with severe ID, 1 with borderline-normal intellectual functioning, 1 did not exhibit ID) where this feature was further commented on.

A recurrent missense variant was found in all 12 affected individuals [NM_001328.2:c.1024C>T - p.(Arg342Trp) or NM_001012614.1:c.991C>T - p.(Arg331Trp)]. De novo occurrence this SNV was shown for (almost) all individuals, although in one case maternal sequencing reads were compatible with low-level somatic mosaicism (4/75 reads) not detected by Sanger sequencing. The mother of this individual was phenotypically normal. The variant is absent from gnomAD. Several in silico predictions (SIFT, PolyPhen2, MutationTaster, etc) suggest a deleterious effect.

Given recurrence of this specific variant, and presence of LoF ones in healthy individuals (pLI of 0.98 though in gnomAD) Beck et al. suggested a dominant negative or a gain-of-function effect rather than a loss of function mechanism.

Exclusion of alternative causes: was mainly discussed for the subject reported by Sommerville et al., due to the primary suspicion of a mitochondrial disorder (sequencing and research for mtDNA rearrangements, additional analysis of nuclear genes for mitochondrial disorders).

Expression: CTBP1 encodes C-terminal binding protein 1, with expression among others in brain and cerebellum (https://gtexportal.org/home/gene/CTBP1).

Role and Functional studies:
- The major nuclear isoform of CTBP1 (corresponding to NM_001328.2) and of its paralog CTBP2 function as transcriptional regulators (corepressors). The PLDLS(Pro-Leu-Asp-Leu-Ser)-binding cleft domain where this variant lies, acts as a high-affinity protein-binding interface to recruit DNA-binding repressors and chromatin modifying enzymes (PMID: 17967884).
- In a human glioblastoma cell line interaction of various cofactors with (Flag-tagged) CTBP1 was studied by immunoprecitipation with the Flag antibody and subsequent proteomic (LC-MS) analysis. This demonstrated reduced interaction in the case of R342W (compared to wt) with Zn-finger transcription factors, histone deacetylases, histone methyltransferases, histone H3-K4 demethylase etc. Western blot analyses also revealed reduced interaction of the R342W with several CTBP cofactors.
- RNA-seq analysis in glioblastoma cell line revealed similar overall transcriptional profiles between wt and R342W though multiple RNA species showed significant differences (eg. genes involved in the biological processes of mitotic nuclear division, DNA repair, transcription and regulation of transcription among those that were most upregulated and genes involved in brain development among the most downregulated).
- Patient fibroblasts under conditions of glucose deprivation exhibited strikingly more cell death compared to control fibroblasts. Study of mRNA levels of pro-apoptotic genes by q-RT-PCR revealed that Noxa expression under glucose deprivation vs under normal glucose was 8 to 10-fold enhanced for control fibroblasts, but more than 30-fold enhanced in the case patient fibroblasts. Western blot analyses were also in line with this.
- Mitochondrial dysfunction (probably secondary) with evidence of decreased complex I (and complex IV) activities in skeletal muscle was the case for 2 individuals among multiple patients who had muscle biopsies.

Animal models:
- Beck et al. discuss previously published mouse models where Ctbp1/2 both play overlapping transcriptional roles during development. Homozygous deletion of Ctbp2 is embryonically lethal (>E10.5). Homozygous deletion of Ctbp1 results in viable mice with reduced size and lifespan (Cited: Hildebrand et al. 2002 - PMID: 12101226)
- As commented on by Sommerville et al., Ctbp1 knockout in mouse embryonic fibroblasts resulted in elongated mitochondria, abnormal mitochondrial cristae, diminished ATP and O2 consumption and mitochondrial membrane potential.

----
CTBP1 is associated with Hypotonia, ataxia, developmental delay, and tooth enamel defect syndrome (617915) in OMIM. It is not associated with any phenotype in G2P.
Some diagnostic laboratories (eg. GeneDx participating in the first study and others) include this gene in panels for intellectual disability.
----

As a result, CTBP1 can be added in the current panel probably as green.; to: 12 individuals with a recurrent missense variant in CTBP1 have been reported, all summarized in the last article:
- Beck et al. 2016 (PMID: 27094857) : 4 individuals
- Sommerville et al. 2017 (PMID: 28955726) : 1 subject
- Beck et al. 2019 (PMID: 31041561) : 7 further individuals

Features included hypotonia, DD/ID, ataxia and tooth enamel defects. The degree of ID - when present - appeared to be highly variable based at least on the first two reports (3 individuals with severe ID, 1 with borderline-normal intellectual functioning, 1 did not exhibit ID) where this feature was further commented on.

A recurrent missense variant was found in all 12 affected individuals [NM_001328.2:c.1024C>T - p.(Arg342Trp) or NM_001012614.1:c.991C>T - p.(Arg331Trp)]. De novo occurrence this SNV was shown for (almost) all individuals, although in one case maternal sequencing reads were compatible with low-level somatic mosaicism (4/75 reads) not detected by Sanger sequencing. The mother of this individual was phenotypically normal. The variant is absent from gnomAD. Several in silico predictions (SIFT, PolyPhen2, MutationTaster, etc) suggest a deleterious effect.

Given recurrence of this specific variant, and presence of LoF ones in healthy individuals (pLI of 0.98 though in gnomAD) Beck et al. suggested a dominant negative or a gain-of-function effect rather than a loss of function mechanism.

Exclusion of alternative causes: was mainly discussed for the subject reported by Sommerville et al., due to the primary suspicion of a mitochondrial disorder (sequencing and research for mtDNA rearrangements, additional analysis of nuclear genes for mitochondrial disorders).

Expression: CTBP1 encodes C-terminal binding protein 1, with expression among others in brain and cerebellum (https://gtexportal.org/home/gene/CTBP1).

Role and Functional studies:
- The major nuclear isoform of CTBP1 (corresponding to NM_001328.2) and of its paralog CTBP2 function as transcriptional regulators (corepressors). The PLDLS(Pro-Leu-Asp-Leu-Ser)-binding cleft domain where this variant lies, acts as a high-affinity protein-binding interface to recruit DNA-binding repressors and chromatin modifying enzymes (PMID: 17967884).
- In a human glioblastoma cell line interaction of various cofactors with (Flag-tagged) CTBP1 was studied by immunoprecitipation with the Flag antibody and subsequent proteomic (LC-MS) analysis. This demonstrated reduced interaction in the case of R342W (compared to wt) with Zn-finger transcription factors, histone deacetylases, histone methyltransferases, histone H3-K4 demethylase etc. Western blot analyses also revealed reduced interaction of the R342W with several CTBP cofactors.
- RNA-seq analysis in glioblastoma cell line revealed similar overall transcriptional profiles between wt and R342W though multiple RNA species showed significant differences (eg. genes involved in the biological processes of mitotic nuclear division, DNA repair, transcription and regulation of transcription among those that were most upregulated and genes involved in brain development among the most downregulated).
- Patient fibroblasts under conditions of glucose deprivation exhibited strikingly more cell death compared to control fibroblasts. Study of mRNA levels of pro-apoptotic genes by q-RT-PCR revealed that Noxa expression under glucose deprivation vs under normal glucose was 8 to 10-fold enhanced for control fibroblasts, but more than 30-fold enhanced in the case patient fibroblasts. Western blot analyses were also in line with this.
- Mitochondrial dysfunction (probably secondary) with evidence of decreased complex I (and complex IV) activities in skeletal muscle was the case for 2 individuals among multiple patients who had muscle biopsies.

Animal models:
- Beck et al. discuss previously published mouse models where Ctbp1/2 both play overlapping transcriptional roles during development. Homozygous deletion of Ctbp2 is embryonically lethal (>E10.5). Homozygous deletion of Ctbp1 results in viable mice with reduced size and lifespan (Cited: Hildebrand et al. 2002 - PMID: 12101226)
- As commented on by Sommerville et al., Ctbp1 knockout in mouse embryonic fibroblasts resulted in elongated mitochondria, abnormal mitochondrial cristae, diminished ATP and O2 consumption and mitochondrial membrane potential (Cited: Kim and Youn 2009 - PMID: 19136938).

----
CTBP1 is associated with Hypotonia, ataxia, developmental delay, and tooth enamel defect syndrome (617915) in OMIM. It is not associated with any phenotype in G2P.
Some diagnostic laboratories (eg. GeneDx participating in the first study and others) include this gene in panels for intellectual disability.
----

As a result, CTBP1 can be added in the current panel probably as green.
Intellectual disability v2.938 CTBP1 Konstantinos Varvagiannis changed review comment from: 12 individuals with a recurrent missense variant in CTBP1 have been reported, all summarized in the last article:
- Beck et al. 2016 (PMID: 27094857) : 4 individuals
- Sommerville et al. 2017 (PMID: 28955726) : 1 subject
- Beck et al. 2019 (PMID: 31041561) : 7 further individuals

Features included hypotonia, DD/ID, ataxia and tooth enamel defects. The degree of ID - when present - appeared to be highly variable based at least on the first two reports (3 individuals with severe ID, 1 with borderline-normal intellectual functioning, 1 did not exhibit ID) where this feature was further commented on.

A recurrent missense variant was found in all 12 affected individuals [NM_001328.2:c.1024C>T - p.(Arg342Trp) or NM_001012614.1:c.991C>T - p.(Arg331Trp)]. De novo occurrence this SNV was shown for (almost) all individuals, although in one case maternal sequencing reads were compatible with low-level somatic mosaicism (4/75 reads) not detected by Sanger sequencing. The mother of this individual was phenotypically normal. The variant is absent from gnomAD. Several in silico predictions (SIFT, PolyPhen2, MutationTaster, etc) suggest a deleterious effect.

Given recurrence of this specific variant, and presence of LoF ones in healthy individuals (pLI of 0.98 though in gnomAD) Beck et al. suggested a dominant negative or a gain-of-function effect rather than a loss of function mechanism.

Exclusion of alternative causes: was mainly discussed for the subject reported by Sommerville et al., due to the primary suspicion of a mitochondrial disorder (sequencing and research for mtDNA rearrangements, additional analysis of nuclear genes for mitochondrial disorders).

Expression: CTBP1 encodes C-terminal binding protein 1, with expression among others in brain and cerebellum (https://gtexportal.org/home/gene/CTBP1 ).

Role and Functional studies:
- The major nuclear isoform of CTBP1 (corresponding to NM_001328.2) and of its paralog CTBP2 function as transcriptional regulators (corepressors). The PLDLS(Pro-Leu-Asp-Leu-Ser)-binding cleft domain where this variant lies, acts as a high-affinity protein-binding interface to recruit DNA-binding repressors and chromatin modifying enzymes (PMID: 17967884).
- In a human glioblastoma cell line interaction of various cofactors with (Flag-tagged) CTBP1 was studied by immunoprecitipation with the Flag antibody and subsequent proteomic (LC-MS) analysis. This demonstrated reduced interaction in the case of R342W (compared to wt) with Zn-finger transcription factors, histone deacetylases, histone methyltransferases, histone H3-K4 demethylase etc. Western blot analyses also revealed reduced interaction of the R342W with several CTBP cofactors.
- RNA-seq analysis in glioblastoma cell line revealed similar overall transcriptional profiles between wt and R342W though multiple RNA species showed significant differences (eg. genes involved in the biological processes of mitotic nuclear division, DNA repair, transcription and regulation of transcription among those that were most upregulated and genes involved in brain development among the most downregulated).
- Patient fibroblasts under conditions of glucose deprivation exhibited strikingly more cell death compared to control fibroblasts. Study of mRNA levels of pro-apoptotic genes by q-RT-PCR revealed that Noxa expression under glucose deprivation vs under normal glucose was 8 to 10-fold enhanced for control fibroblasts, but more than 30-fold enhanced in the case patient fibroblasts. Western blot analyses were also in line with this.
- Mitochondrial dysfunction (probably secondary) with evidence of decreased complex I (and complex IV) activities in skeletal muscle was the case for 2 individuals among multiple patients who had muscle biopsies.

Animal models:
- Beck et al. discuss previously published mouse models where Ctbp1/2 both play overlapping transcriptional roles during development. Homozygous deletion of Ctbp2 is embryonically lethal (>E10.5). Homozygous deletion of Ctbp1 results in viable mice with reduced size and lifespan (Cited: Hildebrand et al. 2002 - PMID: 12101226)
- As commented on by Sommerville et al., Ctbp1 knockout in mouse embryonic fibroblasts resulted in elongated mitochondria, abnormal mitochondrial cristae, diminished ATP and O2 consumption and mitochondrial membrane potential.

----
CTBP1 is associated with Hypotonia, ataxia, developmental delay, and tooth enamel defect syndrome (617915) in OMIM. It is not associated with any phenotype in G2P.
Some diagnostic laboratories (eg. GeneDx participating in the first study and others) include this gene in panels for intellectual disability.
----

As a result, CTBP1 can be added in the current panel probably as green.
Sources: Literature; to: 12 individuals with a recurrent missense variant in CTBP1 have been reported, all summarized in the last article:
- Beck et al. 2016 (PMID: 27094857) : 4 individuals
- Sommerville et al. 2017 (PMID: 28955726) : 1 subject
- Beck et al. 2019 (PMID: 31041561) : 7 further individuals

Features included hypotonia, DD/ID, ataxia and tooth enamel defects. The degree of ID - when present - appeared to be highly variable based at least on the first two reports (3 individuals with severe ID, 1 with borderline-normal intellectual functioning, 1 did not exhibit ID) where this feature was further commented on.

A recurrent missense variant was found in all 12 affected individuals [NM_001328.2:c.1024C>T - p.(Arg342Trp) or NM_001012614.1:c.991C>T - p.(Arg331Trp)]. De novo occurrence this SNV was shown for (almost) all individuals, although in one case maternal sequencing reads were compatible with low-level somatic mosaicism (4/75 reads) not detected by Sanger sequencing. The mother of this individual was phenotypically normal. The variant is absent from gnomAD. Several in silico predictions (SIFT, PolyPhen2, MutationTaster, etc) suggest a deleterious effect.

Given recurrence of this specific variant, and presence of LoF ones in healthy individuals (pLI of 0.98 though in gnomAD) Beck et al. suggested a dominant negative or a gain-of-function effect rather than a loss of function mechanism.

Exclusion of alternative causes: was mainly discussed for the subject reported by Sommerville et al., due to the primary suspicion of a mitochondrial disorder (sequencing and research for mtDNA rearrangements, additional analysis of nuclear genes for mitochondrial disorders).

Expression: CTBP1 encodes C-terminal binding protein 1, with expression among others in brain and cerebellum (https://gtexportal.org/home/gene/CTBP1).

Role and Functional studies:
- The major nuclear isoform of CTBP1 (corresponding to NM_001328.2) and of its paralog CTBP2 function as transcriptional regulators (corepressors). The PLDLS(Pro-Leu-Asp-Leu-Ser)-binding cleft domain where this variant lies, acts as a high-affinity protein-binding interface to recruit DNA-binding repressors and chromatin modifying enzymes (PMID: 17967884).
- In a human glioblastoma cell line interaction of various cofactors with (Flag-tagged) CTBP1 was studied by immunoprecitipation with the Flag antibody and subsequent proteomic (LC-MS) analysis. This demonstrated reduced interaction in the case of R342W (compared to wt) with Zn-finger transcription factors, histone deacetylases, histone methyltransferases, histone H3-K4 demethylase etc. Western blot analyses also revealed reduced interaction of the R342W with several CTBP cofactors.
- RNA-seq analysis in glioblastoma cell line revealed similar overall transcriptional profiles between wt and R342W though multiple RNA species showed significant differences (eg. genes involved in the biological processes of mitotic nuclear division, DNA repair, transcription and regulation of transcription among those that were most upregulated and genes involved in brain development among the most downregulated).
- Patient fibroblasts under conditions of glucose deprivation exhibited strikingly more cell death compared to control fibroblasts. Study of mRNA levels of pro-apoptotic genes by q-RT-PCR revealed that Noxa expression under glucose deprivation vs under normal glucose was 8 to 10-fold enhanced for control fibroblasts, but more than 30-fold enhanced in the case patient fibroblasts. Western blot analyses were also in line with this.
- Mitochondrial dysfunction (probably secondary) with evidence of decreased complex I (and complex IV) activities in skeletal muscle was the case for 2 individuals among multiple patients who had muscle biopsies.

Animal models:
- Beck et al. discuss previously published mouse models where Ctbp1/2 both play overlapping transcriptional roles during development. Homozygous deletion of Ctbp2 is embryonically lethal (>E10.5). Homozygous deletion of Ctbp1 results in viable mice with reduced size and lifespan (Cited: Hildebrand et al. 2002 - PMID: 12101226)
- As commented on by Sommerville et al., Ctbp1 knockout in mouse embryonic fibroblasts resulted in elongated mitochondria, abnormal mitochondrial cristae, diminished ATP and O2 consumption and mitochondrial membrane potential.

----
CTBP1 is associated with Hypotonia, ataxia, developmental delay, and tooth enamel defect syndrome (617915) in OMIM. It is not associated with any phenotype in G2P.
Some diagnostic laboratories (eg. GeneDx participating in the first study and others) include this gene in panels for intellectual disability.
----

As a result, CTBP1 can be added in the current panel probably as green.
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v2.938 CTBP1 Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: CTBP1 was added
gene: CTBP1 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: CTBP1 was set to MONOALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal, imprinted status unknown
Publications for gene: CTBP1 were set to 27094857; 28955726; 31041561
Phenotypes for gene: CTBP1 were set to Generalized hypotonia; Global developmental delay; Intellectual disability; Ataxia; Abnormality of dental enamel
Penetrance for gene: CTBP1 were set to unknown
Mode of pathogenicity for gene: CTBP1 was set to Loss-of-function variants (as defined in pop up message) DO NOT cause this phenotype - please provide details in the comments
Review for gene: CTBP1 was set to GREEN
gene: CTBP1 was marked as current diagnostic
Added comment: 12 individuals with a recurrent missense variant in CTBP1 have been reported, all summarized in the last article:
- Beck et al. 2016 (PMID: 27094857) : 4 individuals
- Sommerville et al. 2017 (PMID: 28955726) : 1 subject
- Beck et al. 2019 (PMID: 31041561) : 7 further individuals

Features included hypotonia, DD/ID, ataxia and tooth enamel defects. The degree of ID - when present - appeared to be highly variable based at least on the first two reports (3 individuals with severe ID, 1 with borderline-normal intellectual functioning, 1 did not exhibit ID) where this feature was further commented on.

A recurrent missense variant was found in all 12 affected individuals [NM_001328.2:c.1024C>T - p.(Arg342Trp) or NM_001012614.1:c.991C>T - p.(Arg331Trp)]. De novo occurrence this SNV was shown for (almost) all individuals, although in one case maternal sequencing reads were compatible with low-level somatic mosaicism (4/75 reads) not detected by Sanger sequencing. The mother of this individual was phenotypically normal. The variant is absent from gnomAD. Several in silico predictions (SIFT, PolyPhen2, MutationTaster, etc) suggest a deleterious effect.

Given recurrence of this specific variant, and presence of LoF ones in healthy individuals (pLI of 0.98 though in gnomAD) Beck et al. suggested a dominant negative or a gain-of-function effect rather than a loss of function mechanism.

Exclusion of alternative causes: was mainly discussed for the subject reported by Sommerville et al., due to the primary suspicion of a mitochondrial disorder (sequencing and research for mtDNA rearrangements, additional analysis of nuclear genes for mitochondrial disorders).

Expression: CTBP1 encodes C-terminal binding protein 1, with expression among others in brain and cerebellum (https://gtexportal.org/home/gene/CTBP1 ).

Role and Functional studies:
- The major nuclear isoform of CTBP1 (corresponding to NM_001328.2) and of its paralog CTBP2 function as transcriptional regulators (corepressors). The PLDLS(Pro-Leu-Asp-Leu-Ser)-binding cleft domain where this variant lies, acts as a high-affinity protein-binding interface to recruit DNA-binding repressors and chromatin modifying enzymes (PMID: 17967884).
- In a human glioblastoma cell line interaction of various cofactors with (Flag-tagged) CTBP1 was studied by immunoprecitipation with the Flag antibody and subsequent proteomic (LC-MS) analysis. This demonstrated reduced interaction in the case of R342W (compared to wt) with Zn-finger transcription factors, histone deacetylases, histone methyltransferases, histone H3-K4 demethylase etc. Western blot analyses also revealed reduced interaction of the R342W with several CTBP cofactors.
- RNA-seq analysis in glioblastoma cell line revealed similar overall transcriptional profiles between wt and R342W though multiple RNA species showed significant differences (eg. genes involved in the biological processes of mitotic nuclear division, DNA repair, transcription and regulation of transcription among those that were most upregulated and genes involved in brain development among the most downregulated).
- Patient fibroblasts under conditions of glucose deprivation exhibited strikingly more cell death compared to control fibroblasts. Study of mRNA levels of pro-apoptotic genes by q-RT-PCR revealed that Noxa expression under glucose deprivation vs under normal glucose was 8 to 10-fold enhanced for control fibroblasts, but more than 30-fold enhanced in the case patient fibroblasts. Western blot analyses were also in line with this.
- Mitochondrial dysfunction (probably secondary) with evidence of decreased complex I (and complex IV) activities in skeletal muscle was the case for 2 individuals among multiple patients who had muscle biopsies.

Animal models:
- Beck et al. discuss previously published mouse models where Ctbp1/2 both play overlapping transcriptional roles during development. Homozygous deletion of Ctbp2 is embryonically lethal (>E10.5). Homozygous deletion of Ctbp1 results in viable mice with reduced size and lifespan (Cited: Hildebrand et al. 2002 - PMID: 12101226)
- As commented on by Sommerville et al., Ctbp1 knockout in mouse embryonic fibroblasts resulted in elongated mitochondria, abnormal mitochondrial cristae, diminished ATP and O2 consumption and mitochondrial membrane potential.

----
CTBP1 is associated with Hypotonia, ataxia, developmental delay, and tooth enamel defect syndrome (617915) in OMIM. It is not associated with any phenotype in G2P.
Some diagnostic laboratories (eg. GeneDx participating in the first study and others) include this gene in panels for intellectual disability.
----

As a result, CTBP1 can be added in the current panel probably as green.
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v2.857 MED12L Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: MED12L was added
gene: MED12L was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: MED12L was set to MONOALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal, imprinted status unknown
Publications for gene: MED12L were set to 31155615
Phenotypes for gene: MED12L were set to Motor delay; Delayed speech and language development; Intellectual disability; Behavioral abnormality; Abnormality of the abdomen; Seizures; Abnormality of the corpus callosum
Penetrance for gene: MED12L were set to unknown
Review for gene: MED12L was set to AMBER
Added comment: Nizon et al. (2019 - PMID: 31155615) report on 7 unrelated individuals with nucleotide or copy-number variants in MED12L.

Features included motor delay (4/7), speech impairment (7/7) with ID of variable degrees (7/7 - mild to severe). Variable behavioral abnormalities (ASD in 4/7, aggressive behavior, ADHD, etc), functional GI anomalies, corpus callosum abnormalities and seizures were among other features noted in some/few. There was no recognizable facial phenotype.

Nucleotide variants included 1 stopgain, 1 frameshift and 2 splice site variants. 3 CNVs were reported (two 3q25.1 microduplications of 460- and 147-kb respectively and one microdeletion of 291-kb) although all spanned also other genes.

De novo occurrence was shown for 2 CNVs and 2 SNVs, as parental samples were unavailable for 3 of the subjects.

Contribution of other genetic (eg. an inherited 22q11.2 microduplication, VUS in other genes) or environmental factors could not be ruled out for few individuals.

Among the arguments provided:

MED12L encodes a subunit of the kinase module of the mediator complex, a complex required for transcription by RNA polymerase II. Mutations in other subunits of the kinase module (eg. MED12, MED13L, etc) have been implicated in intellectual disability.

The protein is localized in the nucleus. The gene is mainly expressed in the brain.

The functional effect of 2 CNVs was evaluated using the recovery of RNA synthesis assay, an assay reflecting global transcriptional activity. Fibrobast studies from one individual with microdeletion and one further subject with microduplication demonstrated decreased RNA synthesis compared to controls. Decreased RNA synthesis was also observed in cell lines from individuals with mutations in other genes for subunits of the mediator complex (eg. MED12 or MED13L) or from individuals with Cockayne syndrome.

Therefore haploinsufficiency is suggested to underly the transcriptional defect. (MED12L also appears to be intolerant to LoF variation with a pLI score of 1).

Some features appear to be common among the disorders caused by pathogenic variants in MED12L or other subunits of the kinase module (MED12, MED13, MED13L) eg. ID, abnormal behaviour or autistic features.

Animal models are not discussed / (probably not) available (MGI for Med12l : http://www.informatics.jax.org/marker/MGI:2139916).

MED12L is not associated with any phenotype in OMIM or G2P. The gene is not commonly included in gene panels for ID offered by diagnostic laboratories.

As a result, this gene can be considered for inclusion in the ID panel, probably as amber (4 variants affecting only MED12L, segregation studies performed for 2, degree of ID reported mild on 2 occasions) pending further reports.
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v2.800 ZNF142 Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: ZNF142 was added
gene: ZNF142 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: ZNF142 was set to BIALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal
Publications for gene: ZNF142 were set to 31036918
Phenotypes for gene: ZNF142 were set to Global developmental delay; Intellectual disability; Seizures; Tremor; Dystonia
Penetrance for gene: ZNF142 were set to unknown
Review for gene: ZNF142 was set to GREEN
Added comment: Khan et al. (2019 - PMID: 31036918) describe the phenotype of 7 females from 4 families, harboring biallelic likely pathogenic ZNF142 variants.

Overlapping features included cognitive impairment (ID in 6/7 from 3 families, borderline intellectual functioning was reported one occasion), speech impairement and motor impairment (7/7), and variably penetrant seizures (5/7), tremor (4/7) and dystonia (3/7). Most individuals (5/7) had experienced at least one episode of seizures (tonic-clonic) though seizures were recurrent in 3 sibs.

Other disorders with ID (eg. Angelman syndrome, Rett syndrome, chromosomal disorders) or movement disorders as a feature were previously ruled out for many subjects.

6 individuals were homozygous or compound heterozygous for LoF (stopgain or frameshift) variants. One individual harbored 2 missense SNVs in the compound heterozygous state. Variants reported include (NM_001105537.2): c. 817_818delAA (p.Lys273Glufs*32), c.1292delG (p.Cys431Leufs*11), c.3175C>T (p.Arg1059*), c.4183delC (p.Leu1395*), c.3698G>T (p.Cys1233Phe), c.4498C>T (p.Arg1500Trp) with the LoF variants predicted to result in NMD. Expression or functional studies were not carried out.

ZNF142 encodes a C2H2 domain-containing transcription factor. Mutations in other zinc finger proteins (ZNF/zfp) have been reported in several neurodevelopmental disorders impacting the CNS (eg. ZBTB20 and ZBTB11 heterozygous and biallelic mutations, respectively) and/or presenting with movement disorders among their manifestations (eg. YY1).

As the authors comment, homozygous ablation of the orthologous (Zfp142) locus in mice results in behavioral and neurological phenotypes [MGI ref.ID: J:211773 cited - http://www.informatics.jax.org/marker/reference/J:211773 (though Zfp142 or its locus do not seem to appear in the list)].

ZNF142 is not - at least commonly - included in gene panels for ID offered by diagnostic laboratories. It is not associated with any phenotype in OMIM, nor in G2P.

As a result, this gene can be considered for inclusion in the current panel as probably as green (individuals from 3 families, appropriate degree of ID for the current panel) or amber (if further evidence would be required).
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v2.800 SNAP25 Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: SNAP25 was added
gene: SNAP25 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature,Radboud University Medical Center, Nijmegen
Mode of inheritance for gene: SNAP25 was set to MONOALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal, imprinted status unknown
Publications for gene: SNAP25 were set to 29491473; 28135719; 29100083; 25381298; 25003006
Phenotypes for gene: SNAP25 were set to ?Myasthenic syndrome, congenital 18, 616330
Penetrance for gene: SNAP25 were set to Complete
Review for gene: SNAP25 was set to GREEN
gene: SNAP25 was marked as current diagnostic
Added comment: Probably 9 individuals with heterozygous SNAP25 pathogenic variants have been reported to date, most summarized in the first reference (NM_130811.2 used as reference for all variants below):
- Fukuda et al. (2018 - PMID: 29491473) 2 sibs (~11 and 2.5 y.o) with seizures and cerebellar ataxia but not ID. harboring c.176G>C (p.Arg59Pro) variant which was inherited from a mosaic unaffected parent.
- DDD study (2017 - PMID: 28135719) [also in Heyne et al. 2018 - PMID: 29942082] 3 inividuals (11 m - 7 y of age) with DD and seizures due to c.118A>G (p.Lys40Glu), c.127G>C (p.Gly43Arg) and c.520C>T (p.Gln174*) de novo variants.
- Hamdan et al. (2017 - PMID: 29100083) a 23 y.o. male with epilepsy and ID and c.496G>T (p.Asp166Tyr) de novo variant
- Shen et al. (2014 - PMID: 25381298) a 11 y.o. female with epilepsy and ID and c.200T>A (p.Ile67Asn) de novo variant
- Rohena et al. (2013 - PMID: 25003006) a 15 y.o. female with epilepsy and ID and c.142G>T (p.Val48Phe) de novo variant
- Decipher patient 292139, a male with c.212T>C (p.Met71Thr) with hypotonia, DD, poor coordination and additional features (epilepsy not reported).

Seizures of variable type [absence seizures, generalized tonic-clonic (most), focal clonic, myoclonic, etc] have been reported for most (8/9) of these individuals. DD was a feature in several subjects and intellectual outcome has been specifically commented on for 5 (2 without and 3 with ID - moderate/severe/not further specified).

SNAP25 encodes a (t-)SNARE protein essential for synaptic vesicle exocytosis. Mutations in genes for other components of the SNARE complex (eg. STXBP1) have been associated with epilepsy and/or ID.

SNAP25a and SNAP25b are the 2 major protein isoforms [corresponding transcripts: ENST00000304886 (NM_003081) and ENST00000254976 (NM_130811) respectively]. These isoforms are produced by utilization of alternative exons 5 (5a or 5b) though the amino-acid sequence encoded by these exons appears to be identical except for 9 residues. Most variants reported to date affect both transcripts (and protein isoforms) although 2 were specific for ENST00000254976 (or SNAP25b isoform - Fukuda et al. and Shen et al.).

Mouse Snap25 has also 2 isoforms. Both are predominantly localized in embryonic and adult mouse brains. Snap25a is produced before Snap25b though the latter becomes the major isoform early postnatally (by the second week) [PMIDs cited: 7878010, 21526988].

Based on the phenotype of some individuals with chromosome 20 deletions in Decipher (note: only 3 deletions spanning SNAP25 however appear currently, the phenotype is not specified and 2 of them are >4.5Mb) or the pLI of 0.96 in gnomAD, haploinsufficiency has been proposed as a likely mechanism. A dominant-negative effect was however suggested for the Ile67Asn studied by Shen et al. Functional studies have not been performed for other variants.

Animal models discussed:
- Snap25 null drosophila show complete loss of synaptic transmission upon electroretinogram recordings (PMID cited: 12242238).
- In mice, elimination of Snap25b expression resulted in developmental defects, seizures and impaired short-term synaptic plasticity (PMID cited: 19043548).
- Mice with a 4.6 Mb deletion encompassing 12 genes (incl. Snap25) display seizure predisposition (PMID cited: 23064108).
- Heterozygosity for Ile67Thr in (blind-drunk mutant) mice results in impaired vesicle trafficking, impaired sensorimotor gating and ataxia (PMID cited:17283335).

In OMIM, heterozygous SNAP25 mutations are associated with ?Myasthenic syndrome, congenital, 18 (with intellectual disability and ataxia). SNAP25 is part of the DD panel, associated with "Epilepsy and intellectual disability" (disease confidence: probable).

This gene is included in gene panels for ID offered by some diagnostic laboratories (incl. Radboudumc). SNAP25 is among the genes discussed by Erger et al. (PMID: 30914295) as associated with ID in OMIM/HPO/G2P/SysID but not included in the current panel.

As a result SNAP25 can be considered for inclusion in the ID panel probably as green (3 individuals with ID, role of SNARES in "synaptopathies", supportive animal models) or amber (if functional studies for individual variants would be required).
Sources: Literature, Radboud University Medical Center, Nijmegen
Intellectual disability v2.798 P4HTM Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: P4HTM was added
gene: P4HTM was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: P4HTM was set to BIALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal
Publications for gene: P4HTM were set to 30940925; 25078763
Phenotypes for gene: P4HTM were set to Central hypotonia; Muscular hypotonia; Global developmental delay; Intellectual disability; Seizures; Abnormality of the eye; Hypoventilation; Sleep apnea; Dysautonomia
Penetrance for gene: P4HTM were set to Complete
Review for gene: P4HTM was set to GREEN
Added comment: Rahikkala et al. (2019 - PMID: 30940925) report on 13 individuals from 5 families with biallelic pathogenic P4HTM variants. 6 of these individuals from a large consanguineous family from Finland were previously reported by the same group, although studies at the time had revealed a 11.5 Mb region of homozygosity with 3 genes within this interval considered to be candidate for the patients' phenotype (P4HTM, TKT, USP4) [Kaasinen et al. - PMID: 25078763].

Common features included Hypotonia (13/13), DD and ID (the latter present in 12/13 individuals with appropriate age for evaluation) and Eye Abnormalities, reason why the acronym HIDEA is suggested for the disorder. Epilepsy was observed in 10 individuals (10/13). Hypoventilation, sleep apnea and dysautonomia were additional features reported.

Muscle biopsies from 4 individuals had variable findings suggestive of disruption of normal mitochondrial function.

Finnish patients were homozygous for a SNV - possibly a founder variant in this population - predicted to lead to a missense change in the canonical transcript (NM_177938.2:c.1073G>A) but causing an in-frame loss of the complete exon 6 of another transcript (NM_177939.2).

The latter transcript (encoding a 502 aa protein) is the prevalent one in fibroblasts/myoblasts instead of the canonical one (563 aa). It is not known whether the canonical transcript is the prevalent in brain tissue although northern blot analysis in a previous study suggested presence of a 2.3 kb mRNA in brain instead of a 1.8 kb observed in other tissues, a finding which may be suggestive of expression of the canonical transcript. [Reviewer's note: In gnomAD based on the pext values from the GTEx, the noncanonical transcript appears to be prevalent in brain regions - https://gnomad.broadinstitute.org/gene/ENSG00000178467]

All variants reported in affected both transcripts. All 5 variants have been submitted to LOVD ( https://databases.lovd.nl/shared/variants/P4HTM?search_var_status=%3D%22Marked%22%7C%3D%22Public%22 - the first author appearing as the submitter).

Overexpression of wt and 3 mutants (His161Pro, Gln352*and Exon6del) in insect cells followed by analysis with SDS-PAGE and western blot revealed severly reduced/abolished fraction of soluble protein for the 3 studied variants suggesting improper protein folding.

Knockout of the gene in mice leads to retinal defects and/or visual impairment in line with eye abnormalites (nystagmus, strabismus, achromic retinal fundi or cortical blindness) being a prominent feature in affected individuals. Mouse studies suggest that this gene is also important for renal function, although kidney problems were not reported in any affected individual.

Overall loss-of-function is suggested to be the underlying mechanism.

P4HTM is not associated with any phenotype in OMIM, nor in G2P. This gene is not (at least commonly) included in gene panels for ID offered by diagnostic laboratories.

As a result P4HTM can be considered for inclusion in the ID and epilepsy panels probably as green (several affected individuals, degree of ID relevant) or amber.
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v2.787 CDK8 Konstantinos Varvagiannis commented on gene: CDK8: Calpena et al. (2019 - PMID: 30905399 - DDD study among the co-authors) report on 12 unrelated individuals with pathogenic CDK8 missense variants.

Common features included hypotonia and DD (universal feature). Older children displayed variable degrees of ID (2 mild, 5 moderate, 2 moderate-severe). Other features included feeding difficulties, behavioral disorders, CHD, epilepsy (2 individuals), impaired vision and hearing problems in few.

CDK8 (alternatively CDK19) serves a one of the four subunits of a kinase module that reversibly binds to the mediator complex to regulate its activity (in turn, regulation of transcription). Mutations in other genes coding for the 3 other subunits of the kinase module (eg. MED12 or MED13L) lead to syndromic neurodevelopmental disorders.

8 missense CDK8 variants were reported in total. Ser62Leu (NM_001260.2:c.185C>T) was recurrent, observed in 5 subjects. The variants had occurred as de novo events in all cases (10 individuals) where parental samples were available.

All variants clustered in the kinase domain (residues 21-335 - of 464 total) around the ATP binding pocket. A thermal stability assay did not reveal gross protein instability in the presence or absence of ATP while the ability to bind ATP was retained for most/all variants. Study of STAT1 phosphorylation was suggestive of attenuated kinase activity for all variants, though to a lesser degree for 2 of them. Given the type of variants (all missense) and the pLI of 0.38 haploinsufficiency appears to be unlikely. A dominant-negative mechanism is favoured.

CDK8 is not associated with any phenotype in G2P.

As a result, CDK8 can be considered for upgrade to green or amber (if the degree of ID is relevant for the current panel).
Intellectual disability v2.779 KDM5B Ivone Leong Added comment: Comment on publications: PMID: 30217758 reports on 2 de novo splice variants found in 3 patients from 2 unrelated families who have ID and ASD. One variant was found in a boy with mild ID and autism traits. In vitro studies found that this variant reduced KDM5B mRNA production. The sister of this affected patient did not have carry this splice variant but she also presented with mild ID and epilepsy. The authors suggest that a variant in another gene may be linked to these phenotypes and that KDM5B haploinsufficiency cannot explain the ID/ASD phenotype.

The other variant was found in a pair of monozygotic twins who both presented with global developmental delay, poor language and ASD. In vitro studies of this second variant showed that it causes the production of an abnormal transcript which is degraded by nonsense-mediated decay.
Intellectual disability v2.654 CUX1 Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: CUX1 was added
gene: CUX1 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature,Radboud University Medical Center, Nijmegen
Mode of inheritance for gene: CUX1 was set to MONOALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal, imprinted status unknown
Publications for gene: CUX1 were set to 30014507; 20510857; 25059644
Phenotypes for gene: CUX1 were set to Global developmental delay with or without impaired intellectual development, 618330
Penetrance for gene: CUX1 were set to unknown
Review for gene: CUX1 was set to GREEN
gene: CUX1 was marked as current diagnostic
Added comment: Heterozygous pathogenic variants in CUX1 cause Global developmental delay with or without impaired intellectual development (MIM 618330).

Platzer et al. (2018 - PMID: 30014507) report on 9 individuals from 7 families with heterozygous null-allele variants in CUX1.

All individuals displayed DD (speech delay 9/9 - motor delay 7/9 - hypotonia 3/7 for whom this information was available). Mild/moderate ID was a feature in 5/8. Catch up was observed in 3/8 individuals who - despite a history of previous significant DD - displayed a normal age-related intelligence. For 1/9 individual (Decipher 338131) information on eventual ID was unavailable. Overall the phenotype was compatible with non-syndromic DD with possible ID.

CUX1 encodes Cut homebox-1 transcription factor.

5 LoF variants (Gln21*, Gln800Argfs*19, Gln873*, Ala1067Cysfs*3, Leu1262Argfs*10) and 2 intragenic deletions (deletion of exons 9-24 in one subject and 3-24 in another) are reported.

In 6/9 individuals the variant (SNV/CNV) had occurred as a de novo event. Mosaic de novo intragenic deletion was reported for the subject from Decipher. In one family 2 sibs with mild ID had inherited a LoF variant from their affected mother with moderate ID (origin of the variant unknown in her case).

Leu1262Argfs*10 lies in the penultimate exon (NM_001202543.1 used as ref.) and is presumed to escape NMD.

Expression studies (or functional studies) are not performed for any of the variants.

As Gln800Argfs*19, found in one subject with mild ID in the present study, has been reported once in gnomAD, and given the presence of 12 individuals overall with LoF variants in the specific database, plausible explanations are discussed (among others : mild phenotype, incomplete penetrance, somatic mosaicism, exclusion of individuals with severe early-onset disorders in gnomAD, etc).

Given the reported variants, the probability of LoF intolerance (pLI:1.00), and the haploinsufficiency score (% HI) of 7.19, haploinsufficiency is thought to be the underlying mechanism. CUX1 however appears to be intolerant also to missense SNVs (z-score : 5.05).

Mouse models suggest a role for Cux1 in brain development and signaling. As the authors note, Cux1 (similar to its paralog, Cux2) is selectively expressed in layer II to IV cortical neurons. In Cux1-deficient mice, dendrites display a simpler morphology with decrease in dendritic length and number of branches (PMIDs cited: 20510857, 25059644). (MGI db for Cux1 - http://www.informatics.jax.org/marker/MGI:88568 : "Homozygotes for a targeted null mutation exhibit delayed lung development and neonatal mortality. Survivors show growth retardation and hair defects. Homozygotes for a partially deleted protein have curly hair, and females tend to lose their litters").

Finally, heterozygous mutations in CUX2, encoding cut-like homeobox-2 transcription factor, cause Epileptic encephalopathy, early infantile, 67 (MIM 618141 - in all cases reported to date due to a recurrent missense variant. Gene rated green in the current panel).
-------
CUX1 is not associated with any phenotype in G2P.
This gene is included in panels for ID offered by diagnostic laboratories (incl. Radboudumc).
-------
As a result, CUX1 can be considered for inclusion in the ID panel as green (or amber).
Sources: Literature, Radboud University Medical Center, Nijmegen
Intellectual disability v2.632 LSS Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: LSS was added
gene: LSS was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: LSS was set to BIALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal
Publications for gene: LSS were set to 30723320; 30401459
Phenotypes for gene: LSS were set to Alopecia; Abnormality of the skin; Hypotonia; Global developmental delay; Intellectual disability; Seizures; Abnormality of the genital system; Microcephaly
Penetrance for gene: LSS were set to Complete
Review for gene: LSS was set to GREEN
Added comment: DD and ID seem to be among the features observed in some individuals with biallelic LSS mutations, although the clinical presentation appears to be highly variable.

PMID: 30723320 [Besnrard et al, 2019] reports on 10 individuals from 6 unrelated families with biallelic LSS variants. One additional subject from a seventh family was found to harbor only a missense SNV (in the maternal allele) while the transcript corresponding to the other (/paternal) allele was less expressed upon RNA studies from patient fibroblasts. The allelic imbalance and the phenotypic overlap with the other individuals of the study were thought to be explained by an LSS defect.

The phenotype consisted of total alopecia (11/11) with additional dermatological features in most (9/11), hypotonia (7/11), DD with variable degrees of ID (11/11 both), epilepsy (8/11), microcephaly and genital anomalies in few. Cataracts were not noted in any individuals. The authors suggest that the phenotype corresponds to that observed in a neuroectodermal syndrome previously known as APMR (alopecia with mental retardation - other genes or loci earlier proposed).

Variants included: 7 missense SNVs, 1 nonsense, 1 frameshift, 2 splice variants (c.1109+2T>C / c.1194+5G>A - using NM_002340.5).

Using a minigene assay the latter variants were confirmhed (both) to affect splicing, at least to some important extent. However the splicing defect for one SNV (c.1194+5G>A - skipping of exon 12) was not confirmed upon RNA studies from blood samples of the respective individuals but an allelic balance in favor of the other allele instead (due to presumed utilisation of an alternative splice site, introduction of a premature stop codon and NMD).

Allelic imbalance is discussed for the individual with the single LSS variant but not shown.

Variants did not show clustering (also upon 3D modelling).

Lanosterol synthase converts (S)-2,3-oxidosqualene to lanosterol in the cholesterol biosynthesis pathway. Quantification of cholesterol and its precursors in affected individuals did not however reveal any important imbalance.

As most individuals harbored an allele with missense variant, and mice homozygous for an allele with absent LSS activity show variable lethality, residual LSS activity is suggested for the individuals studied.

Several other disorders affecting cholesterol biosynthesis present overlapping features eg. DD/ID in Lathosterolosis, Desmosterolosis, Smith-Lemli-Opitz syndrome (in this case also genital anomalies), etc or cutaneous anomalies in others.

A neurodevelopmental phenotype in animal models for LSS deficiency is not commented.
-----
Based on the discussion of the current article (and OMIM):

Earlier studies [PMIDs : 26200341, 29016354 - Zhao et al 2015 and Chen and Liu 2017 respectively] found biallelic missense in individuals with congenital cataracts. DD/ID were not commented/observed. The subject reported by Chen had baldness and genital defects. Shumiya cataract rats due to mutation in Lss gene recapitulate the specific human phenotype [PMID: 16440058 and OMIM]. Cataract was not a feature in any of the individuals of the present study. The corresponding entry for this phenotype in OMIM is Cataract 44 (#616509).

PMID: 30401459 [Romano et al, 2018] reported biallelic LSS mutations in 3 unrelated families with hypotrichosis. Intellectual disability was a feature in 2 sibs from 1 non-consanguineous family (among the three). ID was considered to be coincidental by the authors. The respective entry in OMIM is Hypotrichosis 14 (#618275).
-----
LSS is not included in the DD panel of G2P, nor in gene panels for ID offered by diagnostic laboratories.
-----
As a result this gene can be considered for inclusion in this panel as green (or amber).
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v2.621 NECAP1 Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: NECAP1 was added
gene: NECAP1 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: NECAP1 was set to BIALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal
Publications for gene: NECAP1 were set to 24399846; 30525121; 30626896
Phenotypes for gene: NECAP1 were set to ?Epileptic encephalopathy, early infantile 21, 615833
Penetrance for gene: NECAP1 were set to Complete
Review for gene: NECAP1 was set to GREEN
gene: NECAP1 was marked as current diagnostic
Added comment: Biallelic pathogenic variants in NECAP1 cause ?Epileptic encephalopathy, early infantile, 21 (MIM 615833).
----
PMID: 24399846 (Alazami et al. 2014) report on 6 individuals from an multigenerational family from Saudi Arabia with biallelic NECAP1 nonsense variant. The common phenotype consisted of hypotonia, profound global developmental delay preceding the onset of intractable seizures (fragmented multifocal clonic and tonic) in early infancy. Initial workup excluded metabolic causes.

4 of these individuals were born to first cousins once removed, while 2 additional affected subjects from the broader pedigree were born to seemingly unrelated parents from the same region. All affected individuals shared a single autozygous 4.78-Mb interval on chromosome 12p. Linkage analysis confirmed involvement of this locus (LOD score : 5.0447). Exome sequencing demonstrated homozygosity for a nonsense variant (NM_015509.3:c.142C>T - p.R48*). mRNA levels in lymphoblast cell lines from affected subjects were significantly reduced when compared to controls, probably due to NMD.

Necap1 was shown to be strongly expressed in the developing (E14.5) mouse brain and spinal cord, upon immunohistochemical analysis (part of the current study).

NECAP1 has been previously shown to have a functional role in Clathrin-mediated encocytocis (CME), a process which plays a critical role at the site of synapsis (in synaptic vesicle recycling).
----
PMID: 30525121 (Alsahli et al. 2018) report on a 41-month-old girl with hypotonia, profound global developmental delay and onset of seizures at the age of 3 months (generalized tonic and clonic / flexor hemispasms). Initial workup was negative for an eventual metabolic origin. The girl was born to consanguineous Saudi parents and was found to harbor the p.R48* variant in the homozygous state, following trio-WES.
----
PMID: 30626896 (Mizuguchi et al. 2019) report on a 16-month-old boy, born to consanguineous parents from Malaysia. This individual presented with axial hypotonia and profound developmental delay and developed generalized tonic-clonic and clonic seizures at the (corrected) age of 3 months. EEG demonstrated a burst suppression pattern and a clinical diagnosis of Ohtahara syndrome was retained. Metabolic workup was normal.

Homozygosity for a splice-site NECAP1 variant (NM_015509.3:c.301+1G>A) was demonstrated following exome sequencing. The variant was shown to result in inclusion of a 44-bp intron, resulting in frameshift and introduction of a premature termination codon (p.Gly101Aspfs*45). The level of abnormal transcript was 2-fold increased in lymphoblast cells trated with cycloheximide when compared to cells treated with DMSO, suggesting involvement of NMD.

As also in PMID: 30525121, the present study suggests similarities with the DNM1-related phenotype (Epileptic encephalopathy, early infantile, 31 - #616346 - DNM1 is rated green in the ID panel) as DNM1 also participates in vesicle recycling. The authors of the present study also note that mutations in CLTC (encoding clathrin heavy chain) cause hypotonia with DD/ID with or without epilepsy (Mental retardation, autosomal dominant 56 - #617854 - CLTC is rated green in the ID panel).
----
NECAP1 is not associated with any phenotype in G2P.
This gene is included in gene panels for ID offered by some diagnostic laboratories.
----
As a result this gene can be considered for inclusion in this panel as green (or amber).
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v2.597 PLEKHG2 Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: PLEKHG2 was added
gene: PLEKHG2 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: PLEKHG2 was set to MONOALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal, imprinted status unknown
Publications for gene: PLEKHG2 were set to 26539891; 26573021; 24001768
Phenotypes for gene: PLEKHG2 were set to Leukodystrophy and acquired microcephaly with or without dystonia, 616763
Penetrance for gene: PLEKHG2 were set to unknown
Review for gene: PLEKHG2 was set to AMBER
gene: PLEKHG2 was marked as current diagnostic
Added comment: Karaca et al. (2015 - PMID: 26539891) in a study of 128 - mostly consanguineous - families with neurogenetic disorders and brain malformations, identified an individual homozygous for a PLEKHG2 missense variant (NM_022835.2:c.1708G>A or p.Gly570Arg). This individual (BAB4830) had a similarly affected sib. Features included hypotonia, intellectual disability, microcephaly, cerebellar atrophy and nystagmus (description provided in supplement - Table S1). This variant has been submitted in ClinVar as likely pathogenic by the corresponding laboratory (SCV000537940.1).
-------
Edvardson et al. (2016 - PMID: 26573021) reported on 5 individuals from 2 unrelated consanguineous Palestinian families, harboring a missense variant in the homozygous state (NM_022835.2:c.610C>T or p.Arg204Trp - 1/5 was unavailable for testing).
Unaffected relatives here either heterozygous for this variant or homozygous for the reference allele.

Common features included hypotonia (5/5), DD/ID (5/5), postnatal microcephaly (5/5), dystonia (3/5), nystagmus (2/5) or seizures (1/5) [many of these similar to those reported by Karaca et al]. Brain MRI images were consistent with leukodystrophy and prolonged relaxation of dorsal tegmental tracts (similar findings were not commented by Karaca et al).

PLEKHG2 encodes a Rho guanine exchange factor (RhoGEF). RhoGEFs activate RhoGTPases through release of GDP and binding of GTP. Mutations in other RhoGEFs have been associated with neurodevelopmental disorders.

PLEKHG2 activity was shown to be significantly decreased in HEK293A cells transfected with R204W-PLEKHG2 when compared to tranfection with wt. Western blotting suggested that this was not the result of defective expression.

Using lymphoblastoid cell lines from peripheral B lymphocytes from individuals homozygous for R204W and controls, similar levels of expression were shown between the 2 groups.

As the authors note, PLEKHG2 is required for Rac- and Cdc42-stimulated actin polymerization in leukocytes (PMID cited: 24001768).

SDF1a-stimulated actin polymerization was studied in patient cells and was shown to be significantly impaired. In line with this actin polymerization was also impaired upon siRNA-mediated downregulation of PLEKHG2 expression in control cells.
-------
A subsequent submission of the Gly570Arg variant in ClinVar (2017 - SCV000609979.1 - same variant as the one reported by Karaca et al) reports this as a VUS.
-------
PLEKHG2 is associated with Leukodystrophy and acquired microcephaly with or without dystonia (616763) in OMIM.
This gene is not associated with any phenotype in G2P.
PLEKHG2 is included in gene panels for ID offered by some diagnostic laboratories.
-------
As a result, this gene could be considered for inclusion in this panel probably as amber (or green if the current evidence is considered to be sufficient).
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v2.597 SOX4 Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: SOX4 was added
gene: SOX4 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: SOX4 was set to MONOALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal, imprinted status unknown
Phenotypes for gene: SOX4 were set to Global developmental delay; Intellectual disability; Growth delay; Clinodactyly of the 5th finger; Abnormality of head or neck
Penetrance for gene: SOX4 were set to unknown
Review for gene: SOX4 was set to GREEN
Added comment: Zawerton et al. (DDD study among the co-authors - doi.org/10.1016/j.ajhg.2018.12.014 - PMID:NA) report on 4 unrelated individuals with de novo SOX4 pathogenic variants. The common phenotype consisted of DD/ID (4/4 - very mild to severe), overlapping facial features as well as digital anomalies (5th finger clinodactyly in 4/4).

SOX4 is a member of the SOX family of transcription factors, all presenting at least 50% identity with SRY (the first identified member of this family) in the HMG (DNA-binding) domain. Most SOX genes have important roles in cell fate / differentiation. Mutations in other genes of this family (eg. SRY, SOX9, SOX10, SOX5) are associated with severe human syndromes.

SOX4 is highly expressed in human brain during gestation - particularly in areas of active neurogenesis - with progressive decrease thereafter until the 3rd - 4th decade of life.

Knockdown of the SOX4 ortholog in Xenopus laevis embryos resulted in smaller head size, microphthalmia, shorter body length and underdevelopment of fore- and mid-brain. (Growth deficiency was a common feature in affected individuals, and microcephaly in 2/4).

Sox4-null mice die in utero due to heart septation defects, while such abnormalities were not reported in heterozygous mice. One affected subject had a VSD. Sox4 inactivation in mice results in impaired skeletal growth (similarly to the patients).

All 4 different missense variants clustered in the HMG domain (aa 58-133) which appears relatively (more) depleted in missense variants (only 12 missense HMG-domain variants in gnomAD). [Overall the Z-score for missense variants is 3.72. pLI = 0.38. %HI in DECIPHER : 24.67%].

The 4 missense variants presented impaired DNA binding and transcription activation in COS-1 transfected cells which appeared to distinguish them from the 12 gnomAD ones. Synthesis, stability and nuclear translocation appeared to be similar to wt.

Other parameters eg. residue conservation in the SOX family, presence of "equivalent" known disease causing mutations in other SOX genes or in silico analyses suggesting structural consequences were supportive of a deleterious effect for the 4 variants (but also for some of the 12 gnomAD ones).

SOX4 and SOX11 have almost identical DNA-binding domains, while the mechanism of mutations reported and the phenotypes appear to be relatively similar, as commented by the authors.
--------------
SOX4 is not associated with any phenotype in G2P, nor in OMIM.
This gene is not - at least commonly - included in gene panels for ID offered by diagnostic laboratories.
--------------
As a result SOX4 can be considered for inclusion in the ID panel as green (or amber).
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v2.595 STAG2 Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: STAG2 was added
gene: STAG2 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: STAG2 was set to X-LINKED: hemizygous mutation in males, monoallelic mutations in females may cause disease (may be less severe, later onset than males)
Publications for gene: STAG2 were set to 29263825; 28296084; 30158690; 30447054; 19449417; 26443594; 25677961; 23637084; 25450604
Phenotypes for gene: STAG2 were set to Global developmental delay; Intellectual disability; Abnormality of head or neck; Microcephaly; Growth delay; Hearing impairment; Abnormal heart morphology
Penetrance for gene: STAG2 were set to unknown
Review for gene: STAG2 was set to GREEN
gene: STAG2 was marked as current diagnostic
Added comment: Several affected individuals (from at least 8 unrelated) families have been reported in the literature. The phenotype consists - among others - of DD/ID. STAG2 is located on long arm of chromosome X (Xq25). Based on these reports, both males and females can be affected.

Soardi et al. (2017 - PMID: 29263825) report an affected male belonging to a large pedigree with 4 other similarly affected males. The disorder in this pedigree followed a typical X-linked inheritance pattern. All affected males were hemizygous for a missense variant (NM_001042749.1:c.980G>A or p.Ser327Asn). Common phenotype consisted of moderate ID, short stature, sensory hearing loss and some similar facial features. Unaffected males did not harbor the variant. Heterozygous females were not affected. Co-segragation of the variant with the affected status under an X-linked model, appeared unlikely to have occurred by chance (probability of 1/131,072 - logarithm of odds score of 5.12).

Mullegama et al. (2017 - PMID: 28296084) report on an 8-year-old girl harboring a de novo nonsense variant in STAG2 (NM_001042749.1:c.205C>T or p.Arg69Ter). This individual presented - among others with - DD, microcephaly, growth delay, digit anomalies, particular facial features, and anomalies of other systems (eg. hearing loss, cardiac defect, etc). The authors summarize the features of 2 subjects from the DDD study as available in DECIPHER, without additional details. [Variants of these individuals NM_001042749.1:c.1913_1922del10 or p.(A638Vfs*10) / NM_001042749.1:c.1811G>A p.(R604Q)].

Yuan et al. (2018 - PMID: 30158690) report on 4 females with de novo LoF STAG2 variants as well as 1 male subject with a de novo missense one. DD (5/5) and ID (4/4) were features in all individuals for whom this information was available. One additional female had an intragenic STAG2 deletion, although this subject was not reported to have DD or ID (table S6 : microcephaly, seizures and facial phenotype). It is not known whether the deletion was inherited or had occurred as a de novo event. All variants from this study have been submitted in ClinVar (phenotype : STAG2-related disorder).

Mullegama et al. (2018 - PMID: 30447054) report on a 4-year-old male with DD, microcephaly, growth delay, digit anomalies due to a de novo missense STAG2 variant (c.3027A>T or p.Lys1009Asn). As discussed by the authors at the time of the study 33 males with Xq25 duplications and ID had been reported (PMIDs cited: 19449417, 26443594, 25677961, 23637084, 25450604).

Discussed in these articles :

STAG2 (or STAG1) is one of the 4 core proteins of the cohesin complex, the other 3 being SMC1A, SMC3 and RAD21. Mutations in genes encoding these proteins or their interactors (eg. NIBPL, HDAC8, ESCO2, etc) have been associated cohesinopathies, a group of multisystem developmental disorders (eg. Cornelia de Lange syndrome, Roberts/SC phocomelia, etc).

It has been commented that the phenotype of STAG2-related disorder presents overlap with other cohesinopathies (eg. DD, microcephaly and growth retardation, craniofacial features, anomalies of the digits, etc).

Decreased proportion of nuclei with premature sister chromatid separation compared to controls was found on one occasion (suggestive of tighter sister chromatid cohesion) [Mullegama-A]. Sister chromatid cohesion was not affected in another report [Soardi et al.].

Western blot demonstrated significant reduction of STAG2 levels for a nonsense variant [Mullegama-A]. Levels were not perturbed for a missense variant [Soardi et al.].

Upon immunofluorescence STAG2 presented normal (nuclear) localization for a missense variant for which this was studied [Soardi et al.].

Perturbation of the cell cycle profile (higher percentage of G2/M cells) was demonstrated for patient fibroblasts compared to controls on one occasion where this was studied. [Soardi et al.].

Microarray expression studies in patient fibroblasts demonstrated altered transcription (upregulation) of genes implicated in cell division, mitosis and DNA replication upon comparison with normal fibroblasts [Soardi et al.].

The effect of a missense variant on STAG2 binding to other cohesin subunits (SCC1, SMC1 and SMC3) and regulators was studied. Binding was found to be reduced in vivo (in HeLa cells) for SCC1 (its direct binding partner) as well as SMC1, SMC3 (possibly indirectly). Reduced STAG2 binding to cohesin regulators was also shown in vivo. However, in vitro studies were not suggestive of impaired binding of STAG2 to SCC1 (a finding difficult to explain) [Soardi et al.].

STAG2 appears to be intolerant to LoF variants (pLI of 1 in ExAC). Z-Score for missense variants is 5.11.

Mullegama et al. (B) comment that Xq25 duplications in males may be associated with milder phenotypes compared to intragenic variants. They further hypothesize that males are able to survive less damaging variants while females are able to survive more deleterious (eg. LoF) ones though with more severe phenotypes (similarity to the MECP2 model is discussed).
----------
STAG2 is not associated with any phenotype in OMIM.
In G2P this gene is associated with STAG2-related developmental delay with microcephaly and congenital anomalies (disease confidence : confirmed / Both DD and ID among the phenotypes assigned to this entry).
----------
STAG2 is included in gene panels for ID offered by some diagnostic laboratories.
----------
As a result, this gene can be considered for inclusion in the ID panel as green (or amber).
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v2.595 ZMIZ1 Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: ZMIZ1 was added
gene: ZMIZ1 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: ZMIZ1 was set to MONOALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal, imprinted status unknown
Publications for gene: ZMIZ1 were set to 29754769; 18053775; 17967885; 26163108; 27479843
Phenotypes for gene: ZMIZ1 were set to Global developmental delay; Intellectual disability; Feeding difficulties; Growth abnormality; Microcephaly; Abnormality of the skeletal system; Abnormality of the urinary system; Abnormality of the cardiovascular system; Abnormality of head or neck
Penetrance for gene: ZMIZ1 were set to unknown
Review for gene: ZMIZ1 was set to GREEN
gene: ZMIZ1 was marked as current diagnostic
Added comment: Carapito et al. (doi.org/10.1016/j.ajhg.2018.12.007 - PMID to add) report on 19 individuals with variants affecting ZMIZ1 (alternative symbols RAI17/KIAA1224/ZIMP10).

Features included DD/ID (19/19), feeding difficulties, growth failure, microcephaly and variable congenital malformations. Seizures were noted in 3 unrelated individuals (with different variants).

Variants included 6 missense SNVs, 5 frameshift variants, 1 splice site variant, 1 synonymous variant with probable impact on splicing (not studied) and 2 translocations.

In all individuals for whom parental studies were possible (n=16), the variants had occurred as de novo events while for 3 sibs harboring a frameshift variant parental samples were unavailable. These subjects however harbored the same variant as a DDD study participant included in the current report.

One translocation disrupted only ZMIZ1 while a second [t(X;10)] did not disrupt the coding sequence of any gene but only a distal enhancer 276 kb upstream of ZMIZ1. A previous study had found recurrent SNVs of the same region in ASD subjects and suggested possible interaction with the ZMIZ1 promoter (Liu et al. - PMID: 29754769).

The deleterious effect of both translocations was confirmed by quantitative RT-PCR. For 4 missense SNVs as well as a splice variant mRNA levels were similar to controls. The splice site (-2) variant was shown to produce 2 new splicing isoforms from utilization of alternative splice site acceptors.

ZMIZ1 belongs to the PIAS-like family of transcriptional coregulators.

Five missense variants were located in an alanine rich domain (aa 280-305). Seven other variants were predicted to shorten or remove the C-terminal transactivation domain.

This gene enhances - among others - the transcriptional activity of androgen receptor (AR). In vitro studies using HEK293T cell lines supported impaired coactivation of the AR for 3 variants studied. In utero electroporation of pathogenic variants in mouse embryos (E14.5) led to impaired neuronal positioning of the electroporated neurons and disruption of the morphology/polarization.

As the authors note previous studies have shown expression of Zimp10 in the developing mouse brain, craniofacial tissue as well as the interdigital region of limbs (PMIDs cited : 18053775 and 17967885) in line with ID, facial phenotype and syndactyly observed in some patients.

Finally the authors cite a previous report on an individual with ID due to a translocation [t(10;19)] disrupting both ZMIZ1 and PRR12 (Córdova-Fletes al. - PMID: 26163108). Although disruption of ZMIZ1 is discussed as a cause, PRR12 has recently been proposed as (also) an ID gene (Leduc et al. - PMID: 29556724). [For details see PRR12 in the current panel].
------------
One of the variants found in 2 unrelated individuals in the aforementioned study [NM_020338.3:c.899C>T or p.(T300M)] has been reported in a further individual investigated for ID in the context of a bigger cohort (Lelieveld et al. - PMID: 27479843).
[ Details in the denovo-db : http://denovo-db.gs.washington.edu/denovo-db/QueryVariantServlet?searchBy=Gene&target=ZMIZ1 ]
------------
ZMIZ1 is not associated with any phenotype in OMIM, nor in G2P.
This gene has been included in gene panels for intellectual disability offered by some diagnostic laboratories.
------------
As a result, ZMIZ1 can be considered for inclusion in the ID panel as green.
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v2.588 CWF19L1 Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: CWF19L1 was added
gene: CWF19L1 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature,Radboud University Medical Center, Nijmegen
Mode of inheritance for gene: CWF19L1 was set to BIALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal
Publications for gene: CWF19L1 were set to 25361784
Phenotypes for gene: CWF19L1 were set to Spinocerebellar ataxia, autosomal recessive 17 (MIM 616127)
Penetrance for gene: CWF19L1 were set to Complete
Review for gene: CWF19L1 was set to GREEN
gene: CWF19L1 was marked as current diagnostic
Added comment: Biallelic pathogenic variants in CWF19L1 cause Spinocerebellar ataxia, autosomal recessive 17 (MIM 616127).
-------
Burns et al. (2014 - PMID: 25361784) report on 2 sibs born to consanguineous parents, homozygous for a splice site variant (NM_018294.5:c.964+1G>A). Congenital ataxia with hypoplasia of vermis and cerebellar hemispheres and ID were features reported in both in this study.

Clinical details on this family were published previously (Yapici and Eraksoy - PMID: 15981765) where ID appeared to be a feature for one of the sibs (FSIQ of 68) but not the other (IQ of 90) [the sibs seem to correspond to patients 5 and 6 from the third family of the original report].

Expression in patient lymphoblastoid cell lines was reduced using expression micro-arrays and quantitative reverse-transcription PCR.

The variant was shown to lead to skipping of exon 9. Introduction of an out-of-frame stop codon (thus NMD) may explain mRNA levels.

Western blot using epitope spanning exons 5-7 demonstrated absence (in patient but not in control LCLs) of the 2 protein bands expected based on this epitope. [A shorter isoform due to downstream alternative start site would not be detectable].

Using commercial normal tissue brain lysates revealed only the canonical protein band suggesting that this is the isoform present in brain.

Morpholino knockdown of cwf91l1 in zebrafish resulted in altered cerebellar staining (/structure) and abnormal motor behavior.
--------
Nguyen et al. (2016 - PMID: 26197978) report on a further individual with ID, ataxia and abnormal cerebellum (extensive discussions whether this represents hypoplasia/atrophy) compound heterozygous for a missense (NM_018294.4:c.37G>C / p.Asp13His) and a nonsense variant (c.946A>T / p.Lys316*).

mRNA expression in patient fibroblasts was similar to control while cDNA sequence analysis was suggestive of lower levels for the r.946A>U transcript (compared to r.37G>C) possibly due to NMD.
--------
Evers et al. (2016 - PMID: 27016154) report on a further individual, born to consanguineous parents, homozygous a frameshift variant (NM_018294.5:c.467delC or p.Pro156Hisfs). This individual presented with ID, ataxia and similar cerebellar anomalies.

cDNA of 3 different regions of CWF19L1 suggested tht mRNA was not entirely degraded by NMD. Western blot demonstrated absence of a band corresponding to the longest isoform in patient LCL cells. [All isoforms discussed in Fig3].

A subsequent pregnancy of the same couple was terminated due to presence of additional fetal anomalies possibly not explained by homozygosity (only) for this variant which was confirmed (cerebellar measurements were in the the low-normal range and morphology reportedly normal).
--------
In ClinVar additional variants have been submitted as pathogenic/likely pathogenic (although a phenotype is not specified for all).
--------
CWF19L1 is not associated with any phenotype in G2P.
This gene is included in gene panels for ID offered by diagnostic laboratories (incl. Radboudumc).
--------
As a result CWF19L1 can be considered for inclusion in this panel probably as green (rather than amber).
Sources: Literature, Radboud University Medical Center, Nijmegen
Intellectual disability v2.588 SLC35A3 Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: SLC35A3 was added
gene: SLC35A3 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: SLC35A3 was set to BIALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal
Publications for gene: SLC35A3 were set to 24031089; 28328131; 28777481; 16344554
Phenotypes for gene: SLC35A3 were set to ?Arthrogryposis, mental retardation, and seizures (MIM 615553)
Penetrance for gene: SLC35A3 were set to Complete
Review for gene: SLC35A3 was set to GREEN
gene: SLC35A3 was marked as current diagnostic
Added comment: Biallelic pathogenic variants in SLC35A3 cause Arthrogryposis, mental retardation, and seizures (MIM 615553).
--------
Edvardson et al. (PMID: 24031089) report on 8 affected individuals from 3 nuclear Ashkenazi Jewish families. All harbored a nonsense [NM_012243.1:c.514C>T / p.(Gln172*)] as well as a missense variant [NM_012243.1:c.886A>G / p.(Ser296Gly)] in the compound heterozygous state. Most of the parents, who were heterozygous for the one or the other variant, were distantly related.

Common features included ASD (8/8), arthrogryposis (8/8), seizures (6/8) and intellectual disability (6/8 - variable degrees).

Upon cDNA studies, the (predicted) missense variant led to skipping of exon 8 and there was no normal size transcript (as would be expected for a variant of this type). Introduction of a premature stop codon due to this variant as well instability of the mRNA from the Gln172Ter allele was presumed to lead to absence of functional SLC35A3 protein.

Testing of 2045 Ashkenazi Jewish individuals revealed a carrier frequency of 1/205 for the missense variant in this community (with no occurrence of the nonsense variant).

SLC35A3 is a nucleotide sugar transporter that transports (uniquely) UDP-N-acetylglucosamine (UDP-GlcNAc) from the cytoplasm where it is synthesized to its site of use in the Golgi. Proper function of such transporters is essential for biosynthesis of glycoproteins, glycolipids and proteoglycans.

Although the transport of UDP-GlcNAc is mediated also by other less specific transporters, members of the SLC35 family, reduced transport was shown in patient fibroblasts compared to controls. In addition an abnormal N-glycan profile was shown in patient fibroblasts (but was not the case in serum).

Biallelic SLC35A3 mutations in cattle were previously shown to cause a Complex Vertebral Malformation (CVM) syndrome characterized by abnormal growth, vertebral and heart malformations as well as arthrogryposis (Thomsen et al. - PMID: 16344554). Arthrogryposis as well as some skeletal features observed in patients were similar to those of the animal model.
--------
Marini et al. (PMID: 28328131) report on 2 sibs compound heterozygous for a missense and a frameshift variant [NM_012243.2:c.73C>T or p.(Arg25Cys) and c.899_900delTTinsA or p.(Leu300Glnfs*6)]. Hypotonia, DD with ID, early-onset seizures and arthrogryposis were features in both. Severe scoliosis was also noted in the younger sib.
---------
Edmondson et al. (PMID: 28777481) report on a neonate (follow-up till the 21st day of life) with extensive vertebral anomalies (butterfly vertebrae, hemibertebrae, sagittal clefts, scoliosis), heart defects (PFO, PDA) and arthrogryposis. Presence of hypotonia or other neurologic features (eg. seizures) is not commented on. Conventional caryotype and SNP-array analysis were normal apart from the presence of ROH regions due to parental consanguinity. Exome sequencing revealed only a homozygous missense SNV [c.74G>T or p.(Arg25Leu) - NP_036375.1] which was supported by an abnormal N-glycan profile. As proposed for the bovine model (PMID: 16344554) and discussed in this article, similarity of the skeletal/congenital heart defects with those observed in Alagille syndrome might be due to some of the Notch functions being dependent upon N-acetylglucosamine modification.
---------
In ClinVar :

There is a further submission of p.Ser296Gly as pathogenic (SCV000699337.1 - 2016) apart from the submission by OMIM (SCV000108589.2 - 2013). The associated condition is Arthrogryposis, mental retardation, and seizures.

A frameshift variant [NM_012243.2(SLC35A3):c.680dup (p.Asp227Glufs)- SCV000826704.1 - April 2018] as well as an intragenic deletion [NC_000001.10:g.(?_100472570)_(100477109_?)del (GRCh37) - SCV000837123.1 - June 2018] have both been submitted as pathogenic, associated with Arthrogryposis, mental retardation, and seizures. (Note: due to the different submission dates, one can presume that these variants were found in different individuals).
---------
SLC35A3 is not associated with any phenotype in OMIM.
It is included in gene panels for ID offered by some diagnostic laboratories.
---------
As a result, this gene can be considered for inclusion in the ID panel probably as green (or amber)
[Consider upgrade of this gene to green in other panels (eg. CDGs, arthrogryposis, IEMs) and/or inclusion in other possibly relevant panels.]
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v2.584 ZBTB11 Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: ZBTB11 was added
gene: ZBTB11 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: ZBTB11 was set to BIALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal
Publications for gene: ZBTB11 were set to 29893856; 28382966
Phenotypes for gene: ZBTB11 were set to Intellectual disability
Penetrance for gene: ZBTB11 were set to Complete
Review for gene: ZBTB11 was set to AMBER
Added comment: Fattahi et al. (PMID: 29893856) report on 9 individuals from 2 broader consanguineous pedigrees with biallelic ZBTB11 mutations.

Features in the first family (from Iran) consisted of moderate ID, microcephaly, ataxic gait, and spasticity with MRI findings of cerebellar atrophy and ventriculomegaly.

Individuals from the second family (from Pakistan) presented with moderate ID and variable features.

Homozygosity for missense ZBTB11 variants, private to each family was shown (NM_014415.3:c.2185C>T / p.H729Y and c.2640T>G / p.H880Q for the first and second family respectively).

As the authors note, ZBTB11 is predicted to be a zinc finger transcriptional regulator and one of the hypotheses emitted suggests possible disruption of DNA binding.

Functional studies performed demonstrated that the mutant proteins were excluded from the nucleolus where the (wt) protein localizes.

Previous zebrafish models (PMID: 28382966) suggested CNS degeneration among other phenotypes in Zbtb11 mutants.

Knockdown of the drosophila ZBTB11-ortholog (CkIIα-i1) resulted in recognizable shrinking of the mushroom body with significant reduction in the number of neurons compared to controls.

Other Zinc Finger and BTB Domain-Containing proteins cause disorders with ID as a prominent feature (eg. ZBTB16, ZBTB20, etc.).

ZBTB11 is not associated with any phenotype in OMIM nor in G2P.

As a result, this gene can be considered for inclusion in this panel probably as amber (2 pedigrees only) or green (given the supportive functional studies).
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v2.584 NR4A2 Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: NR4A2 was added
gene: NR4A2 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature,Radboud University Medical Center, Nijmegen
Mode of inheritance for gene: NR4A2 was set to MONOALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal, imprinted status unknown
Publications for gene: NR4A2 were set to 29770430; 30504930; 28544326; 27569545; 23554088; 28135719; 27479843; 25363768
Phenotypes for gene: NR4A2 were set to Language impairment; Intellectual disability; Autism; Behavioral abnormality
Penetrance for gene: NR4A2 were set to unknown
Review for gene: NR4A2 was set to GREEN
gene: NR4A2 was marked as current diagnostic
Added comment: Recent publications provide several lines of evidence that pathogenic NR4A2 variants cause DD/ID and/or autism spectrum disorder (ASD).

Lévy et al. (PMID: 29770430) summarize the phenotype of 2q24.1 microdeletions spanning either only NR4A2 [2 new patients as well as an individual reported by Reuter et al (PMID: 28544326)] or both NR4A2 and GPD2 (1 patient from this study as well as 2 further from Leppa et al. (PMID: 27569545) and Barge-Schaapveld et al. (PMID: 23554088)]. All these CNVs had occurred as de novo events. Common features included - among others - language impairment (6/6), ID (6/6), ASD (3/4) or abnormal behaviour (4/4).

As the authors note, NR4A2 belongs to a subfamily of highly conserved transcription factors. The gene is involved in several developmental processes, among others in neuronal development. Previous studies have also shown high expression in human fetal brain as well as a role in the development of language-related brain regions.

The absence of CNVs in general population encompassing NR4A2 (and presence of such CNVs spanning GDP2) as well as the minimal deletions confined to NR4A2 suggest that happloinsufficiency of NR4A2 is responsible for the DD/ID/ASD phenotypes. This is also supported by the HI index of 1.28 as well as pLI of 0.99.

Guo et al. (PMID: 30504930) report on a patient with de novo frameshift variant (p.P201Rfs*82) and provide a summary of individuals with de novo missense variants reported in larger DD/ID/ASD cohorts, namely :

- The DDD study (PMID: 28135719) : subjects DDD4K.00386 (R312Q - https://decipher.sanger.ac.uk/ddd/research-variant/1e7622c3a0ba1b506c5808ccea46e759#overview) and DDD4K.04161 (R289P - https://decipher.sanger.ac.uk/ddd/research-variant/673e8e570d28dd0c5797ddafb22e53eb#overview)

- By Lelieveld et al. (PMID: 27479843) : patient with ID and V307G

- By Iossifov et al. (PMID: 25363768) : subject with ASD and Y275H.

[All these appear to cluster in a region of missense constraint : https://decipher.sanger.ac.uk/gene/NR4A2#overview/protein-info].

NR4A2 is not associated with any phenotype in OMIM, nor in G2P.

The gene is included in gene panels for intellectual disability offered by diagnostic laboratories (incl. Radboudumc).

As a result, it could be considered for inclusion in this panel possibly as green (or amber).
Sources: Literature, Radboud University Medical Center, Nijmegen
Intellectual disability v2.584 AIMP2 Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: AIMP2 was added
gene: AIMP2 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature,Radboud University Medical Center, Nijmegen
Mode of inheritance for gene: AIMP2 was set to BIALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal
Publications for gene: AIMP2 were set to 29215095
Phenotypes for gene: AIMP2 were set to Leukodystrophy, hypomyelinating, 17 (MIM 618006)
Penetrance for gene: AIMP2 were set to Complete
Review for gene: AIMP2 was set to AMBER
gene: AIMP2 was marked as current diagnostic
Added comment: Biallelic pathogenic variants in AIMP2 cause Leukodystrophy, hypomyelinating, 17 (MIM 618006).

3 individuals from 2 unrelated consanguineous families, of Indian origin have been reported (all in PMID: 29215095).

The phenotype consisted of feeding difficulties, lack of development with intellectual disability and seizures as well as brain MRI abnormalities (cerebral and cerebellar atrophy, hypo-intensities of the basal ganglia on T2w sequences). Severe microcephaly was observed in 2 patients for whom this information was available (birth measurements not specified).

All patients described to date were homozygous for a nonsense variant [NM_006303.3:c.105C>A or p.(Tyr35Ter)] which appears to be a founder mutation in this population.

Quantitative reverse transcription PCR demonstrated reduced mRNA levels in peripheral lymphocytes, but this decrease was not significant compared to controls (the authors presume low level of NMD).

Previous mouse models provide some - but not substantial - support.

The authors note marked similarity with the phenotype associated with AIMP1 (Leukodystrophy, hypomyelinating, 3 - MIM 260600), another auxiliary protein of the macromolecular multienzyme multi-tRNA synthetase complex. AIMP1 is listed in the current panel as green.

AIMP2 is not associated with any phenotype in G2P.

This gene is included in gene panels for ID offered by some diagnostic laboratories (incl. Radboudumc).

As a result, AIMP2 can be considered for inclusion in this panel probably as amber.
Sources: Literature, Radboud University Medical Center, Nijmegen
Intellectual disability v2.584 PAK1 Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: PAK1 was added
gene: PAK1 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: PAK1 was set to MONOALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal, imprinted status unknown
Publications for gene: PAK1 were set to 30290153
Phenotypes for gene: PAK1 were set to Intellectual developmental disorder with macrocephaly, seizures, and speech delay (MIM 618158)
Penetrance for gene: PAK1 were set to unknown
Mode of pathogenicity for gene: PAK1 was set to Loss-of-function variants (as defined in pop up message) DO NOT cause this phenotype - please provide details in the comments
Review for gene: PAK1 was set to AMBER
Added comment: Heterozygous pathogenic PAK1 variants cause Intellectual developmental disorder with macrocephaly, seizures, and speech delay (MIM 618158).

Harms et al. (PMID: 30290153) report on two unrelated individuals with de novo missense mutations in PAK1. Common features included developmental delay with associated intellectual disability, seizures, ataxic gait. Postnatal-onset microcephaly as well as some facial features were also common to both subjects.

Each patient was found to harbour a (private) de novo missense variant [NM_001128620.1:c.392A>G or p.(Tyr131Cys) - c.1286A>G or p.(Tyr429Cys)]. Expression studies demonstrated similar levels for the mutant and wt transcript and Western blot confirmed similar amounts of protein in patient fibroblasts when compared to controls. Functional studies suggest that gain-of-function is the underlying mechanism for both variants.

PAK1 is not associated with any phenotype in G2P.

As a result, this gene can be considered for inclusion in this panel as amber.
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v2.579 PUS3 Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: PUS3 was added
gene: PUS3 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature,Radboud University Medical Center, Nijmegen
Mode of inheritance for gene: PUS3 was set to BIALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal
Publications for gene: PUS3 were set to 27055666; 30308082
Phenotypes for gene: PUS3 were set to Global developmental delay; Intellectual disability; Microcephaly
Penetrance for gene: PUS3 were set to Complete
Review for gene: PUS3 was set to AMBER
gene: PUS3 was marked as current diagnostic
Added comment: PUS3 (Pseudouridylate synthase 3) is proposed as a gene related to ID in a recent publication on PUS7.

Biallelic mutations in this gene are associated in OMIM with ?Mental retardation, autosomal recessive 55 (MIM 617051).

PMID: 27055666 reports on 3 sisters from a consanguineous Saudi Arabian family with failure to thrive, DD/ID, microcephaly and some common (coarse) facial features. These individuals were homozygous for a stopgain mutation in the last exon of the gene. Pseudouridylation appeared to be defective (as has also been the case with other genes related to ID, eg. PUS7).

PMID: 30308082 describes 1 individual born to consanguineous Palestinian parents, homozygous for a further LoF variant. Despite the localisation of this variant (again in the last exon of the gene) qPCR analyses were suggestive of degradation of the abnormal transcript possibly by NMD. The phenotype consisted of DD/ID and microcephaly.

In a further publication (http://dx.doi.org/10.7124/bc.0008D6) Gulkovskyi et al. report on 2 siblings with ID, born to non-consanguineous Ukranian parents. Pathogenicity of the variant is disputed. [NM_031307.4:c.212A>G or p.(Tyr71Cys) is found in an apparent homozygous state in the sibs but was only found in their father. De novo occurence in the maternal allele is proposed although the possibility of microdeletion missed by aCGH or other plausible mechanisms are not considered. This variant has maximum pathogenicity scores in silico (not discussed) and has an allele frequency of 0.00006717 in gnomAD. The authors did not perform studies of pseudouridylation but examined for the presence of hypoproteinemia, observed in some disorders affecting this process).

PUS3 is not associated with any phenotype in G2P but is associated with disease in OMIM.

The gene is included in gene panels for ID offered by various diagnostic laboratories (including Radboudumc). PUS1 is included in the current panel as green and PUS7 has been suggested for inclusion.

As a result, these gene can be considered for inclusion as amber (2 families) or green (given the supportive functional studies and/or the proposed role for the gene).
Sources: Literature, Radboud University Medical Center, Nijmegen
Intellectual disability v2.579 METTL23 Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: METTL23 was added
gene: METTL23 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: METTL23 was set to BIALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal
Publications for gene: METTL23 were set to 24501276; 24626631
Phenotypes for gene: METTL23 were set to Mental retardation, autosomal recessive 44 (MIM 615942)
Penetrance for gene: METTL23 were set to Complete
Review for gene: METTL23 was set to GREEN
gene: METTL23 was marked as current diagnostic
Added comment: Biallelic pathogenic variants in METTL23 cause Mental retardation, autosomal recessive 44 (MIM 615942).

Reiff et al. (PMID: 24501276) report on a consanguineous pedigree of Yemeni origin with 7 individuals presenting intellectual disability. Clinical details are provided for 3 subjects from one branch of the family. Findings included moderate (2/3) or severe (1/3) ID, seizures (2/3) and some common facial features. Seizures were not observed in individuals from other branch of the family. The affected individuals were homozygous for a 4-bp deletion.

Bernkopf et al. (PMID: 24626631) report on a consanguineous family from Pakistan with 2 affected sibs as well as a non-consanguineous family from Austria with 4 affected sibs. The parents in the latter family originated from a small - geographically isolated - village. Individuals from the Pakistani family were homozygous for a nonsense variant, while the sibs from the Austrian family for a frameshift variant. Mild ID was noted in all.

In total 3 different LoF variants have been reported. Extensive functional studies have been performed in both articles.

METTL23 (methyltransferase like 23) is expressed at low-to-moderate levels in the developping human brain. Bernkopf et al. suggest that METTL23 is indeed a methyltransferase.

The gene has 7 transcripts of which one is non-coding. 3 transcripts encode isoform 1 and 3 other encode isoform 2.

The variant reported by Reiff et al. affects the coding region of 3 (of the 6 coding) transcripts (corresponding to isoform 1) and the 5'-UTR of the other 3 transcripts. It is however shown that this first coding exon (specific to isoform 1) is expressed in the developing human brain, though at lower levels than downstream exons common to both isoforms. In addition, only isoform 1 appears to be conserved in most other species.

The variants described by Bernkopf et al. affect all 6 coding trancripts and as a result both isoforms. [However, the individuals reported by Bernkopf et al. were less severely affected compared to those reported by Reiff et al.]

Nonsense-mediated decay appeared unlikely since mRNA levels for both isoforms in lymphoblasts from affected individuals were similar to controls (upon qRT-PCR) [The specific nonsense variant tested would be expected to be subject to NMD given its localization].

METTL23 is not associated with any phenotype in G2P.

This gene is included in gene panels for intellectual disability offered by various diagnostic laboratories.

As a result, METTL23 can be considered for inclusion in the ID panel as green (or amber).
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v2.579 MAST1 Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: MAST1 was added
gene: MAST1 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: MAST1 was set to MONOALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal, imprinted status unknown
Publications for gene: MAST1 were set to 30449657; 28135719; 25666757; 27479843
Phenotypes for gene: MAST1 were set to Global developmental delay, Intellectual disability, Abnormality of the corpus callosum, Cerebellar hypoplasia, Abnormality of the cerebral cortex, Seizures; Global developmental delay, Intellectual disability, Microcephaly, Autism, Seizures
Penetrance for gene: MAST1 were set to unknown
Review for gene: MAST1 was set to GREEN
gene: MAST1 was marked as current diagnostic
Added comment: PMID: 30449657 reports on 6 unrelated individuals with de novo mutations in MAST1. All these 6 individuals were investigated for a strikingly similar phenotype of enlarged corpus callosum (CC), cerebellar hypoplasia, cortical malformation with associated DD/ID. Seizures were a feature in 2/6 (one further had EEG anomalies without clinical seizures).

Three of them harbored an in-frame deletion of 1 amino-acid (3 different indels reported - all in a specific domain) while 3 others had a missense variant (NM_014975.2:c.1549G>A or p.Gly517Ser).

Mast1 has embryonic expression in murine models with postnatal decrease. Similarly qPCR of human fetal brain cDNA demonstrated expression at 13 and 22 gestational weeks. A murine model for L278del recapitulated the brain (incl. CC) and cerebellar phenotype while Mast1 knockout mice do not present similar morphological defects. While Western blot in murine brain lysates demonstrated absence of Mast1 in knockout and reduction in the L278del, Mast1 transcript levels for L278del were similar to wildtype. Other Mast proteins (Mast1 & Mast2) were significantly reduced upon western blot while this was not reflected in their mRNA levels, suggesting a dominant-negative effect, at least for the L278del.

4 additional individuals with somewhat different phenotype consisting DD/ID and microcephaly/autism are described in the supplement. All 4 had de novo missense variants but did not display the CC-cerebral and cerebellar anomalies. Four different (additional to Gly517Ser) missense SNVs were observed.

Several additional individuals exist in the denovo-db (among others DDD participant DDD4K.02310 published in 28135719, 25666757 - McMichael et al. commented in the article, 27479843, etc.). [http://denovo-db.gs.washington.edu/denovo-db/QueryVariantServlet?searchBy=Gene&target=Mast1]

Epilepsy was a feature in 4/10 individuals (with an additional one with EEG anomalies without clinical seizures). One further individual from PMID:23934111 (in denovo-db) had seizures.

As the authors comment (and as evident from the 6+4 reported patients) the related neurodevelopmental phenotype may be more complex.

MAST1 is not related to any phenotype in G2P, nor in OMIM.

The gene is included in gene panels for ID offered by different diagnostic laboratories.

As a result, this gene can be considered for inclusion in this panel as green.
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v2.576 PPP1R21 Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: PPP1R21 was added
gene: PPP1R21 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: PPP1R21 was set to BIALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal
Publications for gene: PPP1R21 were set to 29808498; 28940097
Phenotypes for gene: PPP1R21 were set to Generalized hypotonia; Feeding difficulties; Profound global developmental delay; Abnormality of the face; Abnormality of vision; Abnormal heart morphology; Abnormality of the respiratory system; Hepatosplenomegaly
Penetrance for gene: PPP1R21 were set to Complete
Review for gene: PPP1R21 was set to GREEN
Added comment: Biallelic pathogenic variants in PPP1R21 have been reported so far in 9 individuals from 7 unrelated families. All (7 different) variants reported to date are truncating.

PMID: 29808498 is the first detailed clinical description on the related phenotype. 3 individuals from 3 families are reported. One of these individuals was previously included in a larger patient cohort (in PMID: 28940097).

In a subsequent further publication, Rehman et al. (https://doi.org/10.1002/humu.23694) describe 6 additional patients from 4 unrelated consanguineous families. Again, these individuals were homozygous for truncating mutations. The authors summarize the findings in their patients as well as the previously reported ones.

Common features included feeding difficulties, hypotonia with severe global DD and mildly coarsened facial features (all were observed in 9/9), visual anomalies (8/9), respiratory problems (7/9), cardiac anomalies (4/9) and hepato-/splenomegaly (3/7). Brain MRI anomalies were observed in the majority. DD was severe in all and ID (which is not explicitly mentioned) was evident from the clinical description of several individuals (eg. in PMID: 29808498).

In total 7 loss-of-function variants have been reported. The authors in the first article, underscore the possibility of less severe phenotypes associated to biallelic missense variants (although none has been reported so far).

Functional studies have shown great reduction (but not complete absence) of PPP1R21 mRNA levels in patient fibroblasts compared to controls. A role of PPP1R21 in the endosomal-lysosomal function is demonstrated in line with the presence of myelin figures in patient fibroblasts as well as some phenotypic similarities to neurometabolic/lysosomal storage disorders.

Most variants reported in the most recent publication except one (NM_001135629.2:c.1607dupT) seem to affect all 3 PPP1R21 isoforms (which also seems to be the case for previously published variants). c.1607dupT appears to be the single truncating variant affecting 2 (of 3) isoforms. This variant was however shown to have severely reduced expression in fibroblasts upon qPCR, absent protein staining, and increase in myelin figures.

The protein is expressed in embryonic mouse cortex.

Overall, this gene can be considered for inclusion in this panel as green (or amber).
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v2.574 MCM3AP Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: MCM3AP was added
gene: MCM3AP was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: MCM3AP was set to BIALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal
Publications for gene: MCM3AP were set to 24123876; 28633435; 28969388; 29982295
Phenotypes for gene: MCM3AP were set to Peripheral neuropathy, autosomal recessive, with or without impaired intellectual development (MIM 618124)
Penetrance for gene: MCM3AP were set to Complete
Review for gene: MCM3AP was set to AMBER
gene: MCM3AP was marked as current diagnostic
Added comment: Biallelic mutations in MCM3AP cause Peripheral neuropathy, autosomal recessive, with or without impaired intellectual development (MIM 618124).

All relevant publications [PMIDs: 24123876, 28633435 (first detailed description of a series of patients with functional studies), 28969388, 29982295) are summarized in OMIM.

Overall more than 18 patients from 10 families and at least 8 pathogenic variants have been reported.

Apart from abnormal motor development which may be associated with the sensorimotor neuropathy, intellectual disability was a feature in several individuals (although not a universal one).

Some patients were initially evaluated for their ID while investigations for the neuropathy may be conducted late (as evident in PMID: 28633435).

MCM3AP is included in gene panels for intellectual disability offered by diagnostic laboratories.

As a result, this gene can be considered for inclusion in the ID panel as amber or green (depending on its relevance to the specific panel).
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v2.564 PRR12 Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: PRR12 was added
gene: PRR12 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: PRR12 was set to MONOALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal, imprinted status unknown
Publications for gene: PRR12 were set to 29556724; 26163108
Phenotypes for gene: PRR12 were set to Global developmental delay; Intellectual disability; Abnormality of the iris; Abnormality of vision; Behavioral abnormality
Penetrance for gene: PRR12 were set to unknown
Review for gene: PRR12 was set to GREEN
gene: PRR12 was marked as current diagnostic
Added comment: PMID: 29556724 (Leduc et al. 2018) reports on 3 unrelated individuals with de novo pathogenic variants in PRR12. The common phenotype consisted of DD/ID (3/3), iris anomalies (colobomas in 2/3 with stellate iris patern in all) as well as additional vision problems and behavioral anomalies.

3 different loss-of-function variants are reported. These variants affected the longer transcript (Ensembl ENST00000418929.6 or NM_020719 - short : ENST00000615927.1) with a single one affecting both.

PRR12 appears to be intolerant to loss-of-function muatations (pLI of 1). Some LoF variants exist in ExAC/gnomAD although the majority appear to be low-quality variants.

As commented by the authors 2 individuals with de novo variants exist in Decipher (1 in-frame deletion and a missense SNV - both variants appear in fig.2 of the article) [a few more DDD study participants in the denovo-db all from PMID: 28135719 : http://denovo-db.gs.washington.edu/denovo-db/QueryVariantServlet?searchBy=Gene&target=PRR12].

Alternative explanations for the phenotype (eg. CHARGE syndrome, etc) were ruled out in many individuals in the article.

Functional studies have not been performed. //

PMID: 26163108 (Córdova-Fletes al. 2015) is a previous report cited by Leduc et al. One individual with balanced translocation [t(10;19)] with disruption of PRR12 is described. This individual presented with ID and behavioral anomalies (without details on eventual coloboma or other iris anomalies).

The translocation was balanced and led to fusion of PRR12 with LMIZ1. The breakpoint was located within intron 11 (PRR12 is a 14-exon gene) with fusion of PRR12 exon 11 with ZMIZ1 exon 8 upon RT-PCR. Both PRR12/ZMIZ1 products were predicted to be truncated due to frameshift and introduction of premature stop codon.

[Surprisingly qPCR and Western blot in patient LCLs were suggestive of increased PRR12 expression compared to controls suggesting either a compensation mechanism or longer half-life/accumulation of the aberrant PRR12].

Expression of wt PRR12 was highest during embryonic development in mouse/rat brain cells suggesting a role in early CNS development. The transcript studied (corresponding to the longest human transcript) was exclusively located in the nucleus compared to a shorter one located primary in the nucleus but also outside suggesting that PRR12 might be involved in regulation of transcription.

In line with this several genes linked to neurodevelopmental processes/neuronal communication appeared be dysregulated in lymphoblastoid cell lines (LCLs) from the translocation patient.

A role for ZMIZ1 is similarly discussed. //

PRR12 is included in gene panels for ID offered by diagnostic laboratories. //

As a result, this gene can be considered for inclusion in this panel as green (or amber).
Sources: Literature
Intellectual disability v2.556 DDX59 Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: DDX59 was added
gene: DDX59 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature,Expert Review
Mode of inheritance for gene: DDX59 was set to BIALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal
Publications for gene: DDX59 were set to 23972372; 28711741; 29127725
Phenotypes for gene: DDX59 were set to Orofaciodigital syndrome V, 174300
Penetrance for gene: DDX59 were set to Complete
Review for gene: DDX59 was set to GREEN
Added comment: Biallelic mutations in DDX59 cause Orofaciodigital syndrome V, 174300.

PMID: 23972372 reports on 6 individuals from 2 consanguineous Arab families. All 6 presented with palatal anomalies (cleft palate or bifid uvula), lobulated tongue, facial anomalies (frontal bossing and hypertelorism) as well as intellectual disability.

Individuals from the first family were homozygous for the Val367Gly (NM_001031725.4:c.1100T>G) variant while those from the second were homozygous for Gly534Arg (NM_001031725.4:c.1600G>A), both predicted to be pathogenic in silico. Immunoblot demonstrated reduced levels of the Val367Gly variant in patient fibroblasts (the other variant was probably not tested). Ddx59 was shown to be expressed in lips, palatal shelves and developing limb buds of mouse embryos.

PMID: 28711741 describes 3 further patients (from two consanguineous Pakistani families), presenting the cardinal features of orofaciodigital syndrome (though polydactyly was only reported in one of the three). Developmental delay was reported in all (in the first family one of the sibs had more severe delay with no speech at the age of 7 years, in the patient from the other family speech was limited to 2 words at school age). Affected individuals from both families were found to harbor a SNV leading to loss of a stop codon, thus extending the reading frame by 21 codons.

PMID: 29127725 reports on two sibs with a diagnosis of orofaciodigital syndrome born to non-consanguineous parents. ID was a feature in both. These individuals were homozygous for a frameshift variant. Reverse transcription PCR/semiquantitative PCR demonstrated reduction of the mutant transcript compared to the levels in wt controls (suggestive of incomplete NMD). Functional studies showed possible perturbation of the Sonic Hedgehog pathway. DDX59 expression in CNS from control post-mortem human brains was confirmed to be high (based on data generated in a previous study). Studies in Drosophila suggest reduced lifespan and neuronal defects secondary to mutations in mahe (the Drosophila homolog of DDX59).

As a result this gene can be considered for inclusion in the ID panel as green.
Sources: Literature, Expert Review
Intellectual disability v2.555 COG6 Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: COG6 was added
gene: COG6 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature,Expert Review
Mode of inheritance for gene: COG6 was set to BIALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal
Publications for gene: COG6 were set to 26260076; 20605848; 23430903; 23606727; 28139241; 28742265; 29445937; 29709711
Phenotypes for gene: COG6 were set to Congenital disorder of glycosylation, type IIl, 614576; Shaheen syndrome, 615328
Penetrance for gene: COG6 were set to Complete
Review for gene: COG6 was set to GREEN
gene: COG6 was marked as current diagnostic
Added comment: DD/ID is an almost universal feature of individuals with biallelic COG6 mutations, whether this is associated with a type II transferrin IEF pattern (as in Congenital disorder of glycosylation, type IIl, 614576) or not (as in Shaheen syndrome, 615328).

More than 15 patients from several different families have been reported to date.

PMID: 26260076 is a collaborative study reporting on new patients as well as on individuals previously described up to 2015 by Lubbehusen et al. (2010 - PMID: 20605848), Huybrechts et al. (2012 - PMID: 23430903) as well as Shaheen et al. (2013 - PMID: 23606727).

As summarized in table 1 of this article, developmental disability was a feature in 8/10, although for a further 2/10 this was probably not relevant (both deceased too early).

The following articles are additional reports although there might be some overlap (applicable for the Saudi patients) : PMIDs: 28139241 (individuals with diagnosis of CDG from Spain), 28742265 (cohort of CDG patients from Saudi Arabia), 29445937 (case report of Saudi subject), 29709711 (Chinese individual with COG6-CDG).

All types of variants have been observed including missense, stopgain and frameshift ones, as well as variants leading to aberrant splicing [eg. positions -2, -9, -24]. The deep intronic variant (position -24) in the individuals reported by Shaheen and others is considered a founder mutation in the Saudi population.

Individuals homozygous for the latter variant have detectable levels of the normal transcript, although 75% of the produced transcript (upon RT-PCR analysis) correspond to retention of 37 intronic nucleotides leading to frameshift and introduction of a premature stop codon. This was also confirmed with Western blot.

Given the detectable levels of the normal transcript, it has been proposed that Shaheen syndrome represents the mildest end of the spectrum COG6-related disorders.

COG6 is included in gene panels for intellectual disability offered by different diagnostic laboratories.

As a result this gene can be considered for inclusion in this panel as green.
Sources: Literature, Expert Review
Intellectual disability v2.555 MACF1 Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: MACF1 was added
gene: MACF1 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature,Expert Review
Mode of inheritance for gene: MACF1 was set to MONOALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal, NOT imprinted
Phenotypes for gene: MACF1 were set to Intellectual disability; Seizures; Lissencephaly; Brainstem dysplasia
Penetrance for gene: MACF1 were set to unknown
Mode of pathogenicity for gene: MACF1 was set to Loss-of-function variants (as defined in pop up message) DO NOT cause this phenotype - please provide details in the comments
Review for gene: MACF1 was set to GREEN
Added comment: Dobyns et al. (doi.org/10.1016/j.ajhg.2018.10.019) report on 9 individuals (all unrelated appart from a pair of monozygotic twins) with de novo variants in MACF1.

All patients presented lissencephaly and brainstem hypoplasia with associated intellectual disability (9/9) and seizures (9/9).

Seven of these individuals had de novo missense variants within the GAR domain and an eighth had a deletion of several exons also spanning this domain and leading to an in-frame deletion. A further ninth patient had a de novo missense variant in the spectrin repeat domain and was found to have similar features although the brainstem dysplasia was rather subtle.

5 missense variants (4 of which in the GAR domain) and an intragenic deletion are reported in total.

The variants in the GAR domain were predicted to have important effect in the zinc-binding pocket. The spectrin repeat (SR4) is thought to have an important role for the function of MACF1 and further to neuronal migration.

Knockdown of Macf1 in mice has been shown to result in developmental defects similar to the human malformation.

The authors note that several high-confidence loss-of-function mutations are listed in ExAC and as a result this type of variants could be non-pathogenic (or lead to neurodevelopmental disorders with reduced penetrance). Still MACF1 has a pLI of 1.0.

As for the missense variants, the authors suggest either a gain-of-function or dominant negative mechanism.

Caution should be taken when interpreting variants as the ENST00000372915.7 (or MACF1-204) transcript is used for the predicted protein changes, although ENST00000361689.6 or MACF1-203 (corresponding to NM_012090.5) has also been used in some tables or figures.

As a result, this gene can be considered for inclusion in this panel probably as green.
Sources: Literature, Expert Review
Intellectual disability v2.535 FUT8 Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: FUT8 was added
gene: FUT8 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature,Expert Review
Mode of inheritance for gene: FUT8 was set to BIALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal
Publications for gene: FUT8 were set to 29304374
Phenotypes for gene: FUT8 were set to Congenital disorder of glycosylation with defective fucosylation, 618005
Penetrance for gene: FUT8 were set to Complete
Review for gene: FUT8 was set to GREEN
Added comment: PMID: 29304374 reports on 3 unrelated individuals with biallelic pathogenic variants in FUT8.

Two of the patients were born to consanguineous parents and were found to be homozygous for stopgain variants (p.Arg239* in one family and p.Arg315* in the other). A third patient was compound heterozygous for a missense as well as a splice variant.

All three presented with similar phenotype consisting of polyhydramnios (2 out of 3), IUGR and failure to thrive with short stature (3/3), severe developmental delay (3/3) with microcephaly (3/3) and seizures (3/3). Variable respiratory problems were also noted in all.

Western blot demonstrated loss of FUT8 protein expression in one individual homozygous for a stopgain mutation as well as the patient who was compound heterozygous for the missense and the splice variant. The splice variant was further shown to produce a shorter transcript due to lack of exon 9, leading to an in-frame deletion of 59 residues critical for the protein function.

Additional studies confirmed the fucosylation defect compared to controls.

The authors note that while Fut8 knockout mice are born normal, 70% die within the first 3 days due to severe growth retardation and respiratory deficiency (similarly to what is observed in humans, though to a lesser extent).

As a result this gene can be considered for inclusion in this panel probably as green (3 unrelated families, strong additional functional data, consistent phenotype) or amber.
Sources: Literature, Expert Review
Intellectual disability v2.530 RHOBTB2 Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: RHOBTB2 was added
gene: RHOBTB2 was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Expert Review,Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: RHOBTB2 was set to MONOALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal, imprinted status unknown
Publications for gene: RHOBTB2 were set to 29276004; 29768694; 26740508
Phenotypes for gene: RHOBTB2 were set to Global developmental delay; Intellectual disability; Seizures; Postnatal microcephaly
Penetrance for gene: RHOBTB2 were set to unknown
Mode of pathogenicity for gene: RHOBTB2 was set to Loss-of-function variants (as defined in pop up message) DO NOT cause this phenotype - please provide details in the comments
Review for gene: RHOBTB2 was set to GREEN
gene: RHOBTB2 was marked as current diagnostic
Added comment: PMID: 29276004 reports on 10 unrelated patients with de novo pathogenic missense variants in RHOBTB2. The phenotype in all individuals was compatible with a developmental and epileptic encephalopathy including early-onset seizures, severe intellectual disability, postnatal onset microcephaly (6/10) and movement disorders (8/10).

The variants occured as de novo events and clustered within the BTB-domain encoding region (within and between the 2 BTB domains). Three missense variants were recurrent and/or concerned the same residue (p.Arg483His in 4 individuals, Arg511Gln was reported in 2, and Arg511Trp was was found in another 2 individuals).

Functional studies in HEK293 cells suggested increased abundance of the mutant protein secondary to decreased proteasome degradation. Using Drosophila as a model organism, altered expression of RhoBTB (the single ortholog of the 3 vertebrate paralogs, closest to RHOBTB2) was shown to result in neurological phenotypes. RhoBTB overexpression in particular was associated with increased bang sensitivity (which was not the case or milder in the case if knockdown of this gene) and impaired performance upon the negative geotaxis assay, similar to the human neurological phenotypes. Altered RhoBTB dosage was shown to be associated with impaired dendrite development.

As commented by the authors, these results as well as the clustering of missense variants and the pLI score of 0.51 reported for RHOBTB2 are consistent with altered protein function (due to the missense variants) rather than haploinsufficiency or loss-of-function.

PMID: 29768694 describes 3 additional individuals, all found to harbor de novo missense variants again within the BTB-domain encoding region. Two of the variants had been reported in the previous study (Arg511Gln and Arg483His) while the third was a private one (Arg507Cys). The phenotype was similar to the previous descriptions. Functional studies were suggestive of impaired degradation of the mutant protein by the CUL3 complex although this was not secondary to decreased binding with CUL3.

PMID: 26740508 (cited by the two aforementioned publications) reports briefly on an individual with de novo missense variant in the same region of RHOBTB2 (Asn510Asp) and Rett-like phenotype.

RHOBTB2 is included in gene panels for intellectual disability offered by different diagnostic laboratories.

As a result the gene can be considered for inclusion in the intellectual disability and epilepsy panels as green.
Sources: Expert Review, Literature
Intellectual disability v2.510 VARS Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: VARS was added
gene: VARS was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Expert Review,Literature
Mode of inheritance for gene: VARS was set to BIALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal
Publications for gene: VARS were set to 26539891; 29691655; 30275004
Phenotypes for gene: VARS were set to # 617802. NEURODEVELOPMENTAL DISORDER WITH MICROCEPHALY, SEIZURES, AND CORTICAL ATROPHY; NDMSCA
Penetrance for gene: VARS were set to Complete
Review for gene: VARS was set to GREEN
gene: VARS was marked as current diagnostic
Added comment: PMID: 26539891 is the first report on individuals with biallelic pathogenic variants in VARS. 3 individuals from 2 consanguineous families are briefly reported. The phenotype was similar in all 3, consisting of severe developmental delay, microcephaly, seizures and cortical atrophy. Subjects from the first family were homozygous for a missense variant in the tRNA synthetase catalytic domain [p.(L885F)]. The patient from the second family was homozygous for a missense SNV affecting the anticodon-binding domain [p.(R1058Q)].

PMID: 29691655 reports on a further patient born to non-consanguineous parents, with 2 in-trans pathogenic variants in VARS. The phenotype consisted of progressive microcephaly (OFC at birth -2SD, at the age of 2 months -4SD), global developmental delay, seizures and progressive cerebral and cerebellar atrophy. An affected brother presented with more severe phenotype (OFC -6SD at birth and -8SD at 2 months of age), seizures, hearing loss but was deceased and unavailable for genetic testing. cDNA studies demonstrated absence of the reference allele for the missense mutation downstream the splice variant (in line with a reduced or absent mRNA allele harboring the splice variant). Similarly, mRNA expression studies demonstrated 50-60% reduction in the transcripts (due to NMD of the allele with the splice SNV). Western blot showed severe reduction in protein levels (more pronounced compared to what would be expected by mRNA expression) presumably secondary to decreased protein stability due to the missense variant. Severe defects in aminoacylation were further confirmatory of a pathogenic role of these variants. The missense variant was affecting the anticodon-binding domain, important for aminoacylation.

PMID: 30275004 reports on 2 siblings with developmental delay, intellectual disability, severe speech impairment and microcephaly, similar to what has been described for the disorder. Clinical findings were somewhat different from previous studies in that microcephaly was acquired, while seizures and cortical atrophy were not part of the phenotype. Both sibs were compound heterozygous for 2 missense variants, though only one of these mutations affected the anticodon binding domain and the other was in the N-terminal region of the protein. Previous metabolic studies and extensive genetic testing (karyotype, CMA, MECP2, FMR1) was normal.

Epilepsy was a feature in 4 of the 6 individuals for whom genetic testing was possible (or 5/7 in total).

VARS belongs to the family of amino acyl-tRNA synthetases (ARSs). Mutations in several cytoplasmic ARSs are associated with severe neurological manifestations including seizures, intellectual disability associated with microcephaly.

VARS is included in gene panels for intellectual disability (but not for epilepsy) offered by different diagnostic labs.

As a result this gene can be considered for inclusion in the ID and epilepsy panel as green (or amber).
Sources: Expert Review, Literature
Intellectual disability v2.510 PIGG Konstantinos Varvagiannis gene: PIGG was added
gene: PIGG was added to Intellectual disability. Sources: Literature,Expert Review
Mode of inheritance for gene: PIGG was set to BIALLELIC, autosomal or pseudoautosomal
Publications for gene: PIGG were set to 26996948; 28581210
Phenotypes for gene: PIGG were set to # 616917 MENTAL RETARDATION, AUTOSOMAL RECESSIVE 53; MRT53
Penetrance for gene: PIGG were set to Complete
Review for gene: PIGG was set to GREEN
gene: PIGG was marked as current diagnostic
Added comment: PMID: 26996948 reports on 5 individuals from 3 families, with biallelic pathogenic variants in PIGG.

Individuals from first family, were born to consanguineous parents from Egypt and were homozygous for a stopgain variant [p.(Gln310*)]. The patient from the second family had a rare missense SNV [p.(Arg669Cys)] and a de novo microdeletion affecting PIGG on her other allele. In the third family (consanguineous parents from Pakistan), two affected sibs were found to be homozygous for a splice variant.

The phenotype consisted of hypotonia, early-onset seizures and intellectual disability. Ataxia was an additional feature in one of the families.

Seizures, were observed in most of patients but do not appear to be a universal feature as they were absent in one of the sibs from the third family (10 years of age), while the other had a single episode by the age of 12 years.

In vitro testing of lymphoblastoid cell lines (generated from individuals from the 1st and 3rd family) indicated that the variants abolished completely the function of PIGG, whereas the surface level of GPI anchored proteins was normal. //

PMID: 28581210 describes the phenotype of 2 sibs from Palestine, homozygous for a stopgain variant [p.(Trp547*)]. Hypotonia, feeding difficulties, severe non-progressive ataxia (with cerebellar hypoplasia), intellectual disability and seizures were common features. Differences in severity and/or additional features might be explained by other homozygous variants (the girl had a concurrent diagnosis of MCAD deficiency).

The authors demonstrated that the PIGG transcript levels were significantly lower (approximately half) in the two siblings compared to their parents, while the transcripts with the mutation in the heterozygous parents were very low due to nonsense-mediated decay.

Patient fibroblasts showed decreased surface level of GPI-anchored proteins, in contrast with what was noted in lymphoblastoid cells in the previous study. //

PIGG has been included in gene panels for intellectual disability offered by different diagnostic labs. //

As a result this gene can be considered for inclusion in this panel as green (or amber).
Sources: Literature, Expert Review
Intellectual disability v2.422 AP1S1 Louise Daugherty Added comment: Comment on phenotypes: extended phenotype description, added OMIM MIMid